10 Lamest WWE Pay Per View Concepts Ever

Not every event can be the Royal Rumble.

By Justin Henry /

With pay-per-view taking a decided backseat to the WWE Network, the idea has been put forth to reduce the number of WWE pay-per-views from its annual dozen. This is actually a reasonable idea. Since nothing of note really happens at secondary events like Payback and Fastlane and Night of Champions, there's really no point in spending three weeks building matches for something that's largely going to be ignored. Keep the big five pay-per-views (Royal Rumble, WrestleMania, Money in the Bank, SummerSlam, Survivor Series), and run seven live specials on the Network on Saturdays in the vein of October's Madison Square Garden show, or the upcoming Toronto event. Hey, bring back Saturday Night's Main Event as a Network exclusive - you don't have to waste the whole roster on insta-feuds that way. If the pay-per-view output is indeed going to diminish, I can't say I'll miss some of the poorer concepts all that much. Once WWE had the idea of expanding their calendar to monthly pay-specials, a period of over-saturation began in earnest. With the pressure to adhere to the calendar, some truly lame ideas for pay-per-views were verbalized at boardroom meetings in Stamford, and you wondered who would plunk down upwards of 55 dollars American to see these shows, based on their selling points.

10. Taboo Tuesday/Cyber Sunday (2004-08)

Once the WWE product began a slow decline in the post-Invasion dregs of 2002, fans became more outspoken and critical of the company they'd held dear during the Attitude Era highs. By 2003, armchair bookers were second-guessing many of the decisions of Vince McMahon and his top lieutenants. In theory, putting together a pay-per-view where the fans got to vote on the matches seemed to be a great (if superficial) way to empower the vocals. Problem is, they didn't go all the way with it. Lame voting choices like, "Which gimmick should Mick Foley portray?" and "What perverted outfits should the Divas wear in a battle royal?" weren't exactly inspiring. It may not have been a show that should've been taken seriously, but it's also not one worth plunking down fifty bucks for, either.

9. Breaking Point (2009)

Talk about interesting timing. After Brock Lesnar's pulverizing of Frank Mir at UFC 100 drew 1.6M buys (topping WWE's best by about 400,000), WWE decides to run a pay-per-view based upon submissions. As it were, three submission matches were booked for what turned out to be the lone Breaking Point in company history. Perhaps it was because the event took place in Montreal that inspired WWE to re-run the hackneyed 'screwjob' finish in CM Punk's victory over The Undertaker to close out the night. That, coupled with John Cena making Randy Orton submit after surviving a handcuffed beating, made for a pretty standard night of WWE sameness. For a concept show, nothing felt particularly different from the norm.

8. Elimination Chamber (2010-15)

There is nothing wrong with the idea of an Elimination Chamber match in and of itself. The problem comes from the idea of its 'play-date' placement on the calendar. The first three Chamber matches took place in differing months: November 2002, August 2003, and January 2005. The gimmick was only invoked when it was felt that the World title picture needed drastic measures taken to settle scores. While TLC and Hell in a Cell suffer from the same watering down of valuable gimmicks, the Chamber was situated just before WrestleMania, and that only watered it down further. When Chamber spun off into its own pay-per-view, it became a building block to WrestleMania, instead of the violent blow-off for multiple feuds. The NFL doesn't hold its playoffs during Week 5, you know.

7. This Tuesday In Texas (1991)

In 1991, WWE undertook an experiment. A full decade before TNA did the same thing out of necessity, the wrestling giant dabbled in the idea of running weekly pay-per-views. Just six days after Undertaker defeated Hulk Hogan for the WWE Championship at Survivor Series, the company staged a rematch for a special Tuesday pay-event. The show would also feature Randy Savage vs. Jake Roberts, with neither man wrestling at Survivor Series, instead cutting promos to hype this forthcoming match. Estimates on the actual amount of buys that This Tuesday in Texas received vary, but it's believed it only drew half the purchases of Survivor Series, despite promoting Savage's first match in eight months. The weekly PPV experiment was a resounding flop.

