10 Things Everyone Gets Wrong About WWE's Attitude Era

Exposing the flawed reality of WWE's most successful period.

By Andy H Murray /

The WWE product has never been as hot as it was during the Attitude Era.

Advertisement

The period saved the company from perishing in the Monday Night Wars, helped Vince McMahon drive every major competitor out of business, and created some of the most memorable angles in wrestling history. WWE were absolutely flying from a business standpoint, too, drawing an average TV rating of 6.00 from 1999 to 2000, and generating historically high profits in '98 and '99.

It is the most talked about, celebrated, and glorified period in wrestling history. Its biggest fans yearn for a return to its edgier programming, and its critics decry it as the worst thing to ever happen to the sport. As usual, the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

Attitude was a grand success in a lot of ways, but harmed wrestling in others. It's a divisive subject that provokes immense hyperbole and selective arguments from both sides, but particularly the eulogisers. The period has been romanticised to ridiculous degrees, and while Attitude was the most exciting thing on the planet for a long, long time, there's plenty of bad to go with the good, and this must be recognised.

10. Championships Meant Much More

There's a lot to be said for the shameful way WWE have treated their championships over recent years (particularly their supposed 'top prize,' the WWE Title, which has now sat on a career-long enhancement talent's shoulder for five months), but holding the Attitude Era up as a bastion of prestige is disingenuous.

Advertisement

The period's title reigns rarely surpassed two months, and countless pay-per-view main events were sullied by interference and other shenanigans. Yes, we got stars like The Rock and Steve Austin at the top, but the former's longest reign lasted just 119 days, and the latter's lengthiest came during his awful post-WrestleMania X-7 heel period. The belt was hot-potato'd like crazy, too, with sub 30-day reigns commonplace, and let's not forget Vince McMahon's title win either.

Things were even worse on the midcard. The Tag Team Titles became hot at the turn of the century, when duos like the Hardys, Edge & Christian, and Dudley Boyz were running wild, but had little worth prior to that. The European Championship became worthless the moment X-Pac and Shane McMahon got their grubby paws on it. The Hardcore Title? Please...

Perhaps the prizes were put on a higher pedestal than they are today, but let's not pretend Attitude's belts weren't booked like knickknacks.

9. Attitude Had Stronger Stables

Attitude is often held up as a golden period for wrestling stables, and on a surface level, it's easy to see why. D-Generation X are one of the most memorable groups in the sport's history, and hugely important contributors to the era's loud, abrasive style. The Corporation, meanwhile, were the ultimate authority stable, and The Ministry of Darkness, for all their flaws, remain cult favourites among Attitude's eulogisers.

Advertisement

The more you look at it, the more the argument falls apart. Any positive traits the Corporation and Ministry carried were washed away by the horrendous Higher Power angle, and DX often strayed into irredeemably childish territory. WWE's brief 'Gang Wars' era spawned horrendous groups like Los Boricuas and The Truth Commission. The Oddities are rightly considered among the worst stables the sport has ever seen. The Mean Street Posse? Kai En Tai? X-Factor? Forget about it.

DX's reputation is deserved, and while none of today's meek groups will ever rival their significance, Attitude never produced a group as exciting as The Shield, as fun as The New Day, or a heel unit as tight as Evolution. Arguments for the Union, Brood, and Right to Censor will not be entertained.

8. The Wrestling Was Infinitely Better

"Today's in-ring style is boring."

Advertisement

This is a common complaint among the PG Era's many decriers, and it's not without merit. The modern main event style is extremely repetitive, with most big matches devolving to mindless finisher kickout-fests by the end, and WWE's heavy restrictions undoubtedly curb their roster's creativity and athleticism.

Attitude's style was far looser by comparison. The era isn't short of classics, with matches like Rock vs. Austin ('Mania X-7), TLC I-III, and Triple H vs. Cactus Jack (Royal Rumble & No Way Out 2000) standing among the best in WWE history. The problem is that almost everything below the upper-midcard was woefully bad, and many of Attitude's bigger bouts were derailed by catastrophic clusterf*** booking, leaving the era's back catalogue surprisingly thin.

From Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco's 'Hardcore Evening Gown' match to the dreaded Kennel From Hell, Attitude's in-ring output was often atrocious, with undercards largely populated by dreadful plodders like Viscera, Mideon, and Ahmed Johnson. Even the likes of Curt Hawkins and Aiden English would wrestle circles around these duds.

That's not to say there aren't bad matches in 2017 (because there certainly are), but PG's quality floor is far higher than Attitude's, even if the action isn't half as visceral as it once was. Athletic standards are higher than ever before, and the sport's evolution can't be stopped.

7. It All Spawned From ECW

To deny ECW's influence on the Attitude Era would be foolish. Paul Heyman's cult promotion's extreme programming captured the zeitgeist and Vince McMahon's attention, leading to a cloudy 'working relationship' that saw WWE partly fund the ECW's operations until the bitter end. There's no denying that Vince's shift towards Attitude's edgier, adult-oriented product was inspired by ECW either, but to say WWE's most successful period was a complete ripoff (as many have done over the years) is inaccurate.

Advertisement

WWE's Hardcore division aped the trashier side of ECW's wrestling style, but Attitude's genesis had as much to do with the Mr. McMahon character as anything else, and where did that come from? WCW.

Vince's evil boss persona has become the benchmark, but Eric Bischoff did it first, and Easy E's emergence coincided with WCW's own thematic shift. While McMahon himself has stated that Attitude came from shows like Jerry Springer, it's far likelier that he felt threatened by WCW's prominence, examined what they'd done to put them in that position, and decided he could do it better.

He was right. WWE prospered, WCW sunk, and while the ECW style was certainly mirrored in certain aspects of Attitude's programming, there was more to McMahon's success than copying the Monday Night Wars' third biggest promotion.

6. The Roster Was A Lot More Stacked

It was, but only if we're arguing in terms of star power.

Advertisement

None of WWE's current top guys compare to The Rock or Steve Austin in this regard. Even Brock Lesnar and John Cena can't stand up to Attitude's biggest draws, and gulf widens after throwing the likes of prime Undertaker, Triple H, and Mick Foley into the mix. The era's main event and upper-midcard scenes were stuffed with genuine megastars, and WWE's broken star-making machine means they'll never reach this level again.

Along with charisma, this is only area in which Attitude's roster trumps today's, with the period lagging well behind in terms of athleticism, workrate, and general wrestling ability.

Yes, Attitude boasted the likes of Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle, but also The Godfather, Gangrel, The Headbangers, and countless others. The current roster isn't always booked well, but even mid-tier wrestlers like Karl Anderson, Apollo Crews, and Rusev are light-years ahead of most Attitude equivalents. AJ Styles, Cesaro, Shinsuke Nakamura? Transport any one of them back to the late '90s and they'd be the best worker on the roster - by a landslide.

Wrestling's talent pool is deeper and more diverse than ever before. The Attitude Era's was top-heavy, disjointed, and messy.

5. It Single-Handedly Put WCW Out Of Business

It certainly played a role, but it wasn't the sole deciding factor.

Advertisement

The reasons for WCW collapse are almost too numerous to list. There was the wholesale financial mismanagement that plagued Ted Turner's ownership, including the signing of countless over-the-hill stars to bloated, long-term contracts. The Starrcade '97 main event. The transfer of power to egos like Hulk Hogan and Kevin Nash. The Fingerpoke of Doom. David Arquette. The flagrant misuse of wrestlers like Steve Austin. Vince Russo. The list goes on.

Ultimately, it all boiled down to the company's inability to generate money for Turner Broadcasting, whose Chairman, Jamie Kellner, made the call to pull the plug on their programming.

The Attitude Era transformed WWE's fortunes in the Monday Night Wars. It gave them the edginess needed to compete with Turner, facilitated their most important historical feud in Austin vs. McMahon, and prompted the two most profitable years in their history (1998 & 1999). If it hadn't come around, there's a decent chance WWE wouldn't be in business today, but it wasn't quite the stake through Eric Bischoff, Ted Turner, and WCW's hearts, though ending their existence was Vince's biggest motivation.

