10 Problems With Tough Enough WWE Doesn't Want To Admit

Airing this season of Tough Enough was a BAD idea...

By Marcus K. Dowling /

Having been in existence since 2001, the idea of WWE Tough Enough is intriguing in theory. Basically, through using a reality TV-type format, the company wants to showcase the industry of pro wrestling as on one level simple enough for anyone to understand, but on another hand difficult for just anyone to master. It's an intriguing premise, and one that with each consecutive season of the program has made it appear to initially be cool and fun, but at some point during the proceedings, just become tiresome, boring and largely ineffective. Considering the fact that at present zero winners of the Tough Enough program are currently employed by WWE, why bring the program back to television? If the winners actually become dead weight that WWE just keeps around in order to satisfy corporate eyes that are curious about their product investment, it feels ultimately worthless. Is WWE a pro wrestling company or are they a corporation so desperate for legitimate corporate respect that they're willing to mortgage their in-ring product in the process? The current season of the resurrected Tough Enough could be the worst one yet. In assessing why this is the case, we can possibly get to the bottom of many issues plaguing not just the show, but the company overall.

10. Tough Enough Is Not Actively Looking For Wrestlers

WWE is now a company where people now routinely actually grapple and oftentimes perform death-defying in-ring stunts as maneuvers. Thus, why is there any reason to believe that a show that features grown men dressing like children's superheroes and women doing B-rate acting will actually bear any worth on either the main roster or in NXT? The idea that this season of Tough Enough is more an addendum tacked on the end of the latest contract between NBC/Universal and WWE is entirely possible. Oftentimes in contracts there are "other considerations," the "player to be named later" that exists in trade agreements in sports. Tough Enough being the "branded WWE content" that was not named is entirely possible. Seeing that they needed something, WWE may have simply poorly chosen an anything to add. Yes, as we're all quite well aware, professional wrestling is a blend of theatrics and athleticism. However, in a company where that balance has shifted between these polar opposite skills, parading these oftentimes hapless wannabes on television and having them endure being forced to embody a WWE product that does not necessarily even exist anymore just makes Tough Enough feel like the most tired program ever.

9. The Winners Are Going To Be Earning A LOT Of Money...

The winners of Tough Enough are scheduled to earn $250,000 contracts from World Wrestling Entertainment. Considering that these performers are going to not be as seasoned as other WWE performers, the idea that they're going to be earning this much money is on some level completely absurd. While all we've heard from NXT is that it's a core of gifted professional whose earnest desire is to put out a quality product, the idea that two overpaid and not-so-gifted performers could spoil the cohesion of that unit is entirely possible. WWE's likely thinking and/or advised their NXT crew against unnecessary hazing of the winners, but to believe that these are performers who will be initially welcomed with open arms is more than likely a fallacy.

8. The Program Is Terribly Formatted

When it's time to vote off one of the combatants is typically the time for the judges to shine. It's the hallmark of what makes judged reality shows like American Idol really fantastic. In Tough Enough being terribly formatted and also not having yet found a judge willing to have that "Simon Cowell" type performance, it makes the entire program fall flat. Yes, Daniel Bryan's a star. However, he's seems to be easily one of the genuinely nicest WWE stars ever. Expecting DB to grill a contestant on this show seems like a lot to ask. As well, there's Paige, who as a WWE diva is only 22 years of age. While yes, she has a saucier demeanor than most divas, her charisma is not necessarily clicking with the show. Also, insofar as Hulk Hogan and Chris Jericho, the idea of them caring about anyone who has one millionth of the level of influence they've had over the business overall, is laughable at best. Also, at an hour long and needing to involve character development, fan voting via an app, the aforementioned judges (who feel detached) and also some sort of interaction between the guest star and the aspiring wrestlers, 42 minutes on on-screen time foreach week of the program feels like woefully too short of a time frame to make any of this actually entertaining or appear to have the goal of creating marketable stars or just being good television overall. In missing core components of great reality television, Tough Enough falls short.

7. There Hasn't Been A Must-Watch Moment

Billy Gunn isn't going to snap and kick ZZ's a**. Unfortunately, if you're watching Tough Enough, you'd hope that one of the trainers would at least attempt to beat some sort of respect for the business into him, but because WWE is a PG company now, that's not going to happen. Like it or not, human beings love pain, violence and drama. In these three core characteristics of quality low-brow American entertainment being absent from Tough Enough, the show suffers incredibly.

