10 PPV Main Events That Killed WCW

Take some over-the-age main eventers and sprinkle in some production errors for disastrous results.

By Erik Beaston /

The demise of World Championship Wrestling in 2001 did not happen overnight. No, the death of the once-dominant sports entertainment was years in the making, the result of backstage politics, bad business maneuverings and egomaniacal performers. Those elements not only put the death knell in the company, it also made for a product that was less-than thrilling to watch once the fun and excitement of the New World Order angle and the ascension of Goldberg wore off. One of the biggest knocks on the WCW product, even at its height of popularity, was the lack of quality main event matches. With stars the likes of Rey Mysterio Jr., Billy Kidman, Juventud Guerrera, Dean Malenko, Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit tearing up the mid and undercard scene, slower, older and more tired acts made up the top of the card. Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, Ric Flair, Roddy Piper and Lex Luger may have been responsible for drawing fans based on name value alone but their poor performances left a sour taste in the mouths of fans who had purchased the pay-per-view events to see their antics in the night's biggest and most important matches. The lack of quality matches in the main event was a major strike against WCW and, after years of witnessing the Hulkster stink up the headline bouts with Nash, Flair and Piper, fans opted to turn to WWE, whose Attitude Era programming was more exciting and interesting, especially with The Rock, Steve Austin, Triple H and Mankind delivering classic and chaotic bouts on a monthly basis. There is no denying the fact that awful main events contributed to the death of WCW. Now, take a stroll down memory lane and relive the matches that should take the most blame for the downfall of Ted Turner's wrestling empire.

10. WCW Championship Match: Sting vs. Randy Savage - Spring Stampede 1998

The build to Sting's WCW Championship victory at Starrcade was a year in the making and should have led to the company's franchise star enjoying a sustained run with the gold. Instead, controversy led to him being stripped of the gold and a rematch with Hulk Hogan at SuperBrawl. Luckily, the brain trust running the company at that point made the correct decision on that February night by putting the Stinger over. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said about April's Spring Stampede, where Sting would again be in the championship main event. His opponent? "Macho Man" Randy Savage who, like Hogan, was a staple of the nWo angle and an aging veteran whose best days were far, far behind him. It felt very much like a match designed to strengthen Sting's title reign while simultaneously setting him up for a bigger, more important match down the road. Perhaps against the surging Bill Goldberg. Instead, Savage beat the Stinger in a typical WCW main event, chocked full of run-ins from every major star who opted to take the night off rather than working an actual match. It was a colossal booking mistake that saw management switch the title for the sake of switching it, looking short term rather than long term. Sting's push was officially dead in the water and instead of becoming the hero and savior of the promotion, he was just another guy, the company cutting his legs out from underneath him and killing another star for the sake of pumping time and energy into the dying nWo faction.

9. Strap Match: Hulk Hogan vs. Ric Flair - Uncensored 2000

The grim reaper was knocking on the door of WCW by the time Uncensored rolled around in March 2000. The ratings had sunk to lows as WWE was doing record business with The Rock and Triple H on top. How did the company combat The Great One and The Game's epic rivalry over on their rival's programming? With yet another in the never ending line of matches between Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair. In what was dubbed a "strap match," Hogan and Flair wrestled a hideous, awful, atrocious match that saw Lex Luger interfere, Flair pull out the same brass knuckles gimmick he had used decades earlier and the Hulkster triumph over evil once again. That the rules were blatantly disregarded, the legends using pinfalls instead of bothering to touch the four corners, as the stipulation called for. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xvaqbd_hulk-hogan-vs-ric-flair-wcw-uncensored-2000-part-2_sport Not only was the match truly awful but the fact that the company continued to rely on guys whose best days were a decade behind them continued to plague them. At a time when WWE was going full throttle with young stars and intriguing stories, WCW reverted back to two over-the-hill stars whose days of drumming up interest had come to an end.

8. WCW Championship Match: Chris Benoit vs. Sid Vicious - Souled Out 2000

At first glance, the Chris Benoit-Sid Vicious main event from Souled Out 2000 had little effect on the overall health of WCW at the time. In reality, the company had already dug itself a grave they could not possibly climb out of. Add to it the fact that Benoit vs. Sid was a makeshift main event following a concussion that ultimately ended the career of then-WCW champion Bret Hart and it would appear as though the company simply did the best with what it had available to them. But upon further investigation, it is clear that by booking Benoit to defeat Sid and capture the title, the company made the Edmonton, Alberta native much stronger in the eyes of the fans, just one day before he left for a bigger stage and brighter future in WWE. The inability of those in power to realize that putting a title on the Crippler would not convince him to stay after years of frustration both in the ring and behind the scenes, doomed the company even further than it already was. Within in a month, Benoit was well on his way to becoming one of WWE's premiere stars while WCW was forced to focus on Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, Kevin Nash and the same group of aging and overexposed stars who had been as equally responsible or their downfall as they were their ascension.

