10 Things Everybody Gets Wrong About ECW
Extremely misunderstood.
The original ECW was a blistering blend of teen angst, grunge flavour, hardcore brawling and the best of mid-90s counter culture. Paul Heyman, the mind responsible for this intoxicating assault on wrestling's status quo, was akin to a mad scientist experimenting and laughing maniacally behind the scenes.
ECW lived up to its name. It was Extreme, and it was a much-needed departure from saccharine-soaked gimmickry found elsewhere in WCW or the WWF. Read the first sentence of this paragraph again though: "ECW lived up to its name". That was true beyond the hardcore branding.
Heyman's group often doesn't get the credit it deserves, and this article is here to explain why. It's also here to temper any and all claims that ECW was a business goldmine waiting to happen. 'If only things had been different,' people say. 'If only they'd had a major TV deal,' others cry. Not so fast.
Extreme Championship Wrestling, through the good and bad, was never meant for mass consumption. It was the renegade, the rebel and quite fitting in that role. Furthermore, retrospect makes it easier to see that ECW was misunderstood...
10. ECW Was Self-Sufficient
Common thinking would claim that ECW existed approximately one million miles outside the child-friendly limitations imposed on both the WWF and WCW in the '90s. ECW was everything those groups weren't. Brash, unapologetically violent and "damn proud of it" (as Paul Heyman would remark), it was a true alternative.
It was also being kept afloat by Vince McMahon's millions.
Back then, people could be forgiven for thinking ECW was a self-sufficient beast that could survive without the bigger companies. That's not true. Thanks to podcasts from Bruce Prichard, Jim Ross and others, it's become clear that Paul Heyman's organisation relied on financial support from McMahon's WWF to stay in business.
Stripped of those kickbacks, there's a chance ECW would've been dead before it produced pay-per-view or hit national television. No, Heyman's league wasn't self-sufficient. He happily took McMahon's cash to maintain his dream of writing a product to be proud of.
9. It Could've Been Number Two
Here's another typical thought back in the mid-to-late-90s.
Had it not been for Ted Turner's backing, WCW would've been ousted from the major promotion picture and ECW would've supplanted it as the number two promotion in the land. Then, hardcore fans reasoned, Heyman could've focused on tearing down the corporate juggernaut that was Vince McMahon's WWF.
Bullsh*t. As already established, ECW relied upon financial support of its own from a company so many fanatics despised. Plus, who could say with any guarantee that ECW would outright replace WCW had Turner's operation ceased in the '90s? Where's the evidence to back that up? There isn't any, and saying it might've happened by default is flimsy.
ECW was a niche product. It was one with potential, granted, but to say it'd automatically take WCW's place is foolish. WCW, for all its own faults, had an audience who genuinely enjoyed following that company. It's far-fetched to claim they'd become ECW fans overnight had WCW disappeared.
8. ECW Made Paul Heyman
Paul Heyman became a grizzled, overworked pariah of the major leagues who built ECW's extreme philosophy brick by bloody brick. He was everything the fat cats tried to squash, the narrative screamed, and he was your pro wrestling promoter. Part of that is true (Heyman did have everyman qualities), but he had a career pre-ECW too.
Before putting all his eggs in one basket and going the promoter route, Heyman was slick-suit-wearing, fast-talking, cellphone-toting heel manager Paul E. Dangerously, and he was damn good at it. Indeed, any WWF devotees who ignore anything NWA/WCW are doing themselves a disservice by not checking out some of Paul E's work.
ECW didn't make Paul Heyman; he was somebody before it.
The old managerial qualities of before have popped up in the modern era since Heyman returned to WWE in 2012. He's that slimy agent again, albeit older and less likely to take mullet-shaking bumps. Honestly, as a manager, Paul was one of the best.
7. The Crowds Kicked Off Fan Rebellion
Watch pretty much any wrestling show these days and you'll see at least a pocket of fans acting like high school jocks after a keg of beer. They'll boo the babyfaces, cheer the heels, reject any attempts at storytelling and display a cynical need to let WWE know they suck. The era of audience smart-assery has evolved to a whole new level.
Some might point to the antics of those old ECW crowds and blame them for this. After all, they did chant thinks like, "You F*cked Up" with glee when performers made mistakes, and they were partial to the odd "That Was Sh*t" chant when the violence wasn't up to par. Also, who could forget the delightful, "She's A Crackwhore" singalong?
The argument falls down when realising that ECW's core fanbase actually enjoyed what they were seeing for the most part, and they were encouraged to partake. The wrestlers were in on it, Heyman booked a style that catered to their tastes and everyone had fun. There weren't many people going to ECW shows only to stage a dummy-spitting protest.
ECW crowds were part of the magic rather than working against it.
6. Barely Legal Was A Classic
Barely Legal was ECW's first foray into the pay-per-view marketplace. Listen to any militant fan of the promotion and they'll wax lyrical about how it was the show that medium needed. Chip away any partisan bias though and it's obvious that the 1997 debut was never going to live up to the hype.
Sorry, folks, but Barely Legal is a tough watch 22 years on.
