10 Old School Wresting Gimmicks That Need To Return
Back To The Future.
Not all wrestling was better in the past. You don't always have to be born earlier.
WWE's decades-long monopoly over the mainstream has raised several generations of fans to accept a number of troubling norms as the "right" way to do things. This - much like WWE's initials still being the shorthand for wrestling in general - is the power that market dominance (and complete ownership) provides.
Billionaire-backed AEW is not a little engine that could or some sort of plucky upstart organisation, but by adhering to so many more long-standing tenets and attempting to create new ones, they are trying to retrain audiences conditioned to cheap finishes and dreaded "protective" booking measures. To be successful beyond its first four years, Dynamite can't be a show that leans entirely on the past. But to not embrace the elements that worked would be the sort needless negligence thankfully not yet exhibited by their booking practices.
It doesn't work every time. There is nothing - nothing - on a, say, a 1982 edition of the World Wrestling Federation's weekly television show that would stand up against just about any Seth Rollins match from 2020, and one of them included a man's f*cking eye being extracted. But that's not to say that same episode wouldn't have tight psychology worth studying, or a connection between babyface and audience a contemporary star could grab from.
The below personas have mostly been consigned to the past. But then, if wrestling's as cyclical as all the old-timers say...
10. Horsemen
All Elite Wrestling almost certainly won't call a new group The Four Horsemen should they reveal themselves within the next few weeks or months on Dynamite, but a new stable will be that in all but name.
But...what's causing all this?!
Every tease - red herring or otherwise - of its future existence has been laden with references to the legendary quartet. It began in the background when Cody's relationship with "coach" Arn Anderson saw Andersons and Rhodes' breaking bread for the first time. In a legendary 1994 promo Dusty once told Dustin that "the view never changes" in relation to why he couldn't trust 'Double A' in his role as Ric Flair's enforcer. He wasn't around to do that for the 'American Nightmare'.
Since then, Tully Blanchard has resurfaced from wrestling obscurity, got inside the head of Shawn Spears to target Cody (and, latterly, given him Barry Windham's black glove to get f*cking serious) and helped guide FTR to tag team glory as natural successors to his devastating 1980s double act with Anderson. MJF has suggested he might need a stable, Cody has flashed the four fingers, FTR stood for "Fear The Revelation" despite not revealing anything and on and on it goes.
The gimmick doesn't need this list to show why it's still needed - it'll soon show it.
9. Perfect Record
This one's sort of already happening too, as it happens.
During her time in NXT, Bianca Belair confirmed herself as 'The EST' by rapidly backing up her bluster with a series of tremendous performances that marked her as a star-in-the-making. All actions and words, she was the ideal combination to possibly dethrone the unstoppable Shayna Baszler before the brand decide to double down on the 'Queen Of Spades' for several more months.
After finally getting one last shot at the gold in February 2020, Belair arrived on the main roster in a largely forgotten WrestleMania cameo before falling into the Raw midcard vortex with similar speed to her NXT ascension. Thankfully, post-Draft, she's been rebooted.
She's the fast-est, strong-est and quick-est, and fortunately for her you can't put "est" on the end of "worst" regardless of what sh*t WWE might throw her way. Well, unless you're a toddler, but WWE can't secure younger viewers for love nor money at the moment. To build from these Mr Perfect-adjacent vignettes, hopefully the brilliant Belair will go on an unbeaten streak that at least gets her to WrestleMania season a contender for one of the company's top titles.
8. The Stats Guru
The world is now dominated by data.
Every move you make on the internet is documented. Every single click, scroll or or hover carefully spotted by another device somewhere else collating the data to be fed into a bank housing the everybody else's data in order to service the tech industry's muscle with advertisers.
Computers remain just as powerless as they were when WCW's York Foundation used to pretend their robotic minds could locate the weakness of a potential opponent, but the data that can be entered into and mined from them has never been more potent or powerful. All that Terri Runnels' Alexandra York character professed to be now actually exists in the form of the Tech Bros and Data Gurus of Silicon Valley.
AEW flirted with the idea during their first Dark Order reboot, but wrestling in general hasn't tapped into an increasing social dilemma powerful enough to give a Netflix exposé its perfect title. It should - if only to scare some of the worst offenders off Twitter for good.
7. A Ripped Narcissist
There are characters that flirt with elements of this gimmick at present, but nothing that brings it all together to capture the sheer sh*thousery of Lex Luger in various incarnations, Rick Martel in all his late-80s 'Model' pomp or even Chris Masters before his work was badly, badly exposed and his body was mocked by his boss' son-in-law following a wellness violation.
When Brian Cage has finished doing the bidding for Team Taz, he should get to flexing a little more for the good of himself. Humongous mirror and all. Shayna Baszler is bigger and badder than most of the women on the Raw roster, but that's rarely been enough for Vince McMahon to book her as such thus far. It goes understated how much black humour she adds to her beatings - might she have untapped comedic potential adding braggadocios bullsh*t as well? MJF has mastered "mean and lean" since getting his big television break a year ago and could easily add even grosser narcissism to his bag of tricks.
Wrestling remains an aesthetics industry too - there'll never be a time where the bananas visual of a bananas body would actively hinder somebody's trajectory.
6. Road Warriors
The recent passing of Joe "Animal" Laurinaitis was a reminder when one wasn't particularly needed that people just loved The Road Warriors.
