10 Most Unthinkable Comebacks In Wrestling History
If CM Punk ever returns to WWE, might he even be added to this list?
Wherever CM Punk goes next, if he even goes anywhere at all, it will be unthinkable.
Per the most recent edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, the AEW locker room is mostly united in their loathing of the man, and with good reason. Every painful bump they inflicted upon themselves at All Out meant absolutely nothing in the wake of his profoundly unprofessional conduct at the post-show presser. He all but said that the company meant nothing before he set foot in it; an insulting, complete fabrication. As such, AEW is reportedly in the process of negotiating a contract buy-out - which is proving tricky, because the issue of a no-compete clause is causing a snag.
Could, therefore, the truly unthinkable happen? Could CM Punk return to WWE, where had as much of an issue (if not more so) with Paul Levesque as Vince McMahon?
Could the credibility of his anti-establishment persona withstand such a move? Cody Rhodes buried WWE for a good five years before his return, and all was forgotten by the fanbase. They felt like they get one over on AEW, and Rhodes, simply, is a superstar.
Punk has to be different, surely. So much of his persona and real-life personality is wrapped around his toxic relationship with that company. Then again, he has a way of making you fall for him all over again because he's a genius. Still: unthinkable is right.
But where would it rank amongst the following...?
10. Cody Rhodes Returns To WWE
Brand loyalty is fierce in this toxic, tribalistic landscape - but the fact that the 'E' in AEW stands for 'Elite' obscured, for a time, a core wrestling truth: that loyalty isn't always reciprocated by the workers.
Not that Cody Rhodes actually owed AEW anything. He owed it to himself to make the most money for his family and advance his career on his own terms. Still, that it is named 'AEW' created a certain expectation.
Cody was the most ambitious member of the Elite, and the most savvy marketer of what that particular brand was "meant" to stand for. Screaming revolutionary rhetoric or making small, winking digs at WWE's expense, his work - and it was a work - was so convincing that he, not Hangman Page or even Jon Moxley, was received by the AEW base as the ultimate babyface figure upon the launch of the promotion.
All of which rendered his 2022 return to WWE so unthinkable, even after his star faded and fans were prepared - even very willing - to jeer his conviction over never turning heel. When his quirks were brought into a different focus - the blood, the histrionics, the win/loss record, even if he needed it to remain a star - there was no turning back. He recognised this himself, and made the jump.
It was unthinkable, but Cody is a smart operator. He never received a single boo in WWE despite ripping the piss out of it for five years because he knew he was going to be received as the man who deserted the dreaded competition.
9. Edge Comes Back From Retirement
Neck injuries aren't something to mess about with.
A significant neck injury curtailed Steve Austin's in-ring career. He was lucky to have only experienced temporary paralysis at SummerSlam '97; too many others have suffered a far worse fate. On that basis, Edge had to retire in 2011 upon the advice of doctors. After feeling numbness in his arms, he got through his WrestleMania XXVII match against Alberto Del Rio, but a diagnosis of cervical spinal stenosis meant that it must be his last. He was told that he risked paralysis or death, were even a simple move to go awry, but he alone was not at risk. Having lost a degree of feeling and strength in his arms, there was a chance that he might risk the safety of his opponents were he to lose control of them mid-move.
That had to be that. Unlike, say, Shawn Michaels, who was fantasy booked into various matches after he retired - fans almost willed a dream bout opposite AJ Styles at the 2017 Royal Rumble into existence - Edge was considered forever retired.
Until his neck actually healed, and at the exact same time competition resurfaced!
8. Shane McMahon Returns To WWE
Shane McMahon was thought forever estranged from his family and could have simply lived the brat rich kid life for the end of his days.
For a time, he did, by investing in various companies that you've never heard of and paying a fortune to MMA legends to train under them - which, if you think about it, makes him equally as tough!
He wasn't coming back because he didn't need to and the familial conflict element made things so much more awkward than if, say, he had spent the last five years of his career taking shots at his dad. Shane has said, variously, that he wanted to spend more time with his children and that he wished to branch out. He mentioned in an interview with Mick Foley that his relationship with Vince "stopped being a collaboration and it stopped being fun", which is the most he's talked around what most consider, from the outside, to be the truth of the matter: Shane was passed over as heir apparent in favour of his sister and her husband. This, to be clear, is something Shane has never admitted. They are however easy dots to connect.
