10 Things AEW MUST Do To Compete With WWE

Broaden The Universe.

By Michael Sidgwick /

10 Things AEW MUST Do To Compete With WWE*

Advertisement

*On a national level.

Every time you allow yourself to get excited over the idea that we may see a new, awesome wrestling promotion, the existence of which might just make the premier wrestling promotion that bit less awful, we read that WWE has just renewed its multi-million TV deal in Bahrain, or some sh*t. The notion of AEW competing with WWE on a global scale is absurd.

But domestically?

Prior to its current, modern Golden Age, New Japan Pro Wrestling was not as popular as WWE in its native country. By modifying and improving its product through intricate long-term booking, and promoting sublime, star performers with agency and conviction, this is no longer the case. WWE can be overtaken in certain markets. Abysmal Sky Sports ratings in the UK, and the strangled BritWres uprising, illustrate that WWE knows this all too well.

Not the closest of analogies, granted, but with WWE's viewership receding by the week, those fans aren't falling out of love with pro wrestling altogether. They want a better product. 'Product' is the word, because WWE has stars. Those we know for certain are capable of moving the needle - Ronda Rousey - aren't moving it. The stigma is too glaring; fans know it, want-away talent knows it, and by acknowledging it on TV, WWE knows it.

Of course, AEW will need stars too...

10. Spend The Money

Perception is everything in professional wrestling.

Advertisement

Several disenfranchised WWE fans are hesitant to venture outside of the bubble because everything else looks small time, or less glamorous, in comparison. Anecdotally, an old writer colleague felt removed from New Japan's minimalist production before persisting with and falling for it. This is a real thing, a perception of value warped entirely by capitalism:

If something is so good, why don't more people like it?

It's a cultural shock, one especially bracing to the WWE fan. Wrestling to them is a synonym of WWE. They've persisted with WWE despite falling out of love with it because it provides a level of comfort and familiarity. Something unfamiliar, which they have been conditioned for years to accept as an imitator, is daunting.

ALL IN took the eclectic Independent product and dressed it up ready for its debutante ball. The grand production was the impetus behind AEW and its imminent expansion into network television. It was a masterstroke, really: Cody and the Young Bucks transformed buzz into big, visualising on behalf of money players an alternative to WWE. The same could be true of the wrestling fan, provided it looks significantly bigger than ROH or the TNA of old. Talent jumped to that organisation, but their fans did not. The LOLTNA stigma did not help, nor did the small-time look of the Impact Zone. It felt to fans like a downgrade.

A massive, vibrant stage is needed; otherwise, it will all look a bit niche, a bit hipster - and this dreaded tag is as alienating to certain, defensive fans...

9. Don't Go ALL IN On The 'Alternative Strategy'

As if trying to hide the elephant in the room - a papier-mâché elephant pulped from Tony Khan's billions - Cody had initially presented AEW as an upstart babyface territory.

Advertisement

He didn't wish to compete with WWE, merely to provide an alternative. Whether it's mixed messaging, or an intensified campaign, or whatever, the pointed word choice of the new, trademarked slogan 'Change The Universe' exposes the strategy. This bait, the "we're going to promote tag team wrestling" campaign promise, the illusion of real pyros at the inaugural rally - it's all very much of a kind. AEW is in danger of fashioning itself not as an alternative to WWE, but anti-WWE - a promotion that makes good what WWE makes sh*t.

The problem with this strategy is that, for whatever reason, WWE fans sure love WWE - and AEW needs WWE fans to exist as a viable mainstream entity. The mere, earnest recommendation of a Kenny Omega match inspires within some of them full-on conniption fits. It's a form of brainwashing. It's a pure denial that anything else can possibly be good.

Going full WCW - which in retrospect paints WCW as a desperate joke, very much the proto-TNA - is only going to intensify a denial warped by insult.

8. Heed The Various, Hilarious Lessons Taught By Impact Wrestling

The TNA roster of 2010 reads as something quite incredible all these years later: A Kurt Angle that could still call himself a wrestling machine, AJ Styles, Bobby Lashley, Hulk Hogan, Bobby Roode, Samoa Joe, Mick Foley, Desmond Wolfe, Ric Flair, Jeff Hardy as the biggest babyface star in all of wrestling - all of whom had a major and different role to play in an alternative timeline not mapped by a bunch of past-it, self-serving f*ckwits.

Advertisement

The company itself was considered a desperate joke. The company was considered a desperate joke because:

Hardy returned, unadvertised, not as a main event star, but in an X-Division segment. An opening segment designed expressly to compete with WWE RAW as the opening shot of the New Monday Night Wars. An opening segment designed expressly to compete with WWE RAW that drew loud "This is bullsh*t" chants because the audience couldn't see what was actually happening. Also, Homicide got stuck up the cage.

