10 Next Big Things In Wrestling That Totally Flopped

WWE had such high hopes for these aspiring stars, but then the bell rang.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE knew they were taking a risk when they dubbed Brock Lesnar the 'Next Big Thing' in 2002. No, it wasn't much of one, because Brock was a can't miss prospect with clear potential to become a federation focal point, but pinning a promotion's future on any wrestler is always uncertain.

Advertisement

Brock worked out - everyone here...didn't.

OK, so there's still time for a couple included. They could turn things around and prove to be success stories in the end, but right now? Right now, they're main event busts that didn't pan out the way everyone behind the scenes hoped. Then, there are the outright flops from yesteryear. They were lessons learned for creative, and hopefully Triple H was paying attention.

There's room for one AEW star too. He seemed to have a rocket strapped to him, and fans were responding in kind, but then Tony Khan got in his own way and fumbled the ball big time. There's probably no going back. "Probably" doesn't mean never, but things don't look good.

Wrestling fans have watched some number of next big things come and go. Here are the worst examples of misplaced confidence!

10. Austin Theory

It hurts a wee bit to put Austin Theory here, but he belongs.

Advertisement

WWE surely thought Theory would be a multi-time World Champion and wildly successful main event heel by now. That seemed to be the plan when Austin was hanging around with Vince McMahon on-screen, winning Money In The Bank and bragging to anyone who'd listen that he beat John Cena.

Things went south post-Cena though. In truth, they'd threatened to do so for a while before that; probs stretching back to Theory's MITB experience. It didn't quite springboard him into the headline mix permanently, shall we say. Today, he's in a heel tag-team with Grayson Waller that'll maybe lead to an unlikely breakout babyface run.

Nothing is guaranteed though. So, yes it hurts to put Theory here (and he's on the list so early because the dude still has a chance), but it's also difficult to deny that he flopped in a featured spot. Perhaps it came too soon for the ex-Evolve blue chipper.

9. Wardlow

Tony Khan should hang his head in shame at the way his booking fumbled Wardlow. The big powerhouse had AEW audiences eating out of the palm of his hand for a spell, but then a baffling series of TNT Title-related decisions wrecked his momentum and cooled big Wardy to the point that he's currently ice cold.

Advertisement

Great job, 'Booker Of The Year'!

Look, no wrestling boss is going to get everything right, but the way Khan systematically stripped away everything that made Wardlow great was akin to self-sabotage. It just didn't make sense if you were following the product either. He's gone from MJF's bodyguard > emerging babyface > super-over upper-midcarder > heavy in The Undisputed Kingdom.

That group sucks, by the way. It's been held back by injuries to key members (Adam Cole), sure, but that doesn't give Tony a pass for the dreadful way he booked Wardlow. All he had to do was keep powerbombing everyone, get ultimate revenge on MJF and then move on with fans in his corner.

8. Alberto Del Rio

Speaking of self-sabotage.

Advertisement

Alberto Del Rio's personal life has been a whirlwind frenzy of bad decision making and regrettable moments. Few who weren't there actually know the ins and outs of his first WWE departure in 2014, but Del Rio can't be tut-tutted for standing up in the face of racist comments. Everything else? Impossible to defend his behaviour.

This isn't an exclusive deep dive on all of Alberto's crappy life choices though. He had issues in front of WWE's cameras too. At one point, the company seemed keen to try him on as a new era Eddie Guerrero. That was most true when he was written as an inspiring babyface champion who had serious heart.

People weren't buying it, and that was a problem once it became clear that Del Rio's upward mobility was limited as a heel too. WWE persevered by shoving Alberto down everyone's throats across multiple stints, but it never really worked the way they wanted it to.

7. Sin Cara

Shout out to Hunico for taking the wounded Sin Cara gimmick and turning it into a sustainable WWE career until 2019. It's amazing that the Cara character survived that long considered how hard to original tanked. In 2011, the wrestling world buzzed with excitement when Mistico put pen to paper on a contract.

Advertisement

That excitable chatter would soon change to awkward glances.

Mistico bombed as Cara. He was supposed to become WWE's go to masked star and replace Rey Mysterio. He was meant to dazzle everybody with incredible aerials and five-star matches. He was going to be a headliner who'd shift more merch than WWE could keep in stock. None of those things happened, and it didn't take long for Cara to derail.

Vince McMahon tried teaming him with Mysterio and letting Cara rub shoulders with top stars like John Cena, but nothing seemed to work. His matches weren't anything special, and there was a disconnect with fans who couldn't relate to the faceless and voiceless mystery masked man.

Hunico needs a statue outside WWE HQ for salvaging something out of this mess.

6. Nathan Jones

Nathan Jones had potential to become Nailz with a greater physique and without the Vince McMahon choking. The idea that this imposing criminal had been locked up in a maximum security prison for 10-ish years with nothing to do but lift weights and get angrier was alluring. It's a pity Jones couldn't live up to the hype.

Advertisement

WWE clocked that early on.

They pulled him from a scheduled tag bout with The Undertaker vs. Big Show and A-Train at WrestleMania XIX. Instead, 'Taker took on two brutes solo, then Nathan worked a run-in spot afterwards. That was a major red flag. If he wasn't ready to have his hand held through some basic power spots, then what chance did Jones have of thriving on his own?