7. WCW Championship Match: Sting vs. Hulk Hogan - Halloween Havoc 1999

The first pay-per-view under supposed creative "genius" Vince Russo, Halloween Havoc 1999 should have been a turning point for World Championship Wrestling. Instead, it was yet another strike against a company on its descent into oblivion, thanks in large part to a main event that demonstrated everything wrong with Russo's "crash TV" style of booking. Sting's heel turn at Fall Brawl in September 1999 was shocking, especially since the Venice Beach native had not been a full blown villain in well over a decade. It was a fresh development that had potential, even if his opponent was the same tired, red-and-yellow wearing Hulk Hogan that had dominated the industry for far too long. Rather than delivering a straight up main event that paid off the angle that preceded it, Russo tried to get too controversial, booking a scenario in which Hogan walked to the ring, laid down and let Sting pin him. It was controversy for controversy's sake, a huge mistake given the fact that it made no sense whatsoever in the context of the story being told. Fans looked upon the angle as what it was: another lame attempt by Russo to get fans talking. It failed, as WWE was so hot at the time, the twists and turns on their weekly television far more advanced and smarter than any of the desperate attempts to grab the attention of the audience that Russo was manufacturing.

6. First Blood Barbed Wire Steel Cage Match: Hulk Hogan vs. Ric Flair - Uncensored 1999

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x54swh_uncensored-1999-hulk-hogan-vs-ric-f_sport If it was not clear already that Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair could no longer hang atop the card in the main event, the fact that WCW went through the trouble to pile stipulations and gimmick matches on top of each other for their world heavyweight title match in March 1999 at Uncensored certainly served as evidence. In what was a horribly contrived, typically bad match, David Flair and Torrie Wilson interfered, Then Arn Anderson made his presence felt, wiping out the privileged son and sending his squeeze packing. Referee Charles Robinson was bumped, of course, and Flair won the match via pin while trapping Hogan in a Figure Four leg lock. Now stop for a moment and think about this: Hogan lost via pinfall. In a FIRST BLOOD MATCH! We have already touched upon Hogan and Flair's inability to follow anything remotely resembling a complicated stipulation earlier in this list but the fact that someone booked that finish, in a match that clearly states that the only way to win is to make your opponent bleed, is proof that attention to details was another element of WCW's demise. There was only so much bad wrestling and nonsensical booking that fans could be asked to sit through before switching to the competition. At a time when fans were leaving for the brighter pastures and edgier content of WWE, this was hardly the main event WCW needed to convince them to stay.

5. Triple Cage Match For The WCW Championship: Diamond Dallas Page vs. David Arquette vs. Jeff Jarrett - Slamboree 2000

Allow this writer to preface this by saying that the match in question was actually a damn fine one, with Diamond Dallas Page and Jeff Jarrett working a hell of a brawl in a match that was little more than an excuse for the company to spotlight the Triple Cage that was featured in the major motion picture "Ready to Rumble." With that said, the contest is notorious for its inclusion of David Arquette, Hollywood actor and unfathomably, WCW World Heavyweight champion. His title victory effectively killed the credibility of the company's most coveted prize. DDP would admit in an interview years later that Arquette wanted nothing to do with the title but WCW was determined to get some free publicity and, at the same time, promote its first foray into Hollywood. The contest was yet another failed attempt by WCW to catapult itself back into relevancy at a time when their television ratings were a third of what their competition's were. Arquette turned heel and Jeff Jarrett regained the heavyweight title. Then, in a moment that showed just how clueless a company WCW was at that point, they booked an angle in which Chris Kanyon was thrown from the top of the cage and through the entrance ramp. In the Kemper Arena in St. Kansas City, Missouri. The same arena in which Owen Hart fell to his death almost exactly a year earlier. It was insensitive and, while that may not have been part of what helped aid in the demise of WCW, it was just another ridiculous idea by the brain trust that ran the company at that point.

