10 Major Flaws With WWE's Current Pay-Per-View Model
The Network has changed WWE for the better, but PPVs have never felt so expendable.
WWE's pay-per-view model has changed immensely since the Network was introduced in 2014. The company are no longer focused on selling individual PPVs, but monthly subscription fees, resulting in a dramatic shift in the way their biggest events are promoted, presented, and built towards.
Following WWE has never been so cost effective. The subscription fee is less than a quarter of what WWE charged under the old model, and with the promotion producing more major shows than ever before, the value for money is undeniable. Unfortunately, the shift has also brought a lot of excess baggage and created an environment in which pay-per-views just don't feel special anymore.
Battleground 2017 takes place this Sunday (23 July), but the fanbase isn't exactly buzzing with excitement. WWE used to put immense time and effort into making these events feel as enticing as possible, but they've grown complacent in recent years, and provide few reasons for fans to tune in anymore.
Moving back to the old system would be terribly regressive, but the current model is rife with problems, and unless they're addressed, PPV hype levels will remain a fraction of what they once were.
10. Oversaturation
A huge problem during the original brand split, pay-per-view burnout is back with a vengeance in 2017. At its peak, audiences were presented with 16 PPV events a year, and while WWE scaled back to 12-13 when the split was canned, the issue resurfaced in 2016, when the company held 15 major events.
With several empty holes on the calendar, WWE look set to top this in 2017. This weekend’s Battleground event will be their fifth pay-per-view in nine weeks, and they’ll likely hit 16 or 17 total shows by the year’s end. With an average time between PPVs of less than three weeks, the events have been completely devalued. Angles aren’t given enough time to build, and post-PPV Raws and SmackDowns are rife with repetition from the previous arc, or demonstrable panic as creative struggle with where to head next.
WWE are fitting too much into too small a timescale. PPVs now feel routine, and their mystique expired a long time ago. Fans will still tune in out of habit, but the company’s focus on ‘super serving’ their audience has led to a situation where there’s little to separate their biggest shows from the average episode of Raw or SmackDown anymore.
9. Using PPVs To Set Up TV Angles
Television's role has traditionally been to sell the pay-per-view. This is done by presenting smaller scale angles and matches that build intrigue and lead towards a payoff at the PPV, where the story may not get complete closure, but will at least move on to its next act.
This has been reversed in the modern eras. Instead of using TV to draw eyes to the PPV, it’s now often the other way around. WWE will use their major events to set up angles for their minor weekly shows, with the most recent example coming at Money In The Bank 2017.
Aside from putting Carmella over as a heel, the main purpose of James Ellsworth briefcase grab was to build towards a SmackDown rematch two weeks later. The real payoff came when Ellsworth was banned from the arena (and eventually suspended), and Carmella became the first Ms. MITB on her own accord, without his help.
This is something that WCW used to do all the time in their dying days, and the same goes for TNA when they were at their lowest. Those aren’t exactly favourable comparisons, and if WWE want to make their PPVs feel important again, they must kick this habit.
8. Giving WrestleMania Away
WWE love dishing out free Network trials. Those who cancel their subscriptions are often enticed back to the platform with the promise of a couple of free months, and issuing these rewards has become an annual tradition on the road to WrestleMania.
The past two years have seen WWE allow new customers the chance to watch their biggest show of the year completely free. This predictably results in a significant spike in Network subscriptions in Q2, but retention rates are poor, and the numbers inevitably slide when the bulk of these free viewers decide they don’t want to pay $9.99 a month.
This model may attract more eyes to ‘Mania, but it doesn’t make a whole lot of sense outside of boosting that specific metric. ‘The Showcase Of The Immortals’ is WWE’s crown jewel. If any show is worth paying for, it should be the biggest event of the year, and in theory, WWE ought to be going all-out to earn as much money from the show as possible.
Instead, they give it away, which seems like a huge waste of potential revenue. Sure, it allows more people to experience WrestleMania, but what’s the point if they don’t stick around afterwards?
7. Endless Rematches
One of the biggest problems created by WWE’s PPV overload is the seemingly endless stream of rematches. The limited gap between shows means that creative no longer have enough time to tell a compelling story in a single pay-per-view arc, forcing them to stretch feuds out by booking the same match over and over again. This makes it incredibly difficult for fans to get excited by the show, regardless of potential match quality.
This weekend’s Battleground card says it all. Four of the seven bouts announced so far are contests we’ve seen at least once over the past few months, while John Cena vs. Rusev is a rehash of their lame 2015 feud, and the women’s Fatal 5-Way is the latest in a long stream of multi-person matches featuring the same personnel. This leaves just one first-time bout: Baron Corbin vs. Shinsuke Nakamura.
Some of these bouts may well be excellent, but it’s tough to shake the “been there, done that” vibe. Sadly, pay-per-views have become Rematch City, and it’s hard to see this changing without a significant restructure of the company’s annual schedule.
6. Screwy Finishes
If you like your big wrestling matches to finish cleanly, decisively, and logically, WWE isn’t the promotion for you. Athletic standards are higher than ever, but the company continually ruin great wrestling with bad writing. No show ever passes without a myriad of distractions, disqualifications, and countouts, and the habit is wearing thin.
Such conclusions can be valuable storytelling tools when used sparingly, but their use expires when they’re called upon multiple times on every single show. Sadly, WWE just aren’t content to let matches succeed on the quality of the actual work anymore, and it’s no surprise that their two best matches of the year (John Cena vs. AJ Styles, Tyler Bate vs. Pete Dunne) featured hard-fought, clean finishes.
