10 Shocking Winners Of Wrestling Observer Awards
Seriously? They won an award?!
Since the 1980s, Dave Meltzer has opened ballots for yearly awards for the best and worst of professional wrestling.
With the launch of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter (WON) in 1982, the awards established themselves as an indicator of what the voting public thought of the current product and they have been a much-anticipated wrestling tradition ever since.
Awards like Wrestler Of The Year, Match Of The Year, Promotion Of The Year and so on are coveted by those in the know, whilst awards like Worst Worked Match and Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic are not accolades anyone wants on their resume. Many great wrestlers have won these awards over the years - some such as Ric Flair, Bruiser Brody, and Bryan Danielson even have awards named after them - but some award winners have been a bit unusual.
Of course, these awards are completely subjective and you could make an argument for all of these winners being worthy. However, the following examples are the ones most likely to encourage debate between wrestling fans... not that many of them need encouraging.
Get ready to pick your jaw up off the floor, because some of these are truly unbelievable...
10. John Morrison and The Miz - Tag Team Of The Year 2008
Thirteen years before they reunited on Smackdown, The Miz and John Morrison were an established tag team on the old ECW brand, gaining popularity through their web series, The Dirt Sheet. The duo picked up two tag team championships during their first run, which ended in 2009 when The Miz rather predictably turned on his partner.
In 2008, Miz and Morrison picked up the prestigious Tag Team Of The Year award from the WON. The two Ms are part of a pool of winners including The Fabulous Freebirds, The Steiner Brothers, Edge and Christian, The Shield, and The Young Bucks.
Whilst not a bad team and miles better than they would become in 2020, to put Miz and Morrison in the same conversation as those teams is a bit of a long shot, especially over other nominated teams in 2008 including The Motor City Machine Guns, Tencozy, and Kevin Steen and El Generico.
If you told an Observer reader today that The Miz once picked up an award over Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn, then they'd probably try and punch you, but it's all there in black and white. Strange how times change, huh?
9. Sasha Banks vs Bayley - Worst Feud Of The Year 2018
Sasha Banks and Bayley's 2018 feud was rubbish. After months of tension, nonsensical betrayals, and pointless counselling sessions, WWE just forgot about these two's hatred for one another, lumped them into a team, and gave them the women's tag belts. Months of build-up and anticipation for precisely nothing. Great.
What's even more shocking is that WWE have done this rivalry really well twice. The first came in NXT where Banks and Bayley where their battle in Brooklyn became the stuff of legend and helped inspire WWE to completely overhaul its presentation of female talent.
Then, during the pandemic, Bayley and Banks teamed up again as The Golden Role Models; an obnoxious heel act that held all the gold and helped carry WWE through its Thunderdome era.
Banks and Bayley make magic together when they're allowed to, but in 2018 they were on a creative leash so tight that fans turned on their former heroes quicker than you can say "Remember that Iron Woman match?". This award is a sad blemish on the otherwise pretty faultless careers of both women. Fingers crossed we never end up in this dark place ever again.
8. The Undertaker - Most Overrated 2001
Between his "retirement" at WrestleMania 33 and his "retirement" at Survivor Series 2020, The Undertaker was not viewed very fondly a majority of the time. His ageing body prevented him from having the barn-burners fans expected and his desperation to have "one last classic" drove him to accept disastrous matches with the likes of DX and Goldberg.
This is not the first time The Deadman has been viewed negatively by the WWE universe. Taker went through a radical shift in character following his 2000 return as the American Badass. Gone were the flowing black robes and satanic imagery of The Lord of Darkness and in came bandannas, chewing tobacco, and motorcycles. Honestly not sure which is more terrifying.
Fans noticed that, with this new character, the quality of Undertaker's matches began to dip. This might explain why Taker was voted the Most Overrated wrestler in 2001 - an award previously won by Bob Backlund, Sid Vicious, and Hulk Hogan seven times.
This fan resentment wouldn't last, but for those who only know The Undertaker as a beloved legend, this award may come as a shock to the system.
7. Matt Striker - Best Television Announcer 2008
To call Matt Striker a contentious figure in wrestling is like calling Paul Wight quite a large man. Striker's abrasive commentary style can rub some people up the wrong way. Equally, some really like his heelish tenancies and his resistance to the crap thrown his way by Jerry Lawler. Striker was clearly popular in 2008 though, as he won that year's award for "Best Television Announcer".
Joining esteemed broadcasters like Gordon Solie, Joey Styles, and Jim Ross, Striker picked up the award for his work as the ECW brand's colour commentator. It was a tight win; Striker edged out Jim Ross by just forty-six votes and this was during JR's unmemorable run as SmackDown lead announcer. Still, a win is a win.
Considering that the third and fourth places in this both went to MMA commentators - Joe Rogan and Mike Goldberg, for those curious - Striker's win is perhaps an indication that wrestling's commentary scene was not in the best place in 2008. He may not be everyone's favourite, but no one will ever be able to take this accolade away from Striker - no matter how much they may want to.
6. Johnny Ace - Match Of The Year 1996
Johnny Ace's biggest influence on wrestling has been behind the scenes as the Head of Talent Relations in WWE. Under his real name of John Laurinaitis, Ace also began appearing as an on-screen authority figure in 2011, which... well, maybe we shouldn't dwell on that too much.
This was far from Laurinaitis' first on-screen appearance. As Johnny Ace, he was a well-travelled wrestler who competed for promotions including WCW and All Japan Pro Wrestling (AJPW), where Ace would form a tag team with "Dr. Death" Steve Williams.