4. WCW Championship Match: Kevin Nash vs. Jeff Jarrett - Great American Bash 2000

While the New World Order threatened to destroy World Championship Wrestling, both on-screen and off, the company could rest peacefully knowing that they were building at least one bright young star who could carry the company into the future. His name was Goldberg and despite the fact that the company had stupidly ended his undefeated streak in December 1998 (more on that in a moment), he was still a huge star in the eyes of the fans. More importantly, he was the biggest babyface star the organization had to offer. That is, until June 2000, when the decision was made to turn him heel. There was nothing really wrong with the main event between Kevin Nash and Jeff Jarrett at that year's Great American Bash. Big Sexy was among the most popular stars on the roster and Jarrett was the heel around which the entire show was being built. The reason that show's marquee match lands so high on this list is the nonsensical heel turn of the biggest home grown star the company had produced since Sting. Goldberg's spear of Nash late in the match essentially killed the company dead. The man who had helped retain a major portion of the audience despite WWE's Attitude Era helping them surge past the Ted Turner-owned company for first place in the ratings war, suddenly was gone and in his place was a heel whose motivations were forced, at best. There was no going back from the Goldberg heel turn. Sure, he would be a babyface again within a few months but the character that fans had known and love, and supported for two-plus years, had disappeared and he was not coming back. The last truly great and original star WCW had left was ruined by a singular decision made only to spike the following night's ratings, with no concern about the long term health of the company.

3. WCW Championship Match: Goldberg vs. Diamond Dallas Page - Halloween Havoc 1998

The main event of the 1998 Halloween Havoc pay-per-view between heavyweight champion Goldberg and people's champion Diamond Dallas Page was not only a huge babyface vs. babyface bout, it was one of the most anticipated contests WCW still had left to offer. Both men were incredibly popular and key to the success the company was enjoying at the time, even as they began to fall more and more behind WWE in the Monday Night Wars. It was the one match that could have made a difference and helped turn the tide in their favor. Instead, a tremendous production error led to fans who purchased the pay-per-view event not even getting to see the contest they so desperately wanted to witness. The show was running long, thanks to a horribly overbooked and wrestled match between Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior. As champion and challenger took to the ring and the bell rang to signal the start of the match, the screen went black. The signal was cut because someone from production failed to notify the pay-per-view companies that they were running late. It was a disaster of epic proportions for the company, who suddenly had to refund paying customers, then aired the outstanding match for free the following night on Nitro. In what was arguably the greatest performance of Goldberg's career to date, he barely got past a determined Page following the Jackhammer. Unfortunately, what should have been a defining match for the franchise star instead turned in to one more death knell for WCW.

2. WCW Championship Match: Goldberg vs. Kevin Nash - Starrcade 1998

Starrcade 1998 was yet another instance of WCW putting its top babyface Goldberg in a main event against another wildly popular star, that being the leader of the nWo Wolfpac faction, Kevin Nash. In one of the biggest main events of the year, Goldberg would put his WCW Championship and his 173-0 winning streak on the line against one of the most decorated stars of the decade. It was a huge match and one that should have served to strengthen the phenomenon's title reign. Instead, it served as the moment the Titanic that was WCW hit the ice berg and began its long and painful descent into the icy waters of the Atlantic. In one of the most shocking conclusions to a main event ever produced by Ted Turner's promotion, Nash capitalized on Scott Hall's interference (complete with the use of a stun gun), delivering a jackknife powerbomb and pinning the previously unconquerable beast to win the WCW title. Fans understandably reacted with furious anger, blaming Nash's backstage political maneuvering, and the fact that he was the head booker at that point in time, for the decision. And they were probably right, despite Big Sexy's assertions that he was doing what he felt was best for the business. In one fell swoop, the mystique that had been built up around Goldberg was gone. There was no putting the genie back in the lamp. The magic was gone and Goldberg's effectiveness as the draw he was prior to that match was dead. Too many questionable booking decisions afterward would kill Goldberg, taking the luster off of him and leaving him just another overpaid star dragging down the quality of main events by the time the company reached its final days.

1. WCW Championship Match: Sting vs. Hulk Hogan - Starrcade 1997

The biggest main event in WCW history was also its greatest disaster, the one moment in which fans realized for the first time that the logjam of political masterminds that had taken up residence at the top of the card may have driven in ratings and helped the company achieve unparalleled success, but they were also going to prevent them from ever enjoying a satisfying product. After a year-long build, the main event of Starrcade 1997 should have seen Sting beat the ever living hell out of Hulk Hogan, capture the WCW Championship and provide fans with the happy ending to the story they had witnessed play out over the preceding 400 days. It also should have spelled the beginning of the end for the nWo and the start of a new direction for WCW programming. Instead, what fans watched was Hogan dominate the early portion of the match, drop the leg on Sting and pin him in the center of the ring as referee Nick Patrick counted to three. It was meant to be a fast count on the official's part but for whatever reason, that was not the case. After a year of investing themselves emotionally in the saga of the Stinger, they had watched their hero pinned unceremoniously one, two, three. Of course, Bret Hart came to the ring, ordered the match restarted under the premise of a screwjob and then called for the bell when Hogan tapped out to the Scorpion Death Lock. The WCW roster poured into the ring and celebrated with Sting but that did not change the fact that, in what was the biggest match in company history, Hogan's ego got in the way of doing business the correct way, killing Sting's heat and lessening what should have been a watershed moment for the wrestling industry.