WWE's annual summertime extravaganza SummerSlam has been home to some of the greatest rivalries in WWE history. The Mega Powers and the Mega Bucks clashed at the inaugural event in 1988, bringing an end to a rivalry that started months earlier at WrestleMania IV. Hogan returned from a career-threatening rib injury caused by newcomer Earthquake two years later to clash with the behemoth at the 1990 event. The love triangle between Triple H, Kurt Angle and Stephanie McMahon took center stage during the WWE Championship defense by The Rock in 2000 and Undertaker and Edge's year-long battle for SmackDown supremacy resulted in a vicious and brutal Hell in a Cell main event in 2008. For every great feud that unfolded on the grand stage presented by SummerSlam, there was a feud that failed to live up to expectations. Some failed so miserably that the only way to properly describe them is to use the term "flop." They entered the event with tremendous hype and benefited exponentially from Vince McMahon's marketing machine but by the end of the evening's broadcast, simply did not leave an impression. Others left such an impression that those involved never quite recovered. Whether it was the participants or the story, they are feuds that are better left unspoken of. Here now are 10 major SummerSlam rivalries floppier than the late Mae Young's breasts during a bikini contest.
10. Hulk Hogan And Brutus Beefcake vs. Randy Savage And Zeus (1989)
The mainstream notoriety that Hulk Hogan achieved as the star of Vince McMahon's then-World Wrestling Federation created opportunities for the Hulkster beyond the squared circle. One of those opportunities came in the form of the McMahon-produced film "No Holds Barred," in which Hogan played Rip, a pop culture icon of a professional wrestler whose unwillingness to sign with the evil Brell resulted in the network executive recruiting the massive Zeus to destroy the popular hero. The movie, clearly the product of the decade in which it was created, was bad but still managed to become somewhat of a cult classic with wrestling fans. Attempting to cash in on the film, McMahon introduced the Zeus character to his programming, despite actor Tiny Lister having no wrestling experience. The unstoppable force aligned himself with "Macho King" Randy Savage in the war against Hulkamania. Never one to let his best friend walk into a two-on-one beating, Brutus "the Barber" Beefcake partnered with Hogan for what was to be a huge tag team main event. Unfortunately, fans never bought into Zeus as being anything even close to a legitimate threat to the WWE champion. After all, he was an actor filling a role, something that was readily apparent every time he attempted the most basic of moves. The match was fairly atrocious and failed to live up to the match between the Mega Powers and Mega Bucks from a year earlier, most because the story made little sense.
9. The Rock vs. Booker T (2001)
It is incredibly difficult to persuade fans to care about a rivalry between two Superstars when one of men involved is portrayed by the writing staff and perceived by fans as being a step below the other. That was the case entering SummerSlam 2001, an event sold on the triumphant return of The Rock and his match with WCW champion Booker T. What should have been a dream match, one of the biggest money matches of the entire Invasion angle, was quickly becoming just another contest on a stacked card. The fact that Booker, one of the most decorated stars in WCW history, was treated like a joke and played second fiddle to Shane McMahon only hurt the feud's potential. In one of the most predictable matches in SummerSlam history, The Rock soundly defeated Booker and captured the WCW Championship. It was the culmination of a feud that never once felt like Booker was the equal to his opponent. He was treated as lesser that the Great One and that is how the fans in San Jose reacted to him. With one of the competitors overshadowed by his opponent and manager McMahon, it was never as effective as it should have been.
8. Bret Hart vs. Isaac Yankem And Jerry Lawler (1995)
Despite the fact that Diesel and Shawn Michaels had spots higher on the card in the summer of 1995, there was no denying that Bret Hart was still the most popular star in the company and a hero to millions around the globe. As such, anything he was involved in was perceived to be more important. That was the case as he rolled into Pittsburgh for SummerSlam and a showdown with evil dentist Isaac Yankem. The product of Jerry "the King" Lawler's humiliating "Kiss My Foot" match loss at the King of the Ring pay-per-view, the feud between Hart and Yankem was the latest chapter in the never-ending rivalry between the Hitman and the King. As popular and great as Hart was, he was unable to hide the fact that a wrestling dentist was ludicrous. Yet another idiotic gimmick in a long line of them during that era, Yankem was failed to connect with audiences, relying heavily on the heat that Lawler elicited to keep fans interested in his portion of the story. Hart did everything in his power to get the best match possible out of the big man and, for the most part, he succeeded. Unfortunately, it made little difference. The feud was dead on arrival and all of the hard work by those involved was for naught.
