10 Most Shocking Wrestling Squash Matches

Squash matches can be one of the most shocking parts of wrestling, whether they are good or bad.

By Marc Callow /

Squash matches are an economic way of telling stories and are often more of an angle than a wrestling contest. The device is often used to profile a new character against unknown jobbers or wrestlers lower down the card. At their best, a squash match can be a shocking way to put over a superstar in a way that is dominant and convincing.

Advertisement

The most recent example of this occurred when Jon Moxley shocked the world by defeating CM Punk in a quick and brutal match to unify the AEW World Championships. Moxley came out of the match looking like the megastar that he is, whilst Punk sold the effects of his foot injury to perfection. Like many squash matches, it received a mixed reaction from fans, but their rematch at All Out in Chicago was all the more exciting because of it.

There is an art to getting a squash match right, as not all of them are good or even purpose-serving in the long run. When done well, such bouts are guaranteed to be shocking and serve to create a great deal of interest in a feud.

10. Kofi Kingston Vs Brock Lesnar - WWE SmackDown 2019

KofiMania was a phenomenon in 2019 that rewarded one of WWE's hardest working performers with an overdue World Title run. Kingston's WrestleMania match with Daniel Bryan was one of the best in the company's recent history and was so emotionally charged that it was always going to be hard to continue the momentum after the win.

Advertisement

Kofi's reign as WWE Champion struggled because it peaked at WrestleMania 35. Lacklustre feuds against Dolph Ziggler, Samoa Joe, and Randy Orton throughout the summer made it clear that his reign had not been a success. However, the way that the company decided to relieve the Ghanaian superstar of the WWE Title was unforgivable, as he was unceremoniously squashed by Brock Lesnar in just seven seconds.

Whilst it was clear that this title reign had not worked out, having the New Day man be embarrassed without so much as an offensive move on Lesnar was insulting. It left many fans clamoring for Kingston to get some retribution on the 'Beast Incarnate,' but that would never come.

It is not the first time that Brock had obliterated his opponent, but it was perhaps the most egregious case of it.

9. The Undertaker Vs The Great Khali - WWE Judgement Day 2006

Considering the stature of The Great Khali, it is unsurprising that in the late-2000s Vince McMahon was eager to push the monster straight to the top of the card. Khali won a series of quick matches against the likes of Funaki, Matt Hardy, Scotty 2 Hotty, and reigning World Heavyweight Champion Rey Mysterio, who he squashed in a non-title match in Rey's hometown of San Diego.

Advertisement

The 'Punjabi Nightmare' was being primed for a feud against the biggest star in the company at that time - The Undertaker - despite his clear in-ring limitations. Given how protected 'The Deadman' was at the time, it was shocking that Khali defeated him in a very convincing way at Judgement Day 2006. The decision to have the giant effectively squash 'Taker clearly wasn't one that was well thought out, as injuries and poor booking proceeded to cool Khali's momentum substantially.

The giant would become World Heavyweight Champion a year later, but even then it was clear that he wasn't effective in that position. The early commitment to his character was not capitalized on and Khali became yet another failed superstar during the Ruthless Aggression Era.

8. Honky Tonk Man Vs Ultimate Warrior - WWE SummerSlam 1988

The Honky Tonk Man does not have the typical legacy of an Intercontinental Champion, as he was not a revered in-ring technician nor did he go on to be a main event star in WWE. However, his record-breaking 64-week run with the title remains iconic today as it is the perfect example of a midcard belt being used effectively.

Advertisement

Stars such as Randy Savage, Ricky Steamboat, Jake Roberts, and Brutus Beefcake were all unsuccessful in trying to pry the title away from the cowardly heel, who frequently abused his right as champion by defending the title under a countout or disqualification loss. This method of booking was very much a product of the time, when touring and live events were more important than television, so repeated use of cheating wasn't as aggravating.

Wrestling fans were dying for someone to take the coveted belt from the Elvis wannabe and the stage was set when he issued an open challenge for the title at SummerSlam 1988. The Ultimate Warrior answered and the rest is history, as the face-painted superstar squashed Honky Tonk Man in just over half-a-minute to end his 454-day reign as champion.

7. Daniel Bryan Vs Sheamus - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII

On paper, a match between Daniel Bryan and Sheamus would be great at any point in their careers, but WWE did not seem to care about this. The promotion will tell you that Sheamus' victory over Bryan in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII kickstarted the 'Yes Movement', but this simply is not true. It was a poor decision that tried to undermine the 'American Dragon' as a future superstar in the company and beyond.

Advertisement

Bryan only overcame this booking because he is one of the best wrestlers of all time and was able to work his way to the top despite WWE's insistence on keeping him as a 'B+ Player'. Not only was he squashed in such a pathetic way, but it was also the end of his first World Title reign, which was underwhelming in itself as he only got to face giants such as Big Show and Mark Henry.

Luckily, Bryan was able to win multiple WWE Championships and go on to have a legendary career despite being frequently booked poorly. The WrestleMania squash would only be a speedbump for him, but it was still a shockingly poor decision from the company.

6. Bob Backlund Vs Diesel - WWE Madison Square Garden House Show 1994

One of the more peculiar returns in wrestling history was when the second longest reigning WWE Champion of all time, Bob Backlund, returned to the company after almost a decade. The star of the late-'70s and early-'80s looked like a relic amongst younger stars of the New Generation Era such as Razor Ramon, Shawn Michaels, and The Undertaker.

Advertisement

Because of this, it was very surprising that Backlund managed to capture the WWE Championship for a second time by defeating Bret Hart for the accolade. 'The Hitman' was the biggest star in the company at the time, and having the veteran defeat him was not a popular decision at all, particularly since there were so many young talents waiting to be pushed to the top.

