10 Terrible Wrestling Matches Everybody Loves

Those wrestling matches that are so damn bad... they're actually pretty darn good.

By Gareth Morgan /

The art of professional wrestling is hugely subjective.

Advertisement

What one fan may absolutely adore seeing go down in the middle of a squared-circle, another will more than likely utterly detest with every fibre of their being.

But in the case of the following collection of widely and often justifiably crapped on showdowns, it's pretty safe to assume that just about anyone who has ever taken in a wrestling contest will agree on these bouts being up there with the very worst ever to go down in-between the ropes.

However, just because they wholeheartedly suck for a whole host of varying reasons, doesn't mean there isn't some joy to be found in the terribleness. In fact, once you look past the surface level dreadful story being told, clunky physicality on show, or a just plain ol' painful botched conclusion, there's actually a lot to love about what you'd be forgiven for classing as some of the all-time worst matches in wrestling history.

So, from lacklustre clashes of the titans going on to become arguably one of the most iconic match-ups in the history of the business, to gimmicky grudge matches that were so horrendous you had no choice but to surrender to the madness, these are those simply atrocious battles that somehow earned a soft spot in many a fans' hearts.

10. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XXVI)

No one in their right mind was expecting an in-ring clinic with this one by any means.

Advertisement

After the infamous events of Montreal all those years ago, fans simply wanted to take in the visual of a returning Bret "The Hitman" Hart getting some physical revenge on Vince McMahon after screwing him on his way out of WWE back in 1997.

And, though the actual content of said beat down wasn't exactly inspired, with Mr. McMahon simply running around like a scared weasel before getting repeatedly knocked silly by the Hart family at ringside and a weapon-wielding Hitman throughout the No Holds Barred fight, it did at least feel rather therapeutic.

Another WrestleMania classic to add to Bret's collection, this was not. It never needed to be, though.

Thanks largely to the fact Hart was forbidden from bumping on the back of his lawsuit with Lloyd's of London, a match nobody genuinely thought would ever be brought into existence, never mind on The Grandest Stage, was always destined to turn into a plodding, drawn out, one-sided ass kicking.

But, you'd be lying if you said you didn't thoroughly enjoy the sight of good ol' Bret finally getting the visual last laugh over Vinnie Mac under the bright light's of his greatest creation.

9. John Cena Vs. The Fiend (WrestleMania 36)

Credit to Bray Wyatt, John Cena, and WWE for trying to think a little outside the box when it came to one of the marquee WrestleMania 36 showdowns unfortunately forced to go down inside of an empty Performance Center. But the fact this particular cinematic showdown came in the wake of an absolutely joyous Boneyard riot did it no favours in the end.

Advertisement

That being said, the all-round insanity that can be found going down during this Firefly Funhouse slice of madness still brought with it a few guilty pleasure highlights along the way.

From The Face that Runs the Place going full Muscle Man, spouting out "Ruthless Aggression!" in full 2002-mode, and donning an nWo shirt for a too sweet "what if?" beat, to Wyatt doing his best Eric Bischoff, a physical battle for the ages was nowhere to be seen. Yet, if you were looking for a few cheap pops in the thick of a terrifying global pandemic, then Wyatt and Cena had you covered.

Time hasn't been all that kind to the amateur dramatics on show from a now-Hollywood Cena, either. And while the "match" also serves as a reminder of everything that was unquestionably wrong about Wyatt's all-conquering Fiend monster, the creative lunacy dotted around Super Cena's deconstruction is still worthy of a spare 15-minutes today.

8. Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg (WrestleMania XX)

The Beast vs. Da Man inside of Madison Square Garden can best be described as two hulking titans gradually losing their cool whilst all in attendance successfully go about becoming the stars of a supposed dream match.

Advertisement

This was just bizarre. And is still hilariously odd to behold nearly two decades later.

With both Brock Lesnar and Bill Goldberg's exits from WWE being made known in the lead-up to this once-highly-anticipated battle of the monsters, it became clear about 20-seconds into their WrestleMania XX battle that it was going to be a long final night at the office for the pair.

Special guest referee "Stone Cold" Steve Austin could do nothing but sit back and watch the car crash unfold - with a twinkle in his eye - as waves of "Goodbye" and "You Sold Out" chants rained down on the departing rivals. And it was the priceless hijacking of this never-ending spell of posturing that made this one of the most enjoyable disasters ever to grace The Grandest Stage.

