10 Most Unsuccessful WWE Tournament Winners

Hopefully the winner of the Mae Young Classic goes on to greater success.

By John F Corrigan /

Wrestling fans are buzzing over the Mae Young Classic, WWE’s first true attempt at a women’s wrestling tournament.

Advertisement

The matches were filmed over a couple days last week, and will air on the WWE Network starting 28 August. In the same vein as the wildly popular Cruiserweight Classic, 32 participants from around the world will compete in the single-elimination tournament to not only be crowned the best but also receive unprecedented recognition from the WWE Universe.

The hype is strong, but there’s concern over the payoff. One can look back to just last summer when the Cruiserweight Classic surpassed expectations, but the follow up to the tournament was disastrous. An entire division of previously intriguing talent has been neutered since gracing the main roster. While the tournament matches were highly anticipated each week, fans have grown accustomed to switching channels or going for popcorn during purple-rope bouts on Raw.

It’s not that WWE can’t do tournaments well; it’s that the company often fails to deliver on the aftermath. After fans have invested in the struggle of these characters to outlast their competition and emerge victorious, they’re usually left disappointed by either the company or the performer dropping the ball afterward. Make no mistake – Austin 3:16 is the exception to the rule.

10. 1-2-3 Kid And Bob Holly

After Shawn Michaels’ and Diesel’s relationship deteriorated during the end of 1994, they forfeited their tag team titles. A tournament to fill the vacancy was announced with all of the federation’s top teams scheduled to participate. Unfortunately, the Smoking Gunns were unable to compete due to injury, so they were replaced by the makeshift pair of 1-2-3 Kid and Bob Holly.

Advertisement

The underdogs surprised everyone by defeating Bam Bam Bigelow and Tatanka in the finals at Royal Rumble 1995. It seemed like a prime opportunity for a couple of young guys to get a fresh start, illustrating the spirit of the New Generation.

That wasn’t the case as 24 hours later on Raw, the Smoking Gunns returned to win the tag team titles. The Cinderella story faded like the memory of a dream.

9. Hideo Itami

During Axxess before WrestleMania 31, there was a tournament held to determine the final participant in the second annual Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. Eight members of NXT competed for the opportunity to appear on the Grandest Stage of 'Em All, essentially making their main roster debut on the biggest platform possible. Hideo Itami defeated Finn Bálor in the finals to receive the golden ticket.

Advertisement

Instead of using the battle royal to propel Itami into stardom, or at least showcase his talent to a mainstream audience, WWE simply viewed him as an extra body. He was the seventh man eliminated, tossed out before scrubs like The Ascension and Los Matadores.

Perhaps winning the tournament was a curse as other participants like Neville, Kalisto, Baron Corbin and Bálor all received more significant transitions to the main roster.

8. Rey Mysterio

When CM Punk shocked the world by winning the WWE Championship and walking out of the company at Money in the Bank 2011, WWE officials desperately tried to name a new champion. An eight-man tournament was designed for the next night on Raw, with semi-finalists Rey Mysterio and The Miz slated to battle for the belt the next week. Mysterio emerged victorious and held the belt…

Advertisement

...for only an hour or so, because he then had to face former champion John Cena, who enacted his rematch clause. As usual, Cena ended the night with his hand raised and the title wrapped around his waist. It rendered the entire tournament pointless, portrayed Cena as a conniving prick, and cemented Mysterio’s status as less than elite.

By the way, Punk returned to the company that same night, agreeing to face Cena at SummerSlam to crown an undisputed champion, nullifying everything that happened over the past two shows.

7. Roman Reigns

Speaking of WWE Championship tournaments, the worst occurred in 2015 after Seth Rollins had to vacate due to injury. Speculation ran rampant heading into Survivor Series as fans brainstormed how WWE would crown its new champion. A disappointing tournament including few big names concluded at the pay-per-view as Roman Reigns defeated Alberto Del Rio and Dean Ambrose beat Kevin Owens to meet in the finals.

Advertisement

After a measly nine minutes, Reigns pinned his buddy to win the title. As confetti fell and most of the audience booed, Triple H came out to congratulate the new champion. Except he was referring to Sheamus, who cashed in his Money in the Bank contract to beat Reigns in 30 seconds.

Once again, WWE presented a pointless tournament that undermined the credibility of the winner.

