10 Rare Awesome WWE Surprises
When WWE actually earned "Let it play out" - featuring Daniel Bryan, Chris Jericho, and others...
In theory, a big mystery angle appeals to the most basic human curiosity and raises our foolish hope that WWE does not write week-to-week under a framework ritually shredded by a brain-wormed autocrat.
For months in 2019, fans cautiously tried to peek into Erick Rowan's cage, half-expecting tosh, half-expecting something that wasn't an obviously fake, gigantic spider. It was a spider. Of course it was a spider.
That's a bad example. It was hardly going to be a seven-inch tall future megastar that had generated huge buzz on the Independent scene enclosed in that cage. That's physically impossible. Not that seven-inch tall part; an indie guy working a WrestleMania event is far less likely.
WWE has previous with such disappointments, even when expectations were reasonable.
Huge, mystery opponent? Existing midcard act Savio Vega!
Higher power? More like existing power!
Who ran over Stone Cold Steve Austin? The guy who claimed WWE does not like "Island boys", as The Rock held the belt right on front of his bloody eyes.
WWE literally laid an egg at Survivor Series 1990, and there was a literal turkey inside, and still we raise our hopes.
But - and here's that bargaining impulse - they also debuted...
10. The Undertaker Debuts
Ted DiBiase teased a mystery partner for Survivor Series 1990 ahead of his match against the Dream Team.
In one of those wonky, shouty, awesome say-anything-just-say-it-quickly-and-loudly group promos, Bret Hart et al. assessed the imminent threat, and vowed to overcome it with old-fashioned babyface resolve. Jim Neidhart didn't need no damn private investigator to find out who that person was. He was just going to punch him in the face and then do his mad cackle. Goddamnit, the Survivor Series was absolutely ace, and it's legacy is hugely enriched by the debut that followed.
DiBiase cut an in-ring promo to announce his new hired gun, which sort of implied that the funeral business wasn't doing too well. Trust WWE to prove an adage wrong. But this pedantry wasn't in the minds of the terrified young children drawn to the WWF through those juice explosions of Coliseum VHS covers.
His eerie presence was sold phenomenally by Gorilla Monsoon and Roddy Piper, as if he were Gary Strydom and they were Vince McMahon. The Undertaker stalked the ring, backed by the funeral march, and proceeded to annihilate Koko B. Ware and Dusty Rhodes in an inspired, committed bid to get him over huge.
The debuting WWF Superstar usually racked up wins over puny jobbers. Instantly, 'Taker was set apart with an indiscriminate massacre at the shocking expense of established name talent.
9. The Brodus Clay Bait And Switch
Somebody call my lawyer!
Yes, Brodus Clay's recent, alleged problematic behaviour somewhat undermines a wistful reminiscence on that time he disco-danced his way into our slack-jawed hearts - but what a fabulous, inspired bait-and-switch this was.
For weeks, vignettes aired teasing the arrival of a game-changing monster, and they were produced effectively enough as to obscure the memories of Clay looking sick of his life on NXT and doing little to get over as Alberto Del Rio's bodyguard. The verbiage was so over-the-top that it hid the punchline in plain sight - "I am the fall of humanity!"; "I am a physical juggernaut!" - but, troublingly, this was more or less consistent with every other time WWE debuts a new menace with spooky music and dumb-sh*t hyperbole.
But, on the January 9, 2012 RAW, the gag revealed itself: Clay was now the 'Funkasaurus', as Vince McMahon, true to form, stumbled on the Walk The Dinosaur craze some decades after everybody else. Clay danced, terribly, and that was the gag. He got over with this endearingly bad act, improvised crowd shut-downs, and the sheer audacity of the bit. The gag ran its course, and Clay's presence gradually receded.
For the best, that.
8. That's Gotta Be Kane!
In one of the all-time great WWE storylines, even to those adverse to the supernatural leanings of professional wrestling, Paul Bearer for months alluded to a terrifying, vengeful presence set to wreak havoc on the Undertaker: his brother, Kane, long thought dead in a harrowing childhood tragedy.
