10 Most Unprofessional Performances In AEW History

Not doing the job: it's not just about refusing to lay down...

By Michael Sidgwick /

The worst bad faith analysts will tell you that AEW is in a state of systemic dysfunction, and that Tony Khan lacks the spine and the leadership to fix it. 

Advertisement

They’d be…half-right, sadly. 

Tony Khan is fickle, or can be fairly accused as much; the identity of his promotion seems to shift depending on who is applying the most pressure at any given time. If the fans are in a state of despair at the sports entertainment overtones, Khan will book something like the Continental Classic as a PR move. Conversely, if a certain wrestler - let’s call them Chris J…no, that’s too obvious, let’s say C Jericho - wants to do more sports entertainment-leaning angles, you’ll see a sports entertainment angle that week. 

Khan deserves a bit more credit than that; he, for example, brought the fight to Warner and gifted fans the wonder that is Mark Briscoe: major cable television star. Still, there’s a sense that ‘Mid-South Tony’ could do with using a bit of the old Bill Watts discipline. 

The following performances were very compelling for those addicted to the wrestling backstage drama cycle, but, ultimately, were very far from ideal…

10. CM Punk Goes All Out

CM Punk actually praised Hangman Page during the Double Or Nothing 2022 post-show presser - which took place, obviously, after Page had buried him in a promo segment designed to build the match. 

Advertisement

It was only when Punk broke his foot on the subsequent episode of Dynamite that his mood seemed to darken. He was venomous even by his standards upon returning, very shortly after which he called out Page, labelled him a coward, and demanded a public apology. 

In what was surely a premeditated rant, Punk, infamously, created the 21st century equivalent of the Montreal Screwjob at the All Out press conference: a company-defining event after which nothing was the same. 

Despite Dave Meltzer and Sean Ross Sapp each clarifying in the aftermath that they’d never discussed the rumour with a single member of the Elite, Punk unleashed a furious (and frankly unbelievably compelling) rant. He said that Elite were children who played games with the media in a bid to discredit his name, and that he was not responsible for Colt Cabana’s near-exit from AEW/Ring of Honor. Countless AEW sources are adamant that he was, but Punk’s conviction is such that he could convince you that the earth is flat. 

Punk, granted, probably wasn’t to know that you’d all still be talking about this almost two years later - but he knew what he was doing. With this wild, selfish outburst, he dragged AEW into disrepute. He portrayed the promotion as a complete sh*t-show. The stigma remains. 

AEW, the gossip cycle, hell, pro wrestling itself: nothing has felt the same since.

9. Ivelisse Downs Tools

A parent would much rather their toddler scream down the house than enter the dreaded mode of pure stillness. 

Advertisement

At least when they’re cranky and overtired, a parent knows that the child will eventually surrender to sleep. That, or they’ll eventually concede that they’re hungry. When they enter a stubborn state of virtual catatonia, oh boy. You can’t do anything.

Parents worldwide knew the feeling when Thunder Rosa attempted to apply a seated full nelson on Ivelisse on the September 10, 2020 Dynamite. After a deeply awkward and stiff affair, Ivelisse simply stopped working. She sat there, with an incredibly apathetic expression on her face, staunchly refusing to do anything, much less convey that she was in a position of peril. 

It’s one thing to refuse to do a job - but it’s quite another to refuse to do your job slap bang in the middle of a match. 

She looked bored at the prospect of maintaining the illusion - in refusing to act out her profession, for those brief but damning moments, she literally epitomised the unprofessional. 

8. Jon Moxley Doesn’t Care About Full Gear

Jon Moxley is a genuine soul who cannot allow himself to do something that he doesn’t want to do. 

Advertisement

This is an enviable quality, particularly for a babyface. When he’s dialled in, Jon Moxley is an electrifying, authentic experience - all too rare in an often formal and homogenised pro wrestling landscape.

Conversely, when Jon Moxley isn’t into something, it’s very obvious, and very distracting. If the character doesn’t give a toss about what’s happening in a story, the audience can’t, either. 

Ahead of Full Gear 2022, MJF was either in or being courted by the Firm stable - the purpose of which was rendered pointless when CM Punk was suspended. The idea that the Firm was to influence the World title match was a red herring designed to obscure the William Regal turn. It was all a bit unwieldy, and got in the way of MJF Vs. Mox II as a big-time one-on-one PPV attraction, and Mox seemed baffled - and disinterested - by the mysyery storyline.

