10 Incredible Records & Firsts WWE Set At WrestleMania 40

The Showcase of the Immortals breaks new ground in several fun, interesting and wild ways.

By Scott Carlson /

WrestleMania 40 (or XL) is in the books, and depending on your view, it was either the greatest night in all of sports entertainment, a huge spectacle masquerading as professional wrestling, or somewhere in-between.

Advertisement

Regardless, WWE put on a hell of a show that swept up the ~70,000 fans in attendance this past weekend. They finished numerous wrestlers’ stories, not just the main one involving Cody Rhodes. They charted new paths for several stars, crowned new champions, and utilized some of the company’s biggest legends as supporting characters rather than centerpieces.

With 40 editions now completed, there is plenty of history to be celebrated and made at the same time, not just for WWE, but for individual superstars. WrestleMania 40 was no different, with several records and individual firsts being logged throughout the weekend. Some of these have been broadcasted across WWE’s social channels, while others are a bit more obscure.

But in the immediate aftermath of the industry leader’s biggest show of the year, it’s worth taking stock and laying out the new records, the historic firsts, and the notable takeaways from this year’s WrestleMania.

Let’s get to it…

10. A New Era

A recurring theme throughout the entire weekend, WWE made no secret of the fact that they consider WrestleMania 40 the beginning of a new era for the company founded by the toxic and troubled Vince McMahon.

Advertisement

Without mentioning Vince’s name once during the show he created, WWE repeatedly told the public that this was the first Mania of “the Paul Levesque Era,” sending no less that Vince’s daughter Stephanie McMahon out Sunday night to proclaim it.

Indeed, this was the first WrestleMania since Triple H took the reins in mid-2022 where he was in charge for the entire year prior, giving him a full 12 months to build the stories and book a Mania to his liking. One doesn’t need to dance around and say things like, “Triple H’s fingerprints were all over this show.” WWE quite literally told you in no uncertain terms that this was his Mania from start to finish during media appearances throughout the week and weekend.

WWE is wise to forcefully turn the page from Vince, especially after Stephanie’s embarrassing and inexcusable leading of a “Thank you Vince” chant when he resigned in disgrace in 2022, only for the old man to force his way back into power just six months later.

9. R-Truth Finally Gets A Mania Win

At 52 years of age, R-Truth is a remarkable case study in longevity, a wrestler who debuted in WWE when The Rock, “Stone Cold” Steve Austin and Triple H were dominating the show each week. And yet, 24 years later, he is considered an active part of the roster rather than a legend who shows up periodically, like many of his peers.

Advertisement

Despite his lengthy run with the company – a brief stint in 2000-01 and back with WWE since 2008 – Truth had never won at WrestleMania. He lost a tag title match alongside John Morrison at Mania 26, was on the losing side of a 12-man Raw versus SmackDown tag match at 28, and failed to capture the Intercontinental Championship at 31 – among other smaller appearances.

That streak ended Saturday night when the Awesome Truth secured the Raw Tag Team Championship, marking Truth’s first Mania win and first proper title (not counting the 24/7 Championship) in five years.

Truth’s title reign might not last long – it’s possible it has ended before this article is even published – but it still goes down in the record books.

8. Rollins Gets Proper Spotlight

Seth Rollins did not have a good WrestleMania 40, but he did get plenty of time in the spotlight during the weekend. He probably just wishes it went a bit better for him.

Advertisement

Rollins had his first proper WrestleMania main event as part of the tag team match on night one alongside Cody Rhodes taking on The Rock and Roman Reigns. The duo were unsuccessful in preventing Bloodline Rules, but for Rollins, a multi-time world champion and main-event player for the past decade, it was the first time his name appeared on the marquee for a WrestleMania main event.

To be fair, Rollins did wrestle in the main event of Mania 31, cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase mid-match to win the world title from Brock Lesnar by pinning Reigns.

Rollins also joined rare company this weekend by becoming just the third wrestler to compete in both an opening and closing match at the same WrestleMania. The others: Bret Hart at 10 and Daniel Bryan at 30. Of course, they accomplished that feat in the era of one-night WrestleManias, while Rollins closed out Saturday and opened Sunday’s show.

7. Reigns Set A New Bar

There is no doubting Roman Reigns’ dominance at the top of the WWE card for the past several years, and there’s probably no better proof than the record he tied and broke during WrestleMania 40.

Advertisement

Reigns surpassed a 31-year-old record this past weekend when he main-evented both nights of WrestleMania, giving him nine Mania main event matches and eclipsing Hulk Hogan’s mark of eight, which he set by closing out eight of the first nine Manias, with WrestleMania IV being the lone exception.

The Tribal Chief most likely will be taking time off after losing the title Sunday night, but if he returns for WrestleMania 41, odds are very good that he will pad his record.

As a side note, Roman also tied a Hogan record by posting his fifth consecutive WrestleMania main event match (Hogan finished WrestleManias 5-9).

