10 Precise Moments Wrestling Fans Rejected Internet Darlings

10. Johnny Gargano - WWE NXT, November 7, 2018

"You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain."

This is

A) What actually happened to Johnny Gargano midway through his programme with Tommaso Ciampa from 2016-2020

and

B) The plagiarised purpose behind his heel turn; NXT attempted to turn an excellent grudge feud into a sprawling saga of comic book movie scope, and the results were risible.

The ambition was beyond pretentious.

Wrestling fans simply wanted to watch the babyface wrestler triumph over the heel wrestler in a storyline that justified its length. It all went to sh*t by the end with the masturbatory parody of an "epic" match that was 'One Final Beat' in April 2020. It was an unintentionally hilarious story of two former friends agonising for an hour about what they had become, but what they'd really become were poor actors. By then, it was already over for Gargano.

It was effectively over on the November 7, 2018 NXT, when Gargano cut an excruciating tweener promo under the delusion that he was the Winter Soldier when in fact he was Tobey Maguire in Spider-Man 3. The story was so removed from what it was that Adam Cole evolved into the fan favourite role. Gargano's incredible performance at TakeOver: New York was a blip; he was never the top babyface ever again.

To his credit, Gargano sensed this, too, and reinvented himself as a comedic goober - only deliberately, this time - as the leader of the Way faction towards the end of his WWE run.