Despite being the biggest wrestling promotion in the world, WWE has many, many flaws. While the companys top figureheads must be celebrating over their 1 million WWE Network subscribers, there are many other problems that are plaguing the company right now. Aging Superstars, irrelevant titles, questionable booking decisions, uncertainty for Superstars revenue sources, other financial problems, low pop culture relevance, and a possibly-insane Chairman are all serious problems that need to be solved. In order to deal with these issues, WWE need look no further than the #2 wrestling promotion in the world, New Japan Pro Wrestling. Since 2009 or 2010, New Japan has experienced an explosion in international popularity and relevance in the wrestling industry. In terms of draws and financial success, it was the #1 Japanese promotion throughout the 1980s and 1990s, before an internal crisis in the early 2000s nearly destroyed it. Since then, it jumped back to the top, overtaking All Japan and NOAH, both of which had enjoyed status at the top during the 2000s. These days, New Japan is lauded for having the best wrestling matches, a roster filled with interesting stars for everyone, and the genius booking of wrestlers Gedo and Jado. Because of its recent success, it would make sense for a troubled company like WWE to look to their Japanese competition and see what they did to become so popular. Here are ten lessons WWE can learn from New Japan
10. Working With The Right Publications
While not every fan reads wrestling magazines anymore, third-party print material on wrestling sometimes has a sense of legitimacy. If the right magazine or journal says something about your company, then that would help boost your companys image. New Japan, like other Japanese wrestling promotions, has to answer to Tokyo Sports, a daily sports newspaper that was founded in 1958. The magazine covers every sport including wrestling, and they have awards and recognitions for great matches, rising stars, etc. If Tokyo Sports says something positive about one of New Japans stars, that help the promotion without them having to do anything themselves. So which magazines does WWE work with? Well, WWE Magazine was discontinued in 2014, after some thirty years of operation. Other than that, the only news site that WWE appears to have any sort of working relationship with is TMZ. Thats right; someone in WWEs top brass thinks its a good idea to give the celebrity gossip organization TMZ special access to leaked info and other tidbits about WWE. Because apparently its more important to be recognized by TMZ than by Pro Wrestling Illustrated, Sports Illustrated, etc. While TMZ does benefit from media attention by providing breaking news from WWE, it doesnt make sense because TMZ focuses more on the reality side of WWE, ruining the validity of their storylines. If you were to Google search WWE and TMZ, the headlines they focus on are more about shock and scandals than about the actual WWE product. Lawsuits, firings, suspensions, deaths, Darren Young coming out (which, in hindsight, is actually historically-significant), these are the things that TMZ focuses on. You arent likely to find any kind of plug for WWEs actual shows other than weekly summaries, which doesnt really differentiate it from any other wrestling website. If WWE really wanted to make their product appear to be something cool, it might not be a good idea to associate with a media organization that has been criticized for attempting to portray people in the worst light possible.
9. Proper Merchandise Crossover And Product Placement
New Japan is owned by a Japanese corporation called Bushiroad, which specializes in trading cards and collectibles of various kinds. Any big company would use every asset it has to promote its goods to as large an audience as possible, while trying their best to not force the product down the audiences throat. So how does New Japan promote the products created by its parent company? Like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TJeX4EVd9Q For those that didnt watch the video, basically one of their biggest stars, Kazuchika Okada, makes an extra-long entrance, accompanied by an animatronic Velociraptor and carrying a large anime-inspired sword, both of which are related to Bushiroads other products and brands. While it might seem outlandish or borderline cartoony, there remains a special kind of appeal of a world champion wrestler walking down towards the ring carrying a sword and accompanied by a dinosaur. So what does WWE do to promote something? A simple 30-second plug of a companys product line by the announcers, or by wrestlers who over-sell. Its been done several times: RAW is in an intermission between matches or interviews, and the camera suddenly turns to Michael Cole and company, who have either the latest WWE toys in front of them and pretending to be excited (because every man older than 40 loves plastic childs toys), or they plug something like a sponsors food line (as seen with Jerry Lawler eating food from Sonic, despite his on-air heart attack allegedly stemming from poor diet). As for the wrestlers, DX and more recently Adam Rose have been infamous for plugging wweshop.com, and you could tell in their voices that it was shameless plugging. In some cases, it almost sounded like they were trying to say, Buy this product of ours because we said so, instead of giving them a legitimately good reason for buying it. While it certainly works in some respects, theyre still just repeating the commercials after all, instead of doing something novel like New Japan does. New Japan doesnt make the product the focus of the segment; its used carefully without taking the focus away from the wrestler, which is a philosophy that WWE should try emulating.
