10 Things WWE Actually Got Right In 2019
Because even a stopped clock could book Survivor Series with a roster this stacked.
It’s easy to be critical. It’s especially easy if you want to criticise WWE in 2019. It is, after all, a company run by a mad, old billionaire (who ought to be a trillionaire), who ignores his product’s own fans but sucks up, biannually, to a morally decrepit Saudi Arabian political regime.
A company that won’t provide their “independent contractors” with insurance, pay for their travel or, until very recently, allow them to leave - but will endanger said “independent contractors” by leaving them stranded in Saudi Arabia under mysterious circumstances after a dispute with the aforementioned morally bankrupt regime.
A company that responded to big league competition by getting worse, that ruined The Fiend and Seth Rollins in one match, that instigated the godforsaken Wildcard Rule!
So yes, it’s easy to criticise but it’s also easy to overlook the things WWE have actually got right this year. This being WWE, this list comes with a fair amount of caveats but Christmas is a time for forgiveness, so let’s take a deep dive into some of WWE’s best decisions of 2019.
10. New Stages
Both SmackDown and Raw had long been in need of freshening up, having looked the same, and interchangeable with each other, for years now (minus the colour, obviously).
Change was all the more necessary with the arrival of AEW and the gorgeous, futuristic looking duel portals Jon Moxley is apparently so scared of.
This autumn’s, “season premieres,” with SmackDown in a new home and time slot and Raw, well, rolling on but in a, “season premiere,” way, was the perfect opportunity to introduce a new look and WWE’s production teams seized it.
Both Raw’s skate ramp and SmackDown’s giant brackets looked beautiful and were further enhanced by the re-introduction of pyro. It’s good, you know, pyro. Fans probably should have been calling for it for years.
Of course, a wrestling show stands and falls not on the splendour of its set but the strength of the show it presents on that set. Unsurprisingly then, these new sets didn’t usher in a new era of critical acclaim and massive ratings. Still, WWE’s television product briefly looked and felt like the big deal it purports itself to be.
9. AJ Styles’ Heel Turn
So far, WWE seem to be handling Seth Rollins’ heel turn pretty well but we can’t give them too much credit because, A) we need to wait and see how it pans out and, B) WWE didn’t make the turn until the decision was basically forced upon them.
They can however, take some credit for AJ making a similar switch this year. Having made his name elsewhere there were those who felt AJ would never top McMahon’s tree, with Vince preferring to back his own, home grown stars. So it was good to see ‘The Face That Runs The Place’ earn an extended run with the company’s top title. That said, as the company’s top face, AJ could be a touch on the bland side.
With his career slowly winding down as he moves to a lighter schedule, his new role as an upper mid-card heel is perfect for him. While not as natural on the mic as some of his peers he still makes for an amusing d*ckhead.
Plus he’s got enough credibility to absorb losses and retain his aura. He was a great choice to rock up on NXT shouting the odds and he could be the perfect gatekeeper to the main event scene. WWE haven’t always used him that way but that’s another story entirely.
8. Bringing Back King Of The Ring
Watching Baron Corbin swagger around with a sceptre, smugly delivering mediocre promos and eating up TV time to the amusement of no one, it’s tempting to think that bringing back King Of The Ring was a drastic misstep.
Let’s not forget however, WWE have long since pushed the limits of fans’ tolerance for ‘The Lone Wolf’. The company even directly blamed him for poor TV ratings last year. Still they kept him hanging around the main event scene. There’s no reason to think Corbin’s push would’ve ended, with or without the tournament. He’s just the same irritant he ever was.
What King Of The Ring did do was provide a bunch of mid-card guys with a bit of actual storyline motivation, something to fight for and several weeks of quality TV matches. It even brought the best out of King Corbin himself, demonstrating a new vicious streak instead of just settling in for a nice long rest hold.
Besides, he was the best choice to win. Chad Gable is the better wrestler but none us wants to see him forced to walk around with a crown on. Corbin can take a cheesy gimmick because he isn’t credible anyway.
7. Handling Tommaso Ciampa’s Injury
The neck injury to NXT’s top heel and title holder Tommaso Ciampa couldn’t have come at a worse time. We were arriving at the payoff of a years long story arc, the rivalry of Ciampa and former tag partner Johnny Gargano. Suddenly, before the pair could have their final TakeOver showdown, the world’s greatest sports entertainer was gone.
Forced to change plans, WWE made the very best of a bad, sad situation. Elevated into the main event, Adam Cole stepped up and NXT gave us potential match and feud of the year candidates with Cole and Gargano over delivering on already lofty expectations.
Meanwhile, Ciampa had been one of the company’s best and most natural heels but sacrificing his body to the cause had babyfaced him in the eyes of the fanbase.
WWE didn’t fight it. They allowed Ciampa to show up and congratulate Gargano on his eventual NXT Championship win and, when he was healthy enough to return, he came back as the badass hero fans wanted.
Since then he’s not been rushed back into the Gargano feud or a title fight with Cole. Instead, the company has done an excellent job of keeping him looking strong without sacrificing other top stars like Finn Bálor and Keith Lee.
6. Kevin Owens Banishes Shane McMahon
Sure, this was a solution to a problem very much of the company’s own making. After all, Shane McMahon is actually a very capable television performer in either the face or heel role. He’s also capable, with the help of smoke and mirrors, of pulling off entertaining matches, despite having the cardio fitness level of an arthritic badger.
