The definition of a dark match is a match that's taped but does not air on television, these usually occur before and after a TV taping. An after taping dark match is usually an extension of the main event, primarily intended to send the fans home happy with the good guys almost always coming out victorious. Pre-tape dark matches are usually much more interesting as they often feature talent from developmental, or unsigned talent in tryout matches to test crowd reactions, or to see if the wrestler can handle the pressure of huge live audiences. We'll be focusing on the latter for this article. Dark matches aren't worth watching for the wrestling content itself, they usually consist of 5-8 minutes with mostly basic wrestling moves and are typically quite bland. However, they provide an intriguing view into the world of wrestling development and creative. They let you see established talent before they ever received their main roster debuts, while also giving an insight into who management were considering for a contract or trying to hire but ultimately didn't, for one reason or another. In exploration in this curious world of secret wrestling, we've dug into the archive for any dark matches that could entertain, appeal or inform. Here's ten must-see WWE dark matches.
10. Kid Kash Vs Justin Credible
Some dark matches give an insight into the company's mind set at the time in regards to tryout matches, as to who makes the cut or not. Paul Heyman has always tried to look after his ECW alumni after the house of extreme collapsed, thus it's no surprise he'd try to get some of his former wrestlers and colleagues in the WWE, after he got his own foot in the door as a commentator and authority figure. One such wrestler was Kid Kash who worked a tryout match with ECW colleague Justin Credible in September, 2001. The match itself is pretty dull, mainly due to Justin Credible stalling for two minutes, in an already brief six minute match. However, the crowd did seem to cheer for Kid Cash's dives and kicks. Also, the crowd seemed to already be familiar with him as he had quite a decent pop on entrance, presumably due to the popularity of ECW. It's said that Kash mainly got a tryout match because of Heyman, but it's plausible they were trying to expand the ECW roster as part of The Invasion angle, with more ECW talent that didn't already previously work for WWE. Kid Kash didn't get a WWE contract until four years later, presumably because the roster was so packed due to all of the ECW and WCW alumni they had already hired, most of which were already relegated to working on b-shows, like WWF Metal and Sunday Night Heat. If the crowd was anything to go by, Kid Kash maybe could have been a decent cruiserweight wrestler or mid-carder.
9. Minnasota Stretching Crew Vs The Disciples Of Synn
Brock Lesnar is a wrestler renown for being a monster, absolutely destroying every rank of competition on his way to numerous WWE Championships. You'd think that teamwork isn't a word in his vocabulary, yet in his early days in OVW, he spent most of his time in training in the tag-team division, believe it or not. He was paired with Shelton Benjamin, as the two were familiar from their days at the University of Minnesota, and it was believed the two could help cover up each others flaws. Brock Lesnar presented the power and brawn, while Shelton had charisma, technicality and speed needed for a successful tag-team. In May 2001, the Minnesota Stretching Club met the Disciples of Synn in a dark match on Smackdown, for the OVW Southern Tag-Team Championship. Perhaps it's just because of how we think of Brock Lesnar in the modern era, but something about there's something about cream trunks, being a face and tag-team wrestling that doesn't suit him. Not to mention, it's hard to stress his power and dominance if he's forced to rely on a partner, it makes him seem weaker than if he was a solo competitor. All in all, not a bad match, with Shelton Benjamin stealing the show as usual. Given the fact this was a dark match, it's possible that WWE Creative were considering bringing the team of Lesnar and Benjamin onto the main roster together. As Lesnar was called to the main roster in November, 2001 in preparation for his debut in 2002, Shelton stayed in OVW and had to find a new tag-team partner. B.J Payne and Brian Logan of the Disciples of Synn never graduated to the main roster.
