10 Matches WWE Could Have Booked For WrestleMania 38

Pointers that could've helped 'The Most Stupendous WrestleMania in History' live up to its billing.

By Troy Ruby /

2022’s Road to WrestleMania has been equal parts intriguing and incomprehensible.

Advertisement

In the weeks since two former UFC stars commandeered both Royal Rumble matches and the men’s Elimination Chamber match, WWE assembled a loaded, albeit peculiar lineup. On one hand, fans have fantasy booked Edge vs. AJ Styles for over a decade. Becky Lynch and Bianca Belair's seven-month arc appears headed for a wild conclusion. Unification stipulation notwithstanding, Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar seem destined for the best match in their WrestleMania trilogy.

Conversely, the interim was weirder perhaps than any year that preceded it.

With days remaining before The Showcase of the Immortals, RAW has hosted a qualifying match to determine who hosts an interview segment. A 15-year veteran is the developmental brand's lead champion. Seth Rollins has been scrambling around like an ostentatious Hamburglar trying to poach other superstars' WrestleMania slots. YouTube stars, podcasters and the guy from ‘Jackass’ received coveted WrestleMania spotlights while trusted regulars were shortchanged, sidelined or shown the door. Peak insanity.

Admittedly, certain aspects of WWE’s build to Dallas have been engaging. However, some of the following contests would have supplied some desperately needed damage control.

10. United States Championship" ‘Demon’ Finn Balor © Vs. Damian Priest

There have been sporadic instances in WrestleMania history where neither the Intercontinental Championship nor the United States Championship were defended. However, this will mark the first time in the event’s history that neither is involved at WrestleMania. Yes, seriously.

Advertisement

This is inexcusable.

In WWE’s quest to promote WrestleMania as a week-long festival, both Intercontinental Champion Ricochet and United States Champion Finn Bálor were docked from the actual two-night Premium Live Event. As a consolation prize, Ricochet will defend the former workhorse championship in a last-minute triple threat addition to the go-home SmackDown 24 hours before WrestleMania. Bálor, alongside former United States Champion and presumed challenger Damian Priest, will compete on Friday evening as well… in the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal.

WWE had all the pieces for a rematch in front of them for a month. On 28 February 2022, Finn Bálor upset then-champion Priest to become the new United States Champion. Since his RAW debut in early 2021, ‘The Archer of Infamy’ had assembled a pristine track record including a six-month run as champion and losses counted on one hand. After months of struggling with a ‘Jekyll and Hyde’ gimmick, Priest finally snapped after dropping the title to Bálor and fully embraced his dark side. One good turn deserves another right? Finn’s ‘Demon’ persona is right there waiting to erase the bitter taste of Extreme Rules 2021.

Alas, no stakes and no stadium show. At least WrestleMania found time over two evenings for three celebrity matches and an interview segment.

9. Sasha Banks & Bayley (c) Vs. Trish Stratus & Lita

Here’s an upsetting glimpse into how little WWE values their women’s tag team division.

Advertisement

A fatal four-way tag match has been booked for this year’s show where every team involved formed in the last four months. Sasha Banks and Naomi are the longest tenured tag partners in the match and just started teaming again for the first time since February 2016. Five of the eight featured participants are competing with different partners from last WrestleMania’s gauntlet due to talent releases.

Only one (Natalya) is entering with a new partner while her former teammate is still under contract. Another missed WrestleMania 37 because she herself was released in 2020 only to be reinstated. The final two in this year’s match were competing for and defending the RAW and SmackDown Women’s Championships respectively last year.

What a state of affairs.

The bottom line is, Carmella and Zelina Vega haven’t set the world on fire as champions. In the titles’ full lineage, only Sasha Banks and Bayley really brought prestige to them. With the latter’s return timetable initially projected for March, her post-WrestleMania return should’ve been expedited to scoop the belts with ‘The Boss’. As for potential challengers, WWE Hall of Famer Lita was on hand for the Royal Rumble, challenged Becky Lynch for the RAW Women’s Championship at Elimination Chamber and then nothing at WrestleMania? Why? Meanwhile, Lita's B.F.F. Trish Stratus is mixing it up in the ring at recent WWE Live shows in Toronto…

Why hasn’t this generational scrimmage been scheduled yet?

