10 Most Unmemorable Title Reigns In WWE History

If a wrestler wins a championship, and no one remembers their reign, did it ever really happen?

By Jacques Martin /

'If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?' is a question philosophers have pondered for centuries.

Advertisement

In a similar vein, the modern wrestling fan is faced with an equally complex question: 'If a wrestler wins a championship, and no one remembers their reign, did it ever really happen?'

Thankfully, at least for the folks who have held said titles, there are records on the internet and video evidence that supports their championship claims. That being said, for a variety of reasons, there has been no shortage of forgettable WWE title runs over the last few decades or so.

In truth, particularly in the case of secondary titles, one could make a strong argument that there have been far more lackluster reigns than memorable ones — in recent years, especially.

Moreover, memories vary on a case by case basis, thus making this the sort of topic that invites contrarians to chime in with, 'I remember his or her title reign.'

Contrarians aside, the ten title runs we are about to discuss, all qualify as extremely forgettable.

10. Shinsuke Nakamura (Intercontinental Championship)

Sure, we all remember Nakamura was Intercontinental Champion. After all, his reign just ended last July. However, the run itself was completely forgettable.

Advertisement

Of course, one of the key ingredients to a memorable title run is defending said title. WWE had Nakamura put the IC strap on the line so infrequently, during this 201-day reign, that it was sometimes difficult to remember that he even held it in the first place.

To illustrate the previous point, when he finally dropped the gold to Braun Strowman on SmackDown, it had been 105 days (over half the length of his championship run) since the last televised intercontinental title defense.

Due in no small part to bad booking, Nakamura's WWE career has been on a fairly steady decline since his WrestleMania 34 WWE Championship match with AJ Styles. Moreover, the I.C. title has been an afterthought for the better part of the last two decades (if not longer). When one considers these two factors, it's easy to understand why this fairly lengthy championship run isn't one we'll be talking about in the coming years.

9. Antonio Inoki (WWF Martial Arts Heavyweight Championship)

It's difficult to have a title reign for the ages when no one can actually remember the title you held. Even an international legend like Antonio Inoki couldn't salvage the long-defunct WWF Martial Arts Heavyweight Championship.

Advertisement

Inoki's battles with legends like Muhammad Ali and Andre the Giant have become the stuff of wrestling lore. However, his not so epic showdown with Texas Red (aka Red Bastien) for the Martial Arts Heavyweight title, most certainly has not.

The Martial Arts Heavyweight strap was created to help give Inoki credibility in North America, which it didn't really do.

His initial reign with this long-forgotten title lasted for a whopping 3,780 days. Of course, he only defended it a handful of times.

In Japan, the championship was contested in MMA-inspired exhibition bouts. In North America, the belt was defended (albeit rarely) in traditional pro wrestling matches against lesser-known performers.

The title, which was launched in 1978, was done away within 1989, much to the dismay of absolutely no one.

8. Layla (WWE Divas Championship)

There are some memorable title reigns that produce legendary matches and feuds, thus helping elevate both the performer and the title itself. Conversely, there are also championship runs that are so awful, despite their best efforts, fans simply cannot forget them. However, it's the area in-between these two extremes where most forgotten championship runs are found.

Advertisement

Layla's post-LayCool, 140-day reign as WWE Divas Champion is an excellent example of a non-descript run that really didn't help or hurt anyone.

In truth, it's a bit unfair to single out Layla. After all, most of the Divas Champions during this time period (2010-14), like Eve Torres and Kaitlyn for example, were mostly just place holders who kept the division afloat.

Sure, the former Diva Search winner eventually became a serviceable in-ring performer and was fairly charismatic. Still, like most of her contemporaries, the ex-champ's run atop the division was seriously lacking in the highlight department and didn't have enough lowlights to stand out either.

7. Ezekiel Jackson (Intercontinental Championship)

With Antonio Inoki, we had a well-known performer who was saddled with an ill-conceived, mostly forgotten title. In the case of Ezekiel Jackson's Intercontinental title run, there's an established belt around the waist of a performer who only hardcore wrestling fans will likely remember.

Advertisement

Jackson was the type of prototypical musclebound, big man WWE highers ups tend to salivate over. However, despite his impressive appearance, the former champ's mic skill left something to be desired. Moreover, WWE's decision to prematurely turn him into a babyface, instead of keeping him as a monster heel (a role he was better suited for) further accelerated his career demise.

Ezekiel Jackson's mostly forgotten 51-day reign as Intercontinental champion was nothing to write home about. If it isn't the case already, in the not too distant future, young wrestling fans will be looking at a list of I.C. titleholders and asking, 'who was this Ezekiel Jackson guy?'

6. Taka Michinoku (WWF Light Heavyweight Championship)

In truth, one could make a strong argument that there weren't any particularly memorable runs associated with the ill-fated WWF Light Heavyweight Championship.

