10 Most Underrated ECW Revival Championship Matches

Not everything about WWE's ECW revival was completely terrible...

By Graham Matthews /

Once ECW's popularity soared to levels that couldn't be ignored, Vince McMahon gave into the fans' demands in mid-2006 when he relaunched the promotion as a third WWE brand. Unfortunately, it never came close to matching the magic the original ECW created. From the debut of The Zombie to Mr. McMahon winning the ECW Championship to the disastrous December To Dismember pay-per-view, there were several signs that indicated the ECW experiment was doomed to fail, and frankly it came as no surprise when it ultimately. did. In February 2010, ECW closed its doors to make way for a "groundbreaking, original show," NXT. By then it no longer served a purpose as WWE's signature "C-show", but it still had its redeeming qualities, focusing less on the hardcore elements and more on the future, providing a platform for up-and-coming stars such as CM Punk, Sheamus and Jack Swagger. Seasoned veterans including Christian and Matt Hardy were also given a chance to revitalize their careers and prove they could still hang with the young guns, and the result was some of the best (and often underrated) matches in WWE from 2007 to 2010. It's time to relive those glories...

Advertisement

10. CM Punk vs. John Morrison vs. The Miz (Survivor Series 2007)

Long before dropping a "pipebomb" on WWE and embarking on the longest WWE Championship reign in the modern era, Punk got his first taste of gold in the form of the ECW Championship. He captured the strap from John Morrison in September 2007, repelled all challengers including The Miz at Cyber Sunday. But The Chick Magnet continued wasn't to be dissuaded, earning another shot at the gold at Survivor Series. Also around this time, Morrison made his return to WWE TV after serving a 30 day suspension and immediately reentered himself into the title picture. Despite Miz and Morrison winning the WWE Tag Team Championship together days before the event, it was every man for himself in the ECW Championship Triple Threat match. It wasn't a great match by any means, but it was certainly solid; moreover, Miz was able to showcase his skills as a singles competitor for the first time, while Punk and Morrison carried most of he match. In the end, the Second City Saint overcame the odds to emerge with his title intact.

9. Matt Hardy vs. Jack Swagger (Royal Rumble 2009)

Upon his arrival in ECW in September 2008, Jack Swagger was touted as a "wrestling prodigy," quickly living up to the hype by racking up wins against Tommy Dreamer, Ricky Ortiz and Finlay. Then, undefeated in singles competition, he convinced ECW general manager Teddy Long to grant him an ECW Championship match, and he and Hardy did battle on the Jan. 12 episode. Following an impressive showing from Swagger, he pinned the seasoned veteran to capture the gold. Hardy's championship pursuits were not yet over, however; he insisted on invoking his rematch clause at the 2009 Royal Rumble pay-per-view only two weeks later. At the event, Hardy and Swagger contested an even better bout than they had previously, filled with close counters and suspenseful nearfalls. Despite his best attempt to win back the belt, The Man Who Will Not Die fell short of victory, keeping Swagger's undefeated streak intact. And with their feud officially finished, Hardy went on to turn on his brother Jeff later that same night.

8. Matt Hardy vs. Evan Bourne (Cyber Sunday 2008)

There was arguably no one hotter on the ECW roster in 2008 than Evan Bourne. After making his debut on the brand that June, he went on to win over the audience with his breathtaking finishing maneuver, the Shooting Star Press. In the months that followed, he gradually built a fan following, culminating in him being chosen as one of three potential opponents for then-ECW champion Matt Hardy at Cyber Sunday. Unsurprisingly, Bourne won the poll, beating out Finlay and Mark Henry by 69 percent of the fan vote. The most interesting aspect of Hardy vs. Bourne was that although it pitted two fan favorites against each other, the live crowd sided with Bourne for most of the matchup; of course, part of that was due to Hardy played the heel in the match by constantly rolling out to ringside and shutting down Bourne's offense at every turn. Nevertheless, it was the young gun's first true test as to whether he could hang with the very best, and he passed with flying colors. Bourne came close on several occasions to winning the title, but Hardy's experience earned him the advantage and ultimately the victory. It was on this night that the master of the Shooting Star Press proved to the masses that he was more than just an adrenaline junkie; he was an amazing athlete ready to make an impact.

