10 Perfect WWE Main Roster Rivalries For Tye Dillinger
It was a long journey for The Perfect Ten to get to the main roster... but what happens next?
Tye Dillinger's long overdue main roster debut was one of the most exciting moments of the first post-WrestleMania SmackDown, but WWE is yet to truly capitalise on The Perfect Ten's call-up to the big leagues. A squash victory over Curt Hawkins and a listless quasi-feud with Aiden English isn't exactly befitting of the man who so fervently captured the hearts and minds of the Full Sail crowd and beyond.
There's reason for optimism, however. SmackDown's self-professed 'Land Of Opportunity' moniker isn't entirely inaccurate, and with WWE currently so incapable of creating genuinely over babyfaces, the company should soon stop hesitating and push Dillinger higher up the card - or even onto the card at all. Even Vinny Mac's well-proven obliviousness must be tested by the loudness of those insistent 'Ten!' chants.
When Dillinger does find himself in a more meaningful role on WWE programming, there're a number of opponents with the potential to showcase his best attributes.
Now what that number could possibly be...
10. Baron Corbin
Under his current persona, a Baron Corbin rivalry is the easiest thing to write in the world. Babyface X (Dolph Ziggler, Kalisto, Jack Swagger, Dean Ambrose, Sami Zayn...) achieves a result over Corbin, which enrages The Lone Wolf, and he proceeds to beat the hell out of his opponent outside of the ring. The beatings continue for weeks until a blow-off match at SmackDown's next pay-per-view.
Corbin's booking and moveset might both be a little basic, but that doesn't mean that the he isn't incredibly effective at what he does. His size and brutish demeanour guarantee sympathy for whoever is facing him, and Tye Dillinger feeds on that sympathetic reaction like no other on the roster. He gets loud enough reactions as it is, but every strike landed against Corbin is going to feel even more impressive. The cheers should be through the roof.
If Corbin doesn't win the briefcase at Money In The Bank, he could very easily find himself immediately entering this feud. He needs a win, having not won on PPV since TLC in December, and after his run in NXT, Dillinger has become an expert in the art of looking good in defeat. Expect to see Corbin-Dillinger on the under-card of Battleground when July rolls around.
9. James Ellsworth
At their core, wrestling storylines often serve as an extended exercise in catharsis. Heels are built up for the feel-good moment of a babyface handing them their comeuppance. James Ellsworth might not be the most intimidating of villains, but it's hard to imagine a moment of greater gratification that his chinless head getting smashed into Tye Dillinger's knee.
It veers between generating the right and wrong kinds of heat, but Ellsworth's deluded toady attitude makes him a reliably antagonistic character, which isn't always easy to come by in the modern era of wrestling. His current embroilment and interference in the SmackDown Women's Championship picture means that retribution is unlikely to be served against him any time soon, so who better to step in and hand him the beating he deserves than The Perfect Ten?
Maintaining sympathy in a match against a clearly weaker opponent is a difficult task to achieve, but if there's anybody who could accomplish it, it's Tye Dillinger. The match obviously wouldn't be a mat classic, but WWE love their squashes, and if Dillinger has to be getting quick, relatively meaningless victories, it might as well be against an opponent who the audience really wants to see get hurt.
8. Roman Reigns
Given that all this is fantasy booking, it seems permissible to leave aside the issues of brands and alignments. Tye Dillinger is, for now, one of the most beloved wrestlers by the WWE audience. Roman Reigns is probably the most reviled. In a different and more logical time, this would really position them on a collision course with one another.
If Reigns already garners barely believable levels of heat, putting him in the ring against Dillinger can only make the match even more electric. This doesn't even rely on the mythical Roman Reigns heel turn; 2016 showed that Reigns can still be 'The Guy' and have engrossing contests against audience favourites like AJ Styles and Dean Ambrose.
Tye Dillinger is fantastic in the underdog role, and being the opponent of the company's golden child is the biggest underdog anyone can possibly be in the WWE. Whatever criticisms can be levelled against his presentation, Roman Reigns' in-ring work is solid and the two should be more than capable of delivering a great match. There's no way in hell that it would ever be booked for Dillinger to come out on top, of course, but being in the same ring as The Big Dog, even on a free TV match, can only serve to elevate Dillinger's stock within the company. Believe that.
7. Dolph Ziggler
It's been overstated as of late, but Dolph Ziggler's state of affairs is currently a fairly sorry one. Once one of WWE's brightest stars, Ziggler has since been relegated to the thankless task of putting over incoming talent like Apollo Crews, Kalisto, and Shinsuke Nakamura. He isn't even that popular in this role; one of the biggest complaints about his Backlash clash with Nakamura is that Ziggler was allowed to get in too much offence.