As disparate attempts proved at various points in their legendary careers, they cannot be imitated, duplicated or reformed in a way that captures the brutal magic seeing Hawk and Animal brutalise poor mugs for the first time. But has there been a better time for the aesthetic of ostentatious bad*sses to make a return than 2020?
We are living through an era never more fragmented in terms of tastes and hobbies. "Niche" is beginning to look like an impossible - or at very least improbable - concept, and the world's better for it. If a wrestler wanted to capture the dystopian chaos of the Legion Of Doom and adopt similarly insane names and clothes to get it done, they'd be beloved by a tribe that would find them.
The main roster probably wasn't ready for The Ascension before they were buried by legends anyway. The Retribution names are as lame as they are as much because of the gimmick as anything else. The 80s and 90s remain en vogue though - use the good bits for a change.
5. A Wrestling Clown
...that starts by destroying The Fiend.
Or not really, (the backlash wouldn't be worth the hot start the push would get) but ultimately two of them cannot exist within the same orbit. A character like this would be best served on a Wednesday Night anyway. Heel Doink was cut from the creative cloth of a Vince McMahon that simply doesn't exist anymore.
He was a psychopath pro wrestler using the clown paint as an artifice before he became a moonlighting children's party entertainer, and it's this gimmick that could probably get over again with the right guy or girl in the gear. The thing about a wrestling clown is that it's the stupidest idea in the world until it becomes the only one that makes sense. Wrestling is a circus, the promoter a literal ring master, and this caricature of wild colour and character is there to either make people laugh or cry with his actions that are in actuality mimicking reality rather than reflecting it.
It's a lot to ask of WWE, but not of AEW nor - to a lesser extent - NXT.
4. WWE-Branded Psychopath
...that starts by destroying The Fiend.
Or not really, (the backlash wouldn't be worth the hot start the push would get) but ultimately two of them cannot exist within the same orbit. A character like this would be best served on a Wednesday Night anyway. A psychopath such as the original incarnation of Mankind was cut from the creative cloth of a Vince McMahon that simply doesn't exist anymore.
But, flippancy aside, McMahon needs to unlock whatever corner of his brain came up with the first Mick Foley persona, or even the one that realised Sycho Sid could do the job justice even with a stupid spelling. Bray Wyatt's 2019 upgrade carried the same weight of threat for precisely one match - a criminal indictment on their process - before gradually being blunted for the good of the merch money and just about f*ck all else.
It's painfully apparent how much the jig is up on getting a new Undertaker, but at least provide some hope that there might one day be a force as strong as his greatest rival.
3. Evil Billionaire
Some would say the world's already being run by one, and World Wrestling Entertainment definitely is, so why on earth is that not being transplanted on screen? And are those two things connected?
As Reaganomics raged throughout the money-obsessed 1980s, Vince McMahon presented Ted Dibiase as a cartoonish manifestation of those he saw living lives similar to the 'Million Dollar Man' in all bar the shiny suits. Over a decade later, he patterned JBL on the type of myopic wealth destined to thrive under George W. Bush's confused and conflict-laden administration. If he were to do the same again in 2020, it would be an even sharper reflection now than it was back then - and might that be why he hasn't?
Instead, the overtly heelish Retribution felt like his wretched take on Antifa, and some vital months spent operating out of Orlando earlier this year were acquired thanks to governmental support. A Dibiase or Layfield - or, for that matter, Mr McMahon - archetype hasn't felt as potent as it does right now. Perhaps the events of November 2020 will determine if the gimmick makes a comeback or we face a minimum of another four year wait.
2. Aspirational Douchebag Yuppies
And not just because The Mean Street Posse were a good laugh in small doses.
If there's one thing worse than feeling incredibly estranged from governments and leaders that are supposed to have your best interests at heart, it's seeing those that either toady up to supposed authorities for favour. Or worse, people you know that embrace said toadying in the hope that they'll get some of that reflected glory.
These are inherently dislikable qualities, and WWE are currently desperate for characters that are actually one thing or a-f*cking-nother. Are The Hurt Business still heels? And if not, does that mean that Cedric Alexander is a babyface again? But Ricochet and Apollo Crews are babyfaces, and he turned on them. But Mustafa Ali was with that group and he's turned heel to join Retribution, so does that make the Hurt Business babyfaces. But. But but but.
Point is, these bootlick types are absolute Grade-A pr*cks in real life and in kayfabe, instantly recognisable for having a load of awful traits and a some idiosyncratic dress code that marks them out as such. Raw could do - and is doing - much worse.
1. Lunatic With An Animal
Albeit in controlled and safe circumstances.
At AEW All Out 2019, Cody's poor dog Pharaoh was put through the ringer by a load of pyro and lights going off before being made to walk to the ring with the 'American Nightmare' as part of a particularly grandiose entrance he didn't even need. This brought back into focus the pointlessness of an innocent animal being exposed to a world they don't really need to be a part of...but villains making monsters of nature's creatures was often the right side of wild.
Jake Roberts setting his cobra on Randy Savage was easily one of the most terrifying moments in company history. Scott Steiner rocking up on the October 23rd 2000 edition of Nitro with a tiger added yet another layer of insanity to the 'Big Bad Booty Daddy's aesthetic. Bad News Brown's "sewer rat" was f*cking massive.
What episode of SmackDown wouldn't be enlivened by The Fiend terrifying the opposition with a real life buzzard parked at ringside? Or Raw Underground coming under threat of alligator attack? Or Retribution's "locusts of contempt" being countered by The Hurt Business' attack dogs. It's been said Vince McMahon treats his wrestlers like animals as it is - might as well book some more.