December is finally here and a brand new year will soon be upon us. As WWE fans embark on a new chapter, they'll be inclined to wonder about what the worlds biggest wrestling company has planned for the coming twelve months... Looking back, 2014 wasnt exactly a banner year for the WWE. It began well enough, with the continuation of the excellent Daniel Bryan vs. Authority angle that (eventually) became the focal point for WrestleMania XXX. Sadly, that turned out to be an example of failing in reverse as WWE put all its stock behind the big money return of Batista (about which nobody cared) and only grudgingly got behind Bryan after they realised that he was ridiculously over with fans all around the world. From there, it all rolled downhill (and rather rapidly, it has to be said)... CM Punk decided to bugger off home, Alberto Del Rio was unceremoniously fired and the WWE Network woefully underperformed. The company placed The Ultimate Warrior into The Hall of Fame, hoping to do some nostalgia business with him, only for the former champion to die on them a few days later. The Undertaker, for his part, lost a so-so bout at WrestleMania to Brock Lesnar, after which Daniel Bryan broke his neck, The Shield were split up, 11 prominent Superstars were released from their contracts and John Cena dropped the WWE belt in a glorified squash. Ouch. Here are 10 questions that desperately need raising at the next WWE board meeting...
10. Who Is Our Next Top Guy?
John Cena has been meticulously constructed to be the star of the PG Era and, for the most part, he is. He draws reasonably well, he works insanely hard and hes a company man, through and through. Unlike previous WWE megastars, hes unlikely to leave for a rival company, retire for Hollywood fame, burnout and go home, refuse to lose when instructed to, or indulge in too many backstage prima donna moments. That said, Cenas potential as a main event talent is thoroughly maxed out now. He will never be a bigger star than he is right now and he will never draw any more than he already has. Hes always going to be at a level just below the companys all-time megastars. That isnt to trash him, just to state an inconvenient fact. Cena has been at the top of the WWE for over a decade now, which is a fact worthy of our respect, no matter what you might think of him overall. He has made A LOT of money for the Family McMahon and he has an army of young fans, eager to buy his merch and cheer him on, at every opportunity. What needs to happen now though, is the creation of a new number one; the search should be on for the next icon of this era. WWE needs to move the big belt away from Cena and stop him being the focal point for the entire company. As it stands, Cena is responsible for far too much right now anyway, which is unfair because he only appeals to one, or maybe two sectors of the overall audience. John Cena, instead of being the companys one major star, should now be sharing the limelight with other, fresher performers. So, how can WWE make the stars of tomorrow? Simple, look to yesterday...
9. How Did We Make Yesterdays Stars Into Todays Legends?
For many fans, the defining moment of WrestleMania XXX was the opening segment between Hulk Hogan, Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock. The three biggest performers in WWE history (first three of a top five rounded out by Bruno Sammartino and Andre The Giant) stood in the ring and talked, to rapturous applause. But thats all they did. They just drank beer and talked. No bumps were taken, no belts changed hands, and not a single punch was thrown. By all rights, the fans should have sh*t all over it, but instead, it turned into far and away the most entertaining segment of the night. Now, theres no question that Hogan, Austin and Rock all have something special, be it looks, charisma or talent. However, it is also fair to say that none of them would be the legends they now are if they hadnt first been pushed to the moon and back by WWE creative. Hogan teamed up with Mr. T at the height of his 80s fame, he slammed Andre The Giant in the SILVER dome and he became a household name thanks to ruling the WWE roost for the better part of a (very successful) decade. Austin, for his part, joined forces with Mike Tyson at the height of his 90s fame, beat up Vince McMahon and, as a result, ended up spearheading the much-vaunted Attitude Era by becoming the poster boy for rebellion all across The States. Of course, The Rock was the top hand in the WWE during its commercial peak, he held the WWE Championship a record-breaking number of times and his immense popularity landed him in Hollywood, where he now makes damn good money as a bankable leading man. WWE execs should go back and re-watch the making of these larger than life (now quasi-mythical) superstars. They should remember that before Hulk Hogan, there was Terry Boulder, before Stone Cold, there was Stunning Steve Austin and before The Rock, there was Rocky Maivia. Nothing happens overnight and absolutely nothing happens in a vacuum. With todays stop/start pushes plaguing WWE talent, what hope is there that the company can build another Rock, Austin or Hogan? It is time, then, for WWE creative to stop talking about promising young talent and to start thinking of them as great talents in their own right. For this, WWE needs to go old school and build stars like Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins, Bray Wyatt and Cesaro into world-beating, moneymaking machines, as opposed to simply tomorrows stars, a promise that, at the time of writing, seems destined never to deliver. How much more thrilling would 2014s Hell in a Cell Pay Per View have been if Ambrose and Rollins were fighting over the WWE Championship? (A title, which, lest we forget, wasnt even contested for at the event?) Which brings us neatly to our next question...