Reportedly, Nathan didn't like the brutal travel schedule WWE demanded either. Combine that with a complete lack of basic fundamentals and this was a disaster waiting to happen. Top brass surely regretted hyping Jones up as a Brock Lesnar-esque sensation.

5. Ronda Rousey

Yes, it's Ronda Rousey.

Advertisement

You might be slightly shocked to see 'Rowdy' here, but don't be. She was supposed to be the final piece of the jigsaw puzzle in WWE's female ranks when signing on full-time in 2018. That women's "revolution" they spoke of? Ronda was going to help kick the doors down and bring her UFC crossover appeal to pro wrestling. It'd be a match made in heaven.

Unfortunately, Rousey never seemed comfortable with the fickle nature of the biz or in-tune with the fact she might...y'know...have to turn heel instead of being some super-popular hero forever. Several shooty comments in the media were ill-advised, then Ronda appeared shocked fans didn't like what she had to say.

WWE tried again by bringing Rousey back in 2022, but it was another failed experiment. She'd be gone by the summer of 2023, and decided to badmouth the company's structure to anyone who'd listen afterwards. The woman who was meant to take the division skyward plummeted whilst it marched on like nothing had happened.

4. Jack Swagger

Jim Ross would still say a lot of the same things about Jack Swagger/Jake Hager if asked. He'd talk about his University Of Oklahoma roots, then point to the man's amateur wrestling credentials as proof fans should take him seriously. This has been the way of it since Swagger first burst onto WWE's main roster in 2008.

Advertisement

Feel old yet?!

You've got to give management some credit here. They really, really tried to make Swagger a household name and symbol of excellence. He won Money In The Bank at WrestleMania XXVI, then cashed in on Chris Jericho to become World Champ. Things went south from there, largely 'cause big Jack lacked natural charisma and struggled to forge a connection with fans.

That wouldn't come until his, "We The People" stuff years later. Even that had a shelf life. Cutting lengthy heel promos as champion and introducing dire gimmicks like "Swagger's Soaring Eagle" didn't work for Jack. His matches as a main eventer were always so-so too.

3. Mr. Kennedy

Mr. Kennedy wrote the playbook on WWE's what might've been.

Advertisement

His obnoxious-but-fun self-intros gripped people in Kennedy fever when he debuted in 2005. In-ring, the man was solid, but the real meat of his act came on the microphone and everyone knew it. Backstage, Vince McMahon was impressed and started pushing Kennedy up the ranks. He went on one hell of an undefeated streak, then won MITB in 2007.

Things spiralled out of control from there. Kennedy suffered a nasty, career-altering injury that paused his top line ambitions. Then, he was one of the wrestlers named in a pharmacy scandal that contravened WWE's Wellness Policy. Things were falling out of place, not in, and they'd only get worse.

More injuries followed, then Kennedy irked Randy Orton during a comeback match on Raw in 2009. WWE cut him loose shortly thereafter, and he'd wind up in TNA bitching about everything. By that point, Kennedy should've been on top of the world, headlining WrestleMania and all that good stuff.

2. Vladimir Kozlov

You knew it was only a matter of time before big Vlad showed up.

Advertisement

He was supposed to be WWE's next top heel after debuting in 2008. The McMahons had Vladimir Kozlov batter everybody they could book, then programmed him opposite star names such as Triple H and The Undertaker in hopes he'd rise to the challenge. Spoiler alert: Kozlov didn't.

Being honest, he was a lower-midcarder dressed up as a main eventer and blatantly wasn't ready or skilled enough to make it work. The dude looked way more comfortable alongside Santino Marella in a comedic babyface tag-team than he ever did beating 'Taker on TV or crushing everyone unconvincingly.

WWE definitely figured Koz would catch fire and become their version of movie monsters like Ivan Drago or Jaws from James Bond though. He was meant to be an unstoppable fighting machine, but Vlad's matches were boring and fans wanted to see other acts on the roster instead.

Namely, literally anyone else.

1. Gable Steveson

Attention, WWE: Maybe don't tell fans that someone is the second coming of Kurt Angle before he's ever wrestled a proper match. They did that with Olympic gold winner Gable Steveson, and even had Kurt endorse him as one of the best to ever do it. Fine, but could that translate well into the entertainment-based pros?

Advertisement

The answer, obviously, was no.

Steveson had wanted to be a WWE success since childhood, which is cool. A lot of people do, but they also lack the ability to make it reality. It certainly didn't help that fans turned their noses up at Gable being pushed hard as Angle meets Brock Lesnar 2.0. Then, he popped up in a few uninspiring cameo spots and people were already bored.

Gable's first and only televised match at NXT's Great American Bash 2023 was fittingly against Baron Corbin. He'd had a stinker when retiring Kurt at WrestleMania 35, and now Angle's so-called second coming was out there suffocating vs. Corbs too. It's strange how things turned out that way, but they did.

Too much hype, zero substance.

What other next big things in wrestling totally flopped? For more WWE, check out 10 Gimmicks Other Wrestlers HATED and 10 New Main Event Megastars WWE Are Secretly Building! 

Advertisement