The production quality was poor throughout, certainly paling in comparison to the top-notch camera work, graphics suites and sheen of the time in WCW and the WWF. Further, some of the matches were (and still are) a colossal disappointment. Taz vs. Sabu, Shane Douglas vs. Pitbull #2 and the main event Three Way Dance remain a big letdown bell-to-bell.
Barely Legal was a tentative step into pay-per-view rather than that hammer to the face ECW sorely needed after all the promotion. Any casual WWF fans lured into buying the show after seeing Vince McMahon talk it up on Raw would've left with a bad taste in their mouths.
5. Paul Heyman Constantly Worked The Boys
That Paul Heyman, eh? What's he like? Somehow, the silver-tongued devil was able to convince men and women to put their bodies on the line night in and night out for years without coming through with money that'd make the pain worth it. Cheques bounced and Heyman worked the boys constantly.
Except he didn't, not really.
Sure, nobody can claim with any sincerity that Heyman didn't know how to talk his way out of a tricky situation, but how is that any different to Vince McMahon or any other number of promoters? Paul didn't force his roster to do anything. They, whether duped by fancy 'rah-rah' speeches or not, did it willingly.
Make no mistake about it: everyone was in on ECW's rags-to-riches story, and they all wanted to prove they were the best locker room in the business. Heyman may have told some porkies to get through another business day, but it's hard to believe he could make anyone do anything they didn't actually want to.
4. Joey Styles Worked Best Alone
When he was asked to be, Joey Styles was a one-man tour de force behind the commentary desk. His voice is synonymous with the original ECW, and with good reason. Phrases like his exaggerated "Oh My God" have become legendary thanks to his stunning passion for the product and unparalleled ability to work solo.
Was he strictly better on his own however? Hmm. Perhaps not.
Partners like Joel "known as your daddy in 50 states" Gertner and Cyrus (The Virus) were marvellous complements to Joey's strait-laced personality in the booth, especially towards the end of ECW's run. With Gertner, Styles had someone he could get along with. With Cyrus, there was a bit of that old Gorilla Monsoon and Bobby Heenan argumentative couple dynamic.
Ignoring the work Joey did with a commentary partner is dismissive of how brilliant those other announcers were at enhancing Styles' relationship with the viewer. Besides, it sounded like Joey was having more fun with a colour man there to wind him up.
3. ECW On TNN Failed
There's no doubt that landing a national television slot was huge for ECW. When news spread that the company would produce a weekly one-hour show on TNN starting in August 1999, fans rejoiced. Finally, their beloved promotion wouldn't have to rely on syndication, and it'd have a platform countrywide.
It's just a shame that TNN never seemed arsed about pushing their new acquisition.
This, along with the fact ECW On TNN only ran for a year or so, has led to people believing the show was a complete failure. Newsflash: it wasn't. The only ones to blame here are TNN. They were the ones who refused to promote Paul Heyman's product despite solid ratings, and they were the ones who weirdly pressured him into changing aspects of it.
TNN obviously didn't do their homework before agreeing the deal. Had they done some research, they would've known that ECW was an untamable beast that needed to be wild. That, ladies and gents, was kinda' the entire point of the thing.
2. "Hide The Negatives, Accentuate The Positives"
The sub-heading to this entry has long been considered a key part of Heyman's game plan. If a promoter can mask shortcomings and tart up strengths, then talent will theoretically swim rather than sink in front of the audience. It's a sound plan, and one that Heyman has been called a master of, but it wasn't always true of his ECW roster.
Take Raven, for example. He was the kind of talent that could wrestle, brawl, talk and was smart enough to work on the fly when sensing the crowd wanted something different. He definitely wasn't someone who needed booking that'd hide his limitations. Raven, especially in ECW, was a world class worker.
This "Hide weaknesses, accentuate positives" (sometimes said the other way round) mantra has become phoney law when fans revisit ECW's glory days. It shouldn't be taken as gospel for everyone who was on the roster - only some who actually needed to cover up their deficiencies.
Raven, Mick Foley and Rob Van Dam were all great without need for that heralded blanket booking style.
1. They Only Did Hardcore
Typically, the original ECW is called a 'hardcore' or 'blood n' guts' company that leaned on weapon-laced brawling and grisly blade jobs to get by. Whilst that did play a big role in ECW's appeal, it wasn't the only thing they had going for them. There was some seriously good wrestling on those cards.
For proof, check out the series of stunners Rob Van Dam and Jerry Lynn worked between 1999-2001. Then, there were those lightning-fast sequences worked by Tajiri, Super Crazy and Little Guido that helped build the template for modern independent wrestling. Others, like Lance Storm and the forgotten EZ Money often worked without shortcuts too.
ECW wasn't "only" a hardcore promotion. It was a variety show of Attitude era-like chain wrestling, Cruiserweight action, brawling, attractive women and gratuitous violence before Attitude was even part of WWE's lexicon. Heyman's product was ahead of the curve by years, and it deserves more credit for its diversity of styles than it gets.
Blood and brawling was only part of the brand's output.
-
What else do you think people get wrong about the original ECW? Let us know down in the comments section below!