When WWE announced that they were bringing Tough Enough back for airing in June, it excited the WWE Universe because we know what we're going to get with Tough Enough. It's a reality TV show that is a competition where one or more people will earn WWE contracts. In the upcoming sixth season of Tough Enough, it was announced that one male and one female will be given WWE contracts. Any reality TV show is questionable in terms of what's real and what's fabricated. We all know that. However, there's something cool about Tough Enough because we get to see these guys and girls put their bodies on the line during their training to be WWE superstars. We will get to see them taking bumps in the ring to see who has what it takes while also seeing who might quit when the pressure is on. The first three seasons of Tough Enough aired on MTV from 2001-03, then fourth season was a part of the Smackdown brand in 2004 and the fifth season took place on USA Network in 2011 with the Hall of Famer Steve Austin in the role as the host. We don't know who the new host will be, but it will apparently not be Austin. Those of us that have watched Tough Enough know that just because somebody wins a season doesn't mean they are going to have a successful career. Some of the winners had such short careers that we can barely remember who they are or why they were winners. In fact, the first four winners (Maven, Nidia, Linda and Jackie) all had short careers in wrestling, so they're not among the best former Tough Enough contestants. Who are? Let's figure that out. It's time to look back at WWE's five seasons of Tough Enough look back at the most successful alumni from WWE's original reality show.
10. Son Of Havoc And Ivelisse
Tough Enough History: Season Five Not all Tough Enough alumni have made a name for themselves in WWE. Since WWE either misses out on talent or people just choose to move on, there are other success stories too. If you watch Lucha Underground with any regularity (you should if you are not) then you know who Son Of Havoc and Ivelisse are. They were introduced as a couple with Ivelisse working as a valet for Son Of Havoc, but also wrestling against the guys as well. Son Of Havoc was known as Matt Cross when he was on the fifth season of Tough Enough and even though he had been wrestling for about ten years, he was the second person eliminated. It was a surprising exit for him. Steve Austin simply said that he didn't show them enough. It was ridiculous that a veteran like him would be out before some people on that show who had no business being in the ring (Rima Fakih comes to mind), but that's the way it was. As for Ivelisse Velez, she was the seventh person eliminated due to a leg injury. WWE liked her enough to sign her to a developmental deal in 2011. She worked as Sofia Cortez there, but was released less than a year later. A lot of people were surprised at the release since she has talent. She worked the indies before landing with Lucha Underground in 2014 and she is doing a great job there. Since she's only 26 years old, perhaps that WWE door will be open for her down the road. Another former Tough Enough season five contestant, Martin Casaus, also appears in Lucha Underground although he's mostly just there to put people over. He's not in a featured role. They aren't the only former Tough Enough performers that are a part of Lucha Underground either.
9. The Boogeyman
Tough Enough History: Season Four The story of The Boogeyman's start in WWE is a funny one. He was one of the eight finalists chosen for the fourth season of Tough Enough (the one held mostly on the Smackdown brand in 2004) and after he survived an elimination he admitted he was really 40 years old. The cut-off age for the competition was 35 years old, so he was eliminated after that. Even though he lied to WWE about his age, they still liked him enough to sign him to a developmental deal at the age of 40 and he debuted on Smackdown in 2005. It's one of those things where WWE wanted to debut this Boogeyman character for whatever reason and he's the guy they picked for the role. If you watch him wrestle you can see that he was always pretty mediocre in the ring and almost never had a good match, but the gimmick worked. He was a babyface that was able to make the crowd cheer because they loved watching him spit worms in the faces of his rivals. It was gross, yet entertaining at the same time.He had some memorable moments in his WWE career like when he bit the "mole" off Jillian Hall's face or beat Booker T at WrestleMania 22. Not that many Tough Enough contestants can say they beat a WWE Hall of Famer at a WrestleMania, but the Boogeyman can. The Boogeyman is still used by WWE at times since he was a part of WWE Axxess at WrestleMania this year and also attended the Hall of Fame while wearing black headgear to cover his face because he's a guy that really lives the gimmick.