8. The Importance Of Outside Stars
Maybe this has something to do with WWEs restrictive liability policies, but its rare that anyone outside of indy jobbers would ever perform in a WWE ring unless they sign a long-term contract with WWE first. New Japan, on the other hand, believes in partnering with other promotions and sharing talent. Wrestle Kingdom 9, for example, featured talent from Ring of Honor, Global Force Wrestling, and several freelance wrestlers including Minoru Suzuki, who is part of the Global Professional Wrestling Alliance. Not only does this allow talent from other parts of the world to gain international exposure, but it allows fans of those foreign wrestlers to follow them to a different company, thus increasing New Japans fan base without forcing the product on them. But most importantly, when a new star comes to New Japan, they dont have to change their wrestling styles as much as they do in WWE. Meanwhile, WWE has signed many outside wrestlers like Prince Devitt (Finn Balor), KENTA (Hideo Itami), and Kevin Steen (Kevin Owens), only for them to be put through NXT and re-shaped into a WWE version of themselves. While this might be done to make them appear to be WWE creations, that simply isnt smart marketing. If youre trying to increase your fan base and diversify demographic appeal, why would you sign someone who was a big deal somewhere else, only to clip their wings and have them toil in the minor leagues, and eventually lose their original fan followings? Unless, of course, that is WWEs secret plan: to lure the top stars from the independent scene and marketable wrestlers from Japan with promises of bigger paychecks and a lighter work schedule; strip them of any unique characteristics or wrestling moves; dumb them down from their comfort zones and make them adapt to WWEs style; have them fail at it, shortening the remainder of their careers; and eventually release them, knowing that their star power has diminished? While this might be a farfetched possibility, keep in mind that Luis Ignacio Urive Alvirde was an international sensation as Mistico in Mexico, only to become the walking manifestation of Botchamania as Sin Cara in WWE. That is something that certainly wouldnt happen in New Japan.
7. Understanding Past Vs. Future
The two biggest names associated with post-Inoki New Japan are Intercontinental Champion Shinsuke Nakamura and IWGP Heavyweight Champion Hiroshi Tanahashi. Both of them have been with NJPW since the late 1990s/early 2000s, and today both of them are undeniably the two top stars of the company. Though they rival each other in terms of popularity, skill and charisma, its how they were booked that makes the biggest difference. You see, Nakamuras early career was part of Inokis failed experiment called Inokism, which blended wrestling with MMA. As such, Nakamuras style is centered on stiff strikes and MMA-oriented submission moves, which were core characteristics of NJPWs past. While these skills have certainly helped build Nakamura into a world-renowned star, that doesnt compare to what Tanahashi did. You could say that Tanahashi is very much like Eddie Guerrero in terms of wrestling style, incorporating mat techniques, chain grappling, suplexes, and lucha libre into his arsenal. Also, like Guerrero, Tanahashi exuded more charisma and had a better ability to connect with the fans. In many ways, Tanahashi represented a new way of building stars, while Nakamura, though still a great performer represented the past. This is a crucial lesson that WWE should pay attention to. Vince McMahon has a weird mentality (it cant even be described as old school, because, quite frankly, he has destroyed many wrestling traditions anyway), which is rooted in ideas and beliefs rooted in his old mindset. In other words, hes stuck in the past and doesnt think about the future. Vince still thinks that this is the 1980s, where being a big muscleman is the key to success, despite the opposite being closer to reality. You could say that guys like Cena, Reigns and Sheamus are Vinces versions of Nakamura, in that they represent the old mentality that no longer works; while guys like Bryan, Ziggler, and many of the NXT stars are like Tanahashi, in that they represent the future because they know what works now instead of what worked in the past. NJPW looked to the future and made a successful gamble on Tanahashi becoming the companys new ace. It has since paid off for them handsomely, while WWE is still following the same formula as they did in the 1980s and 1990s, failing to understand that doing the same thing over and over while expecting the same results will not grant them the same success now that it did decades ago.
6. Why Wins And Losses Matter
Something very strange started happening in late 2013 and early 2014 in WWE: there was a surge in frequency of dirty match finishes, which has since become a regular occurrence on RAW and SmackDown. Whatever happened to lengthy matches having a clear winner, without having someone else come in and ruin the match? Maybe its because NJPW treats its wrestling like a legitimate sport, or maybe its because WWEs creative team is afraid of making anyone other than Cesaro lose all the time. Either way, its an incredible annoyance for fans to invest emotionally in a match, only for someone to screw up the ending. This kind of interference is rare in NJPW, and when it happens, there is a good reason for it. For the rest of the time, however, wrestlers win and lose, which are themselves important aspects of storyline progression. Tournaments are considered to be serious matters, and the traditional story of wanting to be the best in the company is still played out without over-complicating rivalries. Even if WWE considers itself sports entertainment, its not like they cant do a better job of making wins and losses mean something for the purpose of entertaining fans. WWE seems to believe that fans have such short attention spans that theyll forget what happened three weeks ago, which is insulting. Victories and defeats matter a lot in every other sport and in many contemporary shows as well. Imagine if, for example, in Game of Thrones, Joffrey himself was fighting the protagonists 1-on-1, was always about to lose, but every time his opponent was about to end the fight, someone would interfere on Joffreys behalf, allowing him to win. Seeing this happen on a regular basis would certainly irritate or at the very least bore the fans. If WWEs top decision-makers cant grasp the simplest understanding of wins and losses like New Japan does, then maybe they need new leadership that does.
