10 Things We Learned From WWE's Mae Young Classic First Round
A bumpy start, but one that bodes well for the upcoming rounds.
The Mae Young Classic is finally here.
Having filmed most of the competition in July, WWE uploaded the first four episodes of their long-awaited women's tournament to the Network yesterday afternoon, giving fans the chance to binge-watch the entire opening round as 32 initial competitors were whittled down to 16.
While not as consistent as last year's Cruiserweight Classic, the MYC wasn't short of highlights. Kairi Sane vs. Tessa Blanchard has garnered most of the hype, but each night had at least one standout match to compensate for the regular dips in quality, and the likes of Sane, Shayna Baszler, and Toni Storm came off like genuine superstars.
There were many ups and downs across these four episodes, but it's important to remember that the preliminary stages are more about familiarisation and getting the major players over than anything else. Match quality will naturally improve now that the lesser workers have been eliminated, and while these four shows showed plenty of promise, the best is yet to come.
If the first round is anything to go by, the Mae Young Classic is shaping up to be another highly enjoyable WWE tournament. Here's what we've learned so far...
10. Serena Deeb Has Still Got It
Serena Deeb returned to a WWE ring for the first time in seven years on the Mae Young Classic's inaugural episode, defeating Vanessa Borne in just over six minutes. It wasn't one of the round's most eye-catching bouts, but it was an enjoyable clash regardless, with Deeb doing the bulk of the heavy lifting.
The former Straight Edge Society member did extremely well to guide the inexperienced Borne (whose career only encompasses 25 matches) through the contest. Her veteran savvy shone throughout, and while Vanessa demonstrated good confidence, she was a clear step or two behind her opponent. Nonetheless, Serena did everything in her power to enhance Borne despite the loss, and she did a good job.
Deeb only wrestled a handful of matches during her previous run with the company, but she definitely hasn't lost a step. This was her first bout in two years, and at just 31 years old, there's clear potential for another WWE spell. It'll be interesting to see how she fares against a more experienced opponent in Piper Niven during the secound round, but Serena clearly still has something to offer.
9. Abbey Laith Needs A Bigger Role (And Jazzy Gabert Needs A Contract)
Abbey Laith and Jazzy Gabert tore it up in the first episode's main event, turning Full Sail University into a cavern of noise with their fast-paced, hard-hitting slugfest.
It started with a seemingly overmatched Laith blitzing the larger Gabert, but she was quickly cut off, with Jazzy throwing Abbey around the ring with the greatest of ease. In the end, Gabert kicked out of a spectacular senton, then laid waste to Laith with some nasty ground and pound, but soon found herself rolled into a cradle for the three count, making this the night's biggest upset.
Both competitors looked excellent, and the bout asks the question of why Laith hasn't featured more prominently in NXT. The former Kimber Lee has been under WWE contract since January, but has competed in just three televised bouts, one of which was a battle royal. Here's hoping this performance earns her a bigger push in the post-Asuka landscape.
Gabert, meanwhile, is a completely unique performer who connected with the Full Sail crowd immediately. Her MMA/power-based hybrid style stood out as strongly as her imposing look, and she should be one of the first people WWE a extend contract offer to after the tourney.
8. JR And Lita Aren't A Great Team
Some of the biggest complaints to emerge from the Mae Young Classic's first round revolve around the commentary, and sadly, they're entirely justified.
Jim Ross is perhaps the greatest wrestling announcer of all time, and a sacred cow to many, but his best days are long behind him. While his voice still brings a sense of importance to everything he commentates, his increasingly robotic delivery means it often feels like he's reading from a script, and he really struggles with conveying emotion these days. A shame, but nobody escapes the passage of time, even WWE's most iconic play-by-play man.
Lita struggled greatly herself. The former WWE Women's Champion was enthusiastic, and sounded more confident than she usually does on pay-per-view Kickoff Shows, but she had little chemistry with JR, and was noticeably slow to react as the action unfolded.
There has been speculation that the duo were made to re-record most of their work as WWE weren't happy with the initial takes. If true, we shouldn't expect to see this combination again. Pairing a universally beloved legend with a genuine women's wrestling pioneer was a nice idea, but it didn't work.
7. The Talent Pool Isn't As Deep As The Cruiserweight Classic
The MYC should be allowed to fail or succeed on its own merit, but some comparisons with the Cruiserweight Classic are inevitable. The two competitions have been presented in a near identical format, after all, and while the MYC outdid its predecessor in a couple of ways, it lagged behind in others.
The talent pool's depth is the most notable example. While the tournament is unquestionably populated by some of the most exciting women's wrestlers on the planet, there were a few duds too. This was best exhibited in Rachael Evers vs. Marti Belle - an uncoordinated, sloppy bout in which neither wrestler looked convincing - but continued across all four shows, with several of the tourney's more experienced grapplers tasked with carrying unseasoned opposition.
It's not a huge issue, as most of the lesser workers have now been eliminated, but it was noticeable throughout. Contrast this with the CWC, when even relative unknowns like Raul Mendoza and Alejandro Saez were able to stand out, and the Mae Young Classic is found wanting. That's not to say there weren't duds in the Cruiserweight tourney's early stages (see: HoHo Lun), but the MYC just wasn't as consistent.
6. Diversity Is Key
Despite the talent pool's noticeable inconsistencies, the Mae Young Classic's impressive diversity cannot be denied. WWE have packed this tournament with a wide array of different styles and personalities, and while a couple of the more interesting wrestlers were eliminated in round one, the company deserve commendation.
Shayna Baszler, Zeda, and Jazzy Gabert all work with heavy MMA influences, but utilise them in completely different ways. Dakota Kai shone through expert selling, and her Bayley-esque ability to get the Full Sail crowd behind her. Toni Storm is a master technician. Piper Niven works with a quickness that belies her powerful moveset. The list goes on.