The trouble is WWE, despite a stacked roster vying for screen time, allowed McMahon to dominate TV so much that fans became utterly sick of ‘The Best In The World.’ They also booked him as a guy who could hang with Roman Reigns, rather than as a weasel who gets by on short cuts, cheating and hiding behind bigger buddies. Plus he pretty much neutered The Miz’s babyface run before it began by winning on back to back pay-per-views via screwy finishes.
So when it finally happened, fans were delighted to see Shane O’Mac banished from our screens. Kevin Owens, armed with the stunner and a new man of the people persona, was the perfect guy to do it too. Of course WWE can be quick to retcon these kind of Loser Leaves Town stipulations but so far, so good, and there’s been no sign of the ageing ‘Boy Wonder’ since.
5. Seth Rollin’s WrestleMania
It’s hard to remember now, but at the time we all really wanted this. People were desperate for someone to take the Universal Title off part time champ Brock Lesnar. Despite everything there was still a lingering “anyone but Roman” sentiment in a section of the fanbase and a cautious but more generous “let’s not rush Roman back to the title picture just yet” feeling amongst the rest of us.
Meanwhile, Shield favourite and respected workhorse Rollins was a popular choice of Royal Rumble winner. Along with Kofi Kingston and Becky Lynch, ‘Monday Night Rollins’ made up a triumvirate of potential feel good, fan favourite victories at WrestleMania. Fan consensus at the time was that we wouldn’t get all three. When we did, we were delighted.
It’s not just that WWE gave Seth the victory, it was the nature of that victory and its position on the card. ‘The Beast, and ‘The Architect delivered a short, sharp shock of a match that gave the crowd a jolt of energy after the pre-show battle royals, to get the show proper off to a flying start.
4. Women Main Event WrestleMania
This one might seem so obvious that it’s hardly worth mentioning. After all, Ronda Rousey was the biggest name in the company, Becky Lynch the industry’s hottest star. Here we are praising WWE for recognising that and letting them main event a pay-per-view? Oh and well done Vince for getting up in the morning and putting your shoes on the right feet...
Thing is, what seems entirely obvious in hindsight, and seemed pretty clear then, wasn’t a move entirely without risk. In wrestling, women aren’t yet a guaranteed draw. We know that the previous year’s Evolution pay-per-view, for example, wasn’t successful enough for WWE to repeat the experiment.
WrestleMania needs to sell tickets, boost Network buy-rates and hook casual fans to keep watching. There was a chance some fans, trained for years by WWE’s own output, would still view women’s wrestling as a titillating sideshow or the toilet break spot. Now WWE were banking on women’s wrestling for their biggest show of the year.
Vince and Co. could have leaned even further into the organic success of #Kofimania to excuse themselves from the gamble but instead they backed Charlotte Flair, Rousey and Lynch and that’s to be applauded.
3. The Rey Mysterio/Brock Lesnar feud
The week of SmackDown’s Fox debut was an absolutely crucial one for WWE and for the most part they completely dropped the ball. They wanted to deliver a memorable week of television, with new sets, big matches and a flying visit from The Rock but most of that has been forgotten now, the memories washed away by a tidal wave of b*llshit at that Sunday’s Hell In A Cell pay-per-view.
That week did at least manage to deliver the start of one entertaining feud. It bridged Raw and SmackDown, scraped through Saudi Arabia and ran all the way to Survivor Series without losing steam.
Throughout we got some career best promos from Rey Mysterio, given solid motivation for revenge and cast as the kind of fiery babyface WWE sorely lacks for the most part.
The whole thing led to a typically brief but fun Brock vs. Little Guy match at Survivor Series complete with a double 619 spot. The result was a forgone conclusion but everyone involved did enough for us to buy into that Dominick assisted pin attempt.
More of this sort of thing please.
2. The Booking Of Survivor Series Weekend
An invasion angle, built across three weekly TV shows, plus a whole weekend of pay-per-view action? There were bound to be niggles, chief amongst them the otherwise well protected, massively over Walter eating the first pin of the men’s Survivor Series elimination bout.
That said, overall WWE more than delivered across Survivor Series weekend with two entertaining PPVs and the build was solid for the most part too. Some highlights include:
Kevin Owens turning up to an almighty pop as Tommaso Ciampa’s fourth man at War Games.
Adam Cole as November’s Iron Man performing out of his skin again and again. Cole/Bryan II can’t come soon enough.
Dakota Kai’s heel turn. In WWE we either get spoon fed heavily signposted story telling or else changes happen suddenly for no reason, leaving us unable to invest. Kai’s heel turn managed to actually wrong foot the audience without feeling unearned.
Rhea Ripley bouncing back from that awful “friends forever” promo to pin three of the company’s top stars in quick succession, announcing herself to main roster viewers as a dominant force and future champion.
Keith Lee transcending his place in the NXT pecking order and becoming an overnight star in front of a crowd agog at both his charisma and agility.
Why can’t every PPV be this good?
1. KofiMania
When forced to replace a performer last minute, WWE have developed a reputation for over delivering. When they booked mid-card stalwart Kofi Kingston to replace an injured Ali in a TV gauntlet match, they cannot have known the chain of events they were setting off.
Kofi of course deserves all credit for the star making performance that forced him into the main event scene and capitalising on that performance was the obvious step.
Still, WWE deserve praise for how they booked the story. Another in-ring showcase and near-win stoked fan fervour at Elimination Chamber. Then, at Fastlane, the company played into its own history of squashing organic fan favourites.
Fans at home and in the arena were furious when Kofi was demolished by The Bar and denied a title shot but WWE were right to prolong Kingston’s chase right up until WrestleMania. It provided the biggest possible audience for Kofi’s instant classic match with Daniel Bryan and gave us all an indelible WrestleMania moment.