8. Do We Really Need Brock Lesnar?
OK, so Brock Lesnar is a former WWE Champion who was also a UFC Champion. He draws money based on his legitimacy and the fact that he is an incredibly impressive athlete. For this, WWE pays him. Handsomely. However, how much money does he really draw as an absentee champion? Are WWE even getting a return on that investment? Personally, Id have to doubt it. The companys finances took a major beating in 2014 - and all the while their Pay Per View events are not featuring their friggin World Champion, thats going to get a lot worse. Bringing Lesnar in for the occasional big money matchup (a UFC vs. WWE package, for example) makes good business sense, but building the company around him simply does not. In fact, building ANY company around a part timer is, frankly, stupid. No wonder share prices have plummeted lately; it cant all be the Networks fault. Lesnar beat the crap out of John Cena to win the WWE Championship, which did nothing but undersell WWEs top drawing card and then infuriate pretty much everybody as the champ took his belt and went home. Fans of Cena are heartbroken after watching their champ lose without any measure of payback, whilst fans of Lesnar are mad that they cant see him defend his title. Adding to that, fans of wrestling in general are furious that a part timer, with, it must be said, no real love for the wrestling business, can easily pick up the worlds premier championship belt, but apparently doesnt respect it enough to even defend it on a regular basis. Brock draws money, of course, but there was no need whatsoever to put the WWE Championship belt around his waist. Instead of seeing Bray Wyatt, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, Cesaro, Dolph Ziggler or any other upcoming star finally graduate to a top spot, we had to watch an old star take the belt home and not even bother to defend it. In what world is that best for business exactly? The question facing WWE now should be, which new star can be anointed with the blood of Brock Lesnar?
7. WrestleMania XXXI Whats Going To Happen?
A great many WWE fans only buy one Pay Per View a year, WrestleMania. The event, then, is a great way to pick up new/lapsed fans by showcasing the WWE product at its very best. WWE seems to be building towards a Cena/Lesnar main event at WrestleMania XXXI, which will likely be both predictable and bland to watch. Lesnar will be picking up a paycheque and Cena will be doing what weve seen him do hundreds of times before, winning the match with his patented five moves of doom and leaving the building as The Champ. Again. As main events go though, thats probably the best way to play it. Besides, its probably too late to do anything else now, anyway. What WWE should be doing, however, is augmenting the rest of the card with some real surprises. Lets see some NXT talent being called up to the main roster and getting to debut in front of WWEs biggest crowd of the year. Yeah, Lesnar vs. Cena might not be your cup of tea, but show me someone who wouldnt pay good money to watch Kevin Owens, Adrian Neville, Sami Zayn and others mix it up with WWEs main roster on the biggest stage of them all. A surprise win here could really make a new star very quickly, in addition to building a solid fanbase from the ground up. WrestleMania XXXI is the perfect opportunity to showcase the WWEs fresh talent reservoir, so that audiences in 2015 are pumped and primed to watch a newer, more exciting WWE product. So, what else can they do to invigorate their cards? On to the next question...
6. Whatever Happened To Tag Team Wrestling?
As WWE, of all promotions, should know, sticking two random wrestlers together does not a decent tag team make. OK, it worked for The Hart Foundation, but they were a special case. WWE keeps chucking an endless cavalcade of these frankenteams at us, like Mizdow and Rybaxel, without giving much thought to the fact that tag team wrestling and singles wrestling are two entirely different animals. Tag team matches are a vital part of any wrestling card, if only because they break up the monotony of singles contests. During the late 90s/early 2000s, WWE fielded some of the greatest teams ever seen in pro wrestling. Teams like The Hardy Boyz, Edge & Christian, The Dudley Boyz, Team Angle, Los Guerreros and Too Cool all made tag team wrestling enormous fun to watch. Today, however, aside from The Usos, how many genuinely good tag teams are really illuminating the WWE? The company should take a look at The Wolves in TNA and try to remember what a real tag team looks and feels like. Lest we forget, WWE was once home to The British Bulldogs, The Killer Bees, The Rockers, The Hart Foundation, The Legion of Doom, Demolition, The Natural Disasters and many, many more great teams; lets get back to teams like that.