The Nasty Boys turned up because they were Hulk Hogan's mates. A lot of things happened because Hogan held sway. Virtually everything that happened happened because Hogan held sway, including the role of Bubba The Love Sponge as interviewer.

No matter how irrelevant or unpopular, any act formerly of WWE was deified because they once appeared on WWE programming. The former Val Venis, Sean Morley, went over the beloved Christopher Daniels. AJ Styles dressed up as Ric Flair. The Nasty Boys turned up. Honestly, and this isn't snark, it's a directly analogy, to make this sort of mistake, AEW would have to draft in Adam Rose and put him over Hangman Page.

We don't think that's going to happen, but it actually did the last time a major corporation backed a wrestling promotion with a marketable roster.

7. Make House Shows Elite

TV is the key revenue stream. This isn't a matter of competing; it's a matter of survival.

Advertisement

TV is also precarious for any new production, much less pro wrestling, to which sponsors are averse. Moreover, the production costs of televised pro wrestling are so prohibitive that AEW had to change the very industry just to get on the negotiating table. TV is so precarious - this isn't WWE, the enduring pop culture cache of which means desperate TV stations will always aspire to it, no matter how desperate ratings get - that AEW must supplement that revenue stream with a live event loop.

This is a no-brainer, obviously, but the way in which AEW manages this is vital. As AEW chases the mainstream crowd, it must also massage its core, cult audience - and squeeze the maximum amount of dollar from them. The thing about devoted cult fanbases is that any threat of "selling out" is felt, emotionally, like a betrayal.

A break-up.

A short, initial loop, touring intimate venues with premium ticket prices, will make the early taste-making devotees feel special - while also preserving the body of Kenny Omega, who realistically cannot enter ***** performances on a RAW schedule.

6. Push Creative Freedom...

This is something Cody has already made very, very clear, with one eye winking at the fans, and another at the boys. That's technically a blink, but you get the idea: this siren call of creative freedom, the foundation on which pro wrestling was built before WWE brought its own house rules down on it, is intoxicating.

Advertisement

Cody is a very, very clever man: he knows that he is the living symbol of what such freedom brings. He transformed himself from New Generation-style WrestleCrap to key executive, doing in just two years what Triple H had managed in eight. Perceived as a revolutionary, his call to arms has alerted undercard chancers and disillusioned top guys alike to a promise land of change and chance.

In WWE, Neville was a Kickoff fixture punished to serve the onscreen punishment of Enzo Amore; in AEW, he will resume his wonderfully unpleasant heel act as main event foil for the Elite's over babyfaces. In WWE, Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder are an afterthought; tag team aficionados the world over can think of no more appealing a match than The Revival Vs. The Young Bucks under AEW's flattering filter. In WWE, Maxwell Jacob Friedman could only realistically hope of a very gradual NXT push on the level of a Dominik Dijakovic. Already, he's stealing scenes on the Elite as a charismatic, scheming d*ckhead.

In WWE, Dean Ambrose was a goofball. In AEW...

5. ...To A Point

Chris Jericho exposed the folly of AEW's big sales pitch just this past Sunday in a somewhat misguided attempt to tweet his own programme with Brock Lesnar.

Advertisement

That wasn't the extent of the optimism; Jericho told the Beast, inviting not a match but meme upon meme, to "lose the gut" - from which we can infer a slumped, drunken Jericho forgot what year it was. Jericho claimed he wasn't pissed - "What's your Twitter, problem?" - but those tweets disappeared quicker than Lesnar did after Royal Rumble weekend. Jericho also agreed with one fan that the Men's Rumble match probably was boring. Matching the classless manner with which WWE has reacted to AEW - principally by Repo Man-ing the sh*t out of its merch - this threatened to undermine AEW's role as the babyface in this new wrestling war.

This didn't harm the perception of All Elite Wrestling one iota - if anything, Jericho's fondness of Grey Goose adds to his marvellous, unhinged crazy old man aura - and the relentless news cycle swallowed it up the second Jericho swallowed his aspirin. Still, there's a lesson here: if AEW is to proceed with the approach, some discipline is required.

If you're going to allow a pro wrestler full rein, that wrestler might just adopt an African accent on national television.

4. Sign A Household Name

Stars still draw.

Advertisement

That they don't in WWE - in which Brock Lesnar and Ronda Rousey barely influence quarter hour ratings or, as was the case at Royal Rumble, ticket sales - is an indictment of the company-wide malaise more than an indictment of their own ability to spark a quantitative interest within the public.

The Elite helped elevate ROH's recent commercial fortunes, drawing company-record crowds in spite of arguably the worst creative period in company history. It is astonishing that ROH once was considered the ultimate benchmark of critical acclaim, but the Elite were immune to that malaise. Promoted as true stars elsewhere, that stardust rubbed off on the ailing company in a far quieter echo of Hulk Hogan's ability to jolt WCW in 1994. They were difference-makers...