8. Josh Mathews
Tough Enough History: Season One Josh Mathews was on the first season of Tough Enough. He made it near the end, but ultimately wasn't chosen to be a WWE superstar because as a 5'9" 150 pound guy he just wasn't big enough. About a year after the show, he signed with WWE as an announcer. He had a really long run as an announcer in WWE starting from 2002 to 2014. There's no other Tough Enough contestant that worked for the company longer than him. He did all kind of announcing work for them as a studio host, a backstage interviewer, calling matches on less important shows like Velocity, NXT, Superstars, Saturday Morning Slam and others. https://youtu.be/KmXBOIQFhOc Mathews also became a lead announcer on Smackdown and appeared on Raw doing commentary at times too. There were also times when WWE put him in physical altercations where he would get beat up because he had that wrestling training and could take those bumps. In June 2014, he was released by WWE because for whatever reason they probably didn't feel like he was going to be some long term announcer for them. Maybe he wanted out. He signed with TNA shortly after and these days is their main announcer. He actually did all of the commentary on TNA Impact last week since Taz left the company. Mathews is an example of a guy that started on Tough Enough and was able to use that experience to do something completely different in WWE.
7. Kenny King
Tough Enough History: Season Two The second season of Tough Enough is the one that most fans consider to be the worst ones because they chose the wrong winners: Linda Miles and Jackie Gayda. Kenny King should have been one of the winners. It was one of those decisions that confused viewers because we figured they would pick one male and one female, but then they went with two females that really didn't impress that much in training. It was an odd choice. For whatever reason, WWE wasn't interested in signing King. Based on talent, he clearly deserved it. Perhaps they felt like he was too small, so maybe they thought they didn't need a guy like that. It was one of those decisions that surprised a lot of people because he had so much potential. King went on to have a pretty good run in Ring of Honor from 2007-12 where he won the ROH Tag Team Titles. After his ROH days were over, he moved on to TNA Wrestling where he's still competing as part of their top heel stable The Beat Down Clan. He's earned a reputation as a very good in-ring worker that's also very charismatic and can have good matches with anybody.
6. Cameron
Tough Enough History: Season Five If you want to look at the most unlikely Tough Enough success story, look at current WWE diva Cameron, whose real name is Ariane Andrew. The fifth season of Tough Enough had 14 contestants and she was the first one eliminated. There was a famous moment in that season where Steve Austin famously asked her what he favorite match in wrestling history is and she said..."Melina and Alicia Fox." That led to a hilarious, stunned reaction from Austin and her lack of knowledge of wrestling probably led to her early dismissal.For whatever reason, WWE remained interested in her and she's the only person from that season that has a WWE contract. She filled a role as a Funkadactyl with Naomi as dancers for Brodus Clay at the start of her career. Then she turned heel on former friend Naomi, so that gave her more of a spotlight. She has also been a part of Total Divas since day one although she's apparently not going to be featured on the next season. She's only 27 years old and has shown some improvement in the ring in the last year, so as long as she keeps trying she could be a Divas Champion one day. Even if that doesn't happen, she has gone farther than a lot of people expected when she was on Tough Enough four years ago.
5. Chris Nowinski
Tough Enough History: Season One It was pretty obvious when watching season one that Harvard graduate Chris Nowinski was going to get a WWE deal whether he won the season or not. He finished third, but was signed by WWE developmental soon after. His in-ring career in WWE started in 2002 and they gave him the gimmick of a Harvard jock type character that bragged about how he was smarter than people as well as being more athletic. It was believable because as a 6'5" 260 pound guy he pulled off the gimmick well. He actually only wrestled for about a year and retired in 2003 due to concussion-like symptoms. The reason he's mentioned here is not necessarily because of his work as an on-air performer. It's what he did after WWE when he helped to form the Sports Legacy Institute that has done phenomenal research on head injuries for athletes. He's done a great job of raising awareness for this huge issue while also getting people in American football, hockey, pro wrestling and other sports to agree to donate brain tissue after death. It's not always about what you do on camera that makes a difference. Nowinski has had a huge impact in sports because of his work in dealing with those with head injuries. He's a huge Tough Enough success story or that reason.
4. Matt Morgan
Tough Enough History: Season Two Matt Morgan is one of the biggest Tough Enough contestants ever. He's a legitimate seven footer that was a former basketball player, so he had the body type that WWE loved. He had to leave season two of the show due to an injury, but WWE liked him enough to sign him to a developmental deal and he was a part of WWE for the next three years. It didn't work out for him WWE, but there's really nobody to blame. It was just a case of a young guy that still had to develop. When Morgan got to TNA in 2007, he really showed a lot of improvement. Within a few years, he became a very good all around performer that was capable of having good matches and delivering confident promos too. He was in TNA for about six years and they probably should have put the TNA World Title on him, but it's TNA and they suck at making right decisions like that. A lot of fans that followed the product closely know that guys like him were the ones they should have pushed and they didn't. It's why they are where they are now. Morgan retired from full time wrestling after the birth of his son in 2014 because he said he wanted to be there to raise his boy. That's pretty admirable. He had a career he should be proud of. Just because he didn't spend the majority of his career outside of WWE doesn't mean he failed at all.
