10 Matches That Nearly Made Wrestlers Quit For Good

Punk walked in 2014, but it could've happened a whole lot sooner...

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

Personnel-wise, wrestling is an inherently volatile form of entertainment, with high turnover present in almost every major western promotion, with new performers coming through the door on a constant basis, often crossing paths with those pushed out of it on their way.

Advertisement

True stability is a luxury only afforded to the industry's biggest stars. WWE are a lot less trigger-happy than they used to be, but can still swing their "future endeavours" axe at will, cutting hordes of "independent contractors" from their payroll at a time. As Neville found out last year, however, walking away is an entirely trickier proposition.

Leaving the business (or even one of it's biggest promotions) is often a complex decision at end of of a long period of deliberation and reflection, but sometimes, as we're about to prove, a single match is the trigger point for a wrestler saying "screw this, I'm done," packing their bags, and trying to get the hell out of there.

But just when these guys thought they were out, the business pulled them back in, even if the following bouts gave each one a legitimate reason to walk away, whether creative, personal, injury-related, or something else entirely...

10. Chris Jericho Vs. Viscera (WWE Heat - 4 April 2000)

Chris Jericho came within a hair of being crowned WWE Champion on the April 17, 2000 episode of Raw. He pinned Triple H that night, drawing a massive pop from the audience, and everyone thought the charismatic former WCW star had just scored the biggest win of his career. It wasn't to be, though. The vendetta-driven Earl Hebner's count was fast, and 'The Cerebral Assassin' pressured him into reversing the decision, creating a memorable in-kayfabe screwjob.

Advertisement

Remarkably, 'Y2J had come within a hair of quitting WWE that very evening. As revealed in a 2013 interview with Sirius XM's Busted Open Radio, he was on his way to Vince McMahon's office to seek his release, citing a recent loss to Viscera on Sunday Night Heat as the deciding factor, but changed his mind when the Chairman told him of the Triple H/WWE Title plans.

Jericho ended up sticking around, of course, but god bless the beautiful irony of this happening to a man who once gleefully bragged to Power Slam magazine that he could drag Viscera to a five-star match back in 1999.

9. Becky Lynch Vs. Kisu (GSW - September 2006)

After five years with WWE, Becky Lynch has now finally been part of the company longer than her injury-imposed hiatus from the sport, which kicked off properly in 2008.

Advertisement

Her issues stemmed from a 2006 match against a wrestler named Kisu for German Stampede Wrestling. The duo went 10 minutes on a card featuring the likes of Roderick Strong and Christopher Daniels, and Lynch wasn't in a good way. Afterwards, she suffered considerable vision problems and headaches, and was diagnosed with cranial nerve damage, forcing her first year on the sidelines.

Becky tried to return in April 2008, but no-showed a Shimmer Women Athletes event. It looked very much like her wrestling career was over, but she returned as a manager in 2011, working closely with the mother-daughter duo of Saraya Knight and future WWE cohort Paige. Then, finally, Lynch resumed her in-ring career in 2012, before WWE swept in, signed her to developmental deal the following April, with her skill, charisma, and work ethic soon establishing her as one of NXT's Four Horsewomen.

An awesome journey, and one that would never have happened if not for her hiatus.

8. Big Show Vs. Braun Strowman (WWE Raw - 4 September 2017)

In a March 2017 interview with Sports Illustrated, Big Show revealed that he planned on drawing the curtain on his wrestling career when his existing WWE deal expired the following February. He claimed there'd be "no last matches, no fanfare, just riding off into the sunset and disappearing," adding that he'd accomplished everything he ever wanted to in the business, and that it was time to let younger generations take the reigns.

Advertisement

This looked to have been fast-tracked last September, as Show wrestled Braun Strowman as part of a surprisingly productive Raw programme. It was a hard-hitting slugfest typical of the bouts they'd had up to that point, and 'The World's Largest Athlete' paid for it, suffering a serious hip injury that was expected to keep him sidelined until after his contract ran out.

