10 REALLY Long WWE Title Reigns That Didn’t Work

The Long And Grinding Road.

By Michael Hamflett /

The Honky Tonk Man is still, to this day, 'The Greatest Intercontinental Champion Of All Time' by his own longevity measure. The insufferable Elvis impersonator's 454 days with the belt remains a record, and unlike other extended spells with straps enclosed within this list, was easily justified by the most obvious metric of all - money.

Advertisement

Business boomed across the board during Honky's tenure, but he himself was considered a tangible draw in an era where such a thing was still A Thing. Audiences were desperate to see him dethroned, and box office receipts from his house show loops persistently proved it.

From the moment he shockingly toppled the heroic Ricky Steamboat in 1987 to the earth-shattering comeuppance received by The Ultimate Warrior over a year later, Jimmy Hart's man was peak pr*ck, sneaking through every single title defence on the lowest possible road. He took count-outs, caused disqualifications and always cheated on the few occasions he actually won. Being champion wasn't about upholding the prestige of the title, but just getting to gloat about carrying the prize. It was a booking masterstroke performed brilliantly by an old school wrestler unafraid of the heat and unburdened by technical ego.

Honky's reign was aided by the era it occurred in. Few - if any - performers could sustain such a role in 2018's era of the over-serve. A month is often more than enough, let alone the mammoth stretches certain wrestlers have unjustly achieved...

10. Brock Lesnar - Universal Champion (453+ Days)

Yes it's another moan about Brock Lesnar's Universal Title reign because yes it's having the most disastrous impact on the company's flagship show and YES characters have either died or been left on life support because of it.

Advertisement

The rationale for 'The Beast' winning any top title in the company was that he offered something special at the top of the card. A motivated and well-deployed Brock Lesnar sh*ts the monolithic star appeal he looks like he'd have no problem eating for breakfast, and yet this version of him seems completely absent since the company awarded him its joint richest prize.

The rationale for winning this particular Universal strap was the need to conclude a legitimately satisfying arc with Bill Goldberg. Their WrestleMania 33 sprint was an unmitigated success worthy of the prestige, but the bulldozing part-timers inadvertently robbed the belt and all the lustre from a programme between Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho that had simmered for months.

The rationale for him keeping the belt and seeing off challenges from Samoa Joe, Braun Strowman and AJ Styles was to reinvigorate the F5 in time for Roman Reigns to kick out of at WrestleMania 34. And he did, five times, and still ended up examining the Superdome ceiling.

The trail of broken careers in his path reads like a hyperbolic video package rundown, but there's no storyline victory beyond 'The Monster Among Men' giving Lesnar a crushing receipt that could possibly match the cold reality.

9. Bobby Lashley - ECW Champion (147 Days)

The shortest reign on this list, but an important (and topical) reminder of the permanent damage that can be done by an ill-conceived tenure with a title.

Advertisement

Bobby Lashley's time atop ECW commenced at the climax of perhaps the most toxic WWE pay-per-view of all time and barely improved from those less-than-humble beginnings. Booed mercilessly by a justifiably p*ssed off crowd on Night One, it took until a WrestleMania build-up for his 'Battle Of The Billionaires' clash with Umaga to get the fans onside.

The distraction pieces around him worked to a point - the presence of Vince McMahon, Stone Cold Steve Austin and Donald Trump will do that for a man - but that glowing profile was only dulled by the supposedly prestigious prize still around his waist. Pay-per-view defences of the strap against Test and Mr Kennedy in January and February were pitiful, and his placement in the aforementioned box office belter at the 'Show Of Shows' resulted in eight actual ECW performers losing out on fighting for a Championship they were theoretically supposed to be working towards.

A muddled handicap match loss to Mr McMahon saw the title hit the bin quicker than Alundra Blayze's old Women's strap, with Bobby's lasting legacy the final decay before its demise.

8. Dean Ambrose - United States Champion (351 Days)

It took Dean Ambrose losing the United States title to Sheamus to remind the audience that he'd even been carrying it around for nearly a year during the height of The Shield's original success.

Advertisement

The trio's post-WrestleMania XXX babyface turn had seen them wage war with Triple H's revived Evolution for two consecutive pay-per-view brawls, but Ambrose was robbed of his prize the night after 'The Hounds Of Justice' first took down the main event trio at May's Extreme Rules supershow.

