Brock Lesnar returned to WWE the night after WrestleMania 28 in 2012. Upon his arrival, he was immediately thrusted into a feud with John Cena. Intrigue in WWE started to flourish and the momentum coming out of WrestleMania 28 was in full-swing. "The Brock Lesnar Experiment" was off to the races. WWE knew that they could bring back The Rock on a part-time basis and fans would be interested. Would the same be said for Brock Lesnar? The majority of wrestling fans didn't know what was in store for Lesnar's WWE run...and we really still don't. He seems to come and go as he pleases and never sticks around long enough to make a difference. Brock has been put in position to be the one man to defeat The Undertaker at WrestleMania and even won the WWE Championship in the most dominant fashion of all time. However, unlike other part-time WWE superstars, Chris Jericho & Rob Van Dam, Brock Lesnar is never around long enough to truly make his presence known. He doesn't wrestle on Raw, Smackdown or house shows and seems to be held above other WWE superstars on the food chain. As of this writing, "The Brock Lesnar Experiment" seems to have failed, even though there is still time to save it. WWE Network subscriptions haven't skyrocketed, ratings are stagnant & overall interest in the product seems to be waning. Here are 10 Reasons why WWE's Brock Lesnar Experiment has failed up to this point.
10. Eight Years Away from WWE
In the world of professional wrestling, eight years is a very long time. The past has shown that eight years can change eras in WWE, and in this case, it has. When Brock Lesnar returned to WWE in 2012, they were immersed in the "PG Era." This era is something different from what Brock left in 2004. While Lesnar was away, a brand new crop of WWE fans were brought into the fold, without a firm knowledge of who Brock Lesnar is and what he once meant to the product. In that eight years, Lesnar's stock as a pro wrestler dropped significantly, as he wasn't in front of pro wrestling fans on a week to week basis. Although his stock as a mainstream, pay-per-view draw was at an all-time high due to huge buy rates while on top of the UFC, pro wrestling and MMA are two completely different breeds. Like all sports, some fans crossover to both realms of entertainment. However, there is a huge MMA fan base that looks down upon pro wrestling and they aren't going to change their ways. Did WWE believe that Brock's MMA fans would cross back over to WWE? A majority of longtime wrestling fans were waiting patiently for a Brock Lesnar return to WWE, but newer fans couldn't care less. There is no question that the eight years away from WWE has effected his longterm viability as a WWE superstar.
9. WWE Viewership
Although there are many factors that go into how WWE determines the overall size of their audience, television ratings are still a major factor. WWE's belief over the past few years has been that having added star power on the show will increase ratings. However, this experiment with Lesnar hasn't reaped the benefits that they may have believed. When Lesnar returned to WWE the night after WrestleMania 28, Raw was able to muster a pretty impressive 3.43 rating with an average of about five million viewers. Brock's return was unadvertised, but a lot of fans knew that he was getting set to return. Later that year, Brock headlined SummerSlam 2012 against Triple H in a match that was built for months. Even though the buy rate for the SummerSlam 2012 pay-per-view was solid at 350,000 buys worldwide, the ratings for the night after SummerSlam were just a 3.14, averaging 4.48 millions viewers. The ratings throughout this run haven't been significantly boosted by Brock's come and go mentality. Raw has pretty much stayed consistent, with or without Brock Lesnar on the show. His presence has not given the casual fan a reason to watch like WWE may have thought. Furthermore, WWE hasn't done a great job in building compelling television around Lesnar's rare appearances.