6. Sheamus

By 2010, the King of the Ring concept had lost its prestige. It was discontinued as a pay-per-view after 2002, and subsequent editions were used to resurrect the classic king gimmick. While Booker T rejuvenated his career in the role, and William Regal parlayed his victory into a short-term main event run, Sheamus suffered a career free-fall.

Advertisement

Immediately after winning the tournament, Sheamus began a losing streak of epic proportions. Week after week he’d lose to John Morrison in singles and tag team action, and then he lost to Evan Bourne of all people in his return to Raw.

Meanwhile, the pasty bruiser looked ridiculous with his green cape and Celtic crown. He’d snap the streak by defeating Daniel Bryan in a U.S. Title vs. Career match, but the long-term damage had been done.

5. Tiger Ali Singh

Tiger Ali Singh debuted on Raw on 21 April 1997, without an entrance, in a miserably boring bout against Salvatore Sincere. He wouldn’t be seen on TV again until August, relegated to Shotgun Saturday Night. The crowd and company’s combined apathy toward the second-generation grappler was crystal clear, which is why it’s mind-boggling that Singh won a tournament the week before his televised debut.

Advertisement

Singh won the second Kuwait Cup, a non-televised tournament in the Middle East as part of the company’s international expansion. The event wasn’t Jobbermania – it included several stars at the time like Stone Cold, Bret Hart, and Sycho Sid. Singh notched up two impressive victories along the way, defeating Mankind in the semifinals and Owen Hart in the finals.

Then he was rarely seen again.

4. Billy Gunn

After years as a tag team specialist, Billy Gunn was ready for a single’s run. Traditionally, the best way to embark on that rise to the top is via the King of the Ring. In 1999, Gunn went through an “injured” Ken Shamrock, a distracted Kane and a legitimately injured X-Pac to ascend the throne. All hail Mr. Ass.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the single’s run was more of a crawl, as Gunn had lingering D-X issues to deal with before facing The Rock at SummerSlam in a “Kiss My Ass” match. While Vince Russo probably had good intentions by booking Gunn to get a rub from The Great One, it ended up backfiring for the less-charismatic performer as The Rock outshone him in every segment. By September, just three months after winning the crown, Gunn was back to teaming with Road Dogg, his single’s run aborted.

3. T.J. Perkins

Representing the Philippines in the Cruiserweight Classic, T.J. Perkins dazzled audiences with his lightning quick strikes, death-defying leaps and technical prowess. After 18 years on the indy scene, surviving homelessness and bankruptcy, he had finally achieved his dream of making it to WWE. Of the four semifinalists, he was the least likely to become the new Cruiserweight Champion. But he did it.

Advertisement

And it’s been all downhill since. When the revitalized cruiserweight division first appeared on Raw, Perkins wasn’t even featured. When he did appear, he was given a gamer character with dorky dialogue albeit a pretty cool entrance. He entered into a feud with Brian Kendrick, who basically made TJP into a dope. Kendrick, a well-known manipulative liar, faked an injury, luring the compassionate yet foolish Perkins into a trap to lose the title just two months after winning it.

Now referred to as TJP, he has become just another lifeless character in the destroyed division.

2. Mabel

Easily the biggest upset in King of the Ring history, the 500-pound “muscle” of Men on a Mission went all the way in 1995. In a tournament including Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, and Yokozuna, it was Mabel who somehow ascended to the throne. His reign was dead on arrival, though, as fans pelted him with garbage during his coronation ceremony.

Advertisement

That didn’t stop Vince McMahon from pushing the monster as the company’s lead villain, slotting him as the number-one contender against WWE Champion Diesel at SummerSlam two months later. After the match bombed, so did the push – Mabel wound up losing to Diesel and then the Undertaker, legitimately injuring both in the process. After Royal Rumble 1996, about seven months after being crowned, he was no longer in the company.

1. Bart Gunn

How could winning a non-scripted fighting tournament designed to determine the toughest, baddest dude on the roster, ruin your career?

Advertisement

Ask Bart Gunn.

In the summer of 1998, Gunn competed in the Brawl For All, a disaster that injured many on the roster, ruined their mystiques, bored live audiences and cost WWE a ton of money. Gunn defeated Bob Holly by decision, knocked out Godfather and tournament favorite Steve Williams and then dropped Bradshaw in the finals to win $75,000.

It should have elevated Gunn from the tag team division to the main event scene; instead, he floated around the midcard until facing famous boxer Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. Within 35 seconds, he was knocked out and his aura destroyed. Gunn would be released before the year ended.

Advertisement