Everybody is buzzing about Stings surprise appearance at Survivor Series. It was the first time the former WCW Champion has ever appeared in a WWE ring in his 30-plus year career. He assaulted Triple H and led to Dolph Ziggler pinning Seth Rollins to win the Team Cena vs. Team Authority 5-on-5 Survivor Series main event, and therefore putting Triple H and Stephanie McMahon out of power for as long as John Cena desires (a little wrinkle that Vince McMahon added at the start of the show). Many have said that it was one of the greatest moments of the year in WWEor was it? On the contrary, there are 10 reasons why Stings debut at Survivor Series was absolutely terrible, not only for the reasons behind deciding to have him appear, but also in the execution of the appearance and the ripple effect it had on everybody else. Its actually pretty depressing, because many of us have dreamed of the Stinger making his WWE debut, thinking about all of the dream matches he could have. But its doubtful that anybody had last nights scenario in mind when they dreamed about it. Here are 10 reasons why Stings appearance at Survivor Series was awful.
10. It Wasnt THAT Much Of A Surprise
Admittedly, Stings appearance at Survivor Series would have been a bigger Holy sh*t moment if WWE hadnt already signed him to a legends deal. Sting had already appeared on WWE programming as part of the Ultimate Warrior week after Wrestlemania, as well as in a commercial and on a celebrity panel for the roster reveal of the WWE 2K15 video game. The possibility of Sting appearing in a WWE arena was actually quite high compared to a year ago at this time. The only question was when. Also, sites like WhatCulture.com had already spilled the beans that Sting could possibly be appearing at Survivor Series. Now, as with any internet rumors, it was taken with a grain of salt and a Ill believe it when I see it attitude, but the possibility of Stings appearance was already in our heads.
9. No Crow Music
When WWE aired the 2K15 commercial teasing Sting, his appearance was accompanied by a symphony of masked Sting look-a-likes playing his WCW Crow theme. It was admittedly chilling as a silhouette of Sting descended from the rafters as the symphony built to a crescendo. Theres no denying it: the Crow music was easily Stings best entrance music in his career (Seek and Destroy by Metallica is second, but a distant second). So it was a puzzling decision by WWE to go with brand new, unidentifiable music for Stings return. It wasnt an issue of usage; WWE already used the theme in the aforementioned 2K15 commercial. The moment would have been that much better if WWE used Stings Crow theme for his appearance at Survivor Series.
8. Its Another Big Cash Investment With Minimal Return
WWE is already hurting financially with the commercial failure of the WWE Network. They are even wondering if continuing to pay Brock Lesnar an exorbitant amount for minimal working dates is even worth it anymore. And thats for a guy who is still in the prime of his career, rather than the twilight. Its highly likely that Sting didnt come cheap. As a legend in the business, Sting should command beaucoup bucks. And while having Sting in a WWE ring is very cool, that kind of moment should be saved for a once-in-a-lifetime event like Wrestlemania. The buyrates and gate for Wrestlemania should more than justify Stings price tag. How much of a hit did WWE take for having Sting appear at a show they were giving away for free?
7. Its An Obvious Push For Network Subscribers
With every announcement of the total number of WWE Network subscribers, WWE gets more and more panicked. The first time, they had mass layoffs. Then they began to push the price point of the Network rather than the content by coming up with the $9.99 slogan. Fans changed it, but they werent willing to pay it. Then they got rid of the six-month commitment and offered the entire month of November (including Survivor Series) free to new subscribers. Its obvious that Stings appearance at Survivor Series was an attempt to get the people who watched Survivor Series for free to pony up the dough for the Network. But it was just another futile attempt. Fans know how good of a deal the Network is; theyre just not willing to pay for it. If pushing the price point and offering a free month wasnt going to drive up Network numbers, what good would bringing in Sting do?