8. Ineffective Promotion
There has been an overall lack of promotion of Brock Lesnar since he's been back in WWE. We all know that Brock is a part-time WWE superstar, but WWE should have had a better game plan with how to inform as many human beings on the planet as possible of his presence on their television show. When Lesnar left WWE in 2004, he was arguably the top draw in the entire company. He became a household name in the sports industry during his run in the UFC. Wouldn't you think that WWE would do all they can to get Brock Lesnar out there to the masses? Where are his radio and television appearances? Where are all of the interviews? Wrestling fans know that Lesnar doesn't like doing public appearances, but when it comes to promoting someone who is going to be one of your top draws, WWE needs to get him out there to as many people as possible. If Brock Lesnar fans from years past don't know that he is back in WWE, how are they going to know to watch? For the first time in recent memory, the WWE Champion doesn't necessarily represent the company in any way, shape or form.
7. Inconsistent WWE Presence
Paul Heyman is the best possible mouthpiece for Brock Lesnar while he is away from the WWE. But truth be told, there is no substitute for the real thing. Brock Lesnar's presence on WWE television has been few and far between since he has come back to the company. When it's time to build to a particular match, Lesnar conveniently shows up to help promote. It's a strategy by WWE to be able to afford his high priced, pay-per-appearance deal. Since coming back, Lesnar has only competed in nine WWE matches from April 2012 to November 2014. This inconsistency effects the continuity of storylines on a month to month basis. While he's only been defeated in three times (one by disqualification), there's no reason for casual fans to stay emotionally invested if he isn't around.
6. Uncreative Opponents
Brock Lesnar is known as a "prize fighter" in WWE. He's only in it for big money matches that draw attention to the company. This strategy isn't working and is causing this experiment to currently fail. Why are fans going to continually pay to see Lesnar wrestle the same guys over and over again? The lack of depth on the roster doesn't give Lesnar a variety of high profile opponents to wrestle against. Since his return, Lesnar has had three matches against John Cena and Triple H. He's also faced CM Punk, The Undertaker and The Big Show one time each. During his first run in WWE from 2002-2004, Lesnar had a series of matches against John Cena, Big Show and The Undertaker. Longtime fans can sense the lack of creativity a mile away when it comes to Lesnar. (Note: Lesnar faced Triple H one time during his first run in WWE in a Triple Threat Match for the WWE Undisputed Title at "WWE Global Warning 2002.") While his matches against CM Punk and Triple H were a change of pace, WWE fans want to see how Lesnar fairs against a new crop of talent. Fresh matches against the likes of Roman Reigns and Daniel Bryan gives fans something to look forward to in the future, but have they waited too long to save his run? We're hardly on the edge of our seats waiting for the next encounter between Lesnar and John Cena. While the rematch is logical, it's going to be difficult to deliver something completely different from their two most recent contests.
5. Uneventful In-Ring Work
He's been known for years as one of the most athletically gifted people on the planet...and he still is. But the athleticism isn't coming across like it should in the WWE for Brock Lesnar. His in-ring style isn't what it used to be and it's hampering the reaction from the live crowd. Fans who expected to see the Lesnar of old are witnessing a slower, more calculated style involving a lot of high impact moves at a snails pace. Whether it is by design or not, Lesnar hasn't exactly been exciting in the ring. It shouldn't be surprising that his best match since his return was his 2013 Match of the Year candidate against CM Punk at SummerSlam 2013. Punk has been known to bring out the best in his opponents and it was no different when it came to Lesnar. The majority of his other matches since his return have been pretty slow and lacking any real work rate. Lesnar improved week after week in WWE from 2002-2004. As his run continued, he adapted to the in-ring styles of many other pro wrestlers who were better than him. Ask any wrestler or expert on pro wrestling: you get better when you work against wrestlers who are better than you. Working consistently against guys like Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit, The Undertaker and others helped to move Lesnar's in-ring career in a positive direction. At the moment, Lesnar comes in, wrestles a match and in the majority of cases, doesn't wrestle another one for a few months.
