10 Stupidest Gimmick Changes In WWE History
Change can be scary sometimes, especially when the gimmicks are this bad.
Many times, a talented wrestler can fail to connect with the audience for a variety of reasons: Maybe his mic work isn't up to par, or his style doesn't translate to television, or his in-ring psychology needs work.
However, sometimes a wrestler's character just simply isn't clicking, necessitating a change in direction.
This has given us many legends from the past: The Ringmaster turned into Stone Cold Steve Austin, Rocky Maivia became the Rock, Hunter Hearst Helmsley became Triple H, and Rocker Shawn Michaels became the Heartbreak Kid Shawn Michaels.
But, for every successful gimmick change, there seems to be about 100 failed changes. History tends to remember the successful transitions but the awful ones get flushed down the proverbial toilet, never to be seen again.
Fear not, dear reader, this list will cover some of those failed gimmick changes and remind you of their silliness all over again.
10. Terry Taylor To The Red Rooster
Terry Taylor was an extremely talented wrestler when he rolled into the World Wrestling Federation in 1988. He had held numerous NWA regional titles around the country and was fresh off a successful World Class run in the Von Erich's territory.
So, when he came to New York, fans had some pretty high expectations for the talented young worker. According to Bruce Prichard, McMahon took one look at Taylor and had the perfect gimmick in mind.
He was going to be a rooster, pal.
McMahon didn't literally mean that Taylor should act like a rooster but was inspired by the fact that Taylor carried himself like he was the "!*$% of the walk" and was better than everyone else.
Taylor, who wasn't exactly thrilled with the idea, took the gimmick literally and began strutting around like a bird and pecking. He even styled his hair into a red rooster comb and began crowing. The entire thing screamed "bush league" and made Taylor a laughing stock before his departure in 1990.
9. One Man Gang To Akeem The African Dream
The One Man Gang was a former UWF heavyweight champion who, as a 400 lbs. heel, was one of the top stars in the territory. It was only natural that Vince McMahon would want the big man during the WWF excess days of 1987. He was given a pretty decent push and even got to "retire" Superstar Billy Graham following a big splash on the floor.
However, after the Wrestlemania IV title tournament, McMahon decided that the Gang needed a change to reconnect with the audience: He needed to go back to his African roots.
Now, forgive me for a minute, but it doesn't take a genius to figure out that George Gray doesn't appear to have any "African roots". Of course, that was the joke because who doesn't love a 450 lbs. white guy from South Carolina who pretends to be black?
Gang was renamed "Akeem, the African Dream" complete with Slick as a manager and a semi-offensive "tribal celebration" to complete his transformation. Akeem awkwardly jive-walked around the WWF ring for two more years before heading into the arms of WCW.
8. Headbanger Mosh To Beaver Cleavage
The Attitude Era of the WWF provided fans with so many memorable moments, it's hard to even list them here. However, due to the "crash TV" manner of the programming, there was an awful lot of crap that made it onto screens as well.
Take Beaver Cleavage, for example.
Chaz Warrington was a longtime tag wrestler who, alongside partner Glenn Ruth, made up the Headbangers. The team had a cup of coffee with the tag titles but were mostly a midcard act.
Enter Vince Russo.
Since Russo was a fan of anything sexual and crude, he jumped at the chance to repackage Warrington when his partner was injured in 1999.
The former Mosh was debuted into a series of vignettes as "Beaver Cleavage" an overtly sexual parody of the classic "Leave it to Beaver" complete with a surgically-enhanced mother (Mrs. Cleavage, of course).
Beaver's segments were filled with sexual innuendo that teased incest and, thankfully, it only lasted a few weeks before it was mercifully killed off.
7. Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart To Who
With Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart, you had one of the most successful tag wrestlers in WWF history but also someone who struggled to connect with the audience as a singles wrestler. While Neidhart may never have main evented on his own, he was an extremely recognizable name to wrestling fans and just needed some freshening up.
The WWF decided that his new character would come from a 50 year old comedy routine.
In 1996, Neidhart debuted as the masked character named "Who"....that was the extent of thought put into the guy. What resulted was Jerry Lawler and Vince McMahon cracking "hilarious" jokes based on the famous Abbott and Costello routine from the 1940s.
The commentary featured comedic gems such as this:
"Who is really taking it to his opponent right now."
"Who is?"
"Yes."
Amazingly enough, this didn't get over with fans and Who went back to being Jim Neidhart.
Who did?
Right.
6. Tony Atlas To Saba Simba
In the pre-Hulkamania days of the WWF, there were only a handful of wrestlers who were bigger stars than "Mr. USA" Tony Atlas. Atlas and his partner Rocky Johnson became the first African-American men to capture the WWF tag titles when they defeated the Wild Samoans in 1983.
Atlas was primed for a run with the Intercontinental title but a growing drug problem caused him to miss several dates for the company and led to his departure. When he returned in 1990, McMahon didn't want Atlas to bring back his "Black Superman" character, he wanted Atlas completely different.
Atlas was morphed into the walking stereotype "Saba Simba", a Uganda tribal warrior who carried a spear and wore a ridiculously over-sized headdress to the ring. I'm not one to throw around the word "racist" very much but this gimmick definitely toed the line.
When he debuted at the 1991 Royal Rumble, McMahon wanted Simba treated like a completely new character and not reference his past as Tony Atlas or as a former WWF tag champion.
So you can only imagine his annoyance when, upon Simba's entrance, color commentator Roddy Piper exclaimed "Hey, it's Tony Atlas!"
