10 Most Painful-Looking Wrestling Matches Ever
Here comes the pain.
A note on the criteria:
What follows is ghoulish, horrific even, but it must involve some level of cooperation. This list doesn't cover gruesome shoots, for no reason beyond a desire to never again sit through something like Yoshiko's harrowing battering of poor Act Yasukawa in the infamous, über-distressing Stardom Incident of 2015. Act looked like a hammerhead shark in the aftermath. It wasn't a match, nor should it have been. Once it became apparent that Act was in no position to defend herself - and that Yoshiko had no intention of curbing the onslaught - an official should have intervened. There was more than enough time in which to do so. This was no flash flood; it was a sustained deluge of disgusting punishment that called an end to a career brimming with potential. That criteria doesn't preclude receipts, pro wrestling's ironic way of maintaining that cooperation, lest things turn uglier.
Does it f*ck preclude receipts.
What follows is the work of mad men and women willing to truly suffer for their art - art that at its most visceral and so subjective certain members of the old guard would chew you out, motherf*cker, for deifying it as such.
"Painful-looking" is a worked title, really, which is more than can be said for the matches that follow...
10. Vader Vs. Ken Shamrock - WWF In Your House 15: A Cold Day In Hell
This wasn't Ken Shamrock's first rodeo; the World's Most Dangerous Man made the transition from the UFC to the WWF by way of the Japanese shoot-style scene. His journey to the work rooted in the shoot, it's little wonder his first major pay-per-view encounter unfolded as it did.
It unfolded thusly: Vader effectively beat the shoot out of Shamrock by beating the sh*t out of Shamrock in a remonstrative lesson. This was no JBL-style bully boy posturing designed to welcome the new kid into the fold; gauging by the squeals Vader emitted in the opening minute, he needed to smarten Shamrock up for the sake of his poor bloody legs, battered as they were by Ken's formally educated feet.
Though perhaps not as stiff as the most infamous snug snafus in the Land Of The Rising Sun, it's Shamrock's legit credentials that purse the lips here. He wasn't a pro wrestler doing pro wrestling harder than most; this was a very dangerous combat athlete not too far removed from his fighter prime. There was a good match here, underneath the infamous, rough-around-the-edges facade; in one great welcome to wrestling spot that served the story tremendously, Vader, his nose bloodied, unleashed a gruesome front suplex from canvas to the floor.
Shamrock did not accept the invite, instead pummelling Vader's face in with such hard knees and fists that the Mastodon, red mist descending in tandem with the red stuff, sent Shamrock flying with a brutal forearm.
9. Katsuyori Shibata Vs. Tomohiro Ishii - NJPW G1 Climax 2013
The narrative of this match was so primal, so completely genius, that it's a wonder no two performers stumbled upon it earlier.
Consider it a simple, untapped chord progression excellent in its simplicity; Shibata and Ishii - serving the major stakes of the tournament in which they fought - emerged immediately from their respective corners as if confronted by their mortal enemies, as opposed to predetermined opponents with no prior personal grudge.
It was modern New Japan's equivalent of the classic irresistible force versus immovable object dynamic.
Shibata played the irresistible force, running the full length of the ring to deliver a huge big boot with the angled shape and cutting impact of a shuriken. Ishii played the immovable object, his legendary ability to absorb punishment carved on this seminal night.
This dynamic could only manifest as a mutual war of attrition somehow fought at warp speed, like pro wrestling's version of Don Frye Vs. Yoshihiro Takayama. It was also oddly, delightfully polite. Ishii and Shibata encouraged one another, patiently, to hit the other as hard as they f*cking could. And Shibata, Jesus Christ, could hit hard: his low corner dropkick almost removed Ishii's scalp.
Ishii took it all. He screamed in the face of punishment, almost blacking out at one point, this unsurpassed selling ability hooking the molten crowd, making them feel it as much as he did.
8. Yumiko Hotta Vs. Aja Kong - All Japan Women's Pro Wrestling January 24, 1994
Joshi fans were long accustomed to the hands-to-open-mouth sight of Aja Kong, in her role as a kawaii-killer, mercilessly knocking f*ck out of her more slender and more beautiful opponents. This night served as a retribution of sorts - a retribution delivered so emphatically that it made one question our inner moral compass.
The referee frantically wedged himself between Hotta and Kong immediately, putting over the clear and present danger. It was a gesture steeped in irony; as soon as he created separation - imagine Michael Cole calling this - Kong scrambled Hotta’s brains with a spinning back elbow. What’s so frighteningly immersive about this match is that it cared not a thing about traditional narrative, consequently separating the audience from any notion of fiction.
This beast didn't “build”.