7. CM Punk vs. John Bradshaw Layfield (2008)
Buried underneath the Hell in a Cell main event between Undertaker and Edge, the titanic battle between John Cena and Batista and Triple H's WWE Championship defense against the Great Khali was a match between World Heavyweight champion CM Punk and John Bradshaw Layfield. The match, the Raw brand's top title contribution to the show, should have been a coming out party for Punk, who cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase to capture the big gold belt just over a month earlier. Unfortunately, the Straight Edge star was not afforded the respect that other champions were. Instead, he was treated like a second class citizen, a Superstar undeserving of the spotlight that accompanies a heavyweight champion. By the time SummerSlam 2008 rolled around, the feud between Punk and John Bradshaw Layfield was ranked fourth in terms of importance. Together, the Superstars crafted a solid-yet-unspectacular match that saw Punk fend off Layfield's high impact, hard-hitting offense to deliver GTS and retain the title. Unfortunately, the fans did not respond overly enthusiastically to the program and Punk's days as champion were officially numbered. By September, he would drop the title without ever losing it and be thrown back into the mess that was the midcard. It would take a second chance, a heel turn and the critically acclaimed Straight Edge Society faction to elevate Punk back up the ladder a year later.
6. Kane vs. Bray Wyatt (2013)
The debut of the Wyatt Family introduced second-generation star Bray Wyatt to a fan base desperately seeking a bright young star that was different from the rest, that stood out and gave them hope that the monotony that had encapsulated World Wrestling Entertainment would be broken. He was believable, thanks largely to the fact that he completely immersed himself in his character. The entrances were cool, the video packages revolutionary and the promo work far superior to that of anyone else on the roster. That he and followers Luke Harper and Erick Rowan targeted Kane ensured that the Wyatt Family's first feud would take on dark overtones. At SummerSlam, Wyatt would wrestle his first singles match, an Inferno match against Kane. The match type piqued fan interest but the story behind it was jumbled and nonsensical mess. WWE Creative clearly did not have the grasp of the Wyatt character like they would later on and as a result, his motivations were unclear and his reasons for targeting the Big Red Monster undefined. When the match turned out to be as bad as it ultimately was, the entire feud was deemed a tremendous flop, to the point that some questioned the long-term success of a performer such as Wyatt, who looked as bad as he did in his first pay-per-view bout.
5. Triple H vs. Brock Lesnar (2012)
Triple H vs. Brock Lesnar from SummerSlam 2012 is a feud that should have been one of the event's greatest. The industry icons had never had a feud of any kind. It was not only a fresh match, it was a dream match and WWE knew it. One of the only big-money bouts left for it to promote, WWE slated the titanic clash to occur on August 19 at the summertime spectacular. Disappointing booking, unsustainable momentum and two guys with very little chemistry made for a disappointing program and an unsatisfying main event. The inability by Triple H to recognize Lesnar's weakness and craft a match designed to hide them only hurt matters. Rather than a heated brawl that played up the intensity of their rivalry and the violence each looked to inflict on one another, The Game guided the Beast Incarnate through a more traditional wrestling match. Unimpressed with what was unfolding before them, the fans inside Los Angeles' Staples Center sat quietly, popping only for the occasional high spot. By the time Lesnar forced a submission with the Kimura armbar, the crowd could not be happier for the disappointing main event to conclude an uneventful SummerSlam pay-per-view. Unfortunately, the program would rage on well into 2013. Triple H and Lesnar worked an equally disappointing No Holds Barred match before wrapping things up with a slightly better Steel Cage match. It was a welcome conclusion for a rivalry that never lived up to its promise.
4. Undertaker vs. Kane (2000)
As one of the marquee attractions for WWE, Undertaker is oftentimes involved in some of the highest profile angles the company has to offer. After returning to the ring in the spring of 2000, he was still trying to find his way as the "American Badass," a biker character that had taken the place of the traditional Dead Man gimmick. With main event stars The Rock, Kurt Angle and Triple H entangled in a three-way rivalry over the WWE Championship, Steve Austin still sidelined following neck surgery and second-tier workers like Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit involved elsewhere on the card, the only thing left for Undertaker to do was feud with brother Kane. An unexpected heel turn leading into the show ignited the rivalry and, while it lacked the drama that their previous feuds had, it still captured the attention of fans thanks to those involved. The match, or lack thereof, was wildly disappointing. The only thing remotely close to memorable about it was the fact that Undertaker ripped his brother's mask off, sending him scurrying to the back in an attempt to hide his scarred face. Undertaker stood tall but the fans were not impressed. Clearly last minute, thrown-together program in hopes of capitalizing on the star power of the two Attitude Era icons, the feud and match was quickly erased from the memories of those more concerned with Terri Runnels and The Kat wrestling in skimpy underwear and Kurt Angle's infatuation with Stephanie McMahon.