8. Battle Royals With ACTUAL Stakes

For a match that supposedly honors the legacy of WWE’s first-ever Hall of Famer, it’s shameful just how poorly the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal has been handled.

Advertisement

To date, the only instalment that felt important was its inception at WrestleMania XXX. With the exception of 2016, it’s been pushed to the margins of the Kickoff Show, the go-home SmackDown or out of the picture entirely. When WWE’s women finally received their counterpart in 2018, it was immediately plagued by a public relations inferno that generally accompanies an ill-advised namesake. The bout has been shelved since the second winner was crowned in 2019.

Dismal timeline aside, a few strategic cosmetic adjustments to the battle royals can rescue even their grievously damaged prestige. Initially, a heavier reliance on NXT and NXT UK shores up roster deficits, facilitating a field of 30 participants on both sides. Second, the Women’s Battle Royal needs a suitable namesake. Bestowing the honor on the late Sherri Martel with a shorthand dubbing as ‘The Sensational Invitational’ should have been the concept from the outset.

Lastly, and most imperatively, the matches need a tangible incentive. Namely, a championship match of the winner’s choosing 24-48 hours later on the RAW After WrestleMania would be ideal. Between the borderline comical fanfare surrounding the week preceding WrestleMania and the night after becoming an event in its own right, this should be an effective selling point. Surely viewership spikes if the new champions defend the night after they won the title, right?

7. Fatal 4-Way For The WWE RAW Tag Team Championships

Where to start?

Advertisement

First, the positives. The triple threat tag team championship match between The Alpha Academy, RK-Bro and Seth Rollins and Kevin Owens on 7 March 2022 was outstanding. The latter in particular were running on all cylinders in recent weeks. Orton and Riddle’s ensuing WrestleMania defense against the Academy and the Street Profits was the best possible remaining call.

While not as woeful as SmackDown’s WrestleMania undercard status, there are aspects of RAW’s tag division raising some questions. Regardless of RK-Bro’s popularity, WWE’s decision to pocket their eventual split rather than host a WrestleMania blockbuster is somewhat baffling. Beyond champions and prospective challengers, things move from confusing to just plain absurd.

Despite steadily climbing traction, support and chemistry, Rollins and Owens diverged following the tag title match. Owens launched an admittedly enjoyable weeks-long campaign against Texas in a successful effort to provoke Stone Cold Steve Austin into an interview segment. Meanwhile, Rollins embarked on a convoluted course of losing streaks, a bizarre qualifier for the aforementioned interview segment and attempted WrestleMania match theft. The presumed endgame is a ‘Mania showdown against the worst kept secret in recent wrestling history.

Then there’s the matter of Robert Roode assisting Dolph Ziggler to the NXT Championship. After 15 years of winning titles, he’s the developmental brand’s lead champion. Sure, why not?

Rollins conquering a four-way melee against the Alpha Academy, Street Profits and Dirty Dawgs while wrangling gold with his sixth different tag partner is a MUCH better use of everyone’s time.

6. SmackDown Women's Championship: Charlotte Flair © Vs. Rhea Ripley

Ronda Rousey’s mainstream crossover appeal cannot be questioned. Her ability to galvanize an angle with Charlotte Flair that doesn’t also feature Becky Lynch, on the other hand…

Advertisement

When Charlotte spent her 2020 Royal Rumble win dethroning NXT Women’s Champion Rhea Ripley at WrestleMania 36, most presumed she was chasing her father’s record as 16-time World Champion. When Charlotte dropped the title to Io Shirai two months later, WWE started dismissing both of her NXT reigns, instead referring to ‘The Queen’ as a “13-time champion”. In other words, the initial title change at WrestleMania was entirely pointless.

WrestleMania two years hence would have been a perfect time to rectify this oversight.

Since becoming the inaugural NXT UK Women’s Champion in 2018, Rhea Ripley has been quickly and quietly racking up the accolades. Reigning with the NXT, RAW and Women’s Tag Team Championships since, ‘The Nightmare’ snapped up every title at her disposal save one. A Royal Rumble win after a silver medal finish in 2021 would have been just the ticket to send her after the SmackDown Women’s Championship in Dallas. Given WWE’s affinity for Grand Slam champions, Rhea Ripley finally toppling Flair to become WWE’s first woman to also hold NXT UK Women’s gold would’ve been something special.