But return he did, because - yes! - Vince McMahon was so dismal at creating new stars that he had to give his spoiled kid a series of birthday presents.
7. Goldberg Returns To WWE
Goldberg's original WWE run was so unfathomably drab. Well, not unfathomably; he used to work for WCW and had to be put in his f*cking place.
In WCW, he wowed fans, stadium-sized for a mere TV show at certain points, against an incandescent, brightly-lit backdrop in short explosive bursts of intense badass energy. His aura was out of this world, and it didn't matter that he only did two moves half of the time because one of them most closely resembled a fatality in the history of the form.
In WWE, with one exception, he left crowds wanting, working long, unflattering matches against that god-awful stained red Raw backdrop, ordered to sell when nobody wanted to feel sympathy for him. Can the guy who breaks people in half with one move withstand the pain of a Triple H chin lock? is the question nobody asked. If you scan his Cagematch listing, the matches weren't strictly as long as you remember, but WWE had a way of making it feel that way. They were meant to feel like they way over in a flash of combat sports energy.
Goldberg hated it too, left, and Triple H spent the next 12 years, when asked, calling him worse than sh*t.
Luckily for WWE - or not, as the case may be - they were so bad at building new stars that they had to rely on the short-term boost in 2016 - and he got over this time when they copied WCW's approach.
6. Triple H Returns To The Throne
This was a narrative twist so unbelievable that, were it not real, would have ruined an otherwise compelling prestige drama series.
It's difficult to overstate just how far Triple H had fallen in 2021. NXT's move from the Network to television was a failure; it was ritually and decisively slaughtered by AEW Dynamite in the 18-49 demographic. This humiliation did not go down well with Vince McMahon; the transformed NXT 2.0 felt like he was the owner rubbing his dog's nose in sh*t. Vince took every promotional impulse of Triple H's and almost literally smeared the reboot with the direct opposite.
Gone were the skulls, the dank, the heavy metal; in their place, splats of colour, migraine-inducing lights, hip-hop. The kick pad lads were marched out by big, generic men with minimal experience.
Bron Breakker even smashed through the old "black and gold" logo, and Christ: Cody Rhodes was less on-the-nose at Double Or Nothing '19.
Of course, the history of pro wrestling is littered with failures resurfacing. Vince Russo was employed for years after the year 2000. Eric Bischoff was involved in WWE creative in 2019. Neither of these men suffered significant heart attacks that were thought to have prevented them ever operating in a high-pressure capacity ever again.
After Vince McMahon shockingly (if not altogether surprisingly) retired in disgrace, Paul Levesque is doing that - and he has galvanised the WWE fandom much like everyone knew he could do in the mid-2010s.
5. Ultimate Warrior Returns To WWE
Ultimate Warrior was a bad human being, the sort who'd unleash a 3,000-word rant on a sweat shop worker if one of his shirt buttons popped off.
That of course isn't why he was estranged from WWE forevermore - if anything, they shared certain beliefs - but rather because WWE went to the unprecedented lengths of producing a special DVD set dedicated to burying him. 'The Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior' DVD was its name, but realistically, it could just as easily have been called 'Why The Ultimate Warrior Was A Sh*t-Disturbing Flash In The Pan Who Was Horrific To Work With And Was Only Liked, For A Very Brief Period Of Time, By Tiny Little Kids Who Really Didn't Know Any Better (And Also His Promos Were Stupid And Unintelligible)'.
They killed the guy on that thing. It was remarkable.
Perhaps it was felt that Warrior had finally reached the point at which an in-ring return was impossible, even for a wrestler that did as little a he did, and they might as well air their grievances. He was apparently asked to participate in a documentary that was almost certainly pitched under a different title until he said no. Is it true?
Were they that petty?
Warrior evidently forgave, but he did not forget: when he made his improbable comeback to enter the Hall of Fame in 2014, he referenced the DVD more than once.
4. Bruno Sammartino Enters The WWE Hall Of Fame
Bruno Sammartino had a strict moral code.
He was born under profoundly arduous circumstances. Four of his siblings died, and, in nazi-occupied Italy, his mother stationed the remaining family in secret mountaintop hide-out from which, at night, she snuck into the nearest town for provisions. As a result, Bruno was a sickly child, which informed his immense drive to become a shoot strong man and professional wrestler. During his legendary career, he portrayed himself as a hero and lived the gimmick, even going as far as to refuse to drink wine in restaurants in which young, impressionable children were present. He - rightly - believed himself to be a good man worthy of representing the community.
