10 Problems With John Cena Vs. The Undertaker At WWE WrestleMania 32

Not quite the dream match it seems.

By Jack G King /

You'll almost certainly have heard the rumours by now but, word going around, is that John Cena could be facing the Undertaker at WrestleMania 32, a match sure to get pulses racing and wallets opening. You may also have read our article on why the bout must happen, but I find myself taking the opposite point of view entirely. Far be it from me to deny the scale of a potential Cena/Taker showdown. They are, after all, two of the biggest stars in the history of the business. If nothing else, it would surely be a huge spectacle - but therein lies the problem. Cena vs. Undertaker would be a shallow match-up, a booking decision made on name value alone, all while ignoring a sizeable list of reasons why it wouldn't be a good idea along the way. There are so many reasons WWE should think twice before booking this match, not only for the sake of WrestleMania 32 itself, but for the sake of Undertaker, Cena, and various other members of the roster, too. Here are ten of the main problems with booking John Cena versus The Undertaker at WrestleMania 32.

10. It Would Overshadow The WWE Championship Match

My own money's on a Brock Lesnar/Roman Reigns rematch, but that's largely irrelevant. John Cena vs. Undertaker is a match that demands main-event status, and we all know how much of a stir is caused when any bout other than the WWE Tile match is placed at the top of a WrestleMania card. Opinions will vary on this, but I believe nothing should take precedence over a WWE Championship match at 'Mania - not even a potential Cena vs. Taker dream encounter. At the same time, it's hard to see either man backing down and accepting a lower position on the card. Between them, they've main-evented an astonishing eight editions of WrestleMania - just over a quarter of the current total. It could be argued that such marquee bouts can be used to make up for title matches lacking in a little star power, such as CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho at WrestleMania XXVIII. However, the long-term damage of devaluing the WWE Championship bout is still felt today; Roman and Brock aside, nobody in the current title picture has headlined a single 'Mania. Not enough stars are being created, and Cena vs. Undertaker at WrestleMania wouldn't help matters at all.

9. It Would Burn A Lot Of Time

WrestleMania 32 isn't going to be a PPV with a lot of spare time to play around with. If the Triple H/Rock rumours are true, both men will surely be given their own lengthy highlight package and entrances. The WWE Championship match will have the same treatment, and Vince is never shy of booking a slightly outdated artist or band to waste a 20-minute segment or two. Once you add the potential of Undertaker vs. Cena into the mix, everything suddenly starts to look bleak for the current roster's many full-time workers. Even when appearing on Raw, Taker's entrance is a long, drawn-out affair. Now think of how elaborate John Cena's WrestleMania entrances tend to be, usually complete with a flashy 'Tron video, expensive props, and all the grandstanding you'd imagine. Now think of the gigantic hype package the production team would make for such a feud; it could well exceed five minutes in length. And finally, after all that, think of the length of the match itself. It wouldn't be a shock to see Cena vs. Undertaker eat up at least 45 minutes of showtime, with a number of current superstars pushed onto the pre-show as a direct consequence. I'm talking to you, Cesaro fans.

8. The Streak's Over So There's Nothing At Stake

Many of you will have seen How WWE Should Have Booked: Ending The Streak, a video starring our very own Adam Blampied. In it, he talks about how John Cena should have been the man to end Undertaker's undefeated 'Mania streak - turning heel in the process. Predictably, these WrestleMania 32 rumours have brought back the Cena heel turn as a viable storyline. Cue mass excitement as we all imagine Big Match John finally, finally embracing the hate, shaking WWE's foundations and opening up a whole new world of storyline possibilities. In Adam's video, the logic works very well. Few things are dastardly enough to turn a figure as beloved as Cena heel, but breaking the streak is certainly one of them. However, with Taker's undefeated run dead for two whole years, an unscrupulous Cena victory wouldn't carry nearly as much impact. Were WWE to actually go down this route, it's likely that an attempted Cena turn would only partially work - about as well as Austin's did at WrestleMania X-Seven, or Undertaker's weird half-turn in the run-up to the latest SummerSlam PPV. The fans are simply too enamoured with certain superstars to allow a heel turn, and Cena cheating to beat Taker wouldn't change a lot without the streak on the line.

7. WWE Wouldn't Actually Turn Cena Heel

Alright, alright - even if a Cena heel turn wouldn't be fully accepted in a post-streak world, it would at least signal WWE's intention of finally shaking up the status quo. But do you actually think WWE would dare tread that path? Not when the good guys always stand tall at the end of every house show, not when fans' reactions are doctored on every single SmackDown and and not when babyfaces mustn't sell too much when leaving the arena after taking a beating. It's the same old argument, but John Cena is Vince's chief moneymaker - the breadwinner across the board, in terms of PPV sales, live event tickets, action figures, t-shirts, colourful cereal, and so on. He makes paper, and he does so because he's beloved by children and families. A heel turn would, in theory, ruin this. Sadly, interesting storylines, dramatic character development, and elevating new stars play second fiddle to the big bucks Cena makes - regardless of how secure these alternatives would make WWE in the long run. It's a damn shame, but one that's very unlikely to change.

6. Their Characters Wouldn't Mesh Well. At All.

Let's assume this match is definitely happening, and fast forward a few months to the Royal Rumble. WWE must book a plausible feud between the two, keeping things fresh and entertaining throughout the whole of the 'Road to WrestleMania'. Undertaker would likely play his mind games to throw Cena off, and Cena would likely react to supernatural gimmicks like he has done in the past - terribly. Remember his horrific "embrace the hate" feud with Kane, or the WrestleMania XXX match with Bray Wyatt? Dark characters bring out the melodramatic worst in Cena, and Undertaker is the darkest character of all. WWE's only other choice would be to go in the other direction and keep things light - have Cena be his jovial usual self. I don't really need to explain why that would be even worse, unless you're the type of fan who'd laugh at endless jokes about Taker being "poopy".