On the go-home Dynamite, MJF and Mox met face-to-face - and the latter was so bemused that it was unprofessional. He barely bothered to unpack the story, speaking in a low, detached way, and wondered aloud what day the pay-per-view was scheduled for. Saturday? Sunday? 

He didn’t care - but his job was to make you care. 

7. Hangman Page Blindsides CM Punk

CM Punk is adamant that he had nothing to do with Colt Cabana’s near-exit from AEW. Virtually everybody else is adamant that he did. Nobody can ever determine what really happened, with 100% certainty, but those in the latter camp must have watched on with a wry smile when Punk - reportedly - banned certain people from various Collision tapings. 

Advertisement

He didn’t exactly cover his tracks there. 

Regardless, Hangman Page shouldn’t have blindsided him on the May 25, 2022 Dynamite. 

On one level, it was admirable that Page - through the use of subtext, anyway - stood up for his friend. He risked his reputation, against a very popular wrestler with an intensely committed fan base, to do what he felt was the right thing by somebody completely expendable. 

This remains a doubly unprofessional act. He failed his collaborator in CM Punk, who was at a loss for a response. The “You talk a big game about worker’s rights…” line was not approved. 

Moreover, while it probably didn’t impact the buys for Double Or Nothing, until the reports emerged months later, nobody knew precisely what the on-screen story between CM Punk and Hangman Page was. The audience could infer it, but at the time, they were baffled and unmoved. 

Page did not a thing to clarify why they were fighting - when that was what he was being paid to do. 

6. CM Punk Buries Hangman Page (Again)

AEW Collision was a compromise about which few were happy, and to underscore that, neither was the star of the show. He knew as well as everybody else that the pseudo soft roster split was untenable. 

Advertisement

It was nonetheless the perfect imperfect situation for CM Punk, if that makes sense. He was the top star. Much of the show - its no-frills approach, lengthy main events, methodical plotting - was his doing. He got to hang around with his mates. When people who decidedly weren’t his mates were asked to show up - including the Head of Talent Relations, somehow - Punk, reportedly, told them to hit the bricks.  

He held almost complete dominion over Saturday nights, as Tony Khan chanted his name in the go position. 

It was perfect. He had no excuse to…to be CM Punk, basically. 

But then, prompted by absolutely nothing at all, he, on the August 12 episode, buried Hangman Page after it went off the air. He said ‘Hangman’ is an apt name because his unsold action figures remain hanging on the shelf. Now, Punk did apologise, but that was as unprofessional as it was unjustified. Page, remorseful over the events of the prior summer, had kept quiet since. 

One thing about Punk: he knows how to pick his spots. A top name can get away with this sort of thing in a dark segment. 

A lower name can’t get away with it on the biggest show of the year…

5. Jungle Boy Jack Petty

In a way, it’s difficult not to sympathise with Jack Perry. 

Advertisement

On the All In: London pre-show, he wrestled HOOK and blasted him against a car windshield. In response to Punk not allowing him to use a shoot car in an angle on Collision, Perry said “That’s real glass. Cry me a river.”

He didn’t really do anything that CM Punk hadn’t done a couple of weeks prior: he took a public, unprovoked dig at somebody he doesn’t get along with.  

The idea that you can resent Jack Perry and support CM Punk is laughable nonsense driven by biased parasocial types. There is no moral difference. Punk and Perry did the exact same thing; Perry just wasn’t as big a star, and his timing was worse. His dig overshadowed AEW’s biggest ever show. 

Perry didn’t have previous, either. Evidently weighed down by the whole Elite Vs. Punk debacle, he likely stewed over it and erupted at the worst possible time. Isn’t that almost relatable? 

Still, this was wildly unprofessional. What followed is immaterial: Perry shouldn’t have chosen that forum to air his grievances. 

Also: the “Not fair, he did it first!” defence is exceptionally childish. 

4. Sammy Guevara’s Various Misadventures

Remember when Sammy Guevara first won the TNT title? 

Advertisement

He took to saying, to his various TV-level opponents, that they “hadn’t done sh*t” since arriving in AEW. Was this reflective of an entitled attitude? 

And has that attitude hindered his elevation up the card?  

In 2020, Sammy panicked when he couldn’t find the arranged, gimmicked chair, and threw a shoot one in Matt Hardy’s face, splitting it open. On a taped show. 

A year later, he called Eddie Kingson “fat” without his approval in a promo that was scrubbed from the taped edition of Rampage. Guevara was most recently suspended, after defeating Jeff Hardy back in February of this year, for failing to follow concussion protocol during the match (though the argument can be made that the protocol itself is flawed).