Consult with Money In The Bank 2021 for reference on Charlotte and Rhea’s ability to ignite a crowd. It’s an intangible Ripley has demonstrated regularly since and one Rousey still can’t quite access; getting the fans behind you and keeping them there.

5. Rey Mysterio Vs. Dominik Mysterio

Despite recent interviews where Dom attempted to stem said discussions, this match seems destined to occur before dad calls it a career.

Advertisement

Familial warfare and professional wrestling are inextricably linked and a proven formula, given the right storytelling, venue and audience. The Harts, The Hardys, The Guerreros... even Vince and Shane McMahon had an emotionally charged father/son Street Fight for the ages at WrestleMania X-Seven.

Considering the Mysterios’ WrestleMania 38 opponents, maybe it should’ve happened this year.

This is not to diminish The Miz, he’s a former two-time WWE Champion and two-time Grand Slam champion. However, lately, his capacity seems limited to liaison with celebrities. When former tag partner John Morrison was released last year, WWE had to scramble. After centring a flimsy “feud” on Rey Mysterio getting the cover of WWE 2k22, The Miz needed a partner to counter father and son.

Enter Logan Paul.

WWE seemingly labors under the misconception that Bad Bunny’s incredible in-ring performance at WrestleMania 37 is the rule and not the exception. Sure, Pat McAfee’s NXT run speaks for itself and Johnny Knoxville is a certifiable entertainer (emphasis on "certifiable"). But not everyone should be extended the same courtesy. The social media gadfly should’ve been kicked to the curb in favor of Dominik’s ‘sink or swim’ moment.

As for The Miz? While Kevin Owens played ‘Poke the Rattlesnake’ expertly, most would rather WWE’s quintessential antagonist eat a Stone Cold Stunner and a case of whoop-ass on MizTV: WrestleMania Edition instead.

4. Randy Orton Vs. Riddle

To WWE’s extraordinary credit, RK-Bro has been a revelation for just under a year. Even at RAW’s worst in 2021, the pairing was consistently a highlight (sometimes the only highlight). Now in their second reign as RAW Tag Team Champions, recent months have seen even the usually stoic Orton having the time of his life.

Advertisement

Prolonging the partnership, however, might prove a double-edged sword.

When Alpha Academy upended their initial reign prior to the Royal Rumble, most logically concluded RK-Bro’s inevitable split was imminent. Surely, ‘The Viper’ and ‘The Original Bro’ were gearing up for a head-on collision at WrestleMania. Between rumors of Riddle’s planned Rumble win, involvement in Elimination Chamber and discussions that an Orton feud “could only happen for the WWE Championship”, the match seemed all but locked in.

That is, until Brock Lesnar nuked the Chamber.

After toppling the Academy, Seth Rollins and Kevin Owens to reclaim the gold, RK-Bro seems poised for a WrestleMania defense versus Street Profits and the former champions. However, the alliance’s continuation presents two distinct downsides. First, WrestleMania loses a potential show-stealer between former partners. Secondly, WWE subverting expectations of another Orton heel turn via Riddle planting the knife in ‘The Viper’s back instead would resonate profoundly. ‘The King of Bros’ flipping the switch from scooter doofus to MMA mercenary would likewise be a breath of fresh air.

Can Riddle and Orton maintain their figurative contact high long enough to dissolve at SummerSlam? Or do they burn out just after WrestleMania Backlash?

3. Ladder Match For The WWE Intercontinental Championship

The piteous state of WrestleMania’s midcard is truly something to behold.

Advertisement

Ricochet’s Intercontinental Championship defense on the go-home SmackDown extends a year-long PPV drought for the title dating to last year’s WrestleMania. Drew McIntyre is engaged in a listless four-month rivalry with Happy Corbin. Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs challenging The Usos feels like it was pulled from a hat. Sheamus and his Celtic cohorts are soldiering on with a New Day feud minus Big E. Tommaso Ciampa is being primed for a main roster run after his presumed NXT curtain call at Stand And Deliver and Sami Zayn is embroiled in an ‘Anything Goes’ match with Johnny Knoxville.