5. Do We Really Need Michael Cole? (Or, For That Matter, JBL?)
Heres a fun little experiment for you to try. Take a non-wrestling fan and get them to watch a WWE Pay Per View or TV show with you. Then ask them what they liked and didnt like about it. Having tried it personally, I can say that the first thing on the didnt like list is usually the commentary. Michael Coles vintage bag of clichés just seems to sap the energy out of any match, no matter how well-executed it may be, whilst JBLs observations are never anything less than unswervingly self serving, idiotic and completely asinine. In the midst of all this is poor old Jerry The King Lawler, a genuinely entertaining colour man who rarely gets a word in these days, due to JBL and Coles ubiquitous banter (read as: talking all through the match and only ever grudgingly stopping to describe the events/serve the story being told). If I had a penny for every time Cole was gossiping away to JBL like an old maid during a pinfall attempt, only to lazily announce kickout on two after the wrestler has already kicked out, well, Id probably be able to become a majority shareholder in the company and sack the bastard myself... Michael Cole rarely, if ever, names a move and, if he does, he often gets it wrong (in fact, Taz was forever correcting him back in the day). He also fails to get across the psychology behind the move, at every possible opportunity. Not to sound like a bitter old sod, but back in the Attitude Era, Jim Ross would not only (accurately) name the moves, hed also tell you why they hurt and how they were supposed to work, whilst at the same time covering for any in-ring botches so well that only an experienced eye would ever notice them. Thats the difference between a great announcer and a guy who just likes the sound of his own voice. Commentary is a hugely important part of televised wrestling and JBL and Cole putting themselves over ad nauseum and constantly laughing at their own dumb jokes simply detracts from the wrestling and sucks you out of the story. Maybe its time for a fresh voice? ...And, whilst were on the subject of freshness...
4. Who Do The Fans Want To See On Top?
One of the great things about pro wrestling is how fan-friendly it can be. In the end, it all comes down to the fans (thats us) regarding who gets over and who doesnt. Oh, cynics can bleat that Triple Hs workout buddies get preferential treatment (and this is certainly true in some cases), but ultimately, it still falls to the WWE fan collective to give their final seal of approval to a rising star. If fan opinion didnt matter, then Lex Luger would have been a megastar. For that matter, Batista would have won the WWE Championship at WrestleMania XXX, instead of Daniel Bryan. In fact, it was the fans, NOT the office, who made champions of Mick Foley, Bret Hart, Chris Jericho and many others besides. Perhaps the biggest problem facing WWE in 2015 (from a creative standpoint, at least) is the companys apparent unwillingness to listen to their fans. The crowds are actually telling WWE creative, week after week; who they want to see on top, all WWE has to do is listen.
3. Who Needs Re-Packaging?
A lot of WWE talent is in dire need of repackaging. This has nothing to do with the wrestler becoming stale and everything to do with a problem that has ALWAYS blighted WWE, namely, that a large percentage of otherwise great wrestlers get straddled with crappy gimmicks and usually arent resuscitated in time to preserve any main event mystique. Sadly, many of us wont be at all surprised if Kevin Steen/Owens debuts on the main roster as Jackie The Flower Arranger and creative blames him for not getting over. Having said that, a lot of characters simply need some basic tweaking before they start to stagnate. Some of you will remember the way that Connecticut Blueblood Hunter Hearst Helmsley slowly morphed into the Cerebral Assassin Triple H over time, retaining his heel heat, but adding dangerous and controversial new elements to his character as he evolved. The same goes for the weenie version of Kurt Angle, the original model of Kanes character and yes, even The Undertaker. To cite just one example from the many available, the same approach could work wonders for Fandango, who is a very good wrestler and has done amazingly well with a really sh*tty gimmick. Youve got to wonder what that guy would be capable of if he were given a Shawn Michaels-esque narcissist character and told to run with it... This logic also applies to Damian Sandow, who is a hugely entertaining personality that has effortlessly outgrown his one note gimmick, also Dolph Zigger, who is rapidly losing momentum though absolutely no fault of his own. Add to the list Cesaro, Jack Swagger, Sheamus and Bray Wyatt, who, with just a little extra menace (and a few significant wins) could easily become the greatest villain of the PG Era. Look at the success that Dean Ambrose has enjoyed since his split from The Shield. Hes done some great character work all around and all that was needed was to relax the limits of his gimmick a little. This is an approach that almost always works. It worked before and it will work again. Now, onto the elephant in the room...