There’s a perception among certain sects of the audience that every clean loss is a burial, but this just isn’t true. Nobody will look down on a wrestler for losing a good match, and burials only happen when WWE go out of their way to deliberately make a performer look bad (see: Bayley vs. Alexa Bliss). They don’t need to do away with screwy finishes entirely, but they’d definitely benefit from applying some restraint.
5. Giving Big Matches Away On Free TV
Pay-per-views used to be the only place you could see wrestling’s biggest matches. Promotions wouldn’t burn huge, first-time bouts on weekly television, because they recognised that nothing sells a PPV quite like a well built ‘dream match.’ If you wanted to see the best in-ring action the sport has to offer, you had to fork out for the big show. End of story.
This has changed in recent years, and WWE have developed the destructive habit of giving these matches away on Raw and SmackDown. AJ Styles vs. Randy Orton is a huge bout capable of headlining almost any pay-per-view, yet WWE booked it for a random episode of SD in March. The same goes for Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Kevin Owens, albeit on a smaller scale, and the problem persists.
Why would anyone pay a Network subscription when they can see these bouts on television, without paying a dime? It’s another example of the poor job WWE have done of giving fans a reason to subscribe to their streaming service and check their major events out. These bouts could’ve been PPV classics, but there’s a chance most viewers have already forgotten about them, which is a big shame.
4. The Cram
Making it onto a WWE pay-per-view card used to mean something. In the past, spots on the big show had to be earned. Only the company’s hottest feuds and acts (and those they wanted to transform into a hot act) would get the opportunity to shine in the biggest spotlight, and swathes of wrestlers were routinely omitted from cards, even at WrestleMania.
This isn’t the case anymore. It often feels like WWE’s main pay-per-view goal is to cram as many performers onto the show as possible, regardless of whether it makes sense or not. WrestleMania 33 featured a whopping 68 in-ring competitors, and other PPV cards are routinely packed with repetitive multi-person matches, completely devaluing the glory of making it onto the show in the first place.
WWE want to make as much use of their bloated roster as possible, as well as catering to fans of every superstar, but they’re doing so at the expense of storytelling and match quality. Few wrestlers genuinely shine in these crowded matches, and it’s difficult to stand out when sharing the spotlight with four or five peers at a time. It’s great that more wrestlers are receiving a nice little PPV bonus than ever before, but it’s not always enjoyable to watch.
3. Lame Go-Home Shows
Pay-per-view go-home shows used to be among the most enjoyable weekly TV episodes on WWE’s calendar. When buyrates were still relevant, the company would go all-out to sell the PPV with two/three hours of exciting, all-action television. They didn’t always succeed, but when they did, the shows were often exciting enough to convince fans to buy the PPV on their own.
The advent of the WWE Network has changed this. There’s no longer an incentive to build towards conclusive PPV outcomes, as the company don’t need to worry about buyrates anymore. They already have your Network subscription fee, and can therefore do as they please on the go-home show.
This has resulted in little differentiation between the last pre-PPV stop and any other episode of Raw and SmackDown. WWE know they can get away with mailing it in, so why would they do anything else? This isn’t a huge loss, but it has resulted in the dilution of WWE’s PPV cycle as a whole. Go-home shows are now entirely meaningless, and this isn’t something that’s going to change any time in the near future.
2. Too Many Gimmicks
There’s nothing wrong with gimmick pay-per-views when used in moderation. The Royal Rumble and Survivor Series are seminal concepts, and always among WWE’s most enjoyable annual shows. Money In The Bank is going the same way, and while King Of The Ring wasn’t always a great all-round show, the tournament format at least provided a break from the norm.
As with almost every other good thing in their arsenal, WWE have gone too far, and completely burned most of their gimmick PPVs out. Four of the company’s nine 2017 PPVs have come packaged with a flashy concept thus far, and with Survivor Series, TLC, and presumably Hell In A Cell and Clash Of Champions still to come, this percentage could yet increase.
Fans see these gimmicks too often for them to feel special anymore. Their value has been eroded through oversaturation, and the matches themselves are often drab, sanitised affairs, hampered by WWE’s PG restrictions. This provides another reason to scale back on such shows, as WWE are no longer able to deliver on the violence promised by stipulations like HIAC, creating an extreme identity crisis whenever these events come around.
1. Only WrestleMania Matters
Almost everything WWE does onscreen is centred around building towards WrestleMania. It’s not only their biggest show, but their main storytelling focal point: the stage at which most previous storylines reach a climax, and new ones are born in their wake.
This doesn’t necessarily mean that WWE are constantly building towards ‘Mania throughout the calendar year. In fact, the company often rush the lead into their biggest show, cramming as many new developments into the last few weeks as possible. ‘The Showcase Of The Immortals’ is always on their mind, though, and always presented as the year’s most important show, as it should be.
Unfortunately, this has created a situation where WWE’s other pay-per-views don’t just feel second rate, but downright skippable. Even the other ‘big four’ PPVs feel completely insignificant by comparison, with their outcomes and developments often rendered irrelevant in the grand scheme.
This is a marketing and presentation failure on WWE’s behalf. They do a good job building up ‘Mania as a spectacle, but only put a fraction of that care and attention into their other shows. In presenting just one show a year with any kind of consequences, they’re essentially saying “you don’t need to watch the others, as they won’t matter by the time April comes around.”