10 Things That Must Happen At WWE Super Show-Down

How do WWE avoid fans calling this supercard a "glorified house show"?

By Jack Robert /

Alrighty, gang. It's time! It's time!! It's Super Show-Down time!! What, you aren't excited? Well... okay, I see your point, but hear me out:

Advertisement

Given WWE's recent history of supercards taking place outside of an American time zone (i.e. the so-called "Greatest Royal Rumble" this past April in Saudi Arabia), the impression we as fans have is that Super Show-Down, taking place in Melbourne, Australia (and way past the bedtime of most American viewers) will be a completely inconsequential show full of so-so matches and predictable finishes. In other words: a "Glorified house show."

However, even aside from the immense hype they've put behind the main event (which we'll get to), on paper, Super Show-Down doesn't look like a bad show at all. From rematches that we know have delivered in the past to new matches that look entertaining on paper, WWE's big card for October hardly looks like the sort of throwaway exhibition Greatest Royal Rumble ultimately was.

Of course, that's all based on what the card is in paper. What ultimately matters is execution. The worst-looking cards can be great with the right execution, and vice-versa with great-looking cards. If the performers just do what they do best - and WWE make the right decisions - this show could be one for the ages.

What decisions do WWE need to make? Let's find out:

10. Asuka And Naomi Defeat The IIconics

In the first of a series of matches that feel completely perfunctory, serving only to get certain people on the card, the duo of directionless babyfaces Asuka and Naomi take on Australia's own Billie Kay and Peyton Royce.

Advertisement

We can already see how this is going to go: Peyton and Billie are going to come out, shout their canned insults at Asuka and Naomi, and then pretend that they're happy to be in Melbourne, but then say something mean about the local sports teams, or that Australia as a whole is lame or something to that effect. Then they'll have a sub-10 minute match in which Asuka and Naomi go over.

Although that result is predictable, it's still the correct one. You could make the argument that since Peyton and Billie are in their home country and they haven't had anything to do since debuting on SmackDown, they could use the rub. However, given that Asuka is still badly damaged from her feud with Carmella, and Naomi, a two-time Women's Champion, hasn't had anything to do for a year, it would be more in the company's interest to build those two back up so that they can be credible challengers to Charlotte and/or Becky Lynch.

9. John Cena Sets Up A New Long-Term Storyline

Up next on the list of "glorified house show" matches is the team of Kevin Owens and Elias against Bobby Lashley and a returning John Cena. Granted, KO and Elias are currently feuding with Lashley at the story's periphery, but this match was announced way before the fact. Thus, the main source of intrigue is the television return of John Cena. Taking time away to deal with his crumbling relationship and film a Jackie Chan movie in China, Big Match John hasn't been seen or heard from since April, save for an odd house show appearance.

Advertisement

Cena's in a weird place nowadays. Given that he's true-blue part-timer who shows up whenever, it's become difficult to predict what his trajectory is as far as opponents or storylines. While he could always be programmed with other part-timers, that's a no-go at the moment since Brock Lesnar has one foot out the door, and Triple H, The Undertaker, and Kane are all about to have a massive program that involves Shawn Michaels.

Where does that leave Cena? Who knows, but let's hope that at Super Show-Down, we get some sort of indication of what's next for the Franchise. While it's true that he'll be staying in China for a few more months, that doesn't mean WWE can't tease us with what's in store for Big Match John come Rumble season.

8. Charlotte Defeats Becky Lynch

If WWE has taught us anything valuable, it's that friendship is an anchor that you must abandon. At least that's the lesson they've taught with Charlotte and Becky Lynch's feud, as weeks after the latter turned on the former, the Lass-Kicker got a clean victory over the Queen at Hell in a Cell to win championship gold for the first time in two years. For fans of Becky Lynch, that had to have been a sweet victory.

Advertisement

However, Becky fans must have know such a high was only to last temporarily.

You see, Charlotte and Becky have an honest-to-God good, emotional, and believable feud in a company where such a thing has been a rarity for female competitors. Such a program needs to be blown off at Evolution: a PPV devoted to women's wrestling, matches, and feuds. Therefore, to keep up interest, since Becky drew first blood in the feud by winning the title on the first try, Charlotte needs to win it back at Super Show-Down.

