WWE Tough Enough is currently in its fifth season, airing each Tuesday night on the USA Network. The show is a mix of pre-taped footage from the previous week, and a live elimination ceremony similar to American Idol. Contestants live at the WWE Performance Center in Orlando, FL, and go through weekly challenges outside of the center while learning the basics of wrestling in the center. Their trainers are Billy Gunn, Lita and Booker T. They are then judged by the live panel of judges, consisting of Daniel Bryan and Paige. Hulk Hogan was originally the third judge, but after the racism scandal, he was replaced by The Miz, although its unclear whether its a permanent replacement or not. The judges each pick one contestant to be eligible to be eliminated (each judge has a save per season), and the viewers vote on who they want to stay. WWE wants to position itself as an entertainment juggernaut by not only presenting its wrestling product, but also branching out into the reality television market with shows like this and Total Divas. But WWE should stick to its bread and butter. Everything about Tough Enough is terrible, from the contestants themselves to the format...
10. The Fights are Annoying
Of course, it cant be a reality show without some good old fashioned fights, because thats how the drama gets built on an unscripted show. However, the fights on Tough Enough arent that interesting. The arguments between the women are nothing we havent seen before. One side calls the other fake, and that side defends her realness. A couple weeks ago, the topic of breast implants came up, specifically how fresh they were. Thats the most interesting argument that the women have had on this show so far. The men are no better. The topic of most of their arguments are how much better at challenges they are. Unfortunately, the challenges dont determine whether or not they remain in the game, so the arguments end up being pointless. This past week, the most relevant argument between the men referred to ZZs general awfulness, but again, it doesnt matter in the long run, because hes charismatic enough to continue to be voted to remain on the show.
9. The Challenges Mean Nothing
Each week, the Tough Enough contestants have to compete in challenges that revolve around a certain theme that comes with being a WWE superstar. One week it was focus, the other week it was humility, and yet another week it was charisma. The challenges themselves dont really have much in common with the theme, and its a loose interpretation. But the challenges mean nothing. Winning doesnt save you from elimination, and losing doesnt mean youre automatically eliminated. Theyre pretty much a waste of time. Tough Enough should take a page from another reality competition thats actually successful: MTVs The Challenge. The challenges each week matter, as the winner is immune from elimination for the week, and the loser is automatically put into a one-on-one elimination match at the end of the show, with the remaining contestants voting over who gets the face the loser. It creates drama, and whoever stays on actually earns it, rather than being left in the incapable hands of the viewing public.
8. The Contestants Arent Entertaining
To think of the thousands of submissions that were sent in to Tough Enough, the producers decided on these guys as the cream of the crop and the most deserving of a $250,000 contract? Aside from ZZ, none of the contestants exhibit any kind of charisma, and generally come off as full of themselves, entitled, and undeserving. And for as charismatic as ZZ is (and its a dumb kind of charisma), he is just as untalented and out of shape. This past week, one of the contestants, Chelsea, was actively trying to pry some charisma out of Tanner by asking him to cut a promo on her bikini, and he couldnt do it. Theyre really going to offer him a $250,000 contract? Not likely. Charisma isnt something that can be taught. Its an innate quality that either you have, or you dont. Barely any of these contestants are connecting with the audience. That doesnt bode well for any of them.
7. The Contestants Dont Sell
The WWE viewing audience knows wrestling is fake, but at least we are willing to suspend our disbelief when were watching the action, and that helps our entertainment. So it really exposes the business even further when the contestants dont sell that the moves hurt. Each week, a superstar comes in live and does moves to the contestants. Two weeks ago, the Big Show chopped the male contestants in the chest. Last week, Tamina gave a scoop slam and a big splash to the female contestants. The hosts and the wrestlers played it up like the contestants were going to get hurt, but only with a few exceptions (Patrick, Chelsea), the contestants completely no-sold the moves, which looked really awkward. Selling is key to being a good professional wrestler. Even though the crowd knows its fake, a wrestlers job is to make it look as real as possible. The contestants no-selling has made the show, and WWE as a whole, look really bad.
6. The Contestants Arent Knowledgeable About The Product
Its beaten into our heads over and over that to succeed in WWE, you have to live, eat, sleep, and breathe the business. Anything less than total immersion of the WWE, and you wont make it. So is it too much to ask that the Tough Enough contestants actually know something about WWE? It seems like many of the girls arent familiar with the product. A few weeks ago when the WWE Network aired the live special from Japan at 5:30 in the morning, only Patrick woke up early to watch it, which rightfully angered the judges, including Paige. It became pretty obvious that the majority of the contestants dont really care that much about WWE, so how are we supposed to believe theyll make it in the business?