Cheated out of it by his malevolent gaffer, the future 'Lunatic Fringe' was forced to put the belt up for grabs in a 20-man battle royal that he ended up losing to Sheamus. The gutsy display was presented as cynical gamesmanship by 'The Game' in robbing Ambrose of reaching a year, though most were astonished he'd had it that long.

The group's multi-person matches (as well as their involvement in the original Authority Vs Daniel Bryan arc) had rendered singles title matches more of an inconvenience - much like the metal trinket itself at airports across the United States. Ambrose was perhaps quietly pleased to be robbed of it.

7. Gillberg - Light Heavyweight Champion (448 Days)

There was something fittingly troublesome about about WWE's most on-the-nose parody amassing a record 'streak' similar to the hugely popular original.

Advertisement

Bill Goldberg was a bonafide phenomenon in WCW and just about the last thing Vince McMahon had left to poke fun at as his company surged ahead in the Monday Night Wars with 1998 drawing to close. Duane Gill's slavering repaint winning the Light Heavyweight Title wasn't even rooted in complete farce despite the reign amounting to less than that during his stewardship. His fluke win over then-Champion Christian came during the midst of a miniature push for his J.O.B Squad cronies, but the stable had long disbanded by the time he came to lose the title to restart a division long thought dead by virtue of his reign.

The prize wasn't defended once in in WWE in 1999, an inexcusable statistic considering the Crash TV mentality of the time facilitating 15 separate Tag Team Championship switches elsewhere on the cards. It spoke to Gillberg's inadequacies as a long-standing titleholder, that it in turn dragged the title into the gutter before choice stints with Essa Rios and Dean Malenko briefly returned it to relevance.

6. Hardcore Holly & Cody Rhodes - World Tag Team Champions (202 Days)

Originally paired due to the mutual respect they'd gained fighting each other, the veteran/apprentice chemistry between Hardcore Holly and Cody Rhodes didn't ultimately produce the desired outcome for the team - getting the future 'American Nightmare' over.

Advertisement

Holly noted in his autobiography how house show crowds would still cheer him over the upstart, and whilst that didn't particularly seem reflective of their television matches, Rhodes wasn't remotely thriving alongside big bad Bob.

A predictable heel turn for Rhodes alongside fellow second generation star Ted DiBiase gave their run a logical end even if the beginning and middle ensured that few had even invested in the story.

It spoke to Vince McMahon's perpetual disdain for the doubles division (and perhaps Rhodes and Holly as a unit) that the pair held the straps through both the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania yet didn't defend them or even appear in a featured match as a tag team. Their pairing - like the title belts themselves - remained little more than an inconvenience.

5. Brian Kendrick & Paul London - WWE Tag Team Champions (331 Days)

Fellow recipients of record-smashing ignorance by their employers, Brian Kendrick and Paul London's lengthy stint with the blue brand's tag team titles would have been exclusively sad had it not on occasion been absolutely excellent.

Advertisement

Seemingly thriving on the creative ignorance, London and Kendrick elected to just have good matches where there may not have been good matches before - the dreaded SmackDown-only pay-per-views.

The pair had blinding battles with a Dave Taylor/William Regal duo, developmental no-marks KC James & Idol Stevens (pre-Damien Sandow) and emerged victorious and just about unscathed from a memorable four-way ladder match featuring the aforementioned Brits, MNM and The Hardy Boyz.

Much like Dean Ambrose's Sheamus surrender, the decision to take the titles off them so close to the year mark seemed rooted in cynicism - particularly considering that surprise winners Deuce N Domino achieved less than nothing in their own 133 day-reign that followed. Paul London's passive aggressive pearly whites in his infamous 2007 stare-down with Vince McMahon told the whole story of his growing disdain with the organisation after such reckless mistreatment.

4. Triple H - World Heavyweight Champion (76, 280, 91 & 169 Days)

Included as one entry because it conspired to feel like one unending torture, Triple H's vice-like grip over the World Heavyweight Title aided his grand plan to cosplay as his heroes at the expense of a rapidly diminishing core audience.

Advertisement

On offense, he mimicked Harley Race, in everything else it was Ric Flair. His denim dad look was replaced by a bouncing bouffant and buttoned down suit (in style, rather than class), ill-gotten Championship (in reality, rather than storyline) and group of heavies (in Evolution, rather than The Four Horsemen).