...to a niche audience.

ROH fans low on Delirious' booking but high on Omega's seminal New Japan work parted with their cash, but the lapsed WWE audience (or the more casual arm of it) aren't immediately receptive to in-ring work of the highest order. Some are even irrationally put off, depending on which renowned critic is fawning of it.

ALL IN didn't need a Goldberg or a Brock Lesnar to draw a five-figure house, but arguably, that house was drawn because the show was so effectively promoted as a once-in-a-lifetime event. We're in that lifetime now; what was once framed as special is now normal.

3. Health Insurance & EMPLOYEE Benefits

Under WWE deals, everybody, from AJ Styles to Zack Ryder, is categorised as an "independent contractor" - despite being unable to pursue career opportunities outside of the WWE bubble, even those that are mutually beneficial, like the coverage WWE would have drawn by allowing CM Punk to walk Chael Sonnen to the octagon.

Advertisement

But then, 'WWE' and 'coverage' don't belong in the same breath.

Though surgeries are paid for by WWE, full employer-sponsored coverage isn't provided. This is in marked, risible contrast to office employees: those that need it the most, i.e. those who literally put their bodies on the line to finance the company, face insane premiums resulting from the profound occupational hazards that come with the job. There's no retirement plan in WWE, either; when you're out, you're out, and it doesn't matter that, for now, there's no getting out. As a matter of principle, the deals are pathetically draconian, and were in defiance of worker's rights even before WWE erupted into a billion dollar, publicly-traded conglomerate.

Iffy then, they f*cking reek now.

The AEW Vs. WWE war is a war for market share and talent alike. If AEW were to provide full coverage to its employees, they'll be selling both romance and a reality check.

2. Work Well With Others

New Japan Pro Wrestling, at New Year's Dash, flexed and prepared for life without the Elite by booking a main event angle entirely around Jay White's IWGP Heavyweight Title challenge. It wasn't scorched earth stuff, but it was all a very telling glimpse into a defiant future. We don't need the Elite, was the message sent.

Advertisement

On the evidence of the show itself, and the perilous-sounding New Beginning events, NJPW does.

It was not a particularly inspiring glimpse. With the maligned Taichi pushed suddenly to a headlining role, and a gigantic rock placed across the shoulders of top foreign star Jay White, the Elite's departure exposed New Japan's lack of depth - a problem shared by AEW in its infancy, and one compounded by the blurring grind that is episodic long-form television.

A partnership doesn't just parachute new stars into a company - the RevPro/NJPW relationship gave us the technical brilliance of Zack Sabre, Jr., the CMLL partnership Hiromu Takahashi's incredible act - it preserves the vitality of the existing roster, the static cast of which will, at some point, feel over-familiar. NXT TV is the only consistently very good episodic pro wrestling programme, and it is excellent because it is never allowed to grow stale. AEW and NJPW are better together.

Somebody tell that mad f*cker Harold Meij.

1. Go All Out To Sign Dean Ambrose

As AEW formally announced itself, and Reddit posters and content producers alike listed the names most likely to jump ship, Dean Ambrose's wasn't mentioned.

Advertisement

A former WWE Champion, perennial upper midcard fixture, and member of the Shield, Ambrose was a lifer. His zany, breezy disposition felt at odds with Jon Moxley, but memories of that incendiary character waned to an extent that they barely resembled the same person - a perception his apparent contentedness intensified. That Steve Austin podcast appearance and various reports of his lack of ambition painted a picture of a man happy to operate in and commit to a certain, limited role. As he himself made clear on Chronicle, before he attempted to work an angle creative botched to a near-hilarious degree, he just likes to "grapple". WWE provided both financial security and, with its lunatic schedule, several opportunities to do just that. The detailed update provided by Wade Keller on the PWTorch hotline, following the shocking news of his imminent departure, reads like a CV to AEW - not that they'd need to read it, exactly.

Ambrose, allegedly, has experienced creative frustration for some time. He wants freedom to express himself. He isn't burnt out. His perception of his character isn't shared by Vince McMahon ("I'm crazy"; "Zany, gotcha"). He will most likely stay in wrestling because he remains enamoured with it. This isn't just a coup in terms of Ambrose's ability. We know he can excel outside of the WWE bubble; arguably, he never even approached the buzz with which entered it.

This is a perception thing. A precedent thing, even.

Ambrose is a top WWE guy, insofar as anybody is these days. He's synonymous with the company's PG Era. More so than Chris Jericho, who hasn't felt like a WWE guy in an age, this is Lex Luger-on-Nitro stuff - an image of the wrestling world so uncanny that it can't belong to but can only change it.

Advertisement