While many of the competition's less experienced participants are still finding their feet as wrestlers, the likes of Lacey Evans and Zeda showed more than enough personality to compensate. Many wrestlers stood out, with the pre-match video packages shedding light on potentially unfamiliar characters, and while a few of the matches could've benefited from a longer runtime, most were lengthy enough for each participant to get their styles over.
The first four episodes were a complete success in showcasing the full breadth of women's wrestling in 2017, and this should continue throughout the later rounds.
5. Kay Lee Ray Was Eliminated Too Early
Disappointing early eliminations are inevitable in competitions like this. WWE can't just stack the first round with predictably one-sided bouts, and must present at least a couple of early matches between two well-known wrestlers, both of whom could conceiably win. They did it with Johnny Gargano vs. Tommaso Ciampa in the Cruiserweight Classic, and the theme continued with multiple MYC bouts.
While it was a shame to see Jazzy Gabert and Tessa Blanchard both exit in the opening round, Kay Lee Ray is the tournament's biggest loss so far. She was defeated by Princesa Sugehit (the tourney's only Mexican participant) in the competition's very first match, and while both looked impressive, KLR felt like the bigger star of the two.
Ray is one of Europe's most exciting women's wrestlers, and among the best workers in the tournament. Though primarily billed as a high-flying daredevil, she showed off her technical side against Sugehit, but was ultimately forced to tap to an armbar. Her opponent will no doubt impress in her second round bout with Mercedes Martinez, but KLR is someone who could've easily gone as far as the semi-finals, and it's a shame we won't see another singles match from her.
4. Full Sail Can Still Be A Hot Crowd
WWE's Full Sail University crowds have come in for plenty of criticism over the past few years. Often derided for what many perceive as an overwhelming desire to get themselves over, they used to be defined by their boisterous smarkiness, but have now done a full 180, with recent NXT tapings creating deathly quiet atmospheres closer to a library than a wrestling show.
There were fears that the Mae Young Classic would go the same way, with the matches playing out to polite ripples of applause rather than the vociferous roars of old. Fortunately, this wasn't the case, and Full Sail was in fine form throughout.
The crowd were noisier than they've been in months, and their passion helped elevate several bouts to the next level. More importantly, there was no self-promotion, no "we are awesome" chants, and no hijacking the show. They didn't try to take over, and the shows benefited immensely as a result.
Both sides of this debate tend to go a little too far (particularly those who'd actively police how live crowds conduct themselves), but this sounded like a great atmosphere on tape, and was probably even more impressive in person.
3. Shayna Baszler Could Be Asuka's Natural Heir
Though the segment is yet to air on NXT TV, Asuka's departure from WWE's developmental brand was confirmed last week. After 510 days as NXT Women's Champion (and a two-year undefeated streak), 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' is heading to the main roster, leaving a massive hole at the top of the pecking order.
Fortunately, WWE may already have the answer in Shayna Baszler.
A genuine women's MMA pioneer, Baszler has only been wrestling for two years, but you'd never tell from watching her. Trained by former UFC Heavyweight Champion Josh Barnett, her work naturally revolves around MMA-esque holds, strikes, and transitions, and while Baszler made short work of her first round opponent, she stood out more than most.
Shayna and Asuka have clear stylistic differences, but both carry an aura of intimidation. Baszler's comes from her legitimacy as a mixed martial artist, the way she carries herself, and her no nonsense promo style. Oh yeah, and she just so happens to be one of Ronda Rousey's closest friends.
She might be 37 years old, but WWE would be wise to sign Shayna immediately: she's a natural, and if the company book her correctly, there's no reason she can't dominate NXT.
2. Kairi Sane Is Already A Massive Star
Though Shayna Baszler emerged from the opening rounds look like the Mae Young Classic's most legitimate badass, Kairi Sane felt like the biggest star.
A much hyped signing from Japan's Stardom promotion, Sane lived up to her reputation, delivering a great bout with Tessa Blanchard in the fourth episode's main event. Both looked excellent, and the crowd were enraptured without, though they were more excited for Sane than here opponent. Kairi's entrance got a great pop, her spectacular elbow drop was over before she'd even hit it, and Full Sail came unglued when she finally executed the move, putting Blanchard away in just under nine minutes.
While Sane's quality was already well known prior to the tournament, this showing will have served as a massive wake up call to many. She's one of the best in the world, WWE are lucky to have her, and there's nothing stopping her from becoming NXT's next big babyface.
It's a shame Asuka's Women's Title reign ended the way it did, because Sane would've been the ideal candidate to topple her undefeated streak. We'll never get to see that moment, but regardless, Kairi is already a huge star, and the first round only solidified her position as the pre-tournament favourite.
1. The Future Is In Good Hands
While 205 Live's failings show that WWE's women probably don't need their own weekly brand at the moment, the Mae Young Classic's early offerings proved that there's more than enough talent to keep the division well stocked for at least the next four or five years.
Kairi Sane, Mia Yim, and Toni Storm wouldn't look out of place if they arrived on the main roster next week. Shayna Baszler, Candice LeRae, Dakota Kai, and countless others are already streets ahead of most NXT competitors. Performance Center athletes like Zeda and Lacey Evans are are works in progress, but should become stalwarts if their in-ring performances catch up with their character work.
Sure, there were some less than impressive performances on these shows, but at least half of the unsigned competitors are good enough for a full-time role. If WWE follow the CWC blueprint, many of them will ink contracts once the tournament concludes, and the company will be flooded with fresh, exciting talent. There's not enough room for them all to debut at once, but there are more than enough good workers here to not only jolt the stuttering Women's Revolution back to life, but take it to a whole new level.