3. Ryback
Tough Enough History: Season Four Ryback, whose real name is Ryan Reeves, was a part of Tough Enough's fourth season. He was a pretty big guy when he was on the show from over a decade ago. He finished third place on the season and that impressed WWE officials enough that they signed him to a developmental deal in March 2005. He spent nearly five full years in and out of WWE's developmental system before finally catching on as part of The Nexus, but then an injury kept him out when that group started to take off. He was repackaged as Ryback following WrestleMania 28 in 2012 and has had a secure spot on WWE's roster ever since. Ryback has done pretty well for himself in WWE, going as far as main eventing several PPVs in the fall of 2012 against WWE Champion CM Punk. He fell short in his attempts at winning the WWE Title thanks to shady referee Brad Maddox and also the debut of The Shield. His heel turn post WrestleMania 29 in 2013 led to two WWE Title matches on PPV against John Cena, so at least he can say he feuded with top guys at various points of his career. Now 33 years old, Ryback has a shot at possibly becoming a main eventer again although it may be tough since WWE has a talented roster these days. Ryback is proof that you don't have to win Tough Enough to have a career in WWE. He took a very long road to get there, but where he is now is exactly what he wanted when that journey started in 2004.
2. John Morrison
Tough Enough History: Season Three winner The man whose real name is John Hennigan is most known for performing in World Wrestling Entertainment as John Morrison. He actually started out as Johnny Nitro in WWE on the main roster in 2005, then in 2007 became John Morrison until he left the company at the end of 2011. Since he's been out of WWE, he has tried his hand at acting, but also still wrestles in the indies and is featured prominently in Lucha Underground as Johnny Mundo. He was a co-winner of season three along with Matt Cappotelli, who unfortunately was diagnosed with a brain tumor and forced retire from wrestling although he's living a normal life these days, so it's great to know he's doing okay. In terms of in-ring work, Morrison is probably the best performer out of all the Tough Enough contestants. He's an incredible athlete that can have great matches with anybody and really became a popular wrestler because of his aerial skills. He showed those skills off in his early days of Tough Enough too. He kept working at it, built up his body and came very close to being a main event guy in WWE. He actually did take part in some main events, but not in a one on one match. Part of the reason he left is likely because it was tough to break through to the top. His Tough Enough tryout tape is actually pretty funny to watch all these years later.As mentioned, you can watch him on Lucha Underground as Johnny Mundo where he was brought in as one of their most well known stars and a babyface that has had several great matches on their shows. A WWE return for him may not happen again now that he's in his mid-30s, but if it does then most likely WWE fans would be happy to see it. He was always popular with the fans. Morrison is the best winner in Tough Enough history, but he's not the biggest star in the history of the show. That honor goes to one of his former tag team partners.
1. The Miz
Tough Enough History: Season Four runner up. If you have been following the career of The Miz then you know that he didn't have it easy after signing a developmental deal with WWE. He worked hard to get out of developmental and when he made it on the main roster he had to endure some rookie hazing too, so to speak. When he was on Tough Enough he already had a lot of reality TV experience because he was part of MTV's Real World series, so he was very comfortable on camera from the start. He ended up finishing second in season four of Tough Enough because they chose Daniel Puder, who definitely had more of the look of a wrestler, but lacked the charisma that Miz had.The Miz is the only Tough Enough contestant that can say that he main evented a WrestleMania and that's been the WWE Champion. Whether you think he deserved it or not (CM Punk, how you doing?) will never erase the fact that he was in the main event of WrestleMania 27 against John Cena. It seems unlikely that he will ever get to the top again, but he did deserve it and earned the right to be there. It would be smart for WWE to involve The Miz in the new Tough Enough in some way just because of his history as part of the show although as a heel character they might want to keep him away from it. Give Miz a lot of credit for showing that somebody can go from being a reality TV star to being a top guy that is the most successful Tough Enough star that there's ever been.