7. Christian vs. Ezekiel Jackson (Royal Rumble 2010)

Aside from a brief run as Intercontinental champion in 2011, Jackson's six year stint with WWE was rather forgettable; however, his best work came during his time on the ECW brand. As one-third of The Ruthless Roundtable along with William Regal and Vladimir Kozlov, he was protected in most of his matches, but also had the opportunity to work with some of the best, including Christian. While they crossed paths on occasion in late 2009, it wasn't until Jackson was pushed as Regal's prime pupil when he officially moved into a feud with Christian. After becoming the No. 1 contender to the gold with a win in an ECW Homecoming Battle Royal, he was set to contend for the gold at the Royal Rumble pay-per-view. It remained to be seen how well Jackson would fare against the seasoned veteran, but to the surprise of many, he held his own, resulting in an excellent opener. Christian's offense was smooth and fluid, and although Jackson was unsuccessful in winning the title, he looked strong in defeat. As history would have it, the final ECW champion's impressive showing on this show was among the few decent matches he had in his WWE career.

6. Christian vs. Zack Ryder (ECW: September 22, 2009)

Much like with Ezekiel Jackson, Zack Ryder was never taken seriously as an in-ring threat before he arrived on ECW, especially when he started working with Christian. Having spent his entire career as a tag team wrestler, Ryder was separated from his longtime partner Curt Hawkins following his move to ECW in the 2009 WWE Draft. Nothing about him during his time as an Edgehead showed he could survive on his own, but to his credit, he completely reinvented himself upon his arrival in the Land of Extreme. Now known as The Long Island Iced Z, he sported an all-new look with unique attire and spiked hair, making himself stand out from the rest of the roster. Although it took time for him to get noticed, Ryder finally came into his own when he won a Battle Royal on the Sept. 15 edition of ECW to become the new No. 1 contender to the ECW Championship. He may not have been seen as a threat before the bout, but he definitely changed fans' perception of him by the end of the matchup with Christian. The leader of the Zack Pack took him to his absolute limit, forcing him to pull everything out of his repertoire in order to put him away. Even in defeat, Ryder proved he was worthy of a shot at the spotlight, later leading the Ryder Revolution to prominence in 2011 and capturing the United States Championship.

5. Christian vs. William Regal (ECW: November 10, 2009)

During his record-setting reign as ECW champion, Christian defended against all opposition in the Land of Extreme, but his greatest challenge came in the form of one William Regal. Sure, both were past their prime at this point in their respective careers, but they could still deliver a better match than a good portion of the roster. They proved that in their ECW Championship clash at Breaking Point, and although Christian emerged victorious, Regal's title aspirations were far from over. In the months that followed, Regal continued to target the champ, often letting loose his henchmen Vladimir Kozlov and Ezekiel Jackson on him. After a while, he agreed to grant the evil Englishman one last shot at the gold on the Nov. 10 edition of ECW, which would emanate from Regal's home turf of England. Despite the home field advantage for Regal, the momentum was constantly shifting between the two Superstars with every nearfall each of them got over the other. Regal came his closest to winning the gold on that night, but evidently not close enough; Christian planted the former Raw general manager with a Killswitch to score the victory and keep his title run going strong.

4. ECW Championship Scramble Match (Unforgiven 2008)

At the time of its inception, no one knew what to expect from the Scramble match, and in retrospect, it was a total flop because it was never used again (with the exception of one instance in 2009) after 2008's Unforgiven event. What fans tend to forget, however, is that the Scramble match contested for the ECW Championship was actually quite good and the best of the three that night. For those unfamiliar with the concept, the Scramble match consisted of five Superstars entering the ring at a set time interval. Whoever scored a pinfall or submission victory would be named the "interim" champion, and whoever the interim champ was by the end of the match was recognized as the official title holder. As convoluted of a concept as it was, the Superstars of ECW managed to make it work to the best of their ability. Among the combatants in the ECW Championship Scramble match were The Miz, Finlay, Matt Hardy, Chavo Guerrero and defending champion Mark Henry. While it may look like a random cast of characters on paper, they all actually had great in-ring chemistry with one another. Miz had an impressing outing, Henry played the role of the dominant powerhouse well, Guerrero was able to show off his skills, Finlay was his usual great self and Hardy was the underdog babyface everyone wanted to win. In the final few minutes of the bout, Hardy covered Miz for the three count, and in breaking up several pinfall attempts by the other participants, he ended the matchup was the official, and new, ECW champion.