The biggest, crucial difference was match quality. 'The Game' commanded so much time, either during his lengthy Monday Night Raw promos or dirt-worst pay-per-view matches, and so rarely made decisions that suited anybody other than himself. He put Goldberg over long after the former WCW Champion actually required the rub. He went multiple months with Kevin Nash, Booker T, Rob Van Dam and Kane despite never remotely intending to put them over. He jobbed clean to Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton just to win dirty (but conclusively) less than a month after the original defeats.

Only Batista's outstanding rise justified his reign(s) of terror on Monday Night Raw. WrestleMania 21 saw Hunter bid farewell to his 'Nature Boy' dream sequence - but it was in reality the end of a nightmare.

3. Sheamus - World Heavyweight Champion (210 Days)

Sheamus may have experienced an 'Irish Curse' the moment he won the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XXVIII in just 18 infamous seconds.

Advertisement

His victory over Daniel Bryan inadvertently poured gas on a gently-simmering 'YES! Movement', and the flames blew directly back in his face. Despite strictly occasional strong performances in defences throughout 2012, 'The Celtic Warrior' never shook off a smattering of boos that stuck around long enough to guide his heel turn upon a 2014 return from injury.

Whilst CM Punk gamely tried to make some history under the looming shadow of John Cena with his WWE Championship, Sheamus seemed so morbidly content boring audiences with indifferent efforts against Randy Orton, Alberto Del Rio, Dolph Ziggler and any other midcarder the company could laughably reframe as a headline attraction.

Sheamus was no more a 'top guy' then than he is today, despite the tacit implication by virtue of his title. A strap surrender to The Big Show of all people still felt like a breath of fresh air compared to the dull and dingy fog his stint had crafted around the prize.

2. AJ Styles - WWE Champion (234+ Days)

It's with a heavy heart that AJ Styles merits inclusion in a list of this nature.

Advertisement

Every bit the 'Phenomenal' performer he professed to be, Styles looked at points to be completely immune to WWE's dodgy booking by forces of will and skill. His matches superseded shoddy storytelling, effectively carrying angles over the line in spite of themselves thanks to the ultra-high quality payoffs that were guaranteed between the ropes.

This changed (for good?) during his summer series over a secondary strap with Kevin Owens. A series of matches designed to prop up 'KO's bristling rivalry with Shane McMahon, both wrestlers and the title itself were heinously damaged by the treadmill of p*sspoor finishes concluding p*sspoor contests.

Winning the WWE Championship back in November 2017 felt like salvation (more on that later), but the 'richest prize' hasn't really left the gutter since. Styles tried his best to find reason and reality in inherently silly circumstances at the start of the year, but the multi-man battles at Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber were deflating disasters.

Not to worry. 'Styles vs. Nakamura' was can't-miss dream match stuff. WWE even literally labelled it as the latter. They missed. Over and over again they missed. The only thing that did hit was Shinsuke's clenched fist - right up in the balls of one of the world's finest wrestlers. Reality couldn't meet "dream" expectations, even by the time their Money In The Bank Last Man Standing effort had drastically lowered the bar.

1. Jinder Mahal - WWE Champion (170 Days)

Only 170 days, astonishingly.

Advertisement

Jinder Mahal only held the WWE Championship for 170 days in 2017, but that represented exactly 170 days he shouldn't have been in possession of it.

The reasons and ramifications were pored over in such excruciating detail last year that they barely need repeating here, but WWE's transparent (and failed) cash-grabs would have at least had merit had Mahal's matches been any good.

Not only were they not good, they were almost exclusively objectively horrendous. A Shinsuke Nakamura summer series was neither sunk nor supersized by a racist build, his television encounters showed zero improvement in his work despite the low-pressure environment, and the less spewed about his rematches with alleged wrestler's wrestler Randy Orton, the better.

Jinder is, was, and remains a jobber in both practice and execution. His time with the title reflected a dangerous turning point for a belt once considered the preserve of locker room leaders, company figureheads and box office overlords. He was none of those three. He was nothing of anything; just a man with a body and ethnicity type that was in Vince McMahon's wheelhouse long enough to steal focus (and apparently common sense) from The Chairman's ordinarily careful top star selection.

Advertisement