The actual content of the match was about as forgettable as it comes. But Austin's stunning of both of the soon-to-be former WWE stars on their way out the door bookended one of the barmiest and unintentionally funniest blockbuster collisions you're ever likely to witness.

7. Rey Mysterio Vs. Seth Rollins (WWE The Horror Show At Extreme Rules, 2020)

Returning to the regularly outrageous waters that were Performance Center WWE events during the height of the pandemic now, and to a match that very much earned its place on a show absurdly titled The Horror Show at Extreme Rules.

Advertisement

With Rey Mysterio and Seth Rollins gripped in a blood feud heading into the July 2020 PLE, a ton of eye shenanigans had ultimately set the stage for the pair to settle the score in none other than an Eye for an Eye match - "a winner can only be determined by extracting the opponent’s eye", as WWE described it.

Unsurprisingly, what with the rivals being two of the finest performers on the roster, the match itself was a ton of ludicrous, eye-targeting fun. Mysterio once again proved he simply hasn't aged a day in the last twenty years, and a heelish Rollins was at his innovative best throughout.

The glorious chemistry shared between the two in this daft contest, however, is understandably overshadowed by a farcical conclusion consisting of Rey-Rey having his (rubber) eye popped out of his skull and The Visionary seemingly chucking up at the sight of the comical over-the-top finish.

But even that undoubtedly silly closing stretch was the best kind of dumb, with the throwaway line of "his eye is sticking out of his head!" perfectly summing up why many would quite happily sit through this chaos time and time again.

6. The Giant Vs. Hulk Hogan (WCW Halloween Havoc, 1995)

On a night that also featured Hulk Hogan and The Giant battling it out in a Sumo Monster Truck match, that somehow still wasn't the most absurd visual let loose over the course of Halloween Havoc 1995.

Advertisement

After surviving falling off the top of the arena, Paul Wight would dramatically re-emerge to take on The Hulkster in the main event for the WCW World Heavyweight Championship.

And your typical Hogan title defence would ensue as the pair staggered around the ring for ten or so minutes. This all then led to the sort of over-booked finish WCW ultimately became synonymous with as Jimmy Hart knocked down the ref, forcing a DQ victory for The Giant, and eventually turned on Hogan before joining The Dungeon of Doom.

But wait, there was more!

Paying off the reveal of a frozen block of ice supposedly holding an "insurance policy" for the group by the name of The Yeti on a prior edition of Nitro, that very soul then arrived on the scene. And the campiest of all debuts soon became a magnificent reality.

Honestly, the visual of Ron Reis wrapped in bandages helping The Giant give a helpless Hogan and Randy Savage some relentless cuddles is enough to force even the coldest of souls to crack a smile.

It's unequivocally excruciating... but you simply cannot take your eyes away from this legendary car crash of a WCW main event.

5. Intercontinental Championship Elimination Chamber (WWE Elimination Chamber, 2015)

The elimination chamber has played host to some hugely memorable bouts of multi-person madness over the years. And 2015's Intercontinental Championship edition was no different.

Advertisement

But instead of being fondly remembered for dominant performances or jaw-dropping spots, this battle to crown a new mid-card title holder is often cited as the biggest disaster the hellacious structure has ever unleashed. And that's precisely what makes it such a wonderful chunk of unforgettable mayhem to revisit.

Things quickly began to unravel in the wake of Mark Henry's pod accidentally being broken by Wade Barrett, with his unexpected introduction quickly forcing a change of plan. This then resulted in the majority of the field sporting entirely confused expressions on their faces for the remainder of the contest, and likely influenced the many baffling subsequent developments; such as Henry oddly breaking up Barrett's attempts to put away Dolph Ziggler with a Wasteland.

Ziggles attempting to steady the sinking ship with audible spot-calling, the commentary team clearly also not having the slightest clue what was going on, and even more confusion surrounding Sheamus' seemingly malfunctioning pod all helped cement this particular chamber outing as the calamitous gift that just kept on giving.