5. They Have Almost No History

Of Undertaker's many, many WrestleMania bouts, his best are generally considered to be the consecutive Shawn Michaels showdowns in 2009 and 2010. Part of the reason is undoubtedly the excellent in-ring performance by both men, but that's not the only factor. However fantastic a match is from an in-ring perspective, it will always be improved by a better storyline - especially at 'Mania. Aside from a very brief feud in 2003, Cena and Undertaker have had very little interaction with one another, surprising for two men with such longevity. Undertaker and HBK's rivalry stretched all the way back to 1997, and contained many dramatic chapters (such as the first ever Hell in a Cell match, the DX vs. Undertaker feud, and the Deadman's inability to get a decisive win over the Showstopper). Even Undertaker's match with Triple H at WrestleMania XXVII - which featured a very minimalistic build and was announced in a segment with no words at all - had the full weight of history behind it. It followed nicely on from the feud with Michaels, the pair had already clashed at WrestleMania X-Seven, and both were surviving Attitude Era figureheads. Undertaker and Cena have no such history to speak of. They fought at Vengeance 2003 (a match Undertaker won clean) and have barely crossed paths since. So what would they build from?

4. WWE Wouldn't Be Able To Build A Good Story From Scratch

The fact that the competitors share very little history isn't quite this match's death knell, but it's hard to envisage WWE building an entirely new feud from scratch. The Deadman's second 'Mania bout with Michaels came at the end of one of the greatest angles of the 21st century. The story was utterly compelling, from (then World Heavyweight Champion) Undertaker refusing a rematch, to HBK valiantly failing in the Royal Rumble, to Michaels costing Undertaker his belt at Elimination Chamber, to finally agreeing to put his career on the line. Simply put, Cena and Undertaker cannot hope to enjoy such a dramatic Road to WrestleMania - or even half as compelling an angle. Taker's schedule is far too limited now. It could be argued that some dream matches have gone ahead without a particularly hands-on feud behind them, such as The Rock's era vs. era clashes with Hulk Hogan and Cena himself. However, they relied instead upon either competitor's status as an icon of their separate times. Although Undertaker and Cena must certainly be regarded in that same legendary bracket, they've already co-existed for the entirety of the latter's career. This match would have none of that underlying generational tension.

3. Undertaker Should Face Sting

Speaking of stories WWE can build from scratch, a feud that pretty much writes itself (and is therefore far more convenient and plausible than Undertaker vs. Cena) is Taker vs. Sting. The pair have many similarities, to the extent that they can be viewed as opposite sides of the same coin. Both are most famous for performing under dark, intense gimmicks, and both became leading lights of their respective promotions during the Monday Night Wars. Unlike Undertaker vs. Cena, fans have been fantasy-booking this match for over 15 years. What does Undertaker have to gain by facing Cena at 'Mania 32? If he loses, that's another blemish on his record, and yet another scalp for Big Match John. If he wins - so what? He's beaten the biggest stars of various eras. A victory over Cena is hardly going to make his legacy that much more impressive, is it? Sting is a far more exciting opponent, one who deserves a shot at redemption after being so disappointingly mugged at WrestleMania 31. There's a question over his health, especially after sustaining that nasty back injury at Night of Champions - but if he's good to go, WWE should ramp up the pageantry, cut the match time down to a reasonably short length, and let two legends go at it.

2. Cena Should Be Putting Someone Else Over

At WrestleMania XXX, an intense rivalry between Cena and Bray Wyatt culminated in a disappointingly clean win for the babyface, a result which unquestionably damaged Bray's momentum. At WrestleMania 31, an intense rivalry between Cena and Rusev culminated in a disappointingly clean win for the b...oh. Can you imagine where Wyatt or Rusev would be now, if they'd just been given the rub over John Cena at WrestleMania? Since their respective losses, both heels have fallen firmly into the "bark worse than bite" category - intimidating opponents and cutting passionate promos, but rarely picking up any big, meaningful wins. Had Cena lost either of those matches, it's unlikely that his legacy would have suffered at all in the long run. He has a personal collection of groundbreaking WrestleMania moments, with victories over Triple H, The Rock, Shawn Michaels and Batista. He doesn't need to face the Undertaker at the event (and he certainly doesn't need to win). Cena would be much better utilised to finally, finally put a younger star over on the grandest stage of all. Think what a moment that could be for a superstar such as Dean Ambrose or Cesaro.

1. It Won't Be A Good Match

It's no secret that Undertaker's ability to put on fantastic, workrate-heavy matches is waning. The man's 50 years old, so it's only natural that he's slowing down (and a miracle that he was able to work so hard over such a long period). His recent Hell in a Cell encounter with Brock Lesnar went 18 minutes, and masked a lot of its own flaws by simply being an incredibly hard-hitting brawl. It was like something from a bygone era, complete with stiff punches, weapons galore, and gallons of blood. A WrestleMania match with John Cena would have to adopt a more paint-by-numbers, "sports entertainment" format - and would suffer greatly as a result. When paired with an absolute workhorse such as Shawn Michaels, CM Punk, Daniel Bryan or Kevin Owens, Cena is capable of contributing to a classic match - but he's always second fiddle, regardless of the result. A Cena match usually lives or dies on the ability of his opponent, and Undertaker no longer has the ability to steal the show on his own.