Kong grabbed Hotta by the hair, within the first minutes, and didn't telegraph her piledriver through the table with any theatrics. She didn't ask the audience to register what she was about to do. She just did it, and because she didn't hurt Hotta to her satisfaction, she threw a chair directly into her face.
More piledrivers followed. More shots to the face delivered with the audible thwack of a watermelon imploding on concrete. In an attempt to gain some sort of advantage - there was some strategy within the guts - Hotta smeared her own blood into Kong’s eye. It didn't work; Kong was relentless, kicking Hotta’s face in with the zeal of a psychopath.How it was possible to feel sympathy for Kong, after all that, was a mystery. And yet, when Hotta, firing up, did well not to kick Kong’s head off, you do.
It rendered the viewer a spluttering, squealing, head-shaking, guffawing mess, at once gripped, delighted and utterly disgusted with oneself.
7. Big Van Vader Vs. Stan Hansen - NJPW Super Fight In Tokyo Dome
Even without its notorious, nausea-inducing injury, Stan Hansen vs. Big Van Vader merited inclusion here.
Hansen threw his burly frame behind lariats with the force of a godd*mn madman. He was also virtually blind, adding another layer of unhinged danger to his super-realistic strand of the pro wrestling art. In the opposite corner, Big Van Vader was another big, stiff gaijin b*stard of the sort that held nothing back to put their immense physicality over to the Japanese audience. Inevitably, this was more a meeting of two stags on the plain than a simulation of combat, not least because it was barely a simulation. Hansen circled and shoved Vader away like an old, threatened predator. From there, it was proper big b*stard stuff, all pie-faces, overhead punches and jaw-rocking lariats.
With that injury, its brutality became mythical. Vader could only remove his mask, not to see what was in front of him - that might not have been possible - but to attempt to push his eye back into its socket and hold it in place by the lid.
Vader didn't stop; he and Hansen simply battered the f*ck out of each other by ringside before disappearing into the crowd like two surly patrons in a bar fight, holding no interest in the moment in doing anything but batter the f*ck out of each other.
6. Mitsuharu Misawa Vs. Kenta Kobashi - Pro Wrestling NOAH Navigate For Evolution 2003
The series between Mitsuharu Misawa and Kenta Kobashi is more famous for its genius than its stiffness, and is naturally overlooked in that specific regard. This climactic encounter in particular is best remembered for its incredible, passing-of-the-torch finale years in the making, built towards superbly with a battling, career-best babyface performance from the greatest in-ring babyface of all time.
It also looked like it really, really hurt. Likely because it did really, really hurt; Kobashi and Misawa, to their physical and mortal costs, left everything in the ring.
Misawa crotched himself throat-first on the guardrail attempting his elbow suicida in the sort of bump of you yourself can just feel; Kobashi took advantage with a crunching half-nelson suplex to the floor. In a crucial moment reinforcing their grand history, Misawa, as he always did - he was the Ace, Kobashi the perennial underdog - went one better by hurling Kobashi neck-first from ramp to ringside matting with a disgusting tiger suplex. In great camerawork, the director panned to a shocked, standing spectator, unable to register what he had just witnessed.
Mirroring everybody, he could not process the death-defying extent to which these two legends went in the name of the GHC Heavyweight Championship.
5. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind - WWF Hell In A Cell 1998
An enterprising masochist, Mick 'Mankind' Foley knew he stood little chance of bettering the performance of Shawn Michaels at In Your House: Badd Blood. That match entered the canon of classics in part through a flailing, athletic, stamina-driven performance in which he sold for Undertaker as if he were a relentless and indestructible horror movie villain.
This was beyond Foley. (Un)fortunately for him, he was beyond rational thinking.
Foley could barely climb the Cell, such was his knackered physical condition. 'Taker joined him, creating a sense of pure dread. There was only one way down, and a man of Foley's reputation never climbed down from anything. Still, there was something inevitable and inconceivable about the iconic moment that followed. It was something so harrowing that to this day, it feels wrong to watch it. It shouldn't have happened. It wasn't wrestling. And yet, adding to the paradox, it was awesome to watch on the most base, repugnant human level imaginable. The moment didn't need JR's seminal sell-job but - Bah Gawd! - did he put over the agony of Foley's plight. He compelled somebody, anybody, to stop the d*mn match.
Despite the moral protests of several key critics and veterans, in the thrill of the moment, nobody really wanted Foley to climb down from the cage a second time; his searing, unfathomable pain was our poison.
4. Vader Vs. Cactus Jack - WCW Saturday Night, April 24, 1993
Making his third appearance on the list, this is perhaps the most unholy of the violent Vader trinity.