5. Using MMA Stars Properly
Brock Lesnar is widely considered to be one of, if not the biggest name in MMA, at least in North America. He has dominated UFC and garnered a lot of legitimacy as a bona fide bad ass. This, coupled with his previous history in WWE, makes Lesnar an incredible star. However, he wasnt used properly in WWE. Limited dates, boring TV confrontations that usually led to a walk-out, and jobbing out to Cena and Triple H in his first year back after being gone for 8 years all diminished his stature. It wasnt until after he ended the Undertakers Streak that people really started talking about Lesnar in a positive way again. What WWE could learn from New Japan in this regard is now to use an MMA star properly. In this case, that star is Minoru Suzuki, who is more or less the Japanese equivalent of Brock Lesnar, in more ways than one. First, Suzukis persona is that of the smack-talking, arrogant douchebag who thinks hes better than you, and hell tell that to your face. This in turn makes people hate him, because virtually everyone can relate to that experience. Secondly and more importantly, Suzuki can talk all that trash because he can back it up with enough fighting skill to snap you in half like a twig. You see, Suzuki was the co-founder of Pancrase, one of the first and most significant MMA organizations in Japan. He spent many years perfecting his fighting style, and has a considerable amount of legitimacy as a skilled fighter. His final record in MMA was 29-19. Suzuki, unlike Lesnar, is considered a regular on NJPW programming, and thus isnt deemed a special attraction by the companys top brass. While Lesnars skills make him unique in WWE, that doesnt justify having him appear very rarely, and giving him so much liberty in appearances. NJPW did the right thing with Suzuki: he appeared often and showcased his MMA-inspired badassery on a regular occasion, allowing his reputation among the NJPW faithful to grow organically, instead of relying on outside experience in another industry, which is what happened with Lesnar. WWE banked on fans knowing he was a legit fighter in UFC, instead of showcasing him frequently and booking him properly, which was very damaging to him in 2012. After the 'Inokism' catastrophe, NJPW learned from their mistakes and did things right the second time with Suzuki.
4. How To Make A Proper 'Cross-Generational Star'
John Cena, WWEs top man for over a decade, gets a lot of criticism for appealing almost exclusively to younger viewers. In fact, its something that he himself has openly admitted to and is proud of, while at the same time making fun of online critics who wish John Cena would change to cater to them instead. While Cena has certainly brought a lot of success and prosperity for WWE, he still isnt the cross-generational star that WWE would want him (or his possible replacement Roman Reigns) to be. He still lacks the ability to connect with the vocal adult male audience, which is something that New Japans top star, Hiroshi Tanahashi, does very well. Some people might be thinking that it is a stretch to say that Tanahashi is everything that WWE wishes that Cena would be. However, when one considers just how successful New Japan has become thanks to him, then that statement turns out to be very true. First, Tanahashi is widely considered to be the best wrestler alive today. He is a well-rounded athlete, capable of doing virtually everything, and has consistently been putting on Match of the Year-quality performances for years now. His wrestling ability alone is a major factor in his appeal to the diehard wrestling fans out there, who often criticize Cena for lacking this. Second, he has the look and charisma of a champion, which appeals to virtually everyone. He is considered to have massive nationwide appeal in Japan, where men, women, and children alike all find something in Tanahashi that they enjoy (maybe its the abs). This is a man who kisses babies (and they kiss him back) with no detriment to his status. If Cena did that, the WWE Universe would collectively groan in disgust. Third, and most importantly, he had to carry New Japan on his back in the mid-to-late 2000s, which helped catapult the company back into the forefront of Japanese wrestling. But he also had great matches, and wasnt booked as a Superman kind of character. This garnered him the respect of his peers and critical wrestling observers alike, while appealing to virtually all of the different segments of the NJPW audience.