When the WWF embroiled itself in scandal, he could not sanction what had become of the company he forged and was an outspoken critic of it, blasting the influx of anabolic steroids and its vulgarity. Ostensibly the founding father of Vince McMahon's empire, he declined several invitations into its Hall of Fame on that basis.
That was until he was persuaded to do so by Triple H after a long and complex negotiation period, only after observing from afar WWE's approach to wrestling in its PG Era/PR clean-up operation era.
3. Superstar Billy Graham Returns To WWE
The proto-Hulk Hogan, Superstar Billy Graham, was one of the chief architects of modern pro wrestling. His influence is almost as profound as the Gold Dust Trio or Vince McMahon himself.
He was fiercely critical of WWE after his return run in the Golden Era represented a bleak fall from grace; he sued the WWF after alleging that he was forced to inject anabolic steroids to maintain his spot, and, capitalising on the other major controversy of the early '90s, claimed to have witnessed first-hand the molestation of children from WWF officials. He rescinded the allegations, attributing them to his desire to get a payday.
Graham literally called the Fed no*ces and got a Hall of Fame induction a decade later.
It was doubly shocking, because it wasn't as if there was a financial incentive so significant that old feelings could be forgotten. While a trailblazer so significant that pro wrestling would look unrecognisable without his influence - and that is no exaggeration - Hulk Hogan did such an incredible job of using his influence that, to the vast majority of WWE fans, the company might as well have been founded in 1984.
Vince McMahon clearly is a weirdly sentimental fellow, given how, elsewhere, he is more than happy to erase vast portions of his promotion's history when the narrative fits.
2. Eric Bischoff Returns To The Televised Stage
If you think the Tony Khan Vs. Triple H war is ugly, you might not have watched wrestling in the mid-to-late 1990s.
As an analogy, imagine Tony Khan, upon the exit of Cody Rhodes, writing several comedy skits at his expense and broadcasting them on national TV. An actor playing the role of 'Carny Rhodes' is seen gigging himself furiously at a creative meeting as another actor, playing Monopoly Vince, tells him that they "can only do cool stuff like that in AEW!"
In response, imagine Triple H walking down the aisle on Raw, borrowing a fan sign that reads "Tony Con Fears Ratings!"
If the AEW Vs. WWE rivalry happened back then, that's what it would look like. The rivalry wasn't limited to the odd passive aggressive dig on TV; it was hostile in the extreme, or at least, exponentially more petty.
Vince hated Ted Turner more than he ever hated Eric Bischoff, true, but he hardly liked the man. He perceived his brash, clever marketing as a vendetta against what he had worked himself into thinking was the embodiment of the American Dream: a noble mom n' pop operation under threat of an evil conglomerate. However, since he was far more of a carny than a small business owner, he welcomed Bischoff onto Raw one year after purchasing WCW.
It's easy to be snarky about it now, but it was truly brain-scrambling stuff at the time. Imagine Triple H doing the point to Tony Khan on Raw in a couple of years, and you're close.
1. Bret Hart Returns To WWE
There's no delicate way of putting this, and nor should there be: Bret Hart was thought to be the one to actually mean never, given the preventable death of Owen Hart at Over The Edge 1999. The resulting lawsuit was settled out of court, but Martha Hart remains steadfast in that belief, telling Sports Illustrated in 2020 that "I'd never want him recognized by a company responsible for his death and that has been so disrespectful to his family".
While Bret on his Confessions of the Hitman podcast has since expressed his (own, personal) belief that Vince McMahon "had probably very little to do with what happened to Owen," he came to this (personal) realisation over time.
In a secondary story that feels so utterly trivial in comparison, Shawn Michaels had returned to and scripted a second, illustrious chapter of his career when Bret made his own, unfathomable return to the promotion in 2010. He had entered the Hall of Fame in 2006, but only to thank his fans for their loyalty and support. The 2010 return was different; he was once more a character within WWE's fictional world.
It was a bleak viewing experience, all told - Hart's catharsis was all his own in an intense private moment inexplicably broadcast to the world - but his ardent fans still could not begrudge him the opportunity to exorcise those old demons.