6. Chris Jericho Is An Amazing Wrestler And Rock Star But A Poor Show Host

What made the 2010-aired editon of Tough Enough fantastic was the performance of "Stone Cold" Steve Austin as host. He was fully integrated into the program, and took a great deal of pride in being deeply involved in final decisions regarding what talent stayed and went. As well, the advice he imparted on talent was moreso that of what coaches at NXT do than pithy words being uttered by a show host. The thing that plagues Chris Jericho on Tough Enough is the thing that actually has plagued him most with each of his returns to WWE. He lacks the ability to connect with not just the fans, but with his fellow performers, too. Some people leave a business and while the nuts and bolts of the business stay with them, the deeper notions of the business leave. Chris Jericho the wrestler? Still there. Chris Jericho the performer who has a unique and deep connection with the WWE Universe? Unless they're Fozzy fans, Y2J may be G-O-N-E.

5. Hulk Hogan Is Horribly Miscast On This Show

So, yeah. Pictured above is that one time the judge on the low-rated reality TV show wrestled Andre the Giant in front of close to 100,000 people and drew one of the largest gates in pro wrestling history. Why this man is being featured on a show where the winner could be main eventing in front of 100 people in a year from now is honestly beyond anyone's comprehension. Maybe it's corporate suits that called for Hogan to judge? Maybe it was Vince McMahon? Either way, it's a deplorable decision and actually devalues the Hulkster, who on a wanting to be white-hot TV product should totally be cast in even a bit role. Hulk Hogan sitting in a chair looking at might be and never-could-cut-it WWE hopefuls is unfortunate.

4. Where's The In-Ring Prize?

Remember that time that Maven won Tough Enough, entered the Royal Rumble, and then dropkicked The Undertaker over the top rope? Yeah, we all do, and if you don't...well then watch it on Youtube or DailyMotion. While yes, the entire WWE Universe knew that Maven wasn't exactly WWE Championship material, he was certainly the most easily cast for sympathy performer in the ring. WWE's insane to not have an actual in-ring moment already laid out for the winner of Tough Enough. The idea of anything from a US Championship Open Challenge match to the aforementioned Royal Rumble slot is cool because it creates another great plot arc or storytelling device. In a company filled with hungry performers who want to get over, having as many avenues available for getting over as possible is important.

3. This Would Be So Much More Awesome As A Partnership With Ring Of Honor

Ring of Honor's the company that gave WWE Daniel Bryan, CM Punk, Cesaro, Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn and Samoa Joe. Thus, even though the company has TV through Destination America, there's no reason why WWE couldn't work something out where there'd be a WWE contract put on the line for any one of ten Ring of Honor performers. Imagine a competition where talented independent performers were cutting promos, having great matches and being filmed in backstage segments that would be captivating because they'd be tense as hell. Putting gifted wrestlers who'd have immediate impact in WWE on national TV in a competition where they'd be judged by a mix of legends and performers they once shared locker rooms with would make for incredibly compelling television.

2. What About Making Tough Enough A "Second Chance" Program?

Matt Morgan is seven feet tall, a solid promo and a performer who may have had one of the worst booked runs in WWE history. The idea of Tough Enough as a competition that gives established performers like Morgan a second chance at stardom? That'd make for some great television. Imagine a house where Johnny Nitro, Matt Morgan, Chris Masters, Drew McIntyre, Manu, Derrick "EC3" Bateman and more were all competing for a WWE contract. If presented in a certain manner, it'd be must-see TV on a weekly basis.

1. Nobody Believes Any Of These Performers Will Ever Be WWE Main Event Superstars

Again, let's all realize that ZERO Tough Enough winners are presently employed by WWE, and that of the losers of Tough Enough currently in WWE, The Miz main evented Wrestlemania, Ryback's the current Intercontinental Champion and Cameron is currently a main roster performer and also a cast member on E! Network's Total Divas. Thus, putting any weight on the judgments of either the judges or fans via the app is a completely faulty premise. Top-tier talent selection -- especially in pro wrestling, is an imprecise science. Hulk Hogan initially had his leg intentionally broken in training. Steve Austin was fired in WCW and Chris Jericho was deemed too small to be a credible main eventer. Of these 13 contestants, let's presume that there's someone there who just isn't ready for prime time right now who will get overlooked, and someone who seems ready for more at that moment who will inevitably drop the ball. Asking the WWE Universe to wait and watch a season of these aspiring performers at their worst likely years before they might be their best NOT in WWE? Deplorable.