The appeal of Knoxville in such a contest is understandable. He’s the perfect celebrity opponent. Anyone seeing more than 30 seconds of ‘Jackass’ knows that fear of injury is a virtual non-factor. The ringleader among stuntmen would likely be ecstatic at the prospect of annihilation by a pack of professional wrestlers or plummeting through a stack of ladders.

So, grant Johnny his wish.

In one match, WWE could resolve numerous orbiting rivalries, provide an action-packed demolition derby and honor the late Scott Hall’s legacy by making a Ladder Match for the Intercontinental Championship at WrestleMania a permanent fixture. Knoxville serves as the proverbial thorn in Zayn’s side without actively competing. Then there’s the ‘X’ factor of Ciampa. This would be a crucial introduction for someone recently dubbed ‘The Pulse of NXT’--particularly if he had left as champion.

2. WWE Championship: Brock Lesnar © Vs. Cesaro Vs. Bobby Lashley

With patience, foresight and more tactful negotiation, this was one of the myriad options at WWE’s disposal for the WrestleMania co-main event.

Advertisement

Assuming the plan was always for ‘The Beast’ to enter WrestleMania as WWE Champion, the entire Road to WrestleMania could have been salvaged. On a timeline where Lesnar retains against Bobby Lashley under increasingly dubious circumstances, the Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber are both cleared to establish fresh challengers. With Big E defecting to SmackDown, a Rumble win and subsequent pursuit of Roman Reigns for the recently dethroned WWE Champion would have been a shrewd strategy. Meanwhile, a renewed contract and push for Cesaro could’ve conceivably yielded a compensatory brand switch to RAW, victory in the Chamber and a sleeper classic with Lesnar at WrestleMania. A gutsy performance from a wounded but relentless Lashley would make an already monumental clash can’t-miss.

In a perfect world, perhaps.

Unfortunately, WrestleMania hosts Brock Lesnar defending the WWE Championship against Universal Champion Roman Reigns in a main event that didn’t need both titles. Contract talks broke down with the Swiss Superman and 11 years as WWE’s utility player ended five days after Elimination Chamber. Despite moving mountains in order to get medically cleared in time, Lashley is evidently being rewarded with a relatively pointless tilt against Omos instead of the merited rematch with Lesnar. It’s miles from ideal for 'The All Mighty', but at least a match is on the cards.

Which is more than can be said for another former WWE Champion…

1. Winner Take All Match: The Bloodline © Vs. The New Day

Amidst WWE’s maelstrom of panic booking and happenstance, Big E has unfairly become chief among casualties.

Advertisement

When health protocols scuttled the Universal Championship rematch with Roman Reigns at WWE Day 1, WWE panicked, throwing Brock Lesnar into the WWE Championship defense instead. Naturally, Lesnar triumphed by pinning Big E himself instead of one of three other viable challengers. Creative sputtered again at the Royal Rumble in a maddening carousel of questionable decisions.

Much like Kofi Kingston before him, Big E’s rematch with Lesnar never came. Instead, WWE detoured a 12-lane superhighway through ‘Suplex City’ on the Road to WrestleMania, beginning by needlessly burning a potential WrestleMania blockbuster between Lesnar and Bobby Lashley. Additionally, the Rumble, the Elimination Chamber and the WWE Championship itself were hand-delivered to ‘The Beast’ to enhance a marquee practically in place since August.

Meanwhile, the former WWE Champion’s trajectory was slightly more harrowing. After a New Day reunion on SmackDown, Big E’s Road to WrestleMania started with a planned feud against Sheamus and the ‘Butch’-Whackers. It ended with an ill-executed suplex and fractured C1 and C6 vertebrae.

Yes, chapter seven of ‘The Beast’ and ‘The Tribal Chief’ will undoubtedly meet or exceed all advertised expectations. However, given Big E’s clear path to redemption following Day 1 and the proven in-ring chemistry of The New Day, the SmackDown Tag Team Champions and the Universal Champion, one question lingers–

Did WWE leave the better overall story, perhaps even the better ‘Winner Take All’ match, on the table?

Advertisement