6. Its At The Expense Of New Talent
With injuries to Daniel Bryan and Roman Reigns, WWE needs an influx of new talent, and stat. NXT is overflowing with talent that are ready to make the jump to the main roster and give the WWE a much-needed jolt. Longtime NXT talent like The Ascension, Tyler Breeze and Sami Zayn are *this* close to getting their shot. Newcomers like Hideo Itami, Kevin Owens and Finn Balor are also more than ready to skip the whole development process altogether and make their WWE debuts. Rather than focusing on the past, WWE should be concentrating on the future. They got it right in 2012 when they debuted Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, and Roman Reigns all in one fell swoop, and two years later all three are at the top of the card. Theres no guarantee that two years from now, Sting will even still be contracted to the company.
5. It Doesnt Fit With The Storyline
Keep in mind this column was written before Raw, and its possible that Sting will be announced as the new General Manager/Authority Figure for Raw, rendering this point moot. But if Sting isnt announced as any kind of Authority figure, then his attack on Triple H made absolutely no sense. He had no longstanding beef with Triple H or the Authority that we know of. Its highly unlikely that John Cena cut any kind of deal with Sting to interfere on Team Cenas behalf. The entire storyline leading up to Survivor Series was dealing with John Cena and his team being the ones to put The Authority out of business. Having Sting be the one ultimately responsible for The Authoritys downfall undermines the story they were trying to tell for a month now.
4. Its 10 Years Too Late
The novelty regarding Sting is that he was the only WCW Champion to never appear on WWE television. When the WWF bought WCW in 2001, many of the big-name stars didnt immediately come to WWE because they had ironclad contracts with AOL/Time Warner, and they had the choice of sitting home for a year and get paid handsomely, or go to work for WWE for much less money. It was only after the AOL/Time Warner contracts expired that we saw the nWo, Ric Flair, Rey Mysterio and Goldberg appear on WWE television. For whatever reason, Sting never appeared among that bunch. He may have had some fundamental differences with the way Vince McMahon did business, but if there was ever any time for Sting to join the WWE, it was with the rest of the major WCW players in the early 2000s. After wasting a decade of his career away in TNA (and probably being paid handsomely for it), Sting is now 10 years older, which leads us to
3. He Looks Awful
Steve Borden is 55 years old, and looked every bit of it at Survivor Series. He was chunky, he moved slowly, and had a visible bald spot on the back of his head. Basically, he looked like a grandpa with facepaint. Time is the one opponent that wrestlers can never defeat. To his credit, Sting kept in pretty good shape during his 40s when he was in TNA. But no wrestler looks intimidating in his 50s. Sting looked especially pathetic sharing the ring with Triple H, who even in his 40s is a beast in the gym and has a fantastic physique. It was tough to suspend disbelief that Sting could handle Hunter so easily. Once everybody stops marking out and looking at the segment objectively, its actually quite humorous watching how Sting dispatched with Triple H.
2. Seth Rollins Looked Really Bad
Before Stings appearance, Dolph Ziggler hit Seth Rollins with a Zig Zag. After that, Triple H attacked a referee, provided a big beatdown on Ziggler, complete with Pedigree, and called out a referee. After that, Stings music hit, he slowly made his way to the ring, and after a long staredown with Hunter, attacked. He gave Hunter the Scorpion Death Drop, rolled Ziggler on top, and the referee counted three. For a simple Zig Zag, Rollins seemed to be down a very long time. At the very least, Rollins could have kicked out and Ziggler could have hit him with another zig zag for the win. As it was, Rollins getting knocked out is a bad look for a guy who had put the company on his back for the past two months while Brock Lesnar was off television. Rollins will most likely recover, but his growth took a very big setback in the effort to put Sting over.
1. It Ruined Dolphs Moment
One of the best booking decisions WWE made at Survivor Series was to let Dolph Ziggler, not John Cena, be the sole survivor for Team Cena and the one to ultimately put The Authority away. It showed an overwhelming sign of faith in Ziggler to carry the main event, something wrestling fans have been clamoring for ever since he suffered a concussion as World Heavyweight Champion over a year and a half ago. Ziggler had proven his mettle by taking a huge 3-on-1 beating from Team Authority, and managed to eliminate both Kane and Luke Harper before facing Rollins at the end. Had Ziggler put Rollins away without Stings interference, it would have cemented Dolph as a made man and would have positioned him nicely in the main event. As it was, Stings appearance took away from what should have been Dolphs night. Agree? Disagree? Comment below or tweet me @PocketSeagull.