10 Things That Would Happen If AJ Styles Becomes WWE Champion
What would the WWE universe look like with Styles on top?
TNA Icon and New Japan veteran AJ Styles almost became the WWE Champion at Payback 2016, and he'll challenge for the belt once again at Extreme Rules on May 22nd.
Can he actually win it? The idea of Styles as champion remains unlikely, especially with all the investment in the Roman Reigns project. However, WWE are continually pushing a "New Era" theme, and the continuation of the Bullet Club story (with Finn Balor seemingly set to debut soon) does give some food for thought.
What if Styles did win the big one? What would happen in WWE with AJ Styles as the Champion?
Let's take a look...
10. Heel Run
Despite the cheers of the crowd and his cult popularity, AJ Styles as WWE Champion would have to be a heel. That's the direction of the booking with The Club, they are shady bad guys who are reminiscent of the nWo.
It is possible that it will be the opposite of Reigns' duality, so Styles as Champion will be loved by the IWC section of the crowd but despised by the casual audience who are into the traditional superheroes.
As part of that, Styles would win the title by nefarious means. The Club, possibly with Finn Balor joining, could be the option WWE take to get the title off Reigns and onto The Phenomenal One. Styles would then relish in his devilish ascension to the top.
9. The Club Runs Wild
If AJ Styles gets the belt, he's going to hold it for at least a couple of months. A rematch with Reigns would be a necessity, and he could then transition to a feud with another WWE chosen one: John Cena.
This would be the opportunity for The Club to run wild nWo style. Cena would be the establishment, which they'd look to bring down. That would make Styles a heel to the main audience, and a babyface to the IWC. It would be a fun storyline, and they could even team Reigns and Cena together against The Club.
That could be a PPV main event in itself.
8. Business Won't Be Transformed
AJ Styles isn't going to transform WWE.
Business will largely remain the same if he became champion, he isn't going to be a money-maker beyond what Roman Reigns is already achieving in that spot. That's just the reality of the situation and one man can't make a difference to the WWE in the same way an Austin or Rock could nearly two decades ago.
WWE as a brand is what makes a difference and drives business as a whole.
Ratings, ticket sales, Network subs, they'd all remain there or thereabouts. While it would be nice to think that Styles really could usher in a New Era, the reality is that the majority of the WWE audience didn't know who he was prior to Royal Rumble 2016 and he still has some way to go to really make it as a top-tier star in WWE.
7. A Bray Wyatt Feud
Bray Wyatt is long overdue both a babyface turn and title shot. A heel AJ Styles as champion would be the perfect foil, with The Club and Wyatt Family clashing together and Bray taking on Styles at a PPV. It could even be the right occasion to make Wyatt champion, as he offers more of a future than the 38-year-old Styles.
But what would make more sense is to leave the belt on Styles further into the summer. There's more than a few months worth of narrative in the Styles/The Club rally against the WWE establishment.
He could have very good matches with Wyatt as a continuation of that.
6. Criticism
Pro wrestling fans love to see someone rise to the top, just so they can then tear them back down. It has always been the way in this business. The fanbase is notoriously fickle.
How long it will take to play out with Styles is debatable, but if they started putting him against the likes of Rollins, it would quickly become clear where fan loyalty is placed.
Criticism of Styles will revolve around his promo style, which is the area he looks likely to be most exposed in if placed in the champion role. Not looking or sounding like a champion could see him being viewed as a flop in the eyes of the casual audience.
The danger is, in covering his weak points, the run could feel more about The Club than it does about him. It could be a case of a Benoit-esque title run, where the wrestler is respected, but doesn't really fit the bill of the champion.
Fans quickly lost interest in Benoit in 2004, and the same could happen to Styles in 2016.
5. Bad Booking
WWE have a track record of not knowing what to do when they make smaller/unlikely champions. Guerrero, Benoit, Mysterio, Bryan and many others have found that they didn't have the proper creative to support their championship reign. The result was that they floundered in the role and their reigns were viewed as disappointments.
Styles could expect the same problems as champion. He isn't a Vince McMahon guy and that could show in the booking. They could make him champion, but without ever really believing in him. The result? He never really gets over in the spot, and fans are subjected to weeks of lame and contrived storytelling.
4. Roman Reigns Is Damaged
If WWE were to have Roman Reigns losing the championship to AJ Styles, it would seriously damage the Big Dog's hopes of establishing himself as the franchise guy.
It obviously wouldn't be clean, and it would maybe leave Reigns open for other big matches outside the title scene, but nevertheless it would be a sign of failure to relieve him of the belt at this juncture. Especially after the flip flopping of 2015.
Now is the time to give him a lengthy run, at least giving him the chance to succeed or fail in the spot. If he is to drop the belt so soon again, it wouldn't say much for his franchise credentials. But that could be the way WWE go, maybe they think the freshness of Styles is right for right now.
3. Styles Elevated
No doubt about it, even if the run isn't a roaring success, Styles will be significantly elevated by the WWE Championship.
He'll be an upper midcard to main event talent for the remainder of his time in WWE, featuring even more across the franchising and product placements. Fans will see him differently, as a championship to his name transforms the perception. In the grand scheme of things, AJ Styles: WWE Champion is a legacy.
The question WWE have to ask themselves is will it be worth it to elevate a guy who is nearly forty-years-old? Can they get sufficient value back on that investment? Some would say there's nothing to lose and Styles will give a short-term lift, others would argue that WWE need to be investing in younger talent.
2. Jobbed Before The Autumn
If Styles does get the belt, his run will be over around SummerSlam. It could be a little bit before, a little bit after, but around three to fourth months makes sense.
Thats the right amount of time to have this run mean something, but it isn't so long that it will distract from the bigger picture. Putting the title on Styles is one thing, but putting it on for a long time is a whole other matter. Vince McMahons priorities are likely to remain Roman Reigns, John Cena, Seth Rollins, Brock Lesnar and the more established main event stars. Styles would be more like an experiment as champion, much in the same way that Guerrero or Benoit were.
Just like in 2004, it is something for the short-term, with WWE likely to remain focused on the same names in the title picture for the longer term. Eventually losing the belt back to Reigns, or the returning Cena/Rollins/Lesnar would be the ultimate fate of Styles as WWE World Heavyweight Champion.
1. A New Era?
As part of Styles push, WWE keep going on about a 'New Era', and thats why they may be about to put the title on him, as a way of impressing upon fans that the business is entering a new period.
But will his reign actually usher in a new era? No. It is pure gimmick, you can tell that from the way commentary keep on parroting new era on Raw.
Styles may very well get the belt as part of that gimmick, but it isnt like Steve Austin in 1998, or even Lesnar in 2002 or Cena in 2005. Styles and the new era is just a storyline. He could very well be getting the strap, but dont expect much more out of it than what it is worth.