2. How Do We Get The WWE Network Over?
Actually, I dont really want to touch this one, but it has to be mentioned (at least briefly). The WWE Network was (and is) a fine idea, but the lack of sales in the US, together with the lack of availability in some other parts of the world, is killing it at a rapid rate. WWE needs to pull out all the stops to get the Network off the ground. Basically, whatever it takes, they need to do it. Lower prices, introductory offers, promotional gifts anything that can be done, should be done. The major problem here is that only WWE fans purchased a subscription to the Network. Wrestling is an industry in decline right now, which means that casual viewers simply arent watching, which in turn means that there are less fans all round. Casual viewers, for their part, can still watch RAW and Smackdown! on TV as part of their regular subscription package, so they arent about to spend extra money on anything they can get for free. Sure, fans like us may salivate at the prospect of watching 90s ECW treasures and 70s AWA gems, or else re-living the WWEs greatest moments at our leisure, but to the average, casual WWE fan, there really isnt much incentive to buy the Network. Maybe more exclusive content (e.g. Pay Per View events) is the answer? Who knows? Whatever they decide to do, they need to do it soon. The WWE Network needs the full support of the company and the fans and, at the time of writing, it appears to have neither. Of course, one way to sell the Network would be to make it part of a major new marketing blitz...
1. How Do We Make The WWE Product Cool Again?
Cool is good. Cool makes money. Cool draws in casual fans. Like the swing states in US politics, casual fans of wrestling are vital to the growth of the industry. The core fanbase, by which I refer to the rabid, beating heart of the business, i.e. the guys that go to indie shows, buy every Pay Per View and enjoy everything from WWE, TNA, ROH, AAA, NJPW, AJPW, IWGP, NWA (and every other set of initials you care to name) will keep the fires burning at all times, but wrestling wont get big again until non fans start watching it again. Its happened before. Hulk Hogan and a plethora of celebrities ushered in the WWEs Rock n Wrestling era with WrestleMania I, this attracted umpteen million viewers, made Hogan a household name and brought more people to wrestling than ever before. Those fans tuned out by the mid 1990s, but they returned in the late 90s/early 2000s to see stars like Stone Cold Steve Austin, Mankind, HHH, Kurt Angle, The Undertaker and The Rock. Essentially, most people love wrestling, but only when it appeals to them. The right angle can draw in casual viewers in the same way that a big fight draws people that arent boxing fans. The trick is to make wrestling cool again and get it talked about on the right TV shows and featured in the right blogs. To do that, the product needs to be cutting edge, modern and interesting once more. Cutting the crap, getting rid of the same old, same old mentality and aiming for new storylines, new characters and things weve never seen before is the best way to get people interested again. If the WWE product were promoted as the cool thing to have, people would want it again. Simple as. A talent reshuffle, a bit of re-branding and new company outlook would probably be all the WWE would need to get those profit levels flying again. Once the young talents were given the opportunity to break through at the top level, Vince would be laughing his evil laugh all the way to the bank. None of this is actually beyond the reach of WWE, which has a genuinely superb talent roster right now (ESPECIALLY if you include NXT) and more than enough money to get themselves out of this current mess, but will they make the necessary changes, or wont they? In any instance, 2015 will be a make or break year for the WWE. Well either get something new, or more of the same and whichever outcome they give us will determine the companys financial status and fan response over the coming 12 months. ...So thats it, a fans perspective on WWE, circa 2014. Thank you for reading and have a Happy New Year.