3. The Rock vs. Billy Gunn (1999)
By the time 1999 arrived, WWE was at its hottest in terms of storytelling and success. They had finally overcome WCW to prove themselves as the number one company in professional wrestling. In order to maintain the momentum his company had built, Vince McMahon understood that he needed to create new stars to surround his main eventers with and one of his first attempts to do so was Billy Gunn. Known to millions as "Mr. Ass," Gunn had turned on tag team partner "Road Dogg" Jesse James and friend X-Pac, won the King of the Ring tournament and appeared well on his way to a legitimate main event push. The first step in said push? A feud with The Rock. Like Booker T would experience two years later, trying to get over with an opponent on the level of The Rock when booking is doing you no favors is almost impossible. Despite having having the talent to succeed and the charisma that one needed to connect with the audience, Gunn was never booked as though he was a real threat to wrestling's most electrifying star. Instead, he was a strong midcarder with a gimmick that centered around his backside and a skill set that was better suited to tag team wrestling. And that was how he treated, especially when he took to the ring for his match against Rock at SummerSlam. Gunn was outclassed in every way imaginable and became the brunt of a joke when his face was, to quote Jim Ross, "rubbed in that large woman's ass!" Gone was any chance he ever had of being taken seriously as a legitimate foe of Rock, Steve Austin or Mankind. Destined to be recognized as a member of the New Age Outlaws, Gunn would continue to star for WWE for six more years but never against reached the status that he enjoyed entering the annual August extravaganza in 1999.
2. The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker (1994)
When Undertaker disappeared from television sets in January 1994 following a Casket match loss to Yokozuna at the Royal Rumble, men, women and children began reporting sightings of the Dead Man in some of the most curious settings, such as parks, donut shops and fire stations. "Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase eventually claimed to have purchased The Undertaker and reintroduced the Phenom to fans across the globe. Except something was off. DiBiase's Undertaker was shorter and had tattoos that did not quite match those of the original. When Paul Bearer emerged and questioned the validity of the Superstar, everyone had their suspicions confirmed. Bearer vowed to bring the real Undertaker to SummerSlam. To make matters even more ridiculous, actor Leslie Nielsen, who starred in the hit film series "Naked Gun," was recruited to investigate the whereabouts of the Dead Man. True to his word, Bearer led the real Undertaker to the ring for his war against his doppelganger, a war that was won by the purple and black-clad Phenom. The fake would never be seen against and Undertaker would eventual start up a rivalry with DiBiase's Corporation. While many would consider the SummerSlam 1994 bout one of the low points of the Dead Man's Hall of Fame-worthy career, the year-long run of working guys like King Kong Bundy, Kama and Mabel would represent even darker days.
1. Diesel vs. Mabel (1995)
Vince McMahon's attempt to create a new star with Mabel was certainly admirable. He was in desperate need of new blood and turned to the super-heavyweight to provide WWE champion Diesel with competition. In June, the big man was booked to win the King of the Ring tournament, something that was greeted with a venomous reaction from hardcore Philadelphia fans wanting anyone other than Mabel to wear the cape and crown. That should have been the first hint that McMahon's strategy was not working. Instead, he soldiered on, determined to present the former tag team specialist as a legitimate contender to the top prize in wrestling. Fans continued to reject it and longtime babyface "British Bulldog" Davey Boy Smith was turned heel to help mask the utter failure of the King Mabel character. Expectations were understandably low and nothing that Diesel or Mabel did come showtime helped exceed them. It was a slow, plodding match that bored the Pittsburgh fans to tears and had critics wondering exactly why McMahon ever thought a match between the two was a good idea. The involvement of Smith and his former partner, the babyface Lex Luger, helped pop the crowd but the biggest reaction came after the three count from an audience overjoyed with the conclusion of the putrid main event. Mabel never recovered but still managed to have a long career in McMahon's promotion. Diesel, on the other hand, would drop the title three months later to Bret Hart. Didn't see your pick for biggest SummerSlam flop? Let us know in the comment section below.