5. Billy Gunn To Rockabilly
The mid-1990s was not a good time for the WWF. Vince McMahon seemed woefully out of touch with his audience and his audience was rapidly leaving him for the edgier and cooler WCW product.
Nothing better symbolized this disconnect than the storyline about the Honky Tonk Man's protege.
Honky had returned to the WWF as a manager in 1997, announcing that he was searching for his protege to turn into the next great Intercontinental champion. So far, so good. All you needed was a young, upcoming wrestler who could get the rub from Honky and get a little push in the card.
Instead, they repackaged tag wrestler Billy Gunn into "Rockabilly".
It was a sad knockoff of the Honky Tonk Man gimmick and crowds reacted with complete and total apathy. They even did a feud between Rockabilly and "Double J" Jesse Jammes over who was the better singer.
Thankfully, both guys realized how terrible it was and suggested becoming a tag team. Rockabilly smashed a guitar over Honky's head and the New Age Outlaws were born.
4. Isaac Yankem To Fake Diesel
Sticking with the same era for a moment, 1996 could be considered the worst year in the history of the World Wrestling Federation. Not only were TV ratings and live crowds dropping but McMahon had also just lost Kevin Nash and Scott Hall to WCW.
When Hall and Nash appeared on WCW television portraying their former WWF personas, McMahon went ballistic and filed a lawsuit against the company. WCW wasn't exactly hiding that they were booking a WWF invasion angle and McMahon felt that violated his trademarks of Diesel and Razor Ramon.
On the advice of attorneys, McMahon decided to show he still owned the characters by casting new wrestlers to play the role. Rick Bognar got the honor of portraying an overweight Razor Ramon while McMahon had someone else in mind to play Big Daddy Cool.
Glenn Jacobs was stuck working as Jerry Lawler's evil wrestling dentist (no, seriously), Isaac Yankem, or I. Yankem for short. When Jacobs was tapped to portray Diesel, at best it could be considered a lateral career move.
Audiences crapped all over the ripoff characters and, despite being all over television, they failed to get any crowd reaction other than disgust. "Diesel" was taken off of television after the 1997 Royal Rumble and Kane debuted soon after.
3. Cody Rhodes To Stardust
You have to almost feel bad for Cody Rhodes. Despite being an extremely talented performer, he never really clicked with the audience despite being given a huge initial push as part of Randy Orton's Legacy stable.
He had a decent run as a heel on Smackdown and probably could have carved out a solid midcard career but Cody wanted something bigger and decided a drastic gimmick change was in order.
Cody began mimicking Goldust's mannerisms and rechristened himself as Stardust, a name used by his father in the AWA. He acted completely spaced out and spoke of a "cosmic key" that was never really explained, just constantly referenced.
As the gimmick changes, Cody went from being a Goldust imitator to a comic book villain. Cody is a real-life comic book nerd and wanted to bring a supervillain to WWE television complete with minions and a hero defeating him.
It was a cool concept but WWE's creative team just didn't get the character, consistently booking him in pointless feuds and having him job to actor Stephen Amell at Summerslam.
2. Chavo Guerrero To Kerwin White
There's an old saying in wrestling that you can never have too many Guerreros on your roster. Nearly every single member of the family wrestled and they were all tremendous in the ring. That's what made WWE's treatment of Chavo Guerrero all the more confusing.
Chavo was fresh off of a cruiserweight title run in a tremendous act alongside his father, Chavo Classic. For whatever reason, they decided to move Chavo to Raw and change his gimmick from lying, cheating, and stealing Mexican wrestler to gold-playing Caucasian guy.
Chavo was renamed "Kerwin White", a takeoff on WWE director Kerwin Silfies moniker, and dyed his hair blonde. He also started driving a golf cart to the ring and his entrance music became Sinatra-like .
To make things even worse, Kerwin's catchphrase was "If it's not White, it's not right." Needless to say, people were more than slightly offended but that still didn't kill off the character. Nick Nemeth (the future Dolph Ziggler) was even brought in as Kerwin's "caddy".
The gimmick was finally ended after the passing of Chavo's uncle, Eddie Guerrero but its purpose still remains a mystery.
1. Sgt. Slaughter To Sgt. Slaugter Iraqi Sympathizer
25 years later, it's hard to imagine what made Vince McMahon turn Sgt. Slaughter into an Iraqi sympathizer. It may have been one of the biggest misfires in WWE history and they certainly paid for it when Wrestlemania VII rolled around.
Even though Sarge had played a heel multiple times during his career, Slaughter was always a faithful US serviceman. When he returned to the WWF in 1990, Vince didn't want an All-American babyface since he had that in Hulk Hogan, he wanted the total opposite.
Slaughter became an Iraqi sympathizer during a time when tensions in the Middle East were extremely high. Slaughter proclaimed his love of the Iraqi regime because they were "brutal" whereas the United States had gone soft. He even won the WWF title at the Royal Rumble in 1991 just as the US invaded Kuwait and began the Gulf War.
It was even planned that Sarge would burn the American flag on WWF television but that was changed to a Hulk Hogan t-shirt at the last second when cooler heads prevailed. Slaughter faced death threats and had to travel while wearing a bullet-proof vest.
This was clearly the wrong kind of heat that makes people angry and doesn't draw a dime. The backlash was furious and ticket sales for Wrestlemania VII were so poor that the WWF was forced to move the event from the 100,000 seat LA Colosseum to the much smaller LA Sports Arena.
It was a disaster of epic proportions.