10 Modern WWE Hell In A Cell Matches That Didn't Feel PG

The most brutal and visceral Cell matches that could have happened decades ago.

By Logan Kenny /

The Hell in a Cell stipulation has received major criticism over the years since the implementation of the annual PPV. The days of the cage only being brought out for the most violent and monumental matches, filled with dangerous spots and major blade jobs, are gone. Instead, the brand of the match is more important than the commitment to the structure's aura and the boost it can give to narratives.

Advertisement

While the stipulation most known for its violence and involvement in only the most intense feuds has been neutered immensely in the grander scheme of things, many matches within the Cell in the last 12 years have captured that classic feeling of danger and scale. Whether the feuds were incredibly developed leading into the satanic prison, the performers risked their wellbeing in maddening spots or impeccable psychology, all of these contests have the required status to feel worthy of a classic Hell in a Cell match.

The PG era is not a bad thing overall; this list isn't meant as a dismissal of the good qualities it's brought to WWE and their talent. But in the time period of Hell in a Cell no contests, random feuds and a lack of true intensity, it's refreshing to feel transported to a more brutal time by these wonderful fights.

10. Dean Ambrose Vs. Seth Rollins (2014)

While the second feud between Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose in 2018 was absolutely panned due to the incorporation of Roman Reigns' cancer, the character shifts for Ambrose and a terrible match at TLC, their first feud was widely acclaimed and would be seen as a classic rivalry if not for a few baffling decisions.

Advertisement

They would have great matches with wild finishes at Elimination Chamber and SummerSlam, have a genuinely seismic match at Money in the Bank and engage in some of their best ever intensity in the main event of Hell in a Cell 2014. The former Shield brothers immediately started battering each other, fighting on the top of the cage, taking mutual table bumps, stiffing each other with strikes and attacking with ruthless frenzy.

The two felt genuinely dangerous together in all the right ways, creating that classic Hell in a Cell fight feeling that transcended the PG limitations. Unfortunately the finish involving the holographic Bray Wyatt takes this down a lot and was a sign that WWE didn't see star power in Ambrose, but it still mostly holds up as a genuinely intense Hell in a Cell contest.

9. Jey Uso Vs. Roman Reigns (2020)

While Uso and Reigns' modern classic of emotional wrestling narratives doesn't have the violence of the infamous Hell in a Cell bouts of old, they capture the intensity and necessity of the Cell as the conclusion to a feud perfectly.

Advertisement

The feud between "The Tribal Chief" Roman Reigns and his underdog cousin Jey Uso has been the best executed story of the year, genuinely compelling wrestling fans throughout the world with the personal elements and emotional performances. It has filled people that love this industry with the need to see what happens next, the goosebumps upon certain narrative moments happening, the emotional connection to each of the performers. It felt like a storyline akin to Owen and Bret Hart's feud instead of any textbook modern WWE rivalry.

While the brutality wasn't as sadistic as many matches on the list, the way it was structured made it feel monumental, with every move feeling thudding and painful to witness, especially with how broken Jey looked after every offensive move. The emotional incorporation of Jimmy Uso made it feel even more like a classic melodrama, something genuinely challenging and outside of what we expect from PG wrestling.

8. The Undertaker Vs. Triple H (2012)

Similarly to Jey and Roman's contest, The Undertaker and Triple H capture the aura of the Hell in a Cell narratively, using the steel structure as a way to signify the end of this rivalry and a feeling of importance that is rare in the PG era. They might not have bled or thrown each other off of the cell, but they told a monumental story that felt like it happened in another era.

Advertisement

The culmination of a four year narrative of DX attempting to end the Streak, The End of an Era match at WrestleMania XXVIII is one of the finest examples of WWE melodrama in history. The larger than life characters with decades of history and connections with the audience, the clear narrative told over the 30 minute runtime about HHH willing to do whatever it takes to win, the incorporation of Shawn Michaels as special guest referee and the incredible in ring work cement it as a classic.

They made every moment count, piecing together a brutal Cell masterpiece that had audiences hung on every moment. It was the end of the Attitude Era, a match that learned from what came before and combined them into one beautiful new.

7. Sasha Banks Vs. Charlotte Flair (2016)

In many ways, Sasha Banks and Charlotte Flair’s miraculous Raw Women’s Championship match was something that could have only happened in the PG era. After all, WWE only truly started respecting their female talent in the 2010s, with only a few stars getting the opportunity to showcase their abilities beforehand. This monumental match, the first ever women’s Hell in a Cell match and the first ever PPV main event for WWE’s women, is an indication of one of the PG era’s greatest successes.

Advertisement

Yet, in terms of physical action, this was more brutal than either of the other two Hell in a Cell matches from 2016. Sasha and Charlotte beat the life out of each other. The match had the narrative and aura of a main event, and both women lived up to expectations by throwing their bodies around with reckless disdain. The notorious table botches actually improved the match, with Sasha’s bumping off of the wood looking horrific and adding to the danger of the stipulation.

It was a brutal and brilliant way to start off the women’s era of Hell in a Cell matches, capturing the sense of the classic Cell matches while reinventing who could appear in them.

6. The Usos Vs. The New Day (2017)

The Usos and The New Day had the feud of 2017, making up for a notoriously weak era of SmackDown through their excellent matches and segments. Their contest at Battleground 2017 cemented Xavier Woods as one of the best babyface sellers in the world, and they delivered a tag team classic on the SummerSlam pre-show. However, their most acclaimed match together was in the steel structure itself, where they stole the show.

Advertisement

The two teams destroyed each other, implementing genuinely excellent tag team psychology and putting their opponents through hell. It was compelling to watch each team strategise and work together in the lawless cage, especially since it led to even more captivating action between the pair.