6. Run It Back

There has been some fair criticism of WWE through the years for having a very limited cast of true main-event superstars, remaining locked in to a small cadre of wrestlers entrusted to close out the biggest show of the year.

Advertisement

Given that, we’ve seen a handful of repeat main events through the years. The Rock and “Stone Cold” Steve Austin closed out three WrestleManias: 15, 17 and 19. Rock and John Cena were last to go on at WrestleManias 28 and 29. Bret Hart and Yokozuna would have joined them for Mania IX and X if not for Hulk Hogan.

But Roman Reigns and Cody Rhodes set a rather unique record at WrestleMania 40: Their matches at 39 and 40 were the first time there were identical title defenses in the main event, with Roman defending the Undisputed WWE Universal Heavyweight Championship against Cody to close out both events.

Odds are you won’t see this record broken for a while, unless Reigns comes back to challenge Rhodes next year. Barring that, fans should expect to see variety in their main event title matches going forward.

5. Women Break New Ground

During the past decade, WWE has made a conscious effort to put women’s wrestling on a similar plane to men’s wrestling, establishing equivalent matches and titles and featuring them in more prominent roles and positions on the card.

Advertisement

However, at least one distinction eluded the women… until Sunday.

Rhea Ripley and Becky Lynch became the first women to open a WrestleMania in front of fans. With 40 Manias and 43 opening matches before an audience, a women’s match had never opened the show. Opening matches are often entrusted with feeding off the inherent energy of fans and further firing them up for the remainder of the night, and Ripley and Lynch put on a master class Sunday.

The only asterisk here is that both nights of WrestleMania 36 opened with women’s matches, though it should be noted that this pandemic era show was taped, so it’s entirely possible that they were recorded in a different order. Even if not, there were no fans in the Performance Center, making Ripley/Lynch a true first of its kind.

4. The New Streak

The brief appearance of the Undertaker during Sunday’s main event obviously gets fans talking about his legendary WrestleMania streak, a string of 21 consecutive wins at the biggest show of the year.

Advertisement

Of course, that streak was broken at WrestleMania 30. But a decade later, a new streak has emerged.

Bianca Belair chalked up her fourth consecutive win at WrestleMania 40 alongside Naomi and Jade Cargill, giving her the longest active undefeated streak at WrestleMania. It’s a feat that WWE would be wise to nurture and build upon, as Belair is a true star and could make something of it as the years roll on.

It’s worth noting that Rob Van Dam also is undefeated at WrestleMania with a 4-0 record, but he hasn’t been active in WWE for a decade.

3. The Ring General Outmaneuvered

No one in WWE history has held the Intercontinental Championship longer than Gunther.

Advertisement

His single title reign – which ended at WrestleMania 40 when Sami Zayn defeated him – is longer than the cumulative days that any other wrestler has held the championship. It’s an insane feat that very likely will not be eclipsed for decades.

Clocking in at 666 days, Gunther’s reign is a full two-plus months longer than the next closest active wrestler, The Miz, who took eight reigns to reach 592 days.

Of course, Gunther’s IC title reign was not the only record run to end this past weekend…

2. Roman’s Reign Finished

Let’s dispense with the obvious: Roman Reigns’ 1,316-day reign as a world champion is not a company record. It’s only the fourth-longest reign, with Bruno Sammartino more than doubling that total.

Advertisement

However, Roman’s near-four-year run as the top guy is unprecedented in modern WWE, the longest reign in 36 years. It’s an epic run that includes more successful PPV/PLE title defenses – 24 – than any other champion in company history. (During his 1,474 days as WWF Champion in 1984-88, Hulk Hogan only defended his title on PPV three times. Of course, those were very different times.)

During his last couple years with the title, Reigns’ title defenses got more and more sparse. However, Cody Rhodes would need to defend his newly won title at every PLE for the next two years to topple Roman’s single-reign record.

1. And New…

If you enjoy hearing Samantha Irvin announce new champions, WrestleMania 40 was your show.

Advertisement

During the course of the two nights, there were seven new champions crowned, a record for WrestleMania. WWE boasted two new sets of tag champs (splitting the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship), new Intercontinental Champion, two new World Heavyweight Champions (Drew McIntyre and Damian Priest), new WWE Women’s Champion, and new Undisputed WWE Universal Champion in Cody Rhodes.

There have been WrestleManias with five new champs crowned – WrestleManias 34, 35 and 37 had five title changes on the main card – but never seven. Only two champions who walked into WrestleMania 40 – Rhea Ripley and Logan Paul – walked out with their titles intact. They should probably consider themselves lucky.

Is it possible that this record could be broken? With nine active titles on the main roster, it’s entirely possible that WWE could pull the trigger on shaking up every title picture down the line, but this was a truly unique feature for WrestleMania 40.

Advertisement