6. In Your House (1995-97)

The events themselves were usually fine, and were basically treated like two-hour pay editions of Saturday Night's Main Event, where the entire roster wouldn't necessarily be featured. That was an important distinction, because WWE's bloating of the pay-per-view calendar is arguably a reason why the company drowns in its own excess to this day - a fear of scaling back. What earns In Your House its place on this list was the concept of the original show - one lucky fan was actually going to win a new house. Think about that: the expanded pay-per-view calendar was borne not only of WWE's desire to keep lockstep with WCW, but used a free-house giveaway as a justification for fans to buy the events. They only ran the promotion once, but the name still stuck.

5. December To Dismember (2006)

Forget for one second that December to Dismember is the worst pay-per-view in WWE history that wasn't the 1995 King of the Ring, and that it marked the entombing of the ECW brand as anything worth getting remotely excited for. Instead, see it for what it was: the point where WWE realized that split-brand pay-per-views had gone too far. Beginning in 2003, Raw got four exclusive shows, as did Smackdown. A year later, the calendar stretched to fourteen total PPVs, with Raw and Smackdown now each with five, supplementing the time-tested 'big four'. After ECW One Night Stand helped spin off the ECW brand, they too got their own exclusive event, with a roster so thin that it was transparent. After it drew a paltry 90,000 buys, pay-per-views once more featured full squads.

4. Night Of Champions (2007-Present)

You knew it was bad in 2015 when WWE felt they needed to put the Intercontinental and United States belts on Daniel Bryan and John Cena, solely because they realized they needed two proven stars to elevate the belts from the dead. Cena did an admirable job, but it shouldn't have come to that. The belts should have always meant something. Night of Champions as an idea underscores what an awful job WWE does getting its belts over. You shouldn't need an event where the gimmick is, "We have belts, and they'll be on the line!" That should be a given. If you have to get fans excited by saying, "This show is about championships," you're also saying that the other shows aren't. And at times, that's been accurate. Maybe the champions shouldn't lose non-title matches on TV all the time?

3. No Holds Barred: The Match/The Movie (1989)

I refrained from including non-wrestling endeavors of WWE's on this list (The World Bodybuilding Federation events, and the Sugar Ray Leonard money-losing fight of 1988), but had to include this due to the wrestling connection. In 1989, Hulk Hogan starred in a campy B-movie where he basically plays himself, fighting an evil TV executive through his proxy henchman Zeus. Shortly after Christmas 1989, WWE ran a double feature on pay-per-view, featuring the movie itself, followed by a steel cage tag team match pitting Hogan and Brutus Beefcake against Macho Man Randy Savage and Zeus, taped two weeks earlier. The movie was awful, and the match was marginally passable. I would have loved to see this idea recreated in 2006 with The Marine, followed by a John Cena-Robert Patrick street fight.

2. Bragging Rights (2009-10)

The brand extension lost its flavor sometime around 2004-05, when it was apparent that anything with momentum on Smackdown was going to couriered over to flagship Raw. That's what made it all the weirder in 2009, when the Bragging Rights concept came to be. The entire show was centered around the 'rivalry' between Raw and Smackdown. What WWE didn't seem to realize is that so many annual drafts had worn down the concept of brand loyalty. That's not to mention all of the times other wrestlers just appeared on the opposite show with a hearty, "Well, I'm here!", crossing shapeless boundaries to meet WWE's convenience. Besides, Raw was more fun with Eric Bischoff in charge, not the 2009 plethora of disinterested guest hosts.

1. Fatal 4 Way (2010)

It doesn't get any more unimaginative than this. At least with TLC, you're promising the fans a car wreck, even if you're making the matches adhere to a spot on the calendar. Ditto Hell in a Cell, as it's a match that people would look forward to if the feud was enticing. WWE's burned out the audience with gimmick PPVs, but at least most of the gimmicks are exciting. The same can't be said for Fatal 4 Way, an event with a pair of, yes, fatal four way matches for the two World Championships. The idea that a fatal four way could be such a novelty that it would require its own pay-per-view (in 2010!) speaks volumes of how desperately out of ideas the company was in that moment.