10 Most Misused Wrestlers In WWE History
Wrestlers who were way too good for what they were given.
Some wrestlers in WWE have been given characters that worked perfectly for them. The Undertaker has excelled in his role as an undead mortician, Yokozuna became a main-eventer as an evil Japanese sumo wrestler and The Million Dollar Man did well for himself as an egocentric millionaire.
Those are the lucky ones.
Others weren't so fortunate. For example, wouldn’t Brodus Clay likely have been better off had he not been cast as a overweight dancing man? Would Tensai have had better luck if he hadn’t been pushed as a pseudo-Japanese man? Sadly, they are far from the worst of it. Other wrestlers with more talent were completely wasted by the company, because they were pushed in roles not suited for them.
It often seemed so obvious to fans how a certain talent should be portrayed, but WWE creative is often left clueless on what to do. Because of that, a lot of promising careers were damaged, costing the company a lot of money.
For this list, we’re going to attempt to avoid people that were simply underutilized like a Shelton Benjamin, Tazz, Raven, etc. and focus more on people that were given a bit of a push...just pushed completely the wrong way.
Here are the 10 most misused wrestlers in WWE history.
10. Diamond Dallas Page
How he was used: An ineffective stalker and a motivational speaker.
How he should have been used: As a hardworking man of the people.
DDP was in the wrestling business for years before he got over. He was too flashy and too loud as a manager, and that weird act carried over into his early wrestling run. It wasn’t until he started acting as the everyman, the “People’s Champion” did he find his calling. Fans could relate to him as a guy who had to bust his a** for everything he had, and never gave up along the way.
That was all tossed out the window in WWE. He came in as a stalker, a guy who would harass The Undertaker’s wife and go through her belongings. It was a drastic change, and way out of character from anything we’d seen from him in WCW. It didn’t work. People wanted to cheer the star as soon as he arrived, but were forced to boo him.
Had Page came in as a good guy, with the same attitude that made him a top star in WCW, he would have had dream matches with The Rock, Steve Austin, Kurt Angle and others waiting for him. But after all the damage done to him, his highest profile match was against Christian for the European Title at WrestleMania 18.
9. The Bushwhackers
How they were used: a couple of idiots who liked to lick people.
How they should have been used: like they were as the bloodthirsty Sheepherders.
Go watch a Sheepherders match (after finishing this article, of course). Those were entertaining brawls by two stocky, shorter guys who could throw fists with the best of them. Then go watch as they morphed into The Bushwhackers. It's a bit of a minor tragedy.
Kids may have loved Luke and Butch, but try and picture watching them as adults when they debuted. Imagine an act like that going on today and not being the most hated thing in all of wrestling. It was bad casting, as no one ever took the duo seriously, despite all the blood they’d shed over the years in the business.
The Sheepherders were great, and could have been used as top-level villains in the WWF tag division against The Legion of Doom, Demolition and The Rockers. Instead, The Bushwhackers starred in a bunch of bad skits that would make Santino Marella blush.
Though it is still kind of fun to do their arm-swing walk. I’m not a complete monster!
8. Goldust
How he was used: At first creepy, then as a goofy comedy act.
How he should have been used: Kept creepy.
WWE had it right when they first created the Goldust character. An androgynous, bizarre character that was one-of-a-kind, and years ahead of its time.
Much like The Undertaker, it’s a gimmick that could have evolved with the times and taken on different forms. Goldust could have been an upper mid-card act, one that occasionally enters the main event scene to put over a top babyface.
WWE sadly made The Bizarre One do comedy. WWE comedy. As in really, really bad comedy. As soon as that happened, Vince McMahon was infatuated with him. He loved the stupid humor, and besides a brief heel run in 2002, Goldust's character has progressively gotten dumber.
He’s had tourettes, he’s teamed with Booker T and R-Truth, married Aksana and yet, through it all, somehow improved as a worker in his 40s. Not that he's given much of a chance to show off his in-ring work these days.
Dustin Runnels is good at whatever he does, there’s no doubt about that. But he could have been worth so much more to the company if they could have just got over their need for awful, embarrassing humor on a weekly basis.
7. Doink
How he was used: A creepy, diabolical clown turned happy, fun loving clown.
How he should have been used: Always a creepy clown. ALWAYS!
There is no such thing as a non-creepy clown. It doesn’t exist. Even Ronald McDonald has haunted the dreams of children around the world for decades. So it should come as no surprise that no one was going to cheer a clown in a professional wrestling setting.
The WWE didn't just turn Doink good, though, they went all-in on making him an insanely obnoxious goofball, and teamed him up with a group of smaller wrestlers. It was like sitting on a whoopee cushion filled with s**t.
Matt Osborne was brilliant in the role of Doink, but when he departed, he left very big, floppy shoes to fill. Still, that doesn’t mean you turn the character face! Either retire the act, or find someone else who can handle being evil.
I may be the only one who believes this—but much like Goldust—I think that Doink could have been a character for years, evolving with the times in various forms just like The Undertaker did. Maybe that sounds absurd, but if a zombie can last for over two decades in the business, then a clown could have at least enjoyed a few more years in the spotlight.
6. Scott Steiner
How he was used: as a babyface.
How he should have been used: as a heel.
It’s as simple as that. Steiner returned to WWE in 2002 a new man. He’d grown a long ways as a performer since he was last in the company with his brother Rick in the mid-90s. He was now Big Poppa Pump. Your hook up. Holler. If you hear him.