3. Making Secondary Titles Matter
The last time the WWF Intercontinental Championship was truly relevant as a prestigious title was back in the late 1980s when it was held by the likes of Macho Man Randy Savage and Ricky the Dragon Steamboat. It was especially significant at WrestleMania VI, when then-Champion the Ultimate Warrior defeated Hulk Hogan for the WWF Championship. These days, WWEs titles, especially the Intercontinental title, have lost so much value that being a Champion has lost any true significance. Gone are the days where being a champion meant something important, where each champion was the best in his/her division and everyone wanted to take that belt to prove their worth. This is where New Japan succeeds, with the IWGP Intercontinental Championship. Despite being less than four years old (the belt was announced on April 11th, 2011 and the first champion, MVP, was crowned on May 15th, 2011), it has been elevated so much that it is now considered to be on par with, or of greater value than, the IWGP Heavyweight Championship, a belt almost 8 times as old. How was this done? During Shinsuke Nakamuras first two reigns, he would defend it internationally, making it seem like a real world title. This combined with Nakamuras growing star power, culminated in the belt receiving the top billing at Wrestle Kingdom 8 in 2014, New Japans biggest annual show, and was won by former IWGP World Champion Tanahashi. Thus, within the span of 3 years, a new title belt was given importance that hasnt been seen since the Savage/Steamboat days of the 1980s. If WWE wanted to elevate their titles, that is how its done. By booking long-term champions who defend their titles in regular, high-caliber matches, make the biggest stars appear to desire the belt, and feature the title more prominently on major shows. It would also make sense to defend the title on international tours and on special shows emanating from other countries (i.e. the UK), to help bring back the world in world champion. If WWE could manage that, then maybe people would actually care about title matches again.
2. Making The PPV Shows Feel Special And Not Repetitive
In todays WWE, there are only two annual PPVs that really feel special and worth watching. One is the Royal Rumble, due to the eponymous match that only takes place at this event, which is (usually) full of excitement and surprises. The other is WrestleMania, which normally features the best matches, best entrances, and the culmination of the biggest rivalries. But what about everything else? Well, most of the other monthly PPVs dont really have anything special anymore. Even Survivor Series, which has long been heralded for its traditional elimination matches, no longer feels like a major event. Part of this problem is due to repetitive matches (many of which dont feel like PPV quality anyway), and an overabundance of PPVs anyway, both of which lead to too much of the WWE, which is something that Vince McMahon doesnt believe exists. New Japan, on the other hand, makes their shows feel special by separating them. There are special events and tournaments for the top stars (G1 Climax & New Japan Cup, which are similar to the King of the Ring), the Tag Team Division (World Tag League/G1 Tag League), and cruiserweights (Best of Super Juniors). These tournaments allow New Japan to focus on specific divisions in their roster, giving everyone an opportunity to shine. In doing so, the biggest stars dont get overexposed, granting them increased longevity in the company, and less-experienced talent more opportunities to perform. This system could, in theory, work well in WWE. If there were PPVs focused on the tag team division or the mid-card belts, it would give stars in those divisions more screen time, while at the same time making the titles involved feel more important. However, it would require some of the bigger names to stay off shows, which at first would be very risky for WWE. But if they really want to make the most out of the talent they have, they need to re-structure their PPVs in order to make every single one of them feel unique, instead of having so many that are so similar that fans feel like theyre watching TV-quality shows.
1. What Not To Do: Changing Too Much
No one ever said that NJPW was perfect; like every wrestling promotions, their leaders have made big mistakes in the past. Out of all of these screw-ups, the biggest one was when then-owner Antonio Inoki went crazy about Mixed Martial Arts and damaged his own product due to his own ego. When Inoki got bit by the MMA bug, his desire was to either feed his top wrestlers to MMA stars, thus ruining any reputations those guys had as tough guys; or pushing MMA guys in wrestling, despite having little experience in professional wrestling. Either way, the end result was a series of bad matches and tarnished superstars. Eventually, two of his three legendary Three Musketeers, Shinya Hashimoto and Keiji Mutoh, left NJPW, leaving the company without any truly big stars to carry the company outside of Masahiro Chono, Yuji Nagata, and a plethora of MMA stars. What this means is that if a promoter changes their product too much, fans wont accept it. Weve seen this quite often in WWE recently, with the over-dependence on celebrities, promos, authority figures and pushing the wrong people. If a promoter does what he or she wants, instead of truly listening to what fans want, then the company is bound to fail. In many ways, during that MMA phase Inoki was very much like Vince McMahon: he had a radical new idea that his talent and fans didnt support, but he knew in his mind it was the right decision; and when it backfired on him it had serious consequences. It took New Japan almost a decade to regain its relevance in Japan, as NOAH and AJPW had taken over during the 2000s. If Vince doesnt want to experience a terrible drop in relevance like New Japan did, hes going to have to stop making so many changes and unpopular decisions just to fit his own ego.