3. Christian vs. Jack Swagger (Backlash 2009)

Following a three year absence from WWE, Christian made his long awaited return to WWE on ECW in February 2009. Although it was initially seen as a "punishment" in the eyes of the fans, going to the Land of Extreme ultimately ended up being the best thing for him. On the main roster, there's no doubt he would've been lost in the shuffle within a few months, whereas he was able to make ECW his own all the while mixing it up with (and putting over) younger talent. From the instant he debuted on ECW, Christian had his sights set on Jack Swagger and the ECW Championship he was holding. He put out a championship challenge to the winner of the title bout between Swagger and Finlay at No Way Out, which ended up being Swagger. On the Feb. 23 edition of ECW, they clashed with the title on the line, and even though the self-proclaimed wrestling prodigy came out on top, Christian wasn't going to give up just yet. In April, Christian won a "Championship Chase" to become the No. 1 contender to the gold yet again at the Backlash pay-per-view. Not only was their match as good as the first two times they faced off, it was better. It meant more now that Captain Charisma had to work his way back up, and Swagger had his first truly great match against him. The fans were really starting to buy into Swagger as the brand's top heel, and to top it all off, he had the perfect babyface foil in Christian. After a hard-fought battle, Christian outsmarted Swagger by allowing him to run face first into an exposed turnbuckle, capitalizing with the Killswitch to score his first taste of WWE gold in nearly five years.

2. Christian vs. Shelton Benjamin (WWE TLC 2009)

Making the list for the fifth time, Christian really was the saving grace of WWE's ECW in its final year. From William Regal to Ezekiel Jackson, he could be counted on to have a good match with essentially anyone on the roster. Arguably, though, his toughest challenge as champion came at the inaugural WWE TLC pay-per-view where he was set to defend his ECW Championship against Shelton Benjamin in the ever exciting Ladder match. It may have felt like the long awaited matchup between these two came five years later than it should have, but you would have never known from watching this match. Even at 36 years of age, Christian could still deliver at the top of his game, while Benjamin was among the most skilled (and underutilized) athletes on the entire roster. Not only that, but both thrived in the Ladder match environment; thus, it was a recipe for success. Both seasoned veterans put it all on the line in the night's opening bout, throwing caution to the wind all for the ECW Championship. Despite getting busted open early on in the contest, Christian persevered and refused to give up; that's how much importance the ECW title had to him. Benjamin, on the other hand, was looking to prove he was worthy of being a champion, and he did just that by pulling out all the stops. In the end, Christian ascended the ladder to maintain his possession on the prestigious prize, setting the bar for every other match on the card that was forced to follow.

1. CM Punk vs. John Morrison (ECW: September 4, 2007)

Unquestionably the biggest star to come out of ECW, Punk debuted on the brand in August 2006 and fought an uphill battle his entire time there. After solidifying himself as a legitimate threat to the title, he entered the ECW Championship picture the following summer, chasing John Morrison for the belt. Punk came close to winning the strap during each of their encounters, but Morrison always found a way to come out on top. Although they were both great on their own, they never produced the best of matches together. Whether it was lack of in-ring chemistry or just time constraints, their matches on pay-per-view were never any good. However, when the Second City Saint was given one last shot at the gold on the Sept. 4 edition of ECW, something clicked. Perhaps it was the suspense from knowing this could finally be the night Punk won the big one (word had already gotten out Morrison was suspended for 30 days for violating the Wellness Policy). Whatever it was, it enhanced the match significantly, making this not only the best bout they ever contested but the best ECW Championship match in WWE history. As Punk hoisted Morrison up on his shoulders for the Go To Sleep, the Cincinnati crowd rose to their feet in anticipation for what was about to happen. As he connected with his signature maneuver and covered him for the three count, the fans in attendance exploded in elation. After a near year long journey, his quest to capture the title was finally complete, and was the first of many monumental moments in the illustrious career of CM Punk. Which other ECW matches