Now, despite how good Steiner was in WCW his last couple of years there, he was going to have a hard time making things work in his new home due to some serious foot problems he was having. Like barely able to move one of his feet type problems. But when he came in as a face to wrestle Triple H, it was pretty much doomed from the start.
No offense to Scott (seriously, don’t hurt me!), but the man is 100 times better at playing a bad guy than a good guy. His rambling, off-the-cuff, scary promos work much better as a villain. However, it took the company nearly 10 months to turn him heel, but by that point he was stuck with Test in a lousy tag team.
This isn’t a case of hindsight being 20/20. This was an obviously bad decision at the time, and made all his freaks out there a bit sad. No one could hear their hollers for help.
5. Harley Race
How he was used: first as “Handsome” Harley Race, and then a king.
How he should have been used: A badass brawler.
At the time Harley Race joined the WWF, they didn’t acknowledge the accomplishments of wrestlers outside of their company. Unlike today where A.J. Styles and The Club are noted for their work in Japan, Race essentially came into the WWF as a new wrestler. Still, that doesn’t mean he needed to become a cartoon.
After Race won King of the Ring, he dropped the “handsome” part of his act and went full-on royalty. It was silly, and a role not fitting for someone of Race’s history and stature. There were other ways to make him a star.
One of Hogan’s most successful opponents was Andre the Giant, who didn’t rely on a ridiculous gimmick to drum up big business. He was just a huge dude that seemed impossible to beat. Race should have been booked similarly, in that he didn’t need a gimmick to fight.
He simply should have been booked as he was: one of the toughest men in the business.
4. Kurt Angle
How he was used: Usually a comedy goofball, or a chickens**t heel. When he was turned face, he was largely a serious act.
How he should have been used: As the toughest fighter on the planet.
Not everyone is going to agree with this pick, but Kurt Angle should not have done so much comedy. Yes, he was good at it. DAMN good. But WWE went too far with it. Angle is a once-in-a-lifetime talent. He’s an Olympic gold medalist, who became a great in-ring wrestler faster than just about anyone in history, and could also cut great promos.
After Angle’s initial heel run ran its course, it was time to make him a top face for years. But he kept flipping back and forth, and despite being one of the toughest men on the planet, he was made to look like every other ineffective, terrified for their life, heel on the roster.
Angle is one of the top stars of the business over the past couple of decades, but with the right protection (like not wearing a mini cowboy hat), he could have been near the level of Austin and Rock as a top babyface.
3. The Big Show
How he was used: A lovable goofball giant, or a menacing monster...depending on what day of the week it is.
How he should have been used: A special attraction who wrestles a handful of times each year.
Perhaps no wrestler in the entire industry right now induces as much apathy in the fan base than The Big Show. Seeing him is simply tiring. He’s been in over 900 televised matches in his career, and that’s hundreds too many.
When Vince McMahon signed Paul Wight in the late '90s, he had huge hopes for him. He wanted him to be his next Andre the Giant. He should have pushed Show like him then.
Andre was a special attraction. He worked in territories all over the world, but he wouldn’t stay in any for too long. His size was his act, but if you saw him all the time he’d feel ordinary. Even in the WWF, you would only see him a few times a year on TV. That was due to the company putting out less content, but also because Vince wanted to protect his stars and make people pay to see them in big matches. It added to their aura.
Big Show just shouldn’t have been a full-time act. He would have been more valuable showing up a few times a year to take on the top babyfaces in big money matches, or being in tag matches with top faces to chase away some heels.
It’s actually pretty incredible that both WCW and WWE took this larger-than-life athlete and made him feel completely ordinary.
2. Shane Douglas
How he was used: The dean of a college.
He he should have been used: Like he was in ECW.
Everything about Dean Douglas was completely idiotic on every conceivable level. Whoever came up with his act deserves detention...in hell! Okay, maybe that's a bit too far. But there were still many issues with this act.
First off, what college has a 31-year-old dean of the school? What dean dresses in a graduation robe? How could one possibly be the dean of a school and be a full-time wrestler? And most importantly, why give that stupid gimmick to the talented Douglas?
In ECW, Shane Douglas revitalized himself as a character. He became one of the best talkers in the business, and grew to be a solid worker. In the WWF, all of that was looked over. He briefly won the Intercontinental Title, but only to pass it from one Kliq member to the next. And boy, did they ever hate Douglas.
Even in Shawn Michaels first book, he went out of his way to bury Douglas, saying that you just couldn’t get a good match out of him. Odd that he didn’t take the same digs at other opponents of his like Sid Vicious, or Mabel or Yokozuna.
Well, whatever the deal was with Douglas and The Kliq, it got him out of the company quick. A shame, as had he stayed, he likely would have excelled in the company’s Attitude Era. You can only imagine how much money his enemies and his atrocious gimmick cost him.
1. Dusty Rhodes
How he was used: A fat dancing man.
How he should have been used: The everyman. The son of a plumber in all of us.
Vince McMahon could have brought in Dusty Rhodes as a legend. He could have mentioned his years in the business, and made it seem like they picked up the best free agent out there. Rhodes was, after all, one of the most famous wrestlers on the planet at that point, and had millions of fans. People knew who this guy was.
If the company didn’t want to acknowledge that, at least give him a similar gimmick to what got him over and let him go from there. It didn't happen.
Vince never admitted it, but it seems likely that he was trying to punish Dusty for all the years he competed against him. Or at least he wanted to show him who had all the power now. So instead of main event matches against Hulk Hogan, or cast as the No. 2 babyface in the company, Dusty was given Sapphire as a manager, dressed up in polka dots and portrayed as a mid-card goofball.
Money and time well spent!