8. Kurt Angle Vs Meat
Kurt Angle was a huge hit when he made his debut at Survivor Series in 1999, but it was his entrance theme 'Medal', his American colored attire and his can-do attitude that immediately helped distinguish him from the pack with his uniqueness and accolades. Before he made his debut, Angle took part in many dark matches in order to give him some experience in front of a proper live crowd. In 1999, Angle faced off against Shawn Stasiak in a dark match, with Stasiak in his repugnant Meat gimmick which he held for most of his first WWF run. One thing you immediately realize is that without his entrance theme, without his gimmick or his entrance attire, Kurt Angle doesn't immediately catch your eye as a great, distinct competitor. The black trunks and boots make him blend in as if he it was anyone in that ring, his move-set also appeared to be somewhat limited and not that technical, compared to later matches. If WWF creative hadn't come up with the snobby American hero gimmick and ring attire to properly utilize his position as a former Olympic gold medalist, they could have possibly dropped the ball with Kurt Angle, if he first appeared like the Angle we see in this dark match. Thankfully, that wasn't the case and he went on to have a widely celebrated and acclaimed career.
7. Dean Ambrose Vs Chris Kincaid
Dean Ambrose is one of the fastest rising stars currently in the WWE, though it seems he was tested thoroughly in dark matches but his official debut in late 2012 as part of The Shield. In this dark match, Ambrose faces Chris Kincaid, but not as the Dean Ambrose you know now. His ring attire is far different from now, then wearing classic black trunks which is fairly typical wrestling attire, compared to the more individual full body attire he wears now. His persona is that of a cocky heel noted by his boasting and post-match celebration, in contrast to the more traditional heel he was in The Shield at first, or the babyface/anti-hero combination he's adopted since the breakup of The Shield and turning face. It's clear to see why they thought Ambrose was ready and why he's being pushed now, as even then he was able to appear in front of an unfamiliar crowd and warrant a clear audience response, with his distinctive look, in ring style, move-set and persona. It's arguable he'd be able to succeed, no matter how he debuted or what gimmick they gave him.
6. Kanyon Vs Shark Boy
Shark Boy's one of wrestling's most bizarre oddball characters, yet he seems to have a rather large cult following among the wrestling community. After sporadic appearances in the newly formed TNA and numerous other promotions, Shark Boy appeared in a dark match on Velocity, most probably a tryout match, on the 11th of March, 2003. Shark Boy seemed to be hugely over, straight off the bat. From the very start, fans were cheering 'Let's go Shark Boy', alongside 'Kanyon Sucks', with solid cheers every time Shark Boy seemed to regain momentum. If this is any indication, it's possible Shark Boy could have made it in the WWE as a comic relief character, as fans already seemed to connect with the character. The match went near-on ten minutes, with a few near falls and had a great crowd reaction considering dark matches are usually dead silent for the most part. After the match, presumably Shark Boy wasn't offered a developmental contract and it was just a one-off appearance. What a shame.
5. Brock Lesnar And Ron Waterman Vs Rico Constantino And Randy Orton
Two of the biggest wrestling debuts in 2002 were undoubtedly that of Brock Lesnar and Randy Orton. Both men are now multiple time world champions and are two of the most prominent and important wrestlers on WWE programming. Both Orton and Lesnar went through several dark matches before their debut in order to test audience reactions to them, as a way of predicting whether they'd get over or not. In this match, we see the team of big men Brock Lesnar and Ron 'H20' Waterman against the agile team of Randy Orton and Rico Constantino. The first thing you notice is that while Brock Lesnar's move-set and attire seems to be the same as he had on the main roster, Randy Orton seems to act more as a high-flier, as a fast and agile competitor, in dire contrast to the slow, power based move-set that he gradually transitioned to after his debut. Lesnar doesn't do all that much in the match, while Ron Waterman gets double teamed by Rico and Randy for the victory. The team of Rico and Randy was surprisingly good, while Lesnar and Waterman could have been impressive, if they were allowed to appear as dominant monsters. Rico, Randy and Brock would all debut that year in 2002, while former MMA and UFC star Ron Waterman never made it out of developmental.