4. Lack Of WWE Network Subscriptions
WWE had to have believed that Brock Lesnar becoming WWE Champion at SummerSlam would have enticed people to subscribe to the WWE Network to see his various title defenses. The major problem with that theory: Lesnar has only defended the championship once so far in a rematch against John Cena at Night of Champions. According to the 3rd-Quarter conference call that took place recently, WWE gained just 31,000 subscribers and are making major changes to the service enticing people to sign up for free in the month of November. They've also dropped the six-month commitment and are allowing people to pay on a month-to-month basis at just $9.99 per month. Will Brock Lesnar's run as WWE Champion cause a larger increase in WWE Network Subscribers for the final quarter of the year? Word on the street is that Lesnar may not appear much on WWE television or even defend the WWE Championship again until after the end of the year. For such an important fiscal quarter for the long-term success of WWE, wouldn't it be wise to have your WWE Champion mega-star featured on the programming more often? Brock should be on every single WWE pay-per-view, especially the upcoming Survivor Series, which will be a night that every member of the WWE Universe can have the opportunity to watch free on the WWE Network. Nevertheless, WrestleMania 31 will be a crucial night for the success of the WWE Network. We are still a few months away, but the feeling right now is that Brock Lesnar will have a huge position on that show. This will be the final opportunity for WWE to see if their experiment with Brock Lesnar has been worth what it has cost them.
3. Character Development
There has been no character development for Brock Lesnar since he made his return to WWE. He's been stuck in the same role since his return and there is no sign of it changing. Brock isn't your conventional heel character. As a matter of fact, he has more character traits that the WWE Universe could get behind instead of despising. Paul Heyman does a fantastic job in building heat for Lesnar with his mastery of the microphone, but where is it heading? Will Brock eventually turn on his "advocate" or vice versa? It is important to continue to add layers to a WWE superstar over the course of time and the lack of character development has been a major reason why Brock's run is becoming stale. Wouldn't it be interesting if Brock Lesnar and Paul Heyman both turned babyface together? It would be something different for both men and Brock could truly embrace how much of a certified badass he really is.
2. Predictable Run As WWE Champion
When Brock Lesnar won the WWE Championship at SummerSlam, fans could predict where the run is heading: WrestleMania 31. There's no other logical destination for Brock Lesnar to drop the WWE Championship. Not to say that it's not a good idea, but it's definitely predictable. What built WWE into the global phenomenon that it is today was the unpredictable nature of the programming on a week to week basis. The overused phrase of "anything can happen in WWE" hasn't been true when it comes to Brock's run as champion. The destination to WrestleMania 31 needs to have some twists and turns involved to keep interest high. Why not come up with a plan for Brock Lesnar to have a match on Raw and promote it for a couple of weeks? This would be a true twist in the story and would show you if Brock Lesnar being in action on Raw could boost a rating. It could also add a nice twist to The Road to WrestleMania.
1. Brock Lesnar Doesn't Care And Will Leave WWE Soon
The biggest reason why Brock Lesnar's run has been a failure is that he doesn't care about WWE. It's obvious that Brock Lesnar isn't passionate about what he does. He's lost the love of sports entertainment and has gained the lust of money. When he left in 2004, he basically quit in the middle of a domiant run at the top of the promotion. WWE built the Brock Lesnar brand and made it into a viable asset for any company. As a part of Lesnar's settlement to leave, he signed a no-compete clause that would be in effect until June 2010. Lesnar was able to get out of the clause and continue to make money in New Japan Pro Wrestling and later in the UFC. When a pro wrestler doesn't love what they do, it is easy to see it during their performances. It comes out through the TV screen and fans across the world can sense it. Why get invested in a talent when you know that they're leaving soon? In the case of Brock Lesnar, there will be a point where he just won't come back. He'll be done and more than likely, it will be the end of his final run in WWE. Of course, Brock Lesnar's current run hasn't concluded yet and we really don't know exactly where it is headed. We can only judge what we've seen so far and speculate where it is going. And up to this point, The Brock Lesnar Experiment hasn't lived up to the hype. It is failing and WWE needs to do whatever they can to get their most out of Lesnar before he is gone for good.