10 Most Heartbreaking Wrestling Manager Betrayals

Keep your friends closer and your enemies closer.

By John F Corrigan /

Advertisement

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.

Renowned philosopher George Santayana is credited with imparting that wisdom upon the world, urging people to learn from their mistakes. It’s a life lesson that Brock Lesnar hopefully takes to heart because there seems to be growing tension between him and his advocate.

In the weeks leading up to Great Balls of Fire, Paul Heyman commended Samoa Joe on his physical prowess and relentless brutality, two traits that would serve him well against The Beast. During the pay-per-view match, Heyman was visibly concerned as Joe took Lesnar to his limit, almost forcing the champion into submission. The next night Heyman vowed that The Destroyer would never get another shot against his client.

History has shown that when Heyman is worried about his client, fearing that he has finally met his match, the evil genius abandons his man and sides with the next big thing. Heyman isn’t the only one – it’s natural for wrestling managers to betray their clients.

Their greed consumes them, compelling them to shatter loyalty in their never-ending quest for more money and fame.

10. Mr. Fuji Turns On Demolition

Demolition had been running roughshod over the WWE tag team division during its peak, turning back the challenges of fan favorites like the British Bulldogs and the Hart Foundation. Their badass gear and overall dominance had won over many fans, but there was one thing holding them back from becoming uber-popular – their manager Mr. Fuji. Meanwhile, a monstrous force entered WWE: Warlord and Barbarian, collectively known as the Powers of Pain.

Advertisement

During a traditional elimination match at Survivor Series 1988, Mr. Fuji betrayed his team, yanking Smash out of the ring (“by accident”) for a countout. Incensed, Demolition beat down Fuji to massive cheers from the crowd. After they left the ring, the Powers of Pain helped Fuji up and brought him to their corner, signifying a new alliance. The Devious One later revealed his motivations:

Demolition returned to clear them out as Fuji later revealed his motivations: Demolition had grown too big for their britches since becoming Tag Team Champions while the Powers of Pain would be obedient to their master.

9. Rico Turns On Billy & Chuck

It was supposed to be a night of history, progression and love. WWE was holding a commitment ceremony on Smackdown in which tag team partners Billy and Chuck would become life partners. The event gained mainstream attention from LGBT activists like GLAAD, who were thrilled that homosexual characters on a popular television show would be shown in such a positive light.

Advertisement

Of course, this is pro wrestling – progression isn’t as proven a draw as preconceived notions are. It was revealed that Rico, the duo’s stylist, had orchestrated the ceremony as a publicity stunt. He knew that Billy and Chuck weren’t gay, and that they wouldn’t go through with the charade.

So he aligned with Eric Bischoff and Three Minute Warning, and ambushed his buddies as well as Smackdown GM Stephanie McMahon.

8. Bill Alfonso Turns On Taz

Fans had salivated over Sabu facing Taz for a year – it was the ultimate dream match in ECW. After Sabu returned to the company from a stint in WCW, Taz challenged him at every opportunity, begging for a match with his former partner. When they finally collided at ECW’s inaugural pay-per-view Barely Legal 1997, Taz made the scarred kamikaze submit to the Katahajime.

Advertisement

Afterward, Taz offered a handshake to Sabu in a sign of respect. However, Rob Van Dam interrupted and attacked Taz, prompting Sabu to join the onslaught. Then they set their sights on Taz’s manager Bill Alfonso, whose screechy whistle-blowing had been the last sound many opponents heard before being choked out by Taz. As they inched closer, Fonzie took his Taz shirt off to reveal a Sabu one underneath.

He supported Sabu all along, actually betting money on him to win the match.

7. Paul Heyman Turns On Brock Lesnar

In the fall of 2002, Brock Lesnar was realizing his potential as the Next Big Thing. After winning the King of the Ring, destroying Hulk Hogan and defeating The Rock to become the youngest WWE Champion ever (until Randy Orton came along), Lesnar waged war with Undertaker inside Hell in a Cell. He emerged victorious albeit with bruised ribs.

Advertisement

Instead of taking time off to heal as his agent instructed, Lesnar accepted the challenge of the Big Show. Heyman voiced his displeasure over the decision, insisting that the champion was wearing himself thin.

So at Survivor Series, as Lesnar made the cover after a stunning F-5, Heyman yanked the referee out of the ring. His eyes bulged as the Beast fumed over the betrayal and chased him into the ring, where Big Show goozled Lesnar for the chokeslam and the title.

6. Capt. Lou Albano Turns On Jimmy Snuka

On the most memorable episode of Rogers’ Corner, host Buddy Rogers invited Jimmy Snuka and his manager Capt. Lou Albano for a revelation. Rogers discovered that Albano never signed Snuka to a contract – his allegiance was a fraud. But he did embezzle all of Snuka’s money, leaving The Superfly penniless.

