10 Things New Japan Does Better Than WWE

WWE vs NJPW: where does New Japan excell and where does WWE fall short?

By Matthew Dillon /

Vince McMahon’s place atop the wrestling world is as certain as death and taxes, but that doesn’t mean his product is perfect. Before the dawn of the internet a wrestling fan might have been forgiven for thinking the WWE = wrestling, wrestling = WWE, and therefore whatever they did must have been the best possible way to do it.

Advertisement

However, there are corners of the earth that McMahon has not conquered, and it is there that some incredible wrestling has flourished. New Japan stands out to most as the biggest wrestling company not called WWE, but more importantly the promotion has also reshaped the question of what is the best wrestling company. Though they are severely lacking in some facets of the wrestling game, they excel in others to the point where WWE could actually learn a thing or two.

Here are 10 things that New Japan Pro Wrestling does better than the WWE.

10. Cruiserweights

Though it might seem unfair to lambast the WWE Cruiserweight division with it still being in its infancy, this isn’t the first time that WWE has tried to create a distinct role on the card for their smaller performers. Remember the belt that unceremoniously disappeared via Hornswoggle? I hope you don’t. I really hope you don’t.

Advertisement

WWE would love us to pretend that the purple ropes we see now represent a brand new creation but there’s no fooling the internet generation. We’ve seen WWE’s past mishandling of Cruiserweights, and many of us have also encountered the stellar junior division in New Japan. With the annual ‘Best of the Super Juniors’ always managing to capture the attention of worldwide fans (see Ospreay vs Ricochet) and the IWGP Junior Heavyweight championship with lineage including Finn Bálor, Jushin Thunder Liger, and Kota Ibushi, the junior division of New Japan maintains a meaningful role in the company that I’m sure WWE would like to eventually see from their new project.

Also the Young Bucks are stupidly entertaining. 2Sweeeeeet.

9. Use Of Veterans

As evidenced by the upcoming Survivor Series main event, WWE love to roll out their past stars for their biggest occasions, be it a WrestleMania dream match or just to hype the release of their latest video game. Goldberg is just the latest addition on a list including Sting, The Undertaker, The Rock, and Triple H of household names who returned in the hopes of bringing back fans who have since become disillusioned. But does Goldberg returning really help rejuvenate the company beyond a spike in PPV buys?

Advertisement

New Japan could be considered more fortunate that their previous world champions, such as Satoshi Kojima, Hiroyoshi Tenzan, and Yuji Nagata decided to stick around in the wrestling business. However, WWE stalwarts like Kane and Big Show don’t find themselves in meaningful roles or feuds (see Nagata vs Shibata) nearly as often as New Japan’s ‘Third Generation'. Mostly that is down to their honest portrayal as grizzled vets rather than clinging to notions like Kane still being an unstoppable monster. New Japan’s old guard are there on every tour to pop the crowd, put over youngsters, and perhaps most importantly, they don’t come swanning back on occasion for a big payday and the main event spotlight.

8. Finishes To Matches

A subtle difference but one that hasn’t gone unnoticed by the good folk of wrestling subreddits.

Advertisement

John Cena has drawn the ire of ‘smart’ fans through his consistent use of the ‘five moves of doom’ to end his matches after having just received a ton of punishment. Outside of him most of WWE’s contests end with a series of finishers and reversals, reversals and finishers, but New Japan is noted for relying on a more realistic technique for match endings.

Take for instance the Naito/Omega instant classic from the end of this year’s G1. Once Omega had caught Naito with that peach of a jumping knee, he went straight for his signature move and when Naito kicked out he did not hesitate. He didn’t revel in the shock that his opponent had kicked out at two, rather he got straight back up and went for another move, and again and again until Naito stayed down. At no point did Naito look like he could get in that fiery comeback because Kenny didn’t allow him the time to do so, and when you think about it, why would he? If you have an advantage in a fight you cling on with everything you have to keep it.