It wasn't that long ago that things were looking more optimistic, however – Ziggler's late-2016 series with The Miz was well-received. One of the hallmarks of this rivalry was The Miz's assertion that Ziggler was past his prime and no longer relevant. Once used as babyface fire, this trait could similarly be used to reinvigorate Ziggler's heelish venom. Repeating his rivalry with Nakamura, except, you know, better, Ziggler's disgust with the positive fan reaction shown to Dillinger could easily lead to tensions between the two.
Ziggler would make a great first major victory for Dillinger on the main roster before moving on to bigger and better things, and the match itself would have the potential to be a barnstormer. Ziggler getting much more offence in makes more sense against Tye than it did against Shinsuke, and it would be a delight to see Dillinger counter one of Ziggler's superkicks with one of his own. Tye Dillinger has the potential to be a major player for SmackDown, but he needs a stepping stone to reach that level. It's unfortunate, but that's currently the best use for Ziggler that WWE seems to have.
6. Sami Zayn
If the previous story didn't feel all that enthralling, there's a less expected way to spin a similar narrative. One potential barrier to Dillinger's success on the blue brand is the presence of an even greater underdog fan favourite – the former El Generico. Sami Zayn's pluck and courage hasn't been enough to propel him to main roster glory yet, and this should serve as a warning to Dillinger, who fits a similar mould.
Despite how well he's got over as a lovable babyface, it should be noted that Tye Dillinger has spent much of his developmental and indie career as a heel, and the role wouldn't be a stranger to him. Turning on Sami Zayn is a surefire way to get yourself booed, even for a face as popular as Dillinger. They can't (or at least shouldn't) both play the same part, and given that their 'never say never' attitudes and outpourings of fan support haven't particularly brought much success to either man, something's got to give.
A Dillinger-Zayn match would no doubt be fantastic, and it would be refreshing to watch Sami in a singles match where his opponent isn't towering over him. Fast, fluid matches are in relatively short supply in current WWE programming, and it's something that both men excel at. All that's needed is for Dillinger to grow sick of being a fan favourite and turn on one of the few superstars who's more of one than he is.
5. Bray Wyatt
There's often very little rhyme or reason to a Bray Wyatt rivalry (or a Bray Wyatt promo. Or a Bray Wyatt match), so it's easy to throw him against any current roster member you can think of and call it a day. However, Tye Dillinger's excellent rivalry with SAnitY is easily a blueprint to repeat for similar success on the main roster, and a story of that strength could help the revival of credibility that Wyatt needs after the losing the WWE Championship.
Whether it's rebuilding the Wyatt family to give Bray the numbers advantage (or maybe finally utilising those dozens of cloaked followers he seems to be able to beckon) or Tye nobly resisting his tempting offer of an alliance, a re-imagining of one of the last year's best NXT feuds on a larger scale with more screentime should really only boost the profiles of both men, and if it can culminate with as good a match as Tye and Eric Young's recent steel cage match, then everybody should really be satisfied.
At the end of the day, NXT is still a developmental brand, and there's nothing wrong with re-implementing the storylines that work, as well as the wrestlers. Zayn-Owens at Battleground was every bit as good as Zayn-Owens at Takeover: Rival. Chris Jericho's 'sexy pinata' routine was superior to Paul Ellering being needlessly suspended in a shark cage. If done right, then Dillinger vs Wyatt could capture all that was good about Tye's feud with SAnitY, and possibly even take it up another level.
4. Jinder Mahal
It might sound ridiculous to frame the recently debuted Dillinger as the next potential #1 contender, but it's equally (if not more) ridiculous that Jinder Mahal is currently WWE Champion. The rules don't apply anymore. The Perfect Ten missed out on earning any titles in NXT, but his current wave of popularity is enough to propel him to glory. Mahal is one of the most contentious choices for a world champion in recent memory, but parachuting the title back to a safe pair of hands like Randy Orton isn't much more interesting. If WWE are going to take creative risks, then why not take a risk on a guy with such incredible crowd support?
It's support that would only get more vocal if Dillinger was the one chosen to knock off The Maharaja. Even if he didn't win the gold, the momentum of a main event push like that would cement Dillinger as a top contender for a long time. WWE love to throw around phrases like 'land of opportunity' and 'grabbing the brass ring', and there's very few other wrestlers in the company who maximised their minutes in 2016 like Dillinger did. If superstars lower down the totem pole are now eligible to win #1 contendership, then Tye Dillinger should be the first in line.