4. Shawn Michaels Vs. Hulk Hogan (WWE SummerSlam, 2005)

After already witnessing Edge and Matt Hardy go to war in the wake of some real-life relationship drama, and Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio battle it out over the custody of Dominik, fans were also treated to the out-and-out riot that was The Showstopper vs. The Hulkster in an infamous SummerSlam 2005 main event for the ages.

Advertisement

For those unaware, coming into the bout, the original plan for this Icon vs. Legend programme reportedly would've seen Shawn Michaels and Hulk Hogan take part in a best of three series. But Hogan ultimately wanted nothing to do with any of that. And it was his backing out of the subsequent matches that paved the way for HBK going into brassed off selling overdrive in their one-and-only singles showdown.

Yet, far from rejecting the sight of Michaels making a fool out of the supposed babyface on the night, those in attendance and watching around the world absolutely lapped up the veteran's excessive bumping and slapstick selling.

Sure, it may have transformed what could've been one of the biggest matches of the 2000's into little more than a 20-minute joke. But Michaels' admittedly unprofessional call to be a "pain in the butt" for his iconic adversary still sits as one of the most entertaining outings ever to flip onto the SummerSlam stage.

3. Big Show Vs. Akebono (WrestleMania 21)

If nothing else, this was a spectacle.

Advertisement

Often completely overlooked when looking back on a 21st Show of Shows that also boasted the reaching of the top of the mountain for both John Cena and Batista, Big Show's quest to best the mighty real-life sumo wrestling star Akebono at his own game is up there with the most surreal visuals the land of sports entertainment has ever produced. And that is saying something.

Over in around a minute, the brief clash of the giants in a sumo bout isn't exactly going to change your life. But witnessing two 500lbs humans colliding with one another in mawashis definitely boasted the odd big lad highlight; including Akebono suddenly being hoisted up by Show before the latter is swiftly dumped off the canvas like the biggest sack of spuds you've ever laid your eyes on.

Admittedly, when you break it down, it's little more than two larger than life humans slapping and hugging each other for 60-seconds in their oversized underwear. Yet, there's still a surprising amount of joy to be found in this bizarre throwaway 'Mania special attraction.

2. Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley (AEW Revolution, 2021)

The main event of AEW Revolution 2021 will sadly largely be remembered more for its fizzling firework display than for the absolute shift Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley put into the prior 24-minutes of pulsating drama.

Advertisement

Fully embracing the Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch surroundings they found themselves in, the violent pair took great pleasure in launching one another into various barbed wire weapons and ropes, with both world class individuals gushing blood in their efforts to walk out of Daily's Place as the AEW World Champion.

As savage as it was routinely innovative throughout, the bout was building towards what seemed like the perfect crescendo. After being nailed with an exploding barbed wire bat and a second attempt at Omega's all conquering finisher through a chair (thanks to some Good Brother assistance), Mox was defeated.

But the night didn't end there, with Mox being left for dead in the middle of the ring as the countdown clock signalled an incoming catastrophic explosion, only for the end product to consist of the rather embarrassing visual of Eddie Kingston risking his life to save his pal from those deadliest of sparklers.

There's no getting around the fact that said underwhelming closing stretch was about as terrible a PPV conclusion as AEW are ever likely to experience. But never forget that the gruesome, gripping action up to that point is still worthy of admiration.

1. Hulk Hogan Vs. Andre The Giant (WrestleMania III)

Perhaps ranking as the most famous wrestling match ever, there's a solid chance you won't be able to find a single person walking this planet today who hasn't witnessed Hulk Hogan's remarkable feat of strength at WrestleMania III.

Advertisement

But away from the powerslam heard around the world in The Hulkster's main event battle with Andre the Giant... there wasn't actually an awful lot more to write home about, was there?

With Andre not moving all too well due to the sheer stress of his 520lbs weight on his bones and joints, much of the match just consisted of the champ being tossed around like a cruiserweight and squeezed into submission by the giant challenger. Hell, Dave Meltzer even went as far as to give the contest a pitiful -4-star rating when all was said and done.

Yet, while the action itself was about as disappointing as it gets, none of that really mattered.

All those packed into the Pontiac Silverdome cared about was seeing The Hulkster slam his titanic rival and drop the title-defending leg. And when that finally happened, both an instantly iconic wrestling moment and many a new wrestling fan was born.

Advertisement