Bad things happened when Cactus Jack and Vader shared a ring. Bad, incredible things. Jack lost his ear in a match held one month prior to this in Germany. Some six months later, they wrestled - fought/survived - an incredibly punishing war at Halloween Havoc. This match was something beyond even one of the stiffest, most painful-looking ever; it was a veritable video nasty that triggered the broadcasting network to censor its most infamous moment, in which, after his manager Harley Race peeled back the ringside matting, Vader powerbombed Jack onto exposed concrete after several minutes of the sort of sadomasochism Vader and Jack called a pro wrestling encounter.
Nothing detracts from the unspeakable power of the moment.
You can see Vader's right hand attempt to gently control Jack to the floor, but it hardly mattered. He took a back, neck and back of the head-first bump onto the most unforgiving surface manufactured by man. In its aftermath, rather than portraying him as a figure of guts and sympathy, he was repackaged as an amnesiac goof.
WCW.
3. The Belfast Bruiser Vs. Lord Steven Regal - WCW Uncensored 1996
Again: painful-looking is something of a misnomer.
There's something almost pointless about the sheer extent to which Finlay and Regal stiffed one another here. The near-silence to which the action was received magnified the lip-pursing pain of it all. This wasn't an endorphin rush shared between performers and audience, one that allowed us to reconcile the violence in some way. This wasn't two wrestlers finding a cushioned sweet spot with which to create only a slight illusion of audible pain. This was two men exchanging potato shot after potato shot which, in addition to the laborious hold after laborious hold, distanced themselves from the audience that could barely see the very real violence to begin with. Only on the pay-per-view stream was the stiffness apparent - but those actually watching at home, with no heat, couldn't immerse themselves in it either. It endures as a strange curio.
It's also really long and arduous, adding to the headache, resonating as a stubborn and self-indulgent attempt to bring British wrestling to the U.S. that undermines itself.
2. Shawn Michaels Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin - WWF WrestleMania XIV
Think about how much of a prize ar*ehole Shawn Michaels was at the dawn of the Attitude Era.
This was a man who thought nothing of destroying career after career; in fact, he laughed about it with his Kliq buddies, and turned into an even uglier person when he was without them at the midpoint of 1996. He completely derailed plans to return the biggest favour ever paid to him by a fellow professional by refusing to drop the WWF Heavyweight Title back to Bret Hart at WrestleMania 13, while having the audacity also to seek sympathy. He had lost his smile. Most would have been happy to see it wiped off his face, were it actually. It wasn't. He cried crocodile tears.
And still, equipped with that knowledge, one couldn't watch his belated Title loss to Steve Austin at WrestleMania XIV without a degree of the empathy Michaels himself once lacked entirely. His back mangled following the Royal Rumble '98 casket bump once thought to have ended his career, he fought through searing pain to wrestle a match that by his standards was somewhat subpar. It was still very good, but it was more than that: it was a karmic rebalance in which he endured physical agony as penance for the psychological warfare he had waged against the locker room. Just look at that propulsive, thunderous bump in the above GIF, knowing the state his back was in.
If you don't wince, you're either inhuman, or Bret Hart.
1. Samoa Joe Vs. Necro Butcher - IWA Mid-South Something To Prove
This does count as a pro wrestling match, as best we can tell. It was a cooperative exercise in performance art. At some points, both men ran the ropes.
Elsewhere, this was the most infamous match of an infamous career. Necro Butcher, more avant-garde performance artist than pro wrestler, used light tubes in his other matches. He took DDTs on barbed wire boards. He took curb stomps, throat-first, on standing chairs. He took ladders to the back of the head. Broken beer bottles sliced across the forehead. Apocryphally, he also once considered chopping his finger off, with the intention of preserving it in ice for the post-match trip to a local medical facility.
And yet, this match was appreciably more disturbing, for its jelly-brained, concussive aura and gladiatorial atmosphere. The incredible work of Samoa Joe, with his brow furrowed more in anxiety than intensity, lent it a sense of realism in comparison to Necro's other, more convoluted stunt shows.
The opening seconds were incredible; Necro and Joe, to put this over as lawless horror show, laid waste to the ref before piling into one another's faces with sick forearms. Necro ran the ropes; Joe responded with an enzuigiri. Why bother slapping the thigh when, to create the necessary audible impact, you can simply crack, with full-force, the back of the head?
Blood spilled as the action spilled to the floor. Migraine-inducing headbutts were thrown, as were chairs, and chairs, and chairs, directly into Joe's face. Necro didn't take moves "properly", putting this over as something distressingly none-too-real. He didn't rotate when taking body slams and overhead suplexes, instead choosing to absorb the impact on his crimson-soaked forehead.
The commentary team legit squealed for the full ten minutes, like kids swarming a fight, because that is precisely what it was.