Mahal's character is still pretty ill-defined, but one of his strongest traits is his arrogant disrespect towards the WWE Universe. For maximum storyline investment, his next opponent should be a people's hero, somebody who fights on behalf of the fans. There's few currently better suited to that role than Tye Dillinger. WWE struggles to get the fans to cheer the heroes and boo the villains – pitting Dillinger against Mahal with gold on the line is a surefire way to remedy that.
3. Braun Strowman
Tye Dillinger's surprise #10 entry in this year's Royal Rumble and subsequent battle with Braun Strowman may have been the highlight of the entire event. Creating a fully-fledged story between the two feels like a potential goldmine. Little more than a month ago, the two men arguably had the most momentum of any two wrestlers on the roster. While injury and hesitant booking might have stalled both men, putting them in the ring together soon would still feel certain to bring the house down.
Strowman has been improving by leaps and bounds in the ring recently, but if he's to become a main event player, it's advisable to give his in-ring ability all the fine-tuning possible. Dillinger's been in the business for a much longer time and a series against him would definitely help to elevate Strowman's wrestling game. Dillinger hasn't faced any adversity yet on the main roster, and it would be to his benefit as a character to face an opponent who feels like more of a challenge. Challengers don't get much bigger than The New Face Of Destruction.
Whether or not Dillinger wins, he feels like a hero for willingly placing himself in the way of such a monster. Strowman's feud with Sami Zayn was good, but hampered (as always) by too much involvement from authority figures. Simply position Dillinger as the babyface out to teach Strowman a lesson for callously mauling his way through the roster, and you have a programme with the potential to be fantastic. If Dillinger loses, he still comes off as valiant and likeable. If he wins, he's a giant slayer with main event potential.
2. John Cena
As John Cena descends into a part-time role in the WWE, logic dictates that he should start to put over new talent who are on the way up. There's not a chance in hell of this really happening, of course, but it's logical. If WWE really want to create a star out of Tye Dillinger, there's no better way to do it than giving him a shock win over Big Match John himself.
It might surprise some to know that Cena and Dillinger actually have history. In a one-time sojourn down to developmental FCW in May of 2008, Cena was giving a promo when Dillinger (then a heel by the name of Gavin Spears) came out to interrupt him. The two exchanged some entertaining barbs and pre-match tension before Cena predictably proceeded to put his opposition away in less time than it would have taken him to tie his shoelaces. Not exactly befitting of a man who calls himself The Perfect Ten.
There's potentially an entire story to be spun out of this small encounter. Dillinger might still be burning with resentment about being humiliated in such a way and turn heel on The Doctor Of Thuganomics, but a scenario more in keeping with the character that got him over would be for Dillinger to boldly call Cena out, looking to prove himself and how much he's improved over the last 9 years. Letting Dillinger go over would be beneficial to Cena too, allowing him to keep fostering the goodwill of the more hardcore fanbase that he's slowly starting to win over. The long-term benefits of a clean singles win over Cena don't really need to be stated, and while it's not a guaranteed way to stay at the top of the card, there aren't really many better first steps.
1. The Miz
The rivalry between these two practically feels like destiny. The man who took over ten years to fully graduate from developmental versus the man who earned his place through a reality TV competition. The most natural heel in the company (and possibly even the world) versus a man so eminently likeable that he turned narcissism into an endearing trait. The Miz and Tye Dillinger are a match made in heaven and if paired together could even prove to be the defining feud of both men's storied careers.
The Miz excels at incorporating the careers and personal lives of his opponents into his scathing promos, and nobody could provide him with more material than Tye Dillinger. The lengthy stint in developmental, the failed partnership with Jason Jordan, the topknot – all of them excellent targets for a typically blistering character assassination courtesy of The Miz. Dillinger's long road to the top makes him an immediate figure of mockery in the eyes of The Miz, and a natural figure of sympathy for the WWE Universe. They are so perfectly contrasted in an easily exploitable way.
The Miz would no doubt take objection to somebody referring to themselves as a 'Perfect Ten' in his presence, or some other offence against his ego, and then away we go. The Miz at his arrogant, preening, derisive best against one of the most likable wrestlers on the card, but someone who could conceivably lose to him clean, let alone through The Miz's endless chicanery and interference. Miz TV being overridden by incessant 'Ten!' chants. Dillinger dishing out a finale that's even more skull-crushing. Please, WWE. Please.