Advertisement

As Rogers showed Snuka the light, the Captain nervously scratched his head and tugged on his beard before slowly getting in Rogers’ face, accusing him of lying. Snuka believed Rogers and asked him to be his new manager.

As a result, Albano shoved Snuka, who responded with a right hand of his own. This led to “Classy” Freddie Blassie and Ray Stevens getting involved, as the war between Albano and Snuka carried throughout the rest of 1982.

5. Bobby Heenan Turns On Ken Patera

Ken Patera was sentenced to two years in prison after an altercation at a McDonald’s in Wisconsin. The fast food restaurant had closed, but Patera and Masa Saito were hungry. Witnesses say Patera then threw a rock through a window, which he has since denied. When police came to arrest the two wrestlers at their hotel, the villains assaulted the officers.

Advertisement

When Patera was released from prison and returned to WWE TV, he accused former manager Bobby Heenan of selling him down the river. During a televised debate, Patera aired his grievances regarding “The Weasel,” who failed to support his client in the courtroom and in prison. No phone calls, no letters, no visits. Heenan argued that it wasn’t his job to babysit and that Patera is nothing but a lowlife ex-convict.

“The Brain” claimed that Patera was a failure, always wanting a title belt but never winning one. So Heenan gave him a belt, taking his off and whipping the Olympic strongman. Patera quickly turned the tide, pounding his ex-manager in the corner and wrapping the belt around his neck. Then he tossed Heenan across the ring, his neck snapping back in a sickening visual.

4. Paul Bearer Turns On Undertaker

At SummerSlam 1996, The Undertaker faced Mankind in the first ever Boiler Room Brawl. The only way to win was to beat your opponent into oblivion, allowing you to move from the bowels of the building to the ring, where you would retrieve the magical urn from Paul Bearer.

Advertisement

After The Undertaker sent Mankind crashing from the ring apron to the concrete floor, he went between the ropes and knelt before his manager. However, Bearer turned away.

Mankind then attacked The Undertaker, locking the Mandible Claw in as Bearer slapped and stomped his former monster. It was a shocking betrayal as the morbid duo were inseparable for six years, which was too long according to Bearer, who felt that Undertaker hadn’t carried his own weight in their alliance.

3. Sensational Sherri Turns On Randy Savage

After Ultimate Warrior ended Randy Savage’s career at WrestleMania VII, Sherri was pissed. She had been the queen to the Macho King for two years, replacing Miss Elizabeth and enjoying all the spoils. Now that her meal ticket expired, she had to figure out what was next for her own career.

Advertisement

As Savage licked his wounds, Sherri blasted him with kicks to the gut, sucking the air out of the defeated warrior. Then she grabbed his hair and slammed his face into the mat. Within seconds, Savage went from one of the most despised villains to a sympathetic figure, the fans rallying behind the now-retired superstar.

His character transformation was complete as Elizabeth emerged from the crowd to toss Sherri out of the ring and reunite with her former lover.

2. Paul Heyman Turns On CM Punk

Best friends and better business partners, CM Punk and Paul Heyman were the perfect match in pro wrestling. Heyman championed Punk in developmental, recognizing his potential and fostering his passion. Punk sought wisdom and nurturing from Heyman, the only father figure the social outcast has ever had. When Punk brought Heyman in as his advocate during his legendary WWE Championship reign, they devised every scheme imaginable to keep the title.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, Punk lost the title to The Rock, and then failed to end Undertaker’s Streak. He then took a sabbatical and upon returning, ceased professional ties with Heyman, hoping to maintain their personal friendship. Naturally, Heyman saw that as a slap in the face, and decided to sever the personal ties as well.

As Punk was about to retrieve the briefcase at Money in the Bank 2013, Heyman slammed a ladder into his friend’s back. Then he stared him in the eyes, and slammed the ladder into Punk’s skull.

1. Baby Doll Turns On Dusty Rhodes

The American Dream never saw it coming.

Advertisement

After Tully Blanchard slapped his valet Baby Doll and fired her, Dusty Rhodes went to her aid. He always saw the potential she had, and knew she had just fallen in with the wrong crowd. So Rhodes took Baby Doll under his wing, and they became a beloved pair. However, Baby Doll was used to the finer things in life, fast cars and pretty clothes, and unbeknownst to Rhodes, was jonesing for the wrong crowd known as the Four Horsemen.

In August of 1986, Rhodes received a championship rematch against Ric Flair in Charlotte, North Carolina. After nearly decapitating the Nature Boy with a lariat, Rhodes made the cover. Baby Doll shocked the crowd by putting Flair’s foot on the bottom rope. Rhodes didn’t see what happened, but when he had Flair trapped in the figure four and Baby Doll once again saved Flair, he knew the fix was in.

In the aftermath of the betrayal, Rhodes delivered one of his most famous promos, calling Baby Doll a jezebel and vowing to deliver a “shameful” whooping to all the Horsemen.

Advertisement