5. ZZ Will Never Get Voted Off
The problem with putting the ultimate power of who stays and who goes in the hands of the general public is that you get what they give you. Its completely obvious that ZZ is by far the worst contestant of the bunch. Hes out of shape, hes dumb as rocks, and doesnt look like a star. But because he mumbles in that Alabama gator-man voice and is the slightest bit different from the rest of the contestants, America will continue to troll the show and keep him alive. Each week, ZZ is picked to go to the bottom three, and each week, the public always picks him to stay. Unless the producers pull a fast one and take the control out of the hands of the people for one week (and I wouldnt put it past them), theres no way ZZ will ever get voted off the show by the WWE Universe. The point of a competition is that the best people should win. If the worst person wins, the competition is fatally flawed.
4. Nothing The Contestants Do Matters To The Judges
The judging format on Tough Enough is horrible. Each week, the contestants perform challenges for trainers Billy Gunn, Booker T and Lita. However, those three trainers have no say in who gets put in the bottom three. That honor belongs to Paige, Daniel Bryan, and whoever is replacing Hulk Hogan. All they have to go on are the advice of the trainers, and the edited footage that they see at the same time as the rest of America. Its really backwards. This past week, it was obvious that Amanda needed to go home. She wasnt very good at anything other than talking smack about the other girls. She was rightfully put in the bottom three by Daniel Bryan, and rightfully voted by America to go home with only a 13% vote to stay. However, she was saved by replacement judge The Miz because, quote, shes hot, and one of the strongest remaining contestants, Mada, was sent home. Before Mada, Patrick was obviously the top choice, and he was put in the bottom three by Paige for a really shady reason (he was too overconfident), and was voted to go home. So the contestants know that no matter what they do during the week, any of them can be put in the bottom three for any reason, and if youre doing a reality competition, that makes absolutely no sense.
3. Chris Jericho Is No Stone Cold
Truth be told, a lot of the criticisms of this season of Tough Enough could also be applied to the previous season a couple years ago, but the show was a success based solely on the charisma of host Stone Cold Steve Austin. His weekly grilling of the contestants was easily the highlight of the show. Who can forget his classic reaction to when Arianne (Cameron) told him her favorite match of all time was Melina vs. Alicia Fox? Austin was judge, jury and executioner, and the show was entertaining solely because of his input, and nothing else. Chris Jericho is also entertaining, but his role for this season has been reduced to simply playing MC. Anybody could be doing what Chris Jericho is doing. Renee Young, his co-host, could easily do Jerichos job as the main host. Jerichos talents as an entertainer are seriously going to waste in his role. His knowledge of wrestling is also going to waste because he has no input on who stays and who leaves. Why exactly is he there?
2. The Contestants Arent Trained Wrestlers
WWE is supposed to be the cream of the crop in the professional wrestling industry. Ideally, the best wrestlers in the world should be in the best company. WWE is planning to offer the winner of this competition $250,000, which is significantly more money than some of the NXT wrestlers who are really good wrestlers. Its absolutely ridiculous that WWE chose people with no wrestling experience for this competition. Of the remaining contestants, only Chelsea has any wrestling experience. Imagine if UFC took untrained fighters for the next season of The Ultimate Fighter. It would be a disaster. While WWE isnt as dangerous as UFC, its still pretty dangerous, and you should want people who know what theyre doing so nobody gets seriously hurt. Also, imagine how the trained wrestlers feel after theyve spent years toiling in the independents only for somebody with no experience to have 8-10 weeks of training and then be handed a $250,000 contract? It probably wouldnt go over too well.
1. The Whole Competition Is A Huge Waste Of Time
By all rights, the overall objective of the show would be to win $250,000, because judging by history, theres no way that the winner of this competition will ever appear in a WWE ring. There have been four previous seasons of Tough Enough, and not a single winner is still with the company. In fact, the most successful Tough Enough winner, Maven, had a marginal career that never peaked beyond his 2002 Royal Rumble elimination of The Undertaker. Last seasons winner, Andy, never even appeared on television after winning the competition. Its actually better to be a runner up, as guys like John Morrision, The Miz, Ryback, and Kenny King have had much longer careers in the wrestling business than the winners of the event. So while America will continue to vote ZZ into the winning spot, they will never see him in the WWE. Hell go down to NXT, struggle, and be cut. WWE is essentially wasting a quarter of a million dollars on this. Based on history, if the ultimate goal of a Tough Enough contestant should be not to win the competition, then the competition as a whole is a complete failure. Be sure to comment below or follow me on Twitter @PocketSeagull.