10 Last-Minute WWE Payback 2016 Rumors You Need To Know

Are we about to see the arrival of you-know-who?

By Scott Fried /

This Sunday, WWE presents Payback, the so-called first Pay-Per-View of a new era. While WrestleMania was a heavily-criticized show that featured stars of yesteryear like Triple H, The Undertaker, and Shane McMahon in prominent matches, this show is different. In the main event, WWE newcomer (and world-class worker) AJ Styles gets his first shot at the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, and anticipation over the bout and surrounding storylines is reaching a fever pitch.

Advertisement

The other main draw of the show (besides a strong card built largely around up-and-coming talent) is that Vince McMahon will address the future of Raw. Shane McMahon returned to WWE in February demanding control of the show, and Vince said he could have it if he defeated The Undertaker at WrestleMania. Shane lost, but since WrestleMania, Vince has allowed him to run Raw anyway. Stephanie McMahon has challenged that authority, and at Payback, Vince is going to pick which of his children will run the show on a permanent basis.

For these reasons, and many others, Payback looks to be one of the most interesting "B-shows" in recent memory. Even though WrestleMania was last month, this could be the event that, in many ways, determines the course of the company over the next several months.

Here are 10 last-minute rumors you need to know for WWE Payback. As usual, I've ranked them in order from the least to most plausible.

10. Roman Reigns Turns Heel

At WrestleMania, many WWE fans were hoping - expecting, even - that Roman Reigns would turn heel. We knew his title victory was inevitable, but surely the company recognized that he wasn't working as top babyface and a heel turn would freshen him (and Raw) up.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, Reigns won the title, celebrated before a booing crowd, and that was it. Hopes that he would turn on Raw the following evening were dashed when he didn't do anything but cut a promo.

People are still holding out hope that Reigns will turn. He's wrestling a babyface in the main event of Payback, and some people have even floated the idea that Gallows and Anderson could turn on Styles and form a group with the WWE World Heavyweight Champion. Don't expect that to happen - not just because there's no reason for such an alliance, but because Reigns isn't turning.

Yes, it would be exciting, and yes, it would lead to some new stuff on WWE TV, but the company has played their hand and they're going to stick with it for a while. Like it or not, the Reigns era, as it is, will continue.

9. AJ Styles Wins The WWE World Heavyweight Championship

Just like Roman Reigns is sure to continue as WWE's top babyface, he's (almost) equally as sure to continue reigning as WWE World Heavyweight Champion.

Advertisement

His path to the top was famously stilted - at WrestleMania 31, Reigns was deemed too unpopular to put over Brock Lesnar, so Seth Rollins walked out with the title. The company spent the rest of 2015 trying to get Reigns over as a babyface by having him dominate opponents and get screwed out of the WWE Title, and it almost worked - when he won the belt for the second time, fans were actually excited. Soon after, though, it all fell apart, and fans turned on Reigns worse than ever in the lead-up to WrestleMania 32.

Despite the fans' hatred, WWE stuck with their plan to put Reigns over, and he became a three-time WWE World Heavyweight Champion at the show of shows. They didn't ruin WrestleMania's main event just to undo it a month later.

Admittedly, there's always an outside chance that Styles could turn, accept help from Anderson and Gallows, and claim the title, but it's very unlikely. The potentially collusion between Styles and his former teammates is clearly a red herring, and Reigns will keep being champ.

8. Seth Rollins Returns

Rumors have been spreading over the past couple of days that Seth Rollins - who was backstage at WrestleMania - will also be backstage at Payback. Though reportedly he'll only be at the show to discuss direction for his character upon his return, that hasn't stopped fans from speculating that the former WWE World Heavyweight Champion will make an on-screen return.

Advertisement

Rollins has been out of action since November, when he suffered a knee injury at a house show in Dublin and was forced to relinquish the title. Initial estimates indicated that Rollins would be out between six and nine months, but last month, news broke indicating that Rollins was progressing better than expected and had resumed in-ring training.

The sooner Rollins returns to action, the better, but it's unlikely that it'll happen at Payback. The star was reportedly seen limping at WrestleMania, meaning that four weeks later, he's probably not ready to get involved in matches or storylines. Even if he were, there's already so much anticipation over Payback's main event regarding Bullet Club that a Rollins comeback wouldn't get the focus it deserves.

7. Bray Wyatt Appears

Bray Wyatt and The Wyatt Family may have been heavily featured in the poster for this year's Payback event, but that doesn't mean much. Posters are drawn up months in advance, and the parties who created it couldn't have foreseen the group's bad luck.

Advertisement

Last month, former Intercontinental Champion Luke Harper suffered a knee injury during a Raw dark match which was estimated to keep him out of action for five to six months. The group continued in his absence, and a face turn and feud with The League of Nations was teased on the Raw after WrestleMania, but on the opening show of WWE's European tour earlier this month, Bray Wyatt suffered a leg injury of his own. Since then, Erick Rowan and Braun Strowman have also been kept off TV, waiting for their leader to return.

Wyatt's injury is much less severe than Harper's, and he's only expected to miss a total of four to six weeks of action. It's only been about two and a half weeks, though, and even though the Pay-Per-View would be a great place to bring "The Eater of Worlds" back, odds are he's just not physically up to it yet.

6. Vince McMahon Revives The Brand Split

Beside the main event storyline, the most anticipated angle for Payback revolves around the future of Raw. Shane McMahon may have lost his bid to take over the show at WrestleMania, but he's been something of a substitute General Manager for the program ever since the show of shows. That hasn't sat well with Stephanie McMahon, and at the PPV, Vince McMahon will pick one of his children to reign supreme.