At AJPW's Super Power series in 1996, Ace and Williams teamed up to take on the legendary Japanese team of Mitsuharu Misawa and Jun Akiyama. It's a match that many Western fans won't be aware of, but it's definitely worth seeking out as Dave Meltzer awarded it five stars and it later picked up the Observer's much-coveted Match of the Yea" award.
It's hard to believe that the same man who used to ride scooters down to the ring was capable of a five star classic in Japan. Then again, Steve Austin used to ride an ATV down to the ring and what's an ATV if not a big, motorised scooter?
5. New Japan Pro Wrestling - Worst Promotion Of The Year 2004/2005
WWE has won the Observer's Promotion Of The Year award twice. New Japan Pro Wrestling has won it sixteen times, including in every single year between 2012 and 2019. This is why it's so shocking that the company has also won their Worst Promotion award not once, but twice.
To be fair, even the most hardened of New Japan fans would struggle to defend the company in 2004 and 2005. The company was struggling following the departure of founder, Antonio Inoki, and endured such hardships as the disastrous incorporation of MMA into their style and the tumultuous IWGP Championship reign of Brock Lesnar.
What's worse is that the company that won Promotion Of The Year in 2004 and 2005 was Pro Wrestling Noah, one of New Japan's biggest rivals. This would have been an additional slap in the face for a company already in turmoil.
Considering how adored the promotion became years later, seeing that it won the publication's worst promotion award two years on the trot is incredibly surprising. Thankfully the King of Sports managed to bounce back, but that wasn't always a certainty.
4. Tony Hernandez’s Monster Character - Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic 1981
The winners of the WON's Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic award include the following; the Piggy James angle; Katie Vick; exploiting the death of Eddie Guerrero; WWE's relationship with Saudi Arabia; Muhammad Hassan and his gimmick; and the decision to carry on with a pay-per-view shortly after the death of Owen Hart.
All of these things are despicable and worthy recipients of this award, which makes the decision to hand it out to a man dressed in a monster costume even more baffling.
Information is hard to come by regarding Tony Hernandez, but his career "highlight" was portraying a literal monster character in forgotten 80s company, LaBelle Promotions. The character was allegedly a last-ditch effort to save the failing business from going under by dressing Hernandez up in a furry monster suit and claiming he was "made in a lab".
Granted, this tactic was silly and pretty dubious considering most fans still believed in kayfabe at the time, but to call it disgusting might be a stretch too far. On a list that features some of the worst things ever done in the world of wrestling, Hernandez sticks out like a sore thumb... a sore, hairy thumb.
3. Goldust - Worst Gimmick 1995
In 1995, "The Natural" Dustin Rhodes debuted for the WWF as Goldust; an androgynous being covered head-to-toe in gold paint. Goldust was one of the most innovative and unique characters seen in years in the WWF and Rhodes quickly became a key part of their show.
Today, the Goldust gimmick is usually held up as one of the best ever, but this wasn't always the case. Evidence for this comes in the 1995 Wrestling Observer Awards, where Goldie shockingly "won" the Worst Gimmick gong, putting him in the same company as The Oddities, The Shockmaster, and The Gobbledey Gooker.
Whilst the original Goldust character was certainly shocking and played on some very nasty stereotypes, there is no way that this character should have won this award - especially when you consider that other nominees that year were The Shark, Issac Yankem, and The Yeti. He lost to a man covered in toilet paper, for God's sake!
Unfortunately, this isn't the only time Dustin has scooped this award. He "won" it again in 1997 as The Artist Formerly Known As Goldust and then again in 2007 as Black Reign. Actually, yeah, he kinda deserved those two...
2. “The Fiend” Bray Wyatt - Best Gimmick 2019 and Worst Gimmick 2020
At SummerSlam 2019, Bray Wyatt debuted "The Fiend" - a real-life horror villain who would tear through opponents with ruthless violence behind the sinister smile of his exquisite mask.
The Fiend was an instant hit and many fans believed that Wyatt's shaky WWE career was now back on track. This faith was affirmed when Wyatt scooped the Observer's Best Gimmick award. However, if you looked beneath the surface, the cracks in The Fiend's mystique were already beginning to show.
By the end of 2019, Fiend had been through his disastrous rivalry with Seth Rollins, including their much-derided Hell in a Cell match. The shine was starting to fall off The Fiend's apple, shown by the fact that he also came third in 2019's Worst Gimmick category. Wyatt's work earlier that year had been enough to save him, but 2020 would bring no such salvation.
After yet more damaging feuds with Goldberg, Braun Strowman, and Randy Orton, the WON readership's patience with The Fiend ran out. He won their Worst Gimmick award that year, even with stiff competition from Retribution. Fiend might have liked to snap his opponents' necks, but it was his own fall from grace that occurred at breakneck speed.
1. Hulk Hogan vs Andre The Giant at WrestleMania III - Worst Match Of The Year 1987
WrestleMania III - one of the most important wrestling events of all time - was sold almost exclusively on the blockbuster main event of Hulk Hogan versus Andre The Giant.
This was the first truly seismic WrestleMania ender; two of the industry's biggest stars going face-to-face with the real threat that Hogan's multi-year WWF Championship reign might finally end. It was an epic in every sense, but clearly that wasn't enough for some people.
In the shocker of all shockers, the Observer voted this match as the worst one of the entire year of 1987. You can see why this happened when you examine what won Best Match - Randy Savage vs Ricky Steamboat from the very same event.
Savage and Steamboat put on a technical masterclass, whilst Hogan vs Andre was more about crowd work and feats of strength. It's clear that the WON and its readers at the time were less interested in the more pantomime elements of wrestling and preferred some good ol' fashioned rasslin' instead.
Still, to call this match the worst of any year is totally undeserved and proof that those in the know don't always know as much as they think.