10 On-Screen WWE Couples That Had No Chemistry

Many WWE couples have been missing that most vital ingredient.

By John Bills /

For whatever reason, most likely due to the whole 'fictional soap-opera' thing, World Wrestling Entertainment just loves putting two individuals together in an on-screen relationship. It is understandable: if you're going to attempt to give the impression of a 'Universe' then what is a universe without love?

Advertisement

Wrestling and romance go back a long way, with many memorable couples stealing our hearts over the years. 'Macho Man' Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth stand out, as do Eddie Guerrero and Chyna, Edge and Vickie Guerrero, and Billy Gunn and Torrie Wilson.

Wait, what? Billy Gunn and Torrie Wilson? Yeah, sometimes WWE has a hair-brained scheme to put two people together only for them to flounder completely on-screen. Hard work can certainly go a long way to improving in-ring ability or even promo work, but chemistry between two human beings is something that simply can't be taught.

WWE has failed to learn this over the years, and as a result the history of WWE romance is littered with couples that lacked that most vital of romantic ingredients. Here are 10 WWE on-screen couples that had a grand total of zero chemistry.

10. Balls Mahoney & Kelly Kelly

She was a 20-year old former bikini model, head-hunted by the head of talent relations in the company to be the breakout star of a three-woman faction whose entire job description was 'be extremely attractive and remove clothes'. He was a 35-year old grizzled veteran who had first made an appearance in the company when she was just eight years old.

Advertisement

The on-screen flirtations of Kelly Kelly and Balls Mahoney made little sense to anyone, not then, not now. It was creative's attempt to provide a storyline reason for Kelly Kelly to break away from her compadres in Extreme Expose, but her and Balls had little in the way of on-screen chemistry.

World Wrestling Entertainment has as much a history of being obsessed with aesthetic perfection as it does with so-called 'odd couples'. This was one such oddity that just didn't work.

9. Ted DiBiase Jr. & Maryse

They say the apple doesn't fall far from the tree, but this isn't always the case. 'The Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase was one of the most dastardly charismatic heels of the 1980s, fully embodying his arrogant rich man persona. His son, Ted DiBiase Jr. was a talented young man, this much is true, but he didn't exactly have his father's charisma.

Advertisement

After breaking away from the successful Legacy faction, DiBiase was expected to become a big star. He was paired with Maryse, a terrifyingly-attractive and charismatic former Divas Champion. The pairing made sense as an entitled affluent pair, but something wasn't right.

The problem lay with DiBiase, and his seeming lack of confidence in the role. The duo had zero chemistry, and the normally magnetic Maryse was completely neutered. Contrast this with her pairing with real-life husband The Miz today, and you get a real feeling of 'what could have been'.

8. Billy Gunn & Torrie Wilson

Despite being one of the most beautiful women ever to grace a WWE ring, Torrie Wilson wasn't exactly Sherri Martel in the charisma ranks. It didn't help that, with the exception of Tajiri, she was consistently paired with some of the least charismatic performers in wrestling at the time.

Advertisement

The most nonsensical of these was her brief alliance with Billy Gunn. Gunn was in full 'Mr. A' mode, a moniker and gimmick (I guess you could say) that didn't exactly have a lot of depth to it. Billy Gunn liked bums, that was about it. Torrie Wilson? Well, she had a fairly pleasing derrière, and that was all the reasons needed to put them together.

It didn't work, and was abandoned fairly soon after. WWE managed to hit some low points during their brief run, with uber-charismatic Jamie Noble winning a night with Torrie after he and Nidia defeated Wilson and Gunn. Yep.

7. Vince McMahon & Trish Stratus

The more one thinks about it (and I would say it may be better not to do so), Vince McMahon is a bit of an awful man. As the guy who has the final say on what eventually makes it to TV, a lot of the blame for some of the company's reprehensible misogyny can be laid at his door, especially when it comes to angles that he himself is included in.

Advertisement

During the late '90s and early '00s, Vince booked himself into a succession of on-screen relationships with the various beautiful ladies working for WWF at the time, the most high-profile of which was Trish Stratus. Vince's story with Trish was particularly grim, with the Boss famously making Trish bark like a dog.

It is probably understandable considering the awfulness of the story, but Trish and Vince displayed little in the way of chemistry during their pairing. Maybe it was down to the 30-year age difference.

6. Dawn Marie & Al Wilson

Whilst we're on the subject of Wilsons with little charisma and ridiculous on-screen relationships with huge age gaps, where to begin with Dawn Marie and Al Wilson?

Advertisement

Their affair came about in 2002, when Dawn Marie embarked on a feud with Al's daughter Torrie. Seemingly in an attempt to infuriate her foe, Marie seduced Wilson's father. The two became engaged, but Dawn Marie revealed that she had feelings for Torrie and the two enjoyed an on-screen kiss. The wedding went ahead however, with Dawn and Al's vows eventually taking place in nothing but their underwear.