Advertisement

However, Taka Michinoku's reign stands out for a few reasons. He was the inaugural champ, he held the title for almost a year, and he was actually an underappreciated in-ring performer (at least in North America).

If Michinoku debuted in WWE today, based on in his in-ring ability alone, the Japanese standout would, at the very least, have your standard cult following of fans to complain about his lack of a push.

Still, it's hard to deny that, despite having some solid matches, most people can't name more than two wrestlers Michinoku faced during his 300-plus days as champion.

Sadly, more fans remember the first WWF Light Heavyweight Championship for his role in helping to attempt to castrate Val Venis, then they do for his matches with Brian Christopher and... whoever the hell else he wrestled.

5. Jinder Mahal (WWE Championship)

The reason most people remember Jinder Mahal even held the WWE Championship is that folks were critical of the promotion's decision to hand him the strap. This criticism stemmed in part from the fact that, in a relatively brief period, Mahal transitioned from being a border-line enhancement talent to holding the richest prize in the game.

Advertisement

Still, regardless of the decision, 'The Modern Day Maharaja's run as WWE's top dog didn't exactly produce a ton of great moments. Truth be told, there aren't any classic feuds or iconic segments associated with one of the more unlikely WWE Champions in recent memory.

It's fair to assume there aren't a ton of fans out there who are frantically searching the WWE Network to watch Mahal take on Baron Corbin or relive the not so highly anticipated return of the Punjabi prison match.

Sure, bad booking was partially to blame, but that often comes with the territory.

4. Rico And Rikishi (SmackDown Tag Team Champions)

Remember that time, back in 2002, when Rikishi and Rico were tag champs, for around two weeks? Yeah, didn't think so.

Advertisement

One of the interesting things about reading through the lists of former titleholders is quite literally re-discovering completely forgotten names. For the most part, we've talked about champions with forgettable runs with their respective belts.

However, there are also cases where longtime fans may have quite literally forgotten that a certain performer (or performers) ever even held a particular title in the first place. The WWE tag-team division probably has more examples of this phenomenon than any other. Some of these examples include duos like Spike Dudley and Tazz, along with Billy Kidman and Paul London.

As for Rico and Rikishi, the two men captured the tag titles at a Judgment Day pay-per-view and held them for 16 days. They would eventually drop the straps to Billy and Chuck, who, for better or worse, were most certainly memorable.

3. The Headbangers (Tag Team Champions)

The Headbangers' gimmick very much felt like an older, out of touch person's take on the modern heavy metal fan of the time.

Advertisement

If nothing else, the skirt wearing duo of Mosh and Thrasher were at least memorable characters. They also were fortunate enough to be around during a period in which WWE's tag division was very shallow.

The duo would eventually capture the vacant tag titles at a 1997 In Your House pay-per-view event. They held the straps for about month, before losing them to The Godwins (a team that could probably also be featured on our list), thus ending one of the many forgettable tag title reigns of that particular period.

To be fair, the two men were saddled with a gimmick that had little to no upside. You could make a strong argument they overachieved to a degree.

2. Steve Blackman (WWE Hardcore Championship)

For much of its existence, the WWE Hardcore Championships was a comedic title that was passed around from wrestler to wrestler, on an almost weekly basis.

Advertisement

One of the men who had multiple lengthy reigns as hardcore champ was 'The Leather Weapon' Steve Blackman. In fact, the martial artist turned sports entertainer held this less than prestigious strap for 89 days, at one point in 2000.

However, there are a couple of reasons no one really remembers or talks about Blackman's hardcore exploits. First off, 'The Lethal Weapon' was not one of the Attitude Era's most charismatic performers, to put it mildly.

Moreover, by the time 2000 rolled around, fans had already seen plenty of wrestlers hit with kendo sticks and less than durable looking garbage cans. In other words, the novelty of WWE's brand of hardcore wrestling was beginning to wear thin.

Still, WWE decided to keep the title around for another two years or so, before unifying it with the Intercontinental Championship in 2002.

1. The Basham Brothers (Tag Team Champions)

The Basham Brothers were two (kayfabe) siblings that were originally supposed to be part of some sort of S&M gimmick with their valet Shaniqua.

Advertisement

This trio had little chemistry and WWE never really did much with the whole S&M angle. Honestly, the team ended up coming across as a couple of generic dudes in black leather pants, who generated little response from the crowd.

Still, for whatever reason, WWE decided to give them a run as tag team champs that would last 105 days. They defeated Los Guerreros for the straps in October 2003 and would eventually drop them to the team of Scotty 2 Hotty and Rikishi a few months later.

The fact that they held the titles for over 100 days, and are largely forgotten tag team, is somewhat remarkable.

The two men would go on to become members of The Cabinet (a stable run by JBL) and later Paul Heyman's bodyguards, before ultimately being released in early 2007.

Advertisement