Bearer's hammy delivery was the perfect vehicle with which to herald this scenario; warbling, intense, wild-eyed and distinctly southern, his Mobile, Alabama tongue echoed that of a hysterical preacher warning of the end. Kane was over as an unyielding force well before he debuted, and of course, the exact site of his debut was never specified. This had to feel uncertain to reflect 'Taker's fear.
Kane debuted, at long last, at In Your House: Badd Blood.
With Shawn Michaels beat - to something beyond a grotesque pulp, in that classic war - the lights went down. The subtle reaction was inspired; Vince McMahon on commentary didn't overstate things; he said "wait a minute", intentionally off-mic, to create the illusion of a real disturbance.
Then, the church organ blared out, which is when McMahon went into iconic over-sell over-drive. "That's gotta be - that's gotta be Kane!" he roared, as this masked terror stalked the ring and ripped the Cell door off its hinges.
God, this promotion was once so awesome: they created an equal to the Undertaker within seconds of his first material sighting.
7. Bayley
A surprise is distinct to a swerve.
The nature of a surprise invites rampant speculation in an industry that is more than most obsessed with discourse and engagement. It never ends, and thus the audience mustn't be allowed to stop talking about it.
Everybody knew Bayley was Sasha Banks' mystery partner at Battleground 2016. It was the only viable choice; the theme of their last classic encounter had brought them together, and anybody else would have drawn a toxic response from those tethered so tightly to NXT's once-wonderful mythology.
Crucially, everybody wanted Bayley to support the friendship she had forged with Sasha through respect.
This was the essence of fan service distilled to service a narrative development - just a lovely moment of two babyfaces coming together in a package of earnest, earned, forward-thinking nostalgia.
If not a rare surprise, per se, it was certainly a rare, winning use of the otherwise beyond-f*cked machinations that separated and clumsily undermined the proximity between NXT and the main roster.
6. Finn Bálor's Surprise Debut
It wasn't even that contrived, or at least it never felt that way, wired as our minds were in perfect, generous synergy with a brand that generated an endless source of goodwill.
The Ascension had targeted Hideo Itami, a singles competitor, like complete dumbasses. They willed his tag team partner into existence, effectively, for no logical reason. Itami was a singles star who did not threaten their spot on the card. But this contrived plot hole - it was a means of writing the team out - didn't matter; it meant a new star was set to debut.
That star was Finn Bálor, the former Prince Devitt, who in the final phase of his awesome NJPW run had fused excellent professional wrestling with a marketable sports entertainment aesthetic. He was an action figure/workrate hero hybrid who had worked himself, brilliantly, into a position of prominence in a company it was believed, back then, was capable of pushing him to superstardom. He arrived in November of 2014, by Itami's side, to batter Konnor and Viktor with stereo corner dropkicks, symbolising a new era of advanced in-ring work.
To put this into further perspective: Bálor arrived, his new name flashing on the tron, and fans were high on the change where they were once peturbed.
5. Kevin Owens Joins Team NXT
In which WWE in 2019 filled the November plot hole with an awesome - and earned - spot of fan service.
The draft they'd just done was thrown into contrived disarray, as recently-transferred talent defended their new homes as if they were magically super-loyal to them. After a blinding SmackDown, the idea that these men and women were owned and empowered by t-shirts was impossible to escape.
Put on red t-shirt for five minutes = instantly disregard long sentimental history in Orlando that shaped your very career.
The premise was of course farcical with one, excellent exception that worked so well because it framed one member of the roster as a man with the agency to navigate his own life.
Kevin Owens was attacked by the Undisputed Era at the peak of brand warfare, but did not receive this as a blanket attack made by a brand to which he held a certain loyalty. In a great surprise that made rare sense, Owens commanded a deafening pop at NXT TakeOver: WarGames when it was revealed that he had returned home to avenge the assault.
Owens wore his old NXT clobber and bumped big in an über-violent WarGames spectacle that made congruent and perfected an elusive, bastardised premise.
4. Tazz
It wasn't so much a surprise, as a well-calculated scheme to get Tazz over - and WWE were miffed when he got over, but that's a separate, paradoxical issue.
The surprise, if telegraphed, was also very effective.