In terms of rejecting the PG era, it showed audiences one of the most brutal spots of the decade, the mauling of Xavier Woods. Handcuffing him to the ringpost, the Usos battered Woods with kendo sticks as he screamed and convulsed upon every strike. The sounds and expressions were horrifying and it sold just how far The Usos were willing to go.

It was a match that could have easily happened in another era, and we’re grateful we got it in this one.

5. Sasha Banks Vs. Becky Lynch (2019)

Sasha Banks will do anything to her body to get a match over. Despite all the clear differences between the two, she is the closest thing that we have to a modern Mick Foley in terms of attitude. There is no danger she won’t risk if it’ll lead to a memorable spot, no bump she won’t take to get over a narrative. She is a renegade, a tough as nails wrestler able to create masterpieces of chaotic wrestling while telling an emotional, compelling story.

Advertisement

Her feud with Becky Lynch wasn’t perfect leading into the Cell. They had an excellent Clash of Champions match before a humiliating finishing sequence, and Sasha constantly seemed to be booked as lesser to her opponent. None of that came across in the match itself, where two of the Four Horsewomen put it all on the line to deliver an exceptional performance. It was a frenzied and extremely entertaining brawl, containing some of the best Meteoras in history and showcasing how far women’s wrestling in WWE has come.

It had the daredevil spectacle of a classic TV-14 Cell contest and the intricate wrestling from two modern geniuses to help it stand out even further.

4. Edge Vs. The Undertaker (2008)

The first Cell match of the PG era, Edge and Undertaker’s sensational war still felt like a classic Ruthless Aggression main event. The conclusion to the best SmackDown feud of 2008, Edge and Undertaker put their bodies on the line with reckless disregard on the road to creating a classic.

Advertisement

While their WrestleMania main event was fantastic, the two men just clicked even harder in stipulation matches, with their TLC match at One Night Stand being an all time classic of chaotic bumps. The narrative involving Edge and Vickie Guerrero’s manipulation of their power to sabotage The Undertaker was so compelling, with the banning of the Hell’s Gate and Edge’s dastardly interference tactics making fans clamour to see him get demolished.

They somehow topped all their previous encounters with their Hell in a Cell contest, where the two did the wackiest things they could to brutalise each other. Table bumps, bursting through the side of the cage and the famous chokeslam to hell helped cement the match as the final one of its era, the culmination of SmackDown as the home of wacky bloody masterpiece feuds. It didn’t feel PG at all just yet.

3. Sasha Banks Vs. Bayley (2020)

Sasha Banks has been pushing herself further every time she's stepped into the sinister structure. She has amplified the intensity of the bumps she's taking but also that of her storytelling, reinvigorating the Cell stipulation with every immaculate performance. It's only fitting that her best Cell match to date happened with her greatest opponent, Bayley.

Advertisement

The two redefined what women could do in WWE with their nuanced narratives and breathtaking matches. They get audiences invested with their work and fans were desperate to watch this long awaited sequel to their NXT feud. The spots were brutal, with kendo sticks, turnbuckle bumps and chair spots sending shivers down the spine with their impact - but the storytelling was even better.

The worst thing the PG era has done to the stipulation is that it often just feels like something that's happening because of the annual PPV. This needed to be in that cage, not just because of the narrative leading in, but through every expression and action the two women shared with each other. You could feel the heartbreak and anger in Sasha immediately and it lasted even after her hand was raised. It is a transcendent display of what these matches are capable of.

2. The Undertaker Vs. Brock Lesnar (2015)

While other matches don't feel PG because of the feuds going into the Cell or the bumps taken, Lesnar and 'Taker's brilliant second encounter inside the cage is simpler. They wrestled it exactly like a Ruthless Aggression era Cell match, making each other bleed and demolishing each other with strikes.

Advertisement

Undertaker and Brock Lesnar have notorious history with each other, delivering one of the bloodiest matches in WWE history inside the Cell back at the classic No Mercy 2002 event. Add to this, Lesnar ended the concussed Deadman's WrestleMania streak, still the most shocking moment in wrestling history behind the Montreal Screwjob, and you have a feud built for the most nightmarish stipulation in WWE.

They wrestled a modern classic, one of the best WWE matches of the 2010s and the last truly great 'Taker match within a wrestling ring. 'Taker put it all on the line, giving the performance of his late career as he desperately tried to power through the blood and damage to his aging body, only to be repeatedly knocked down by Brock. It was a sadistic and masterful example of what Cell matches used to look like and what they could be going into the future.

1. Randy Orton Vs. Jeff Hardy (2018)

Randy Orton is a fascinating performer. In his late career, with only a few exceptions, his singles matches have been increasingly slow and methodical. Sometimes, when he's committed and the aura is correct, this slow pace adds to the intensity of the narrative. Sometimes it's just boring. But it was perfect here.

Advertisement

His match with Jeff Hardy might not have many electrifying bumps or blood pouring everywhere, but it ranks as the most brutal PG Cell match because he channels his strengths into delivering a classic villainous performance. The infamous spot, where Orton wrenches a screwdriver through the pierced hole in Hardy's ear, wouldn't have been as sickening or notorious if he'd done multiple major spots beforehand.

Orton knows exactly how to pace a match like this, generating sympathy for his opponent through his merciless dominance and cruel mutilation of Hardy's body, while making the central moment of the match feel as violent as a botched blade job. The rest of the match is brutal as well, making the most of the stipulation, but it will always feel transported from another era because of that spot. It's still hard to believe that they got away with it in the PG era.

Advertisement