10 Post-WWE Runs That Were Nothing Like We Expected
Career enders and career renaissances: Not every post-WWE run turns out like you thought it would.
With a roster as bloated as WWE's, it's hardly surprising a lot of wrestlers begin to feel under-utilised. The birth of AEW and resurgence of New Japan have opened up new avenues for newly free workers to pursue beyond the McMahon-owned bubble. It's the first time since the days of WCW that stars have enjoyed financially viable alternatives to the Connecticut conglomerate (unless you count those days when TNA would nab anyone even vaguely associated with WWE).
Plenty of stars have gone out in a blaze of glory, claiming they don't need WWE. Some move on to become wrestling superstars elsewhere. Others suffer the nightmarish fate of fading into obscurity, failing to expand the horizons they initially felt robbed of. Others leave wrestling entirely, finding themselves a new athletic craft. For Brock Lesnar, UFC success made him a bigger star than his original WWE run ever did. For CM Punk, UFC failure has killed a good deal of interest in his return (though for this list we'll be sticking to those who kept on wrestling).
It's a brave call to bet on oneself (and slightly less daunting than for those who got fired), no matter how it turns out.
10. Damien Sandow
Not the most technically skilled of wrestlers, Damien Sandow made up for it with truly exceptional character and promo work. His pompous intellectual persona oozed potential and was getting over right up until he failed to beat a one-armed John Cena. Slipping down the card, Sandow went full comedy as The Miz's stunt double, taking off thanks to his ridiculous displays during Miz's matches. With WWE again dropping the ball on him, Sandow was released in 2016, later debuting in Impact Wrestling.
His first promo for Impact indicated trouble ahead. Instead of playing to his strengths, the now Aron Rex cut a prototypical anti-WWE promo. Lacking the necessary menace and physical ability to carry off a tougher, more serious character, his shine with fans quickly dimmed. It wasn't long before he was free falling down the card once again.
A late stage attempt at a reboot was ultimately the final nail in the coffin. Returning to an attempt at the funny stuff, Rex became a flamboyant, Liberace send-up for his final days with the promotion. A disappointment all round, Sandow's post-WWE run ultimately tanked the connection he'd built with fans. Recent work with the NWA has done little to really get him back on track either.
9. Drew McIntyre
The Chosen One was an obvious star in the making when he debuted on SmackDown in 2009. Presented as a prodigious young heel, McIntyre quickly became IC champion and was starting to garner decent crowd heat. Sadly, a rather embarrassing incident at the Playboy Mansion with ex-wife Taryn Terrell derailed his momentum. WWE punished him with a drop down the card. In place of his old winning streak, he now got to enjoy a losing one.
A comedy run in 3MB appeared to be the final nail in the coffin for McIntyre with WWE releasing him in 2014. Bulking up more than ever before, Drew Galloway quickly became the hardest working man on the indies and a great lead character for Impact Wrestling. Winning gold all over the shop, Galloway was the main event everywhere he went.
It was an impressive display from a wrestler many considered burnt out just a few years prior. Even more impressive was his work leading to a second chance in WWE where he is now the promotion's top babyface. Still the Chosen One after all, his original post-WWE run is one of the most impressive career turn arounds in professional wrestling history.
8. Jack Swagger
'The Savage' Jake Strong was a sadistic force to be reckoned with on the final season of Lucha Underground. His ankle lock was presented as a career ender, kayfabe snapping the bones of Famous B, Big Bad Steve and Sammy Guevara on the way to being the show's final world champion.
Seeing Jake Hager play such a beast on LU was a shocker given his years as a jobber to the stars in WWE. Mr We The People was a perpetual victim of WWE's start-stop habit, occasionally being built up only to be knocked right back down the card. With zero credibility by the end of his run (and a career worst promo to start a doomed feud with Baron Corbin), Jack Swagger was granted his release in 2017.
His presentation as a monster everywhere since is no doubt a head turner for those who've only seen him in WWE. Thanks to his impressive work in Bellator though, Hager has legit fighter credibility and is easy to present as a deadly hard man everywhere he goes. He fits the role of Chris Jericho's dangerous bodyguard nicely in AEW and continues to be a respectable tough guy act for the company today.
7. KENTA
Hideo Itami developed a bad reputation for being made of glass during his time in NXT. Whenever a hot angle was lined up for the former Pro Wrestling NOAH stalwart, the perils of injury would strike. A promotion to 205 Live ultimately played out more like a demotion with the frustrated Itami leaving and returning to his native Japan in 2019.
Most fans expected a NOAH return making his entry into New Japan's 2019 G1 Climax all the more surprising. Poorly received by the New Japan faithful, KENTA turned heel, joined the Bullet Club and beatdown his old pal Katsuyori Shibata. The typically polite audience proceeded to boo the GTS innovator like there was no tomorrow.
KENTA has since found his voice again as a mean-spirited, snarky heel. While years of wear and tear have slowed his wrestling when compared to his late noughties prime, KENTA's character work has never been better. He has become a key moment in AEW history for years to come recently by firing the first on screen shot of an AEW/New Japan working relationship.
Considering how in the dumps his career appeared to be by the end of his time in WWE, this villainous resurgence was the last thing anyone expected.
6. EC3
Derrick Bateman was a funny guy but, in the words of Jim Cornette, "Funny doesn't make money."
Back when NXT was still an awful game show, Bateman was stuck there in a Groundhog Day style loop for years. Despite a good physique and promo chops, it was clear WWE didn't see a hell of a lot in the FCW graduate. Released in 2013, Bateman's departure went barely noticed by viewers.