There was a real creativity to the idea. Instead of pre-recorded vignettes, Tazz's symbol and colour aesthetic haunted the live show; arenas nationwide were bathed in an orange light as various wrestlers made their entrance. The idea conveyed was that Tazz, his debut imminent, was targeting everybody to foreshadow the road of destruction he was to pave.
"The mood is about to change," ran the tagline, and it did. WWF soured on Tazz, who got over, when this marketing campaign was specifically devised to get him over, as most developments booked by a pro wrestling promotion are.
He got over big in Madison Square Garden, at the Royal Rumble, because he was already over to the New York market. Also: because he ruled.
He bludgeoned Kurt Angle with a spree of the sort of dangerously-angled suplexes not seen in the WWF since the Steiner Brothers left, and for three pulsating minutes, after which Angle sold as if he'd been decimated, it felt as though the company had actually transplanted the awesome essence of an outside creation into its arena-sized scope.
3. Chris Jericho Debuts
A countdown began on WWF television in 1999 that captured the imagination of all fans.
It marked the 'Countdown to the Millennium', playing on Y2K fears, but it obviously did not end on December 31, 1999. It ended on August 9, but in the meantime, early Internet adopters sleuthed the dirts and the forums to decode the mystery. The answer was arrived at quickly - Chris Jericho's WCW deal was up, and the machinations at play in that promotion capped his boundless potential as a pro wrestling superstar.
But the wait was significantly slower. A star of such brightness, that stardom was projected onto him by a fanbase ravenous for this wasted, abused polymath.
He finally arrived on the August 9, 1999 RAW, in what was more revelation than reveal: time has dented this promo somewhat - he tried to get too many catchphrases over, and he presented himself as more of a comedic irritant than megastar game-changer - but the moment remains immortal.
The pop was deafening, but it wasn't so much a pop. It was a primal roar so loud that it quietened any remaining murmurs that Billy Gunn might become a superstar.
That SummerSlam match was completely untenable for the poor sod.
2. Diesel's WWE Return
Wrestling is an aesthetics business, which often proves problematic in modern critique, but it's no less true.
It's for this precise reason that Diesel's WWE return got as over as it did at the 2011 Royal Rumble. It spoke to the power of the work as much as the power nostalgia holds. Fans, your writer included, bemoan WWE's insistence on its ironic youth movement approach. People should be allowed to look old. Offscreen coaches should be allowed to be grey.
But Jesus Christ, put a dye-job on Kevin Nash, and suddenly it's 1994 all over again.
The gear and the hair converged to create a wonderful, temporary rush of an illusion. It didn't feel like the typical nostalgia banter appearance the Rumble offered to diminished excess in that period. It was Diesel! His hair was black and everything!
A great, stupefying pro wrestling moment, we were all Matt Striker, except we didn't need to rein in our enthusiasm to remain authoritative/not completely f*cking irritating. Diesel did have to hold the rope to make sure he didn't fall over when lifting his boot to meet Rey Mysterio's hardly towering frame, but it didn't matter.
His hair was black and everything!
1. Daniel Bryan Returns At SummerSlam 2010
Daniel Bryan was fired by WWE for his role in the infamous Nexus formation angle of June 2010.
Given his bizarre run on NXT, it made a terrible sort of sense that he was the fall guy. In a strange departure from the usual over-produced mode in which WWE operates, the eight NXT contestants - i.e., those least familiar with the lay of the land, the hidden curriculum of not what to do, as if that were ever fixed in place - were instructed to go out there and cause a disruption. Bryan, avid wrestling mind, probably surveyed the scene, and, with memories of corpse-shagging and widow-pestering in his head, thought it was OK to strangle Justin Roberts with his necktie to get himself over as an indiscriminate rebel primed to remove every last cog of a machine that had ground him down.
He returned at SummerSlam, after Miz had hesitated to commit to Team WWE. It was a shocking, very welcome surprise; WWE barely seemed to like Bryan when he was there, much less enough to re-sign him and risk displeasing sponsors.
This was a great return in itself, and it resumed his programme with the Miz very effectively. Miz was apoplectic at the idea of Bryan replacing him.
Tremendous world-building stuff that informed the next phase of the narrative, this was antithetical to the usual, definitive cop-out.