That way, at Evolution, the match can be built up as a true test of who really deserves to be SmackDown Women's Champion.

7. Braun Strowman, Dolph Ziggler, & Drew McIntyre Defeat The Shield

While this is in theory just another "house show"-type match, this could, on paper, be a show-stealer. Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns have an undeniable chemistry, and the duos of Ambrose/Rollins and Ziggler/McIntyre are hot off the heels of one of the best tag title matches in years.

Advertisement

However, many seem sour on this match because as it's a "glorified house show," it seems like a foregone conclusion that The Shield are going to go over. Admittedly, I'm probably asking too much of WWE to have the heels go over on Saturday, but here's my rationale:

First off, from a storyline standpoint, it would make sense to make The Shield look vulnerable. They're now playing up that Ambrose may be questioning his place in the group now that Roman and Seth have won singles gold without him. Secondly, from a booking standpoint, Braun hasn't truly gotten one over on Roman since turning heel. To make the Monster Among Men look on even standing with the Universal Champion and Brock Lesnar in the build for Crown Jewel, it would benefit him to get a pin on Roman in this match.

Of course, that's my heart-brain talking. My brain-brain is envisioning Dolph eating the pin like groceries.

6. Buddy Murphy Defeats Cedric Alexander

In a true "let's just throw a bone to the Aussies" move, 205 superstar Buddy Murphy, a Melbourne native, will once again face Cedric Alexander for the Cruiserweight Championship at Super Show-Down. Editorial aside: this author was in attendance in Raleigh, North Carolina for Alexander's last defense against Murphy, and it was fantastic. Frankly, the moniker of "WWE's Best Kept Secret" is misleading for Buddy Murphy, as he's really more "WWE's Most Well-Known Great Hand That Is Stuck On A Show No One Watches." Because trust me, he belongs in a position that'd better showcase his talent.

Advertisement

Anyway, Buddy Murphy should win the Cruiserweight title in his hometown. This would be prudent, not just to throw a bone to the home crowd, but also to reinvigorate the cruiserweight division. While, at the time, it seemed right to base the post-Enzo Amore Cruiserweight division around a pure athlete like Cedric Alexander, ultimately, his straight-up babyface shtick has not endeared fans of 205 Live for very long.

With Buddy winning the title in his hometown on such a heavily promoted show, it would re-invigorate hardcore fan interest in 205 Live, and also make casual fans think, "well, I best take another look at 205 Live, since cruiserweight stuff is actually happening on the PPVs."

5. Sheamus And Cesaro Defeat The New Day

It's truly a testament to how great a group the New Day are that they've managed to stay so successful and so over for all these years. Even for long stretches without tag team gold, they've managed to keep audiences invested in their matches and promos while continuing to up their game in-ring.

Advertisement

Such a testament indicates that they don't really need to be tag champions for long stretches.

Simply put: having the New Day be long-term tag champions is always problematic for the division they're in. On RAW, when they had their record-setting title reign, their antics got incredibly old and people almost got sick of them. It was once they lost the titles and moved to SmackDown that they really began to find their career second-wind, reinventing themselves as babyfaces on the chase rather than the ones being chased.

Plus, with Sheamus and Cesaro as tag champions, that allows the division more variety, as babyface teams like the Usos and Gallows & Anderson can come out of the woodwork and back to prominence as challengers.

Maybe it won't happen in Melbourne, but it would be a cool title change for the crowd there.

4. AJ Styles Defeats Samoa Joe

Make no mistake, in his feud with AJ Styles over the WWE Championship, Samoa Joe has absolutely been on fire. Really, since the moment he debuted on SmackDown, the Samoan Submission Machine has had the room to breathe and establish himself not only as the most menacing heel in the company, but also the absolute best guy on the microphone. Every promo he delivers has that intensity, believability, and (most importantly for a heel) loathsomeness that truly embodies everything you want in a pro wrestling character.