The story was inherently ridiculous, but it certainly wasn't helped by the fact Al had little in the way of understanding regarding the business and was a total vacuum of charisma. Dawn and Al had less charisma than a used teabag. Preposterously, the Dawn Marie/Wilson Family feud lasted an agonising nine months.

5. Stephanie McMahon & Test

It may be the most infamous 'wedding' in the history of World Wrestling Entertainment, but it is often forgotten that Stephanie McMahon and Test showed little in the way of chemistry up until that point. Theirs was the marquee storyline at the time, and whilst 13-year-old John was all-in on the saga it doesn't hold up so well to 30-year-old John.

Advertisement

Stephanie McMahon was new to WWE (then-WWF) television at the time, making her debut just a few months prior. Just 23-years old, Stephanie was somewhat wooden and awkward on camera, which was only exacerbated when paired alongside the equally wooden and awkward Test.

The idea for the story was sound enough, as the company had high hopes for Test and including him in a story with the McMahon family may very well have been the way to go. In hindsight, they would have been better off just having him as a big guy that frequently wrecked shop, as opposed to having to awkwardly emote with a 23-year old rookie.

4. Stacey Kiebler & David Flair

Returning to those apples and their trees, in many ways David Flair was everything that his father Ric wasn't. Ric was the Nature Boy, one of the most charismatic individuals ever to wipe their feet on the apron and strut into a professional wrestling ring. David Flair, well, he was a young guy with bleached blonde hair and that's about it. Still, that surname goes a long way, and as such David got his fair share of spotlight in the dying days of World Championship Wrestling.

Advertisement

Flair had a number of relationships during his tenure in WCW, but none more high profile than his almost-wedding with Stacey Kiebler. It was during this relationship that David turned on his father and shaved his head, because WCW.

The Flair-Kiebler wedding never materialised however, as it was revealed that Stacey was pregnant and David wasn't the father. This made perfect sense of course, as Stacey and David showed absolutely nothing in the way of physical or personal chemistry during their time together.

David and Stacey actually dated in real life, and one can only hope they had more chemistry off camera than on it.

3. Natalya & The Great Khali

Another odd couple, and another ridiculous story in the frequently-ridiculous career of Natalya Neidhart. The farting gimmick may have been the low point, but for a short while Natalya was also involved in an on-screen relationship with The Great Khali of all people. To worsen the act, the duo were joined to the ring by Hornswoggle. If a storyline in WWE is stupid, it usually involves Hornswoggle.

Advertisement

The pair had little in the way of chemistry during their time together, although this can almost be excused. By this point Khali was barely mobile in the ring at all, limiting his physical charisma, and emoting had never really been his strongpoint anyway. Khali looked fairly uncomfortable for the duration of his 'Punjabi Playboy' run, and his tenure with Natalya was the most awkward part.

Zero chemistry, zero sense.

2. John Cena & Aj Lee

From November 2011 until April 2013, AJ Lee was involved in a conveyor belt of on-screen relationships. Daniel Bryan would be the start, and the belt would go through Kane, CM Punk, John Cena, and Dolph Ziggler before coming to an end. AJ Lee was a truly talented performer and managed to make all of these relationships exciting and almost natural. Well, all except the relationship with Cena that is.

Advertisement

Maybe it is his American Action Hero persona, but John Cena and on-screen romance have never been the most comfortable of bedfellows. He kisses like someone who looks like they have been taught how to kiss on-camera, and his smooching with AJ Lee came off as particularly wooden.

Two top performers, but next to no charisma. Luckily, the relationship lasted only a few weeks.

1. Dolph Ziggler & Lana

Good lord I hated this story.

Advertisement

After a fantastic 2014, Rusev and Lana came into 2015 with high hopes. Instead, the Bulgarian Brute and the Ravishing Russian were fed to John Cena before constituting one half of the worst WWE story of the year, the godawful love quadrangle with Dolph Ziggler and Summer Rae.

WWE was hell-bent on turning Lana babyface, and they decided to do this by splitting her and Rusev up and stripping Lana of everything that made her such a compelling character in the first place. She lost her strength, she lost her independence, and she lost her conviction. She even lost her suit dress. She was paired with Dolph Ziggler, and the two became the least compatible couple in WWE memory.

Everything about the duo was awkward, their interactions coming across like two people plucked off the street and asked to portray a fairly complex idea through camera. They held hands like people who had just discovered they had hands, and kissed in such a way that made kissing look like an impossible task.

The entire debacle set Lana back somewhat, and she has since been coupled back up with real-life fiancé Rusev in a much more natural pairing. Dolph Ziggler and Lana's relationship will go down as one of the biggest mistakes in WWE's recent history, as the complete lack of chemistry between the two was just as frustrating as it was difficult to watch.

Advertisement