4. The Prototype Vs Scott Vick
Even a 15-time wrestling World Champion has to start somewhere. Before he was known as John Cena, he went under the moniker 'The Prototype', originally used a semi-robotic character in UPW. After two years in OVW developmental, they tested the waters for John's debut with a number of dark matches before Smackdown and Raw tapings. Seventeen days before his debut against Kurt Angle, The Prototype appeared in a pre-Raw dark match against Scott Vick, who you may or may not know as Sick Boy from his days in Raven's Flock in WCW. The match shows Cena as a classic heel, he frequently argues counts and even shouts 'Ask him' when executing a submission hold, also demanding that his hand be raised a second time after winning. The crowd reaction was very dull in this instance, but his other dark matches with Shelton Benjamin definitely showed Cena in a better light. Cena would go on to become one of the most successful performers in professional wrestling history, while Scott Vick would stay in developmental and never end up making it to the main roster. It's often claimed he was mean't to debut in the controversial Katie Vick storyline with Kane, but obviously it was cut short due to its involvement with necrophilia.
3. Leviathan Vs Nick Dinsmore
Some dark matches are interesting because they show the old gimmicks and ring attire wrestlers used in developmental, before they were completely repackaged to go debut on the main roster. Often a wrestler will look completely different from their developmental stint in contrast to their finalized gimmick - in the case of Dinsmore and Leviathan, that's a fair statement. Who are Leviathan and Dinsmore? Well, Leviathan is the name of the pseudo-satantic gimmick given to 4-time World Heavyweight Champion Dave Bautista in his time at Ohio Valley Wrestling. Nicholas Dinsmore is the real name of former WWE talent and trainer most well-known as Eugene. The dark match shows the monstrous Leviathan squash the smaller, more technical Dinsmore in under 6 minutes, much to the joy of the crowd. Leviathan would wrestle more dark matches in 2001 and the following year, until finally debuting as Deacon Batista in May, 2002. Dinsmore would stay in OVW until 2004, before being stuck with the obnoxious Eugene gimmick on Raw.
2. Jerry Lynn Vs Bryan Danielson
While most fans will know NXT as the start to Bryan Danielson's WWE career, the former three-time WWE Champion, top-tier talent and star was featured in taped dark matches going back to 2001, as part of his first developmental contract. Way before NXT, the WWF was using MCW (Memphis Championship Wrestling) as one of its primary developmental territories, to which Danielson was assigned in 2000. The dark match features Bryan going against TNA and ECW veteran Jerry Lynn. Unfortunately, the poster only managed to catch the last minute of the match, but nevertheless it remains an interesting piece of wrestling history. It's initially strange seeing Bryan vs Lynn as a dark match, it's a pairing that would be made several times later on independent shows and be quite a big hit in a promotion like ROH (Ring of Honor). After the match, MCW would dissolve as part of the the WWF brand reformation, which left Danielson without a job in the aftermath. Lynn would be released in 2002, after over a year of wrestling exclusively on Sunday Night Heat.
1. AJ Styles Vs Rico Constantino
After AJ Styles recently left TNA, many speculated that he might sign with the WWE as they'd surely want to get their hands on such a talent. As is the case with most notable independent wrestlers, he was already involved with the company for a brief period, as he wrestled a number of matches for the WWE going as far back as early 2002. He wasn't signed to developmental, presumably he was brought in as a local talent for the dark match. In this match from the 22nd of January, 2002, a young AJ Styles faces off against Rico Constantino, who many of you may remember as the homosexual stylist of Billy and Chuck. The match shows a lot of raw talent from both men, while that's to be expected from AJ, Rico also showed off a lot of potential that would ultimately be wasted in his WWE run. While most dark matches elicit a very dull crowd reaction, this one actually seemed to excite fans, particularly with Style's use of aerial maneuvers. After the match, Rico would debut a few months later and have a mediocre WWE run lasting a few years, while AJ Styles would go on to face The Hurricane on the b-show known as WWF Jakked four days later. He was then offered a developmental contract which he turned down because he didn't want to relocate.