10 Lessons WWE Must Learn From WrestleMania 32
A terrible WrestleMania must be a learning experience for WWE.
WWE WrestleMania 32 was a commercial success, but a critical disaster. It didn't leave many great memories, but it has left a lot of lessons to be learned.
Those lessons are both positive and negative. On the one hand, it is hard to criticise Vince McMahon when his company drew nearly 100,000 people to Dallas, Texas to see the show in person. There was some seriously good business done, and the lessons from that success can be applied to future megashows.
But on the quality aspect, the lessons are all ones of necessary improvement. Quite frankly, this show sucked. There wasn't one match that fans will be talking about a year from now. The Women's Title match was the best of the bunch, and it will be worth re-watching, but it's not like it was Sasha versus Bayley in Brooklyn. It was just a good match, and there'll be plenty more like it in 2016.
Elsewhere on the card, it was just woeful. Poorly-paced matches and puzzling creative was ever-present throughout the night. Raw the next night was just bad, too.
But it isn't too late to turn things around. If WWE learn from the good and the bad of this past week, and apply those lessons to the future, then the company can quickly return to being a hit with the fans.
Here's the key takeaways they should be thinking about.
10. Bigger Venues, Higher Prices
Let's start with a positive.
At the AT&T Stadidum, WWE were running at the biggest venue they've ever ran in, and charging more for tickets than they did last year. Even with a poor promotional effort, they still drew more fans and got them to spend more money to boot.
The lesson there is that, regardless of quality offered, they can make still more money. The 'Mania brand alone will sell. They should go after bigger venues, and put the ticket prices up even further, because 'Mania 32 proved that the brand name will draw on its own.
Tickets will be even more expensive next year as a result of this year's demand and the astonishing sales figures. Clearly, the threshold can be pushed further, which is great for WWE's business.
9. Less Is More
WrestleMania 32 ended up being a twelve match card held across the pre-show and main broadcast. Compare that to the excellent WrestleMania 31, which was a nine match card across its pre-show and main show.
But the real issue is the fact that WWE crammed so many wrestlers across 'Mania 32's matches. Multi-person matches are fine when balanced out, but this was far from a balanced card.
The reason for so many wrestlers on the card was to make sure everyone had a payday and got their 'WrestleMania moment'. But that's a horrible way of booking, since wrestlers should only feature based on merit, not just because.
Next year they should focus on quality over quantity when it comes to booking wrestlers. That way the results will be more meaningful, creating a grander WrestleMania legacy.
8. Promotional Build Must Be Better
Back at WrestleMania 31, there was evidence that promotional build didn't matter too much. After all, the build for that show was terrible, but on the night it ended up being heralded as an all time great 'Mania.
But this year, it prove that 'Mania 31 was sheer luck. The terrible build for 'Mania 32 undoubtedly had a negative impact on the night of April 3. Fans had largely made up their mind that they were going to hate on the main event no matter how good it was, because the build going in had just been so woefully uninspiring.
Shane McMahon versus The Undertaker was another example of build undermining the match. The story was so underdeveloped, meaning it was hard to emotionally invest in the match.
Up and down the card, there was that same feeling. WWE hadn't gave enough reasons to care. They must put more effort in when they build WrestleMania 33.
7. Protecting From Injuries
One of the things impacting WWE's build, and undermining WrestleMania 32, was the number of injuries to big name stars. It is partly bad luck, but there are things WWE could be doing to better protect their talent.
Weight training is one area that they may want to look at. The unusual number of shoulder injuries, particularly with John Cena and Cesaro, could have been caused by their preference for heavy style lifting.
The gruelling nature of the WWE schedule could also be something for Vince McMahon to consider. Injuries were happening with alarming regularity in the past year, and the company may need to consider measures to ensure the physical demands of the business doesn't come back to bite them again at times like 'Mania.
6. Pacing & Timing
When it came to timing, WrestleMania was one of the worst WWE specials in history. At nearly seven hours over the pre-show and main show, it completely burned the audience out. WWE should never go that long again.