Advertisement

So why do I think, even after the case Joe has established for himself, that AJ Styles should retain the title at Super Show-Down? Well, simply put, it's just not the right time for AJ to drop the title.

With certain people (both face and heel) on the periphery of the WWE title scene, AJ is just the right guy to keep as the guy being chased. Having been built up for the last two years as the Ace of SmackDown Live, he's the right champion for someone, be it Randy Orton, Daniel Bryan, or The Miz, to stand up against and lay claim to the throne. Having Joe become the new champion would immediately shake things up and complicate everything.

So while it's this author's hope Joe's momentum isn't wasted from this feud, a title win in Melbourne is not to be.

3. Nikki Bella Turns On Ronda Rousey

I'm going to spare you the snark in this section, because frankly, I don't want to contrive any ill will I have towards particular superstars that doesn't exist. Nikki Bella is a valuable part of WWE's branding and, anything said about her or her sister's wrestling ability aside, she is one of the most immediately recognizable and popular superstars the company has at their arsenal. Therefore, a main event between her and Ronda Rousey at the first all-women's PPV is... sigh, best for business.

Advertisement

So anyway, with all that that, Nikki Bella should totally make an inexplicable heel turn against Ronda during or after their throwaway six-woman tag team match against The Riott Squad.

I realize it's reflective of WWE's careless, lazy booking that Nikki Bella's changed from face to heel to face lord-knows how many times, but really, if Super Show-Down is to be remembered for anything, it should be for memorable angles. And what should be more memorable to a casual audience who might also be subscribed to the Bellas' highly successful YouTube channel than Nikki backing out of the tag match or kicking Ronda around a bit?

Will it impress hardcore fans? Probably not. Will it get the job done? Probably... yes? I dunno, point is: if they're gonna have this match main-event the next PPV, you might as well build to it in a significant way.

2. Daniel Bryan Defeats The Miz

WWE fans are kind of fickle and impatient. You're shocked by that stunning revelation, I'm sure.

Advertisement

If you were to ask fans a few months ago how Bryan and Miz's feud should go, many would tell you that they should have a long, drawn-out blood feud that culminates at WrestleMania. Granted, some are still saying that Bryan vs. Miz should be the WWE title match at the Show of Shows, but most are now willing to have this feud die down for a bit so that Bryan can move on to something else. And what better way for the GOAT to move onto something else than by beating The Miz to become #1 contender for the WWE Championship?

From a booking standpoint, it only makes sense to give Bryan the win in Melbourne. He jobbed to The Miz at SummerSlam, and he and wife Brie put over WWE's A-List couple at Hell in a Cell. It's time for karma to come around on Miz... for now.

Like I said, they could absolutely re-visit this feud come Rumble/WrestleMania season, but given how Bryan hasn't had so much as a sniff of the WWE Championship since coming back, fans are wanting him to move on from midcard feuds and try to reclaim his spot back atop the card.

1. Triple H Defeats The Undertaker (With A Little Help)

Many rolled their eyes when it was announced the marquee match at Super Show-Down would be The Undertaker vs. Triple H. Last competing in 2012 in their "End of an Era" Hell in a Cell match, the fact that this encounter is being billed as "Last Time Ever" reeked of laziness, and the fact that they've been putting so much promotion into this reeked of WWE stroking Triple H's ego.

Advertisement

However, once Shawn Michaels got involved, it all became abundantly clear. This isn't about Hunter, or even the Deadman. This is about the impending return of Shawn Michaels - a development that fans immediately began speculating over once HBK and 'Taker confronted each other on RAW, and has been confirmed by the likes of Dave Meltzer.

Right now, the plan is to have Shawn return in a tag match with Triple H against the Brothers of Destruction next month at the Crown Jewel event in Saudi Arabia. If that's the case, the best way to set up this match would be to have HBK give into his temptations and help Triple H finally get a win over The Undertaker.

Such shenanigans will force the two teams into combat, and who knows? Maybe we'll get HBK vs. Undertaker "No really, this is seriously the last time, pinkie promise, you guys."

Advertisement