The way that Backlund lost the title was even more shocking, as he only held the title for three days before dropping it to Diesel at a house show in Maddison Square Garden. In hindsight, it is clear that this was a transitional title reign to give Kevin Nash his first World Title in WWE. Still, pushing the old timer to such a position seemed needless given that there were plenty of capable heels on the roster.

5. John Cena Vs Brock Lesnar - WWE SummerSlam 2014

Brock Lesnar's prolonged squashing of John Cena at SummerSlam 2014 is a great example of how to make a superstar look dominant without completely undermining their opponent. Over the course of 16 minutes, Lesnar dismantled Cena as 'Big Match John' tried to repeatedly get back into the match but couldn't, as he was soundly defeated for the WWE Championship.

Advertisement

The match was a great way to continue Brock's dominant run after ending Undertaker's streak at WrestleMania 30 a few months prior. It was a nice subversion of expectation, as fans thought the match would be far more evenly contested given that Cena had always been protected to the point of frustration for many. The fact that the 16-time World Champion was so giving to his opponent made the bout feel different from any other main event WWE produced at the time.

Lesnar would go on to have a dominant run over the next half a decade whilst Cena moved into his Hollywood career, which may make the result of the match look more believable in hindsight. However, the match still goes down as one of the most shocking main events in the company's history.

4. Yokozuna Vs Hulk Hogan - WWE WrestleMania IX

WrestleMania IX is viewed by some as one of the worst 'Manias in the event’s history, and it marked a dramatic decline in WWE's quality after its golden period of the late-'80s ended. This was embodied in the main event, which was meant to be a WWE Championship match between Bret Hart and Yokozuna. Whilst this underwhelming match did occur, it ended up not being the final bout on the card.

Advertisement

Enter Hulk Hogan, who had lost a tag team match against Money Inc. earlier in the night alongside Brutus Beefcake. The Hulkster was upset that his 'friend' Bret Hart had been screwed by Yokozuna's manager Mr. Fuji and accepted an impromptu match with the new champion for the belt. After about 20 seconds and a leg drop, Hogan was WWE Champion for the fifth time.

The whole fiasco was designed to try and push the company's business forward again with another round of Hulkamania, but it just served to discredit the movement toward younger stars in the company. Hogan would leave the company not long after and join WCW to ignite the Monday Night Wars, which only made WrestleMania IX seem even more farcical.

3. Brock Lesnar Vs Goldberg - WWE Survivor Series 2016

As previously mentioned, Brock Lesnar has been a part of many high-profile squash matches during his WWE career to varying degrees of quality. Almost all of these dominant displays have been dealt out by Lesnar, but there is one example of the opposite happening when Goldberg returned to face him at Survivor Series 2016.

Advertisement

The pair last faced each other in both men's final match in WWE during their first stint with the company at WrestleMania XX. It was one of the worst matches in the event's history and was booed out of the building as fans knew about the impending departures of the two superstars.

After over a decade, the pair would try again to put on a memorable match for the right reasons - and they succeeded! Goldberg running through Lesnar in less than two minutes is one of the most shocking wrestling decisions of all time, and it was a smart one. Brock was in unstoppable form going way back to when he returned to the company in 2012, but the former WCW Champion humbled him in an abrupt fashion.

The whole feud between the pair throughout 2016-17 was great and was worth Goldberg coming out of retirement for in itself, even if it did go downhill from there.

2. Cody Rhodes Vs Brodie Lee - AEW Dynamite 2020

One of the most shocking moments in wrestling over the past decade was when Mr. Brodie Lee demolished Cody Rhodes for the TNT Championship on a special Saturday edition of AEW Dynamite. To that point, Cody had been defending the newly established title in open challenges which helped establish the belt as an exciting new facet of AEW's programming.

Advertisement

The 'American Nightmare' had defended his title over the likes of Jungle Boy, Sonny Kiss, and newcomers such as Eddie Kingston and Ricky Starks. Every week throughout the summer of 2020, Cody's TNT Title defenses were the most exciting parts of the show and it was leading to somebody being put over huge when they finally defeated him for it.

The former Luke Harper had just unsuccessfully challenged Jon Moxley for the AEW World Championship and looked likely to do the job for Rhodes, too. This was not the case, as Brodie ran through the the TNT Champion in just over three minutes in one of the best segments the company has ever produced.

It transformed Brodie Lee into a huge star and helped cement his legacy in the promotion as the greatest TNT Champion of all time.

1. Kevin Nash Vs Hulk Hogan - WCW Nitro 1999

The Finger-poke of Doom endures as one of the worst booking decisions ever, and in no small part contributed to WCW's demise. The ultimate swerve was also by its very definition a squash match, as the contest between Hulk Hogan and Kevin Nash did not last long at all.

Advertisement

The leaders of the nWo Hollywood and Wolfpac factions were in cahoots the whole time, reuniting the faction as one big happy family all together once again. It goes without saying that it was outrageously stupid to have a main event title match go down in such a way, and would be only one of many twists WCW would try and book to no success.

To understand the foolishness of the decision, it is perhaps best to imagine the same thing happening today with any of the World Titles across WWE or AEW. It would be comparable to Seth Rollins lying on his back for Roman Reigns because they had agreed to do so beforehand given that they both used to be in The Shield together. Even if this occurred in the main event of RAW or SmackDown, fans would be livid as WWE would not have produced something they had promoted. Of course, when have they ever done that...

Squash matches should have unwilling victims on the other side of them, not big stars who agree to it like 'Big Sexy' Kevin Nash.

Advertisement