Too often do we see WWE wrestlers hit their finisher then stop to consider their life choices. It takes away the urgency and desperation that you would imagine someone in a real altercation would be feeling and once you notice the difference, it’s clear which promotion has the better idea.

7. Commentary

You know if you watch football and the commentators give us the same clichéd, carbon-copy spiel each and every week, and then you watch a video compilation of Mexican commentators reacting to goals and wonder why the hell we don’t have that? I don’t speak Japanese, and I don’t need to. Watching New Japan with Japanese commentary is a delight and if you don’t believe me then just Google ‘Lariatooo!’ and see how unbelievably hyped people can get for a clothesline. It’s just sublime. Give me unintelligible excitement over Michael Cole’s feigned surprise any day of the week.

Advertisement

Plus if that doesn’t tickle your fancy, good ol’ JR often makes appearances for New Japan’s biggest events.

6. Factions

The Shield was terrific. It nearly wasn’t, with Roman Reigns being so blatantly cherished by WWE brass over his stablemates, but it ended in spectacular fashion and all three competitors gained momentum. More importantly The Shield didn’t face the grizzly end that The Nexus did...

Advertisement

Factions occupy a slightly different role in New Japan. They aren’t vehicles for development where the teammates are joined at the hip until they’re ready to swim on their own. They are loose affiliations of liked-minded personalities who band together when they need to fight a common enemy. Goto and Ishii will still go out of their way to get a title shot against CHAOS leader Okada, but when the Bullet Club or LIJ step to them or any of their comrades they come together as one.

The best thing about New Japan’s faction system is simply that it is realistic. No one goes through life in isolation and yet WWE expect us to believe that unless one of their superstars is in a tag team or stable with its own name and t-shirt, they go backstage after they wrestle and get into a cupboard and speak to nobody. WWE recently allowed Kevin Owens’ and Chris Jericho’s friendship to be displayed on RAW and it has consistently been one of the best aspects of the show each and every week, but New Japan seem to find it so much easier to allow their wrestlers to act like human beings, with allies as well as enemies, with both an individual and group identity.

5. Development

WWE are incredibly proud of their developmental system, from their 26,000 sq. foot performance centre to their touring NXT brand. However, their system also comes under a great deal of criticism. For instance, how does Samoa Joe possibly need to develop more than he already has after seventeen years in the game? Or why is Hideo Itami constantly being allowed to get injured wrestling green rookies?

Advertisement

New Japan can recognise when an indie star is ready for their main stage, and when they’re not they are recruited as ‘young lions.’ It is a strict system that insists the novices pay their dues, cleaning up after the veterans and only being allowed to wear plain black trunks until they’re ready to progress. Their system has seen a great number of triumphs from the conversion of an ex-rugby player into the monstrous Bad Luck Fale, to the babyfaced youngster who would eventually hatch into the ‘Rainmaker'. New Japan also see great value in sending their talent abroad to learn and grow, and if ever there was an example of how a wrestler can benefit from a change of scenery, just imagine if Naito had never gone to Mexico…

4. Main-Event Rivalries

Consider the greatest WWE rivalries of the past few decades. Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker put on their most amazing performances just as Shawn was leaving the business. Matt Hardy and Edge engaged in a deeply personal war that WWE managed to mould in their favour. But not since The Rock and Stone Cold have we seen two warriors captivate audiences in the most straightforward of situations: who is the top guy in the WWE?

Advertisement

Sure, they like to sell Cena/Orton to us like Randy Orton ever had a shot of usurping the top spot from ‘Big Match John', but their sprawled out, overexposed feud isn’t likely to be talked about in the years to come as landscape-defining. If you’ve ever been even remotely exposed to New Japan in recent years then you will know about Okada, and you will know about Tanahashi.

Their rivalry has dominated the IWGP Heavyweight title picture for the past few years including back-to-back Wrestle Kingdom main events, with the two most popular stars of this recent period battling to claim the moniker of ‘ACE'. It’s a simple, powerful tale of a main event stalwart fiercely struggling to hold onto his spot at the top while a young, hungry challenger does everything to take it from him and prove that he is better. When they are in the same place at the same time it truly feels like Messi and Ronaldo, Ali and Frazier.