As a result, Big Show looked set to retire on a whimper, but while he's yet to attempt a return, it likely won't be the end of him. He has since confirmed that his original exit plans were scrapped on the injury, and after reportedly signing a new appearance-based WWE deal earlier in the year, we'll probably see him again.

7. Great Bash Heel Vs. CHAOS (New Japan Road - March 2017)

Tomoaki Honma, a wrestler famed for his toughness and durability, injured his cervical vertebrae working this inconsequential tag match on a New Japan house show last year, rendering him unable to move his arms and legs for several days.

Advertisement

There were plenty of reasons for fans of the plucky underdog favourite to be concerned. Honma's paralysis was temporary, but it looked very much like the 41-year-old's career was over, and NJPW's insistence on keeping their most serious injuries a guarded secret left his status up in the air. By all accounts, the fateful rope-hung DDT he took from Jado (one of New Japan's bookers) had ended his run, and, barring a miracle, he'd never step back between the ropes.

A long recovery process and multiple surgeries followed. After a few weeks, Honma announced that he planned on returning to the ring someday, and eventually, he did. The former IWGP Tag Team Champion wrestled his first match in 15 months this June, playing a small, crowd-popping role in a 10-man tag on the NJPW Kizuna Road tour. He's yet to compete again, but at least he's healthy now.

6. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. Rusev (WWE Fastlane 2018)

The rumours have quietened down now, but for a while, it felt like barely a month passed without Rusev's WWE future being thrown in the air. The fan favourite has been linked with the exit door several times over the past year, with multiple sources citing his supposed dissatisfaction with his creative direction, but he remains under contract today, and recently wrestled AJ Styles for the WWE Championship at Extreme Rules.

Advertisement

Talk of his departure was never louder than in the build-up to WrestleMania 34. According to PWInsider's Mike Johnson, 'The Bulgarian Brute' threatened to walk out of WWE a month before 'The Show Of Shows,' such was his despondence, and the company responded by throwing him into Jinder Mahal, Bobby Roode, and Randy Orton's United States Title scramble.

This is all speculative, of course, but if Johnson's sources weren't spinning him a yarn, the reporter's claims aligned perfectly with Rusev's Fastlane loss to Shinsuke Nakamura. If true, the promotion must have appeased Rusev by now. He' going strong on SmackDown, and currently locked in a tense storyline with Aiden English and Lana, though a major push is still forthcoming.

5. Luke Harper's Japanese Match (Dragon Gate The Gate Of Destiny - October 2011)

A current SmackDown Tag Team Champion he may be, but (Luke) Harper came within a hair of walking away from the sport entirely after concluding his last tour of Japan in 2011.

Advertisement

The former Brodie Lee revealed this in a recent interview with Rochester First. Though he was a decade into his career, he had yet to make a major breakthrough, and had to turn down his first offer of a WWE tryout as he was suffering from a broken leg at the time. Tired of the independent grind, and with his partner eight months pregnant, he was at his wit's end, telling his other half: "this is it, I'm done, I'm going to get a real job and we'll make do from there."

He arrived back on American soil days after competing on Dragon Gate's The Gate Of Destiny 2011 pay-per-view, where he lost a lower-card six-man tag. Poetically, WWE called him up with another tryout a few days later. Working that listless bout was not his last dance, and he signed a development deal the following year, saving him from obscurity.

4. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena (Extreme Rules 2012)

'The Beast Incarnate' was not a happy customer after losing his return match to John Cena at Extreme Rules 2012, and not just because of the outcome.

Advertisement

The bout itself was tremendous. Carried by its stiffness, it presented Lesnar in his best light, with his brutal, relentless onslaught leaving Cena a bloodied mess. Superman prevailed, though. He was devastated, but just as he'd done a thousand times before, 'Big Match John' fought through the barrage, eventually putting the former UFC Champion away.