His subsequent rebirth as Ethan Carter III in Impact was a jaw dropper to say the least. Cutting colourful heel promos and ramping up the intensity in his ring work, Carter enjoyed a one way road to the main event. As the spoilt nephew of Dixie Carter, EC3 was an effective heat magnet for the company throughout his bad guy run.
His return to WWE was an exciting prospect this time around right up until he wasn't even allowed to speak on the main roster. A bizarre decision given the mic has always been his biggest strength. Since leaving, EC3's run has been a surprise for fans once again, though this time it's been unexpected mostly for the wrong reasons...
5. Juice Robinson
CJ Parker's hippy persona played out like a babyface jobber version of Daniel Bryan's acclaimed Planet's Champion run. Presented as an eco-friendly eccentric, Parker ate losses left, right and centre before bowing out of the promotion entirely.
Starting all over again with his old Juice Robinson name, he joined the gruelling New Japan Dojo and was retrained in the art of strong style. Free of the goofy antics that anchored him in NXT, Robinson quickly became a lovable underdog. On the mic, he continues to go from strength to strength as a sympathetic fighter trying to claw his way up the card.
The US title never felt more important than during Robinson's reigns. Despite major names such as Kenny Omega, Jay White and Jon Moxley holding the red strap, it was Robinson who presented the belt as the most important thing in his life. When he lost the belt to Moxley in 2019, Robinson appeared genuinely devastated by the setback with the kind of passion and realism modern wrestling often severely lacks. Currently on Impact with tag partner David Finlay, the promotion could benefit greatly from pushing Robinson in singles action this year.
4. Christian
It's... it's Christian.
The difference between Christian's TNA debut and his return to WWE in 09 was like night and day. Unhappy with his perennial midcarder status in WWE, Christian refused an on the spot new contract offer in 2005 and jumped ship. Unlike WWE, TNA appreciated what they had with Captain Charisma and started pushing him right out of the gate.
For viewers watching TNA for the first time, it was mind blowing to see the former IC champ be celebrated by a wave of adoring fans with a world title held high. Christened the Instant Classic, Christian's great babyface work was eclipsed only by his run as a heel. Villainous Christian Cage was so good he even gave old pal Edge a run for his heel money at the time.
Having proven he was more than cut out to be a top of the card star, anticipation for a WWE return was incredibly high in late 2008. Sadly, WWE still couldn't quite see what everyone else could and Christian, despite his all round talent, was debuted on the ECW brand thanks to a leak surrounding his originally planned Jeff Hardy feud.
3. Bret Hart
The Hitman should've been an easy sell as the world's biggest babyface in the wake of the Montreal Screwjob. Anticipation for his arrival in WCW was exceedingly high with rumours abounding of an impending nWo feud. While that would've been nice, it fast became clear that WCW had no clue what they actually wanted to do with Calgary's favourite son.
Even with some creative control in his contract, Hart floundered throughout 1998 as a hot and cold upper midcard act who couldn't decide whether or not he was on the nWo's side. It made zero sense and detracted from the once noble, gritty persona Hart had perfected in WWE. Monumentally disappointing, Hart was trapped in US title purgatory for way too long and by the time WCW committed to pushing him at the level WWE did, it was a case of too little, too late.
Considering all the controversy and hype surrounding Hart leaving WWE, the state of his years in WCW is a big head scratcher from a promotion that was full of them. The fact that he was once so protective of his image made this middling run all the more unexpected for fans and fellow workers alike.
2. Miro
It's WrestleMania 31: Rusev enters on a tank, he's undefeated, a superstar in the making.
It's 15 minutes later: Rusev's fallen to a single AA, he continues falling for years.
Despite a good deal of charisma, intensity and humour in his persona and ring work, Rusev never wound up getting the level of push he was cut out for in WWE. When he and Aiden English partnered up for the popular Rusev Day angle, it seemed like WWE were almost angry with the fans for liking it.
The last straw came with the Jerry Springer-esque Lashley/Lana feud. Paul Heyman at his dirt worst wound up proving fans still wanted to support the Bulgarian Brute. In response, WWE jobbed him out to Lashley on a weekly basis before taking him off TV entirely. With the likes of the late, great Brodie Lee and Jon Moxley finding new life and better star treatment in AEW, expectations for a Rusev run were high.
Before one even gets to his eccentric fashion choices, Miro as a character simply doesn't work. He appears much more interested in promoting his Twitch than in rising up the card. The Best Man angle with Kip Sabian has been goofy undercard fodder at best. Beyond the occasional explosive attack on the likes of Orange Cassidy and Chuckie T, the old Rusev is a distant (and missed) memory for now.
1. Superstar Billy Graham
Superstar Billy Graham was the biggest star in the industry by 1978, ruling WWE as a counter-cultural heel champ. With a jacked bodybuilding physique unlike anything seen in wrestling up to that point, the charismatic Graham revolutionised the industry. Legends to come such as Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair and Jesse Ventura were greatly influenced by his innovative persona.
The first cool heel, Graham left WWE in protest at having to lose the title to the considerably less popular Bob Backlund. Furious that Vince McMahon Sr. had turned down his request to turn babyface and remain champ, Graham returned to the NWA. Beyond a month long reign as IWA World Champ, he did little of note and his once incendiary drawing power cooled off completely.
Many had expected him to be on top in the NWA but the disillusioned Graham seemed uninterested in playing the Superstar character to its former glory. Graham went through several lacklustre runs and character changes throughout the '80s, including 2 brief returns to WWE, the latter of which lead to his retirement.
Given the impact he had on the landscape of professional wrestling in the '80s and beyond, the original Superstar's post WWE title reign runs were deeply disappointing.