4. Violence + Nudity = Good TV

The WWE product has never been as safe or family-friendly as it is today, and this is primarily down to its PG rating. It has washed away all of Attitude's (and to a lesser extent, Ruthless Aggression's) excesses, replacing them with a sterilised brand of wrestling that often feels watered down, but is infinitely more attractive to sponsors and younger viewers.

Advertisement

While few still activity campaign for the restoration of wanton violence and nudity to WWE programming, the idea that these things are what made Attitude feel so special persists. Frankly, this is nonsense.

Blood and violence can still enhance a story, but overindulgence is crass at best, and negligent at worst. Nobody needs to see guys like Mick Foley putting their bodies on the line for entertainment's sake anymore. Uncoordinated cage dives and unprotected headshots are an unnecessary risk, and the way PG has protected the wrestlers' bodies takes precedent over any other argument.

Sexual themes should stay in the past too. The bulk of Attitude's women were pushed on aesthetics, and forced into degrading bra and panties and strip matches to satisfy the salivating masses. It drew, and the likes of Sable were immensely popular, taste and decency are paramount.

3. The Storytelling Was Awesome

Of all the things WWE fans tend to present an over-exaggerated opinion of, the Attitude Era's creative output is near the top of the list.

Advertisement

The writers did a tremendous job of crafting a show that wanted to tune in to see every week, and the period birthed some truly awesome storylines, many of which remain among the most important in WWE history. Austin vs. McMahon, Rock vs. Austin, the big three-way tag feud: these stories deserve their lofty place in history, but they weren't the norm, and aren't representative of Attitude as a whole.

The period saw Mae Young give birth to a son, the Big Bossman crash Big Show's father's funeral, the same crooked law enforcer feed Al Snow his own dog, and the Hawk suicide angle. It was the mother lode of bad ideas. For every captivating, groundbreaking storyline, there was a smattering of unwatchable dross, and the perception that it represents the pinnacle of pro-wrestling storytelling is as warped as the stories themselves.

By all means, celebrate the legitimately great yarns that WWE spun from 1997 to 2002, but let's stop cherry-picking history. Attitude was as creatively inconsistent as any other era.

2. It Changed Wrestling For The Better

This one is true to a certain degree. Attitude helped drag WWE out of the woeful 'New Generation' era, during which the company's programming had never felt so cartoonish and outdated. If this period hadn't died, then WWE would've likely perished during the Monday Night Wars, so yes, Attitude did change wrestling for the better.

Advertisement

But only in the mid-to-late '90s.

Attitude often presented professional wrestling and its most visceral and exciting, but it pushed the sport's limits to levels that should've never been tested, and created expectations that can never be fulfilled by the modern product. How do you raise the stakes after Mick Foley crashes through a cell roof and Shane McMahon dives from the Titantron? You can't. There's nowhere also to go, and today's product has suffered greatly through these comparisons.

It's no wonder those who grew up with the Attitude Era are bored by current programming. The extremes became the norm, and while moving away from them was inevitable, doing so removed the things that made wrestling appeal to these fans in the first place. WWE chose unsustainable "shock" television to outlast WCW: they were successful, but cursed their future to unfulfillable expectations in the process.

1. It Needs To Come Back

No. No it doesn't.

Advertisement

Throwing aside all personal preferences, the idea that a returning to Attitude-style programming would cure all of WWE's modern ailments is preposterous. Doing so would appease certain sects of the fanbase, but alienate others and drive sponsors away, sending TV ratings and profit figures further into the mire.

The Attitude Era was a product of its time. It meshed perfectly with the audience's needs, wants, and expectations, making wrestling genuinely cool and edgy for the first time in decades, but society has changed. The things that made Attitude work aren't cool anymore: they're outdated at best, crude at worst, and entirely unsuited to a world that has moved on from them.

This isn't Generation X anymore. The zeitgeist is dead, the world has evolved, and so should the expectations of wrestling fans.

From a business standpoint, regurgitating these themes would present WWE as a gross, childish organisation that investors, advertisers, and other benefactors simply wouldn't want to be associated with. It just isn't worth it.

The PG Era's failings are numerous, and WWE could stand to benefit from easing off on some of their totalitarian restrictions, but they're operating in a new marketplace now. Attitude's time has come and gone, and short of leaping in a DeLorean and travelling back 20 years.

Advertisement