WWE haven't managed to rediscover that special 'grab-the-brass-ring' rivalry though they may have been close with the Shield Triple Threat, and that match has already been and gone. At a Battleground no less. Bizarre.

3. Tournaments

‘All Hail King Barrett!’ I can’t forgive WWE for that, I simply can’t. They took the gavel-banging, sadistically-sneering Bad News Barrett gimmick and saddled him with a crown, a cape, and a creative death sentence all because he was unlucky enough to win the King of the Ring Tournament.

Advertisement

WWE have shown some promise recently with the CWC and Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic both being engaging and producing exciting matches, but they still have a long way to go to come close to the prestige and downright majesty that accompanies the G1 Climax and its winners over so many years. Besides the momentum that is provided to the winners, tournaments hold a much more significant role in New Japan.

You see, WWE love gimmick PPVs like Elimination Chamber, Hell in a Cell, and TLC, and during the down-time between the Royal Rumble, SummerSlam, and WrestleMania, WWE will build to these ‘hardcore’ showcases where we’ll undoubtedly see one or two wild spots. But for wrestling fans with attention spans that go beyond five seconds, building an entire month to an event where some tables might be broken and a kendo stick might appear can be wholly unfulfilling.

New Japan by contrast operate on a wrestling calendar that you can really sink your teeth into. The G1, World Tag League, and Best of the Super Juniors all take place over two or three-week tours and every match, every victory, and every defeat means something in the long run. Opportunities for breakout performances, upset losses, and storyline development are plentiful, but WWE seem content on going for spectacle over substance in their monthly exhibitions. It may be for the best because I’m not sure I can witness one more poor soul being crowned ‘King of the Ring'. It’s haunting.

2. The 'Sports' In Sports Entertainment

Kayfabe has taken such a gruesome beating since the dawn of the internet that you’d be forgiven for thinking a wrestling promotion could never promote itself as a legitimate sports company ever again. WWE gave up on that dream a long time ago and to their credit have done well navigating the ‘pulling back of the curtain', producing captivating documentaries and giving people a glimpse into the real lives of their favourite wrestlers.

Advertisement

Maybe Japan is just a very different market, but if you take a trip to the Land of the Rising Sun you’ll see that kayfabe is alive and well. The in-ring work is often stiff to the point that you can feel an acute sting on your chest just watching an Ishii chop, and most promos are cut directly to reporters post-match or at press conferences. WWE went through a bit of a press conference phase (remember that ‘Ambrose-face-down-on-the-table' meme?) but it didn’t stick, whereas the Japanese audience have bought into the legitimacy of New Japan and while they do come to be entertained, they graciously allow New Japan to continue the traditions of yesteryear.

1. Wrestling

For those of you who don’t know, Dave Meltzer is an impressively hench, unseasonably-tanned 57 year-old wizard who inhales wrestling content and exhales perfectly-objective match ratings. He is the standard bearer for wrestling fandom worldwide and his word is gospel. The ‘Meltzer 5 Star Match’ is the perennial white whale for many wrestlers in the industry, and to fans it gives an immediate starting point for anyone who wants to poke their nose out into the world beyond WWE.

Advertisement

I say ‘beyond WWE’ because according to Meltzer, WWE have only pulled off the wrestling masterpiece five times since their inception. New Japan have pulled off such a feat five times since the start of last year. Be it the authentic ‘strong style’ that New Japan is known for, their straightforward yet engaging storytelling, or simply the technical, athletic, and creative superiority of their talent both in the ring and behind the scenes, many critics are in agreement that New Japan’s brand of wrasslin’ is the best the world has to offer. If you have the time, watch some of the barn burners at this year’s G1 or Wrestle Kingdom and let yourself bask in the almighty glory of puroresu.

Advertisement