Sammy seems incapable of simply getting his head down and going to work. In late 2022 - with little in the way of self-awareness, since he is the common denominator - he bemoaned that “exhausting” drama seems to follow him everywhere, even if he’s minding his own business. 

All too often reckless, entitled and self-serving, it’s all a bit of a shame. Guevara, who is genuinely outstanding at piecing together a creative plunder match with minimal contrivance, is in danger of being lapped. If he hasn’t been already.  

3. Jim Ross Ogles Anna Jay

The (primary) job of a pro wrestling commentator is to put the action over. They can’t be completely undiscerning, otherwise they’d lack credibility, but they do need to be rather enthusiastic.

Advertisement

It’s a difficult balance to strike, and Jim Ross struggled with it when he was full-time in the AEW booth. It should be pointed out here that Ross has experienced a wide and brutal range of health problems over the last five years, which have likely contributed to his mood. At times, Ross was impatient and irritable, wondering aloud why certain wrestlers would do certain moves or why there was even a referee in the ring, if they weren’t doing anything. He was guilty of breaking the spell of suspended disbelief. He wasn’t the right fit for around 90% of the promotion’s output. His job was to “get it”, within reason, but too often, he used Dynamite as a forum to express his quiet disgust over wrestling’s stylistic evolution. 

Again: Ross was in a low mood because a lot of scary things were happening to him. It’s a complicated and unfortunate story. Ross also used his time in the booth to lech over certain women. That wasn’t “complicated”: that was unprofessional, unnecessary, disgusting.

At All Out 2020, he asked if the then-22 year-old Anna Jay had experienced a wardrobe malfunction, adding “maybe that’s just wishful thinking”. While he apologised for the remark, that wasn’t the only occasion on which he reduced a woman to objects of his desire.

During an edition of Rampage, when the heels Penelope Ford and the Bunny made their entrance, Tony Schiavone tried to put over their wrongdoings and such. 

Ross wasn’t having it. He didn’t put the heels over as heels. “I kinda like ‘em,” he chose to say instead. His libido was apparently more important than their characters. 

2. Bea Priestley’s Stupid Stunt

It all turned out OK for Bea Priestley.

Advertisement

As Blair Davenport in WWE, she ended up on the main roster, and clearly has supporters of some influence: she was never that over in NXT. They must look at her as a long-term prospect. 

She escaped the dreaded “unprofessional” stigma from her brief time in AEW, which is fortunate. She was hardly a star there, either, and it’s usually only the top stars that are allowed to get away with it.

Much of her AEW run unfolded without incident, but Bea used the Casino Battle Royale at All Out 2019 as a platform on which to go into business for herself. 

She had a preexisting “beef” with fellow entrant Sadie Gibbs. Gibbs had left a tour of STARDOM earlier that year. She suffered bereavement; Bea and then-partner Will Ospreay publicly questioned her commitment. It was an ugly chapter in his career, and Ospreay is smarter than you think: he’s clever enough to say, a lot, that he’s done a lot of growing up since. 

At All Out, yelling “STUPID!” the entire time, Bea immediately targeted Sadie, thrashed her over the back, and then took a gorilla press slam. Bea popped up immediately and eliminated Sadie, who looked like a complete loser, out of the match. 

Inevitably, the two almost got into it backstage for real. 

1. Max Caster Takes It Too Far

Max Caster’s gimmick is - to use the vernacular of the young person - to say “out of pocket” things that draw an astonished, delighted gasp from the audience. It’s tricky, in his defence: he has to walk so closely towards the line that he is constantly in danger of crossing it. 

Advertisement

Weird as it is, being an obnoxious piece of work who takes it too far is his profession - but he has taken going too far…much too far before. 

He made light of victims of sexual assault with his vile, wildly misjudged line about the Duke lacrosse team back in 2021. In the same rap, he slut-shamed Julia Hart and mocked Simone Biles for experiencing mental health problems. 

Ugly and insensitive even in the parameters of the heel character he worked under at the time, it was unprofessional in and of itself - and doubly so, given that this episode had an adverse effect on the career of his tag team partner Anthony Bowens. 

Caster’s all-too-candid, unprovoked social media comments continue to have this effect. Increasingly unpopular in certain circles and nowhere near as over as they once were, the Acclaimed get the heat when the team has little to do with it.

Advertisement