Where it was really felt, was in the pacing of the matches. Shane McMahon, a forty six year old businessman, wrestling for half an hour? That was a horrendous decision, and it lead to a terrible match. Not even the spectacular cell bump could save it.
Likewise, the Triple H versus Roman Reigns main event, that went nearly half an hour. Considering fans had vocally made it clear they didn't want to see the match, it was a major error to then make them sit through nearly thirty minutes of it.
All in all, it was a fatiguing watch. For next year, they should proportion time to quality.
5. New Stars Must Be Pushed
Who really got "made" at WrestleMania 32?
The big project was Roman Reigns, but he's no better or worse off than he was before this 'Mania season began.
Baron Corbin did win the Andre battle royal, but that match was such a cluster, mainly put where it was as a buffer between the two main events. The past has proven that it doesn't mean anything, anyway. Just look at Cesaro for evidence of that.
As for the women's match, it was good but it kept all three women in the same spot they had been for the past few months. Nothing was changed. The title itself got a facelift and the "diva" tag was amended, but only a Sasha Banks win would've felt like an actual meaningful move.
Ultimately, it was a night where the older stars faired better than newer stars.
4. Brock Lesnar Needs To Be Back In The Main Event
Brock Lesnar is the biggest star in WWE.
He's headlined all of the biggest shows in the past couple of years, providing excellent main events against the likes of John Cena, Roman Reigns and The Undertaker. For him to drop down to a match with Dean Ambrose at WrestleMania 32, in a pedestrian hardcore match that went just thirteen minutes, it came off feeling like a very weak mid-card offering.
For WrestleMania 33, he should be restored to his full glory. A rematch with Roman Reigns is what would make sense. Their 'Mania 31 effort was a classic, and the unresolved finish left business on the table.
The biggest star should be in the biggest match of WWE's biggest show.
3. Stadium Logistics
One of the biggest complaints from the fans attending live was that the stadium logistics just were not up to the standard of a professional event. That blame could be attributed to AT&T Stadium rather than WWE, but with the event being under their banner, WWE also need to take responsibility and learn lessons from what went wrong.
A big issue was the ticketing. Fans were made to queue in the sweltering heat, due to a problem with scanning the tickets. Some fans reported that they were just able to wander in unchecked as part of the confusion, which also poses security questions.
WWE should work closely with the Citrus Bowl to ensure such problems don't negatively impact the live experience at WrestleMania 33.
2. A Return To PPV?
Something WWE must at least consider for WrestleMania 33, is a one night only return to PPV.
While WrestleMania 32 did an astonishing live gate, it was a different story in its distribution. The event was available free on WWE Network to new subscribers, and retailed for just $9.99 to those who already subscriber.
Putting it in perspective, just one month before 'Mania 32, UFC 196 did 1.5 million PPV buys at $60. The WWE Network was doing about the same number of viewers, but it was either for free or for $9.99.
Basically, WWE have massively devalued their biggest show and made it a bargain product, when it should be a premium product. While the Network is fine for the so-called B shows, it doesn't make sense for events like WrestleMania, when the company could have been making a killing on PPV.
Taking the lesson from 'Mania 32, they should really consider the viability of having Mania as the one show that is solely PPV each year. Presuming that John Cena versus The Undertaker is the main event next year, is that really worth a paltry $9.99?
1. Keeping In Touch With The Fanbase
The biggest lesson WWE must take from WrestleMania 32, is that they need to be in greater touch with their fanbase.
That isn't to say they should bend to the vocal minority of the IWC. It is fine to go against the crowd, particularly the smark section. But when the entire 'Mania card is against not only the IWC, but the mainstream fanbase, that's when problems set in.
Reigns winning was acceptable, they've invested in him and he has a big following with the wider fanbase. That result was always going to happen. But when the rest of the card is also against the will of the crowd, that's where 'Mania 32 really came off badly.
Things like Sasha not winning, the overlooking of Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn when Zack Ryder won, Jericho topping Styles, and Rock's burial of The Wyatt Family... there were a lot of things beyond Roman Reigns that were out of touch with what fans wanted to see.