Cena should have stayed down afterwards, selling the damage Brock had inflicted in defeat. He didn't. Instead, John got up to address the crowd afterwards, totally negating everything 'The Beast' had done during the bout, making the returnee look like an ineffective dork in the process.

According to reports, Lesnar threw an almighty s***-fit afterwards. He was furious with the direction, and it supposedly took a pep-talk from Triple H to calm him down, with the tirade leading to immediate speculation that he was already finished with the company. Fortunately, the two parties soon mended fences, but imagine how vastly different WWE would look today had Lesnar's comeback been one-and-done.

3. Mitsuharu Misawa's Final Match (NOAH Southern Navigation - June 2009)

The perennial nearly-man of '90s All-Japan and '00s Pro Wrestling NOAH, Jun Akiyama entered the business a disciple of the legendary Mitsuharu Misawa, and though never crowned either company's ace, he was an integral part of their success.

Advertisement

Akiyama and Misawa were tied at the hip, wrestling well over 500 matches together throughout their mutual time in the business. They forged a close relationship behind the scenes too, so when Misawa passed away in the ring on June 13, 2009, nobody was more grief-stricken.

Misawa died after suffering a cardiac arrest following a cervical spine cord injury while wrestling Akitoshi Saito and Bison Smith on a NOAH show. The impact was devastating and far-reaching, and Akiyama hit so hard that he suffered post-traumatic stress disorder as a direct result, forcing a period of recovery and self-reflection away from the ring.

Akiyama was already struggling with back injuries, and considered full-on retirement following Misawa's death. He eventually returned on a sporadic schedule, and still wrestles today, though he's very much in the twilight of his career. Still, he may never have made it this far had he not recovered.

2. Steve Austin Vs. Brock Lesnar (WWE Raw - June 2002)

This bout didn't actually happen, but it was the proposed booking decision that prompted Steve Austin's WWE walk-out back in 2002, and was very much on the cards prior to 'Stone Cold's' fateful decision.

Advertisement

Austin was scheduled to lose 'The Next Big Thing' on a June episode of Raw. He disagreed with the decision, claiming that straight up jobbing to Lesnar didn't make sense for either man at that stage in their respective careers. WWE didn't budge, though. 'Stone Cold' told Vince McMahon that he wasn't willing to lose without leaving the company, and thus ended up no-showing an episode of Raw, taking a lengthy hiatus from the business.

This was only a small part of his growing dissatisfaction with his general creative direction within WWE, but still the catalyst for his latest WWE walk-out. It was a messy split. Vince McMahon and real-life friend Jim Ross both buried 'Stone Cold' on-air, criticising him for "taking his ball and going home," and eventually, the company stopped marketing his character, merchandise, and removed him from WWE.com outright.

Austin eventually returned to WWE the following year, but not before paying a hefty $250,000 fine.

1. CM Punk Vs. The Undertaker (WWE WrestleMania 29)

There's an argument to be made that this was the finest bout of The Undertaker's legendary WrestleMania streak, but even if you prefer the Shawn Michaels matches, the CM Punk clash is likely still in the conversation. It's a classic, and well worth revisiting, but it almost prompted Chick Magnet Phil to walk away from the company ahead of schedule, with 'The Voice Of the Voiceless' reportedly threatening to quit prior to WrestleMania 29.

Advertisement

The story goes that Punk was fed up of being constantly lied to about the match. He'd been led to believe that he was going over and breaking the streak, but WWE changed their minds on short notice. Thus, when he learned he was actually losing, the notoriously short-fused star didn't understand the logic of it.

An irate Punk got into it Triple H and Vince McMahon as a result. The disagreement coincided with him being pulled from a series of live events, but he ended up sticking around and doing the job at WrestleMania. His card was already marked, though: Punk's WWE dissatisfaction couldn't be quelled, and he was gone 10 months later.

Advertisement