Advertisement

Naturally, this has refueled months-old speculation that the brand split is returning, with Stephanie (and Triple H) taking charge of one show and Shane piloting the other. Some think it's a virtual certainty that this angle will at least plant the seeds for a dividing of the roster along Raw and Smackdown lines in the future.

I have no problem with a brand split - if handled correctly, I think it could go a long way toward making WWE programming more exciting. That said, there was a split in effect for nine years, and the reasons that the company got rid of it (a shrinking roster and a lack of interest in Smackdown) haven't really changed. It is possible that WWE is planning a split, but I'll believe it when I see.

5. The Miz Beats Cesaro

Cesaro was one of many WWE superstars who suffered an injury late last year, missing WrestleMania and ultimately hurting the event. He was able to make his return the following evening on Raw, though, and while he failed to win a match to determine the new number one contender to the WWE Title, fans were still happy to see him back.

Advertisement

The following week on Raw, Cesaro defeated Kevin Owens to win a shot at the Intercontinental Title, and from there, he began a feud with new champion The Miz. With a suit, sunglasses, and a superstar entrance, the company has tweaked Cesaro's image without changing what makes him great; they may have finally stumbled upon a formula for "The Swiss Superman" where they feel comfortable pushing him.

Despite all that - and the fact that Cesaro really should defeat The Miz - there are people who think that The Miz will be retaining his title. Knowing WWE's propensity for delivering a swerve to fans even when it spites themselves, I wouldn't be too shocked to see Miz cheat to keep the belt. File this one under 50/50.

4. Finn Balor Debuts

Ever since the news broke that Karl Anderson and Doc Gallows were leaving New Japan for WWE, Finn Balor has been teasing a Bullet Club reunion on social media. Now that Gallows and Anderson have debuted on TV and Balor has lost the NXT Championship, there's nothing stopping the trio from reuniting anytime and anywhere.

Advertisement

Payback in Chicago would be an auspicious start for Balor Club (or Bulletproof, or whatever name they use), and there's no doubt that the fans would go wild for the WWE debut of both Balor and the unit. That said, it's possible that WWE wants to go with a slow burn when it comes to piecing the stable together.

Since arriving in WWE, Anderson and Gallows have been linked with AJ Styles, who took over Balor's role as Bullet Club's ace when the Irishman left New Japan for WWE. The Styles association seems temporary, and fans are waiting for Balor to show up, reunite with his comrades, and begin feuding with Styles. While I fully expect the seeds for Balor's imminent debut to be planted at Payback, I'm not as certain that we'll be seeing the man himself. That may come later.

3. Owens Screws Zayn

Kevin Owens debuted in NXT at TakeOver: R Evolution, the same event at which Sami Zayn won the NXT Championship. Following Zayn's win, Owens congratulated him... then attacked his best friend. Owens won the belt from Zayn at TakeOver: Rival, then defended it against him at TakeOver: Unstoppable. Around that time, Zayn suffered a shoulder injury, with Owens taking credit for causing it at Unstoppable.

Advertisement

When Zayn returned to action, Owens was on the main roster, so that's where "The Likable One" followed him. Zayn has spent this year trying to get revenge on his former friend, while Owens has done his best to avoid (or maim) Zayn.

WWE has used all of this history - as well as the previous friendship between the men which extends into their teens - to build up a match that's being billed as a decade and a half in the making. That said, there's still mileage left in the feud, and it doesn't need to be blown off quite yet.

The easiest way to prolong the program is to have Kevin Owens screw Sami Zayn out of satisfaction, either by scoring a cheating win or getting disqualified or counted out. They can face off one final time in a stipulation match at Extreme Rules.

2. The Dudley Boyz Cost Enzo And Cass The Tag Tournament

There's no Tag Team Championship match at Payback, but the event will host the finals of a tournament for number one contendership to those titles. The Vaudevillains and Enzo and Big Cass - who were all in NXT a month ago - will collide for the opportunity to take on The New Day.

Advertisement

Enzo and Cass are undoubtedly future superstars. Their main roster debut on the Raw after WrestleMania was the highlight of the show, and it established them as stars of the tag team division right off the bat. It also established them as rivals to The Dudley Boyz, whom Enzo and Cass defeated to reach the finals of the tournament.

Enzo and Cass are undoubtedly future tag team champions, but they're not through with The Dudleyz just yet. Even though The Vaudevillains haven't gotten over with WWE audiences, they'll stand to benefit from the fact that The Dudleyz will want revenge on their newfound foes (and the fact that the Tag Team Champions are babyfaces).

Expect Enzo and Cass to dominate The Vaudevillains, but interference from The Dudleyz to give the former NXT Tag Team Champions a backdoor victory.

1. Anderson And Gallows Turn On AJ Styles

There's a lot of discussion swirling around the main event of Payback. Who will win? Who will turn? Will Finn Balor debut? We've already addressed those issues, but there's one more - the virtual certainty that Karl Anderson and Doc Gallows turn on AJ Styles.

Advertisement

Since joining WWE, Anderson and Gallows have given Styles unsolicited help in his battle with Roman Reigns, forcing the honorable former IWGP Heavyweight Champion to ask his friends to back off. Anderson and Gallows have paid lip service to Styles's demands, but they've kept attacking Reigns and The Usos in the interim.

Odds are that Guns 'N' Gallows won't brook what they see as ingratitude for much longer. Even though they promised to have AJ's back "forever," it's clear that the association is coming to an end.

Anderson and Gallows will turn on Styles at Payback. The most likely scenario is that they'll come down to ringside during the match and Styles will shoo them away before they can do anything. Reigns will later win cleanly, and after the match, Anderson and Gallows will attack their so-called friend. Maybe Balor will appear and maybe he won't, but Bullet Club 2.0 comes apart (for the second time) at Payback.

Advertisement