10 Things WWE Can Learn From Wrestle Kingdom 12
The best of both worlds.
It's easy to watch a show like Wrestle Kingdom 12, last week's NJPW super-card, compare it to December's Clash of Champions, and conclude that WWE is essentially just the wrestling equivalent of an Adam Sandler movie: popular, but not very good.
This impression is perhaps a little misleading, though. In reality, there are plenty of things Vince McMahon and co do better than their Japanese counterparts, from obvious things like marketing and production, right down to the use of female wrestlers (an area in which WWE now puts its competitors to shame).
Despite what the more partisan members of the online wrestling community may claim, the fact is that both companies have their good and bad points - and, if ego could be set aside for five minutes, there's plenty of things they could learn from one another to improve their respective shows.
Having said all of that, since Thursday's show was such a resounding success (and we're all governed by an in-built recency bias), it's New Japan and its cast of incredible wrestlers that we're about to heap a boat loud of praise on.
10. Time In The Ring
Tally up the match times at last year's WrestleMania 33 and you get a total of around two hours and 20 minutes; do the same for Wrestle Kingdom 12 and you get three hours and 15 minutes (both excluding the pre-show).
This is nothing new, of course: WWE has been trailing its counterparts in terms of match time (by its own design) for as long as we can remember, a consequence of its proclivity for self-aggrandising ceremony, well-produced entrances and - now to a much lesser extent - the odd backstage skit.
Small wonder, given all of that, that NJPW consistency draws greater acclaim for the quality of its in-ring product. There's simply more of it, with wrestlers afforded ample time to craft a compelling story without having to worry about over-treading their allocation.
It's not something that's likely to change any time soon - impressing the purists has never been a priority for Vince McMahon - but maybe they're missing a trick here. Long matches can be just as effective in terms of star-making as a well-executed promo (in today's era, maybe more so).
9. Everyone On The Card
NJPW has borrowed a page from the WWE playbook in recent years by staging a pre-show battle royal to kick-off its annual January show-piece (though it is more about nostalgia and comedy than sign-posting the company's next big push).
However, at Wrestle Kingdom 12 they also booked a gauntlet match for the six-man tag team straps, a decision that allowed pretty much everyone on their roster to get on the show - in a meaningful, high-stakes bout.
This is one area where WrestleMania sometimes disappoints: anyone who doesn't have their own storyline is simply chucked in the Andre the Giant free-for-all, which is great for whomever wins but not so great for those who get dumped out without throwing a punch.
Introducing six-man straps into WWE would be pointless; they simply don't have enough stables to pull if off. But they do have two sets of tag team belts - and booking both a classic, two-on-two feud for one and a chaotic multi-man match for the other is the perfect way to ensure everyone gets their moment.
8. Long-Term Booking
The booking in NJPW, at least as regards the IWGP Heavyweight Title, never fails to fall in in line with what you might refer to as conventional and logically-sound decision-making.
Two years ago, it was Kazuchika Okada who took the mantle of leading man from Hiroshi Tanahashi at the third attempt; now, it seems Tetsuya Naito - who came up just short against Okada at WK 12's main event - is being groomed for the same role.
Put simply, the company is never sitting still. It is forever prepared for the possibility that Okada, currently its top guy, could get struck down with injury or request a lengthy holiday or, worse still, decide to take up an offer from Vince McMahon. They always have someone else equally qualified waiting in the wings.
Compare that to WWE and things seem altogether more chaotic, a point best illustrated by the scramble to crown a new franchise player that has followed the sudden realisation that John Cena won't be around forever. Four years on and we're still waiting for Roman Reigns to realise all that potential.
7. Follow The Crowd
It seems kind of obvious that Tetsuya Naito, the guy challenging for NJPW's biggest prize, should be the most over wrestler on the entire Wrestle Kingdom card - and yet any WWE fans watching may have found that fact strangely unfamiliar.
In the world's number one wrestling promotion, you see, it is not unusual that the wrestler cast in the role of lead baby-face is met with the kind of lukewarm reactions you traditionally associate with the very bottom of the card.
Partly, this is simply a byproduct of NJPW being a much smaller company and therefore able to cultivate a close-knit group of loyal fans who tend to buy into what they're trying to do (something we've seen before in ECW, Ring of Honor and early-era TNA). They attract fewer trolls, in other words.
But perhaps there would be fewer trolls in the WWE Universe if the company actually listened to its audience and put the spotlight on the wrestlers who command the best reactions from the crowd. In other words, let fans decide who is over instead of straight up telling them who they should be cheering for.
6. Delivering On Expectation
For wrestling fans outside of Japan, you probably have to go right back to the days when WCW was still alive and well to find a non-WWE match as well-anticipated as Chris Jericho's date with Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 12.
And, sure enough, NJPW delivered on all the pre-show hype, affording the pair a full half-an-hour in the ring, in which they conspired to put on a match that will probably rank right at the top of the end-year "best of" lists.
It's not like WWE ever deliberately sets out to let the fans down, of course, but too often over the recent past it has seemed like they are holding something back, content to put on a B+ show instead of pulling out all the stops and shooting for an A.
The consequence of this is that fans don't walk out of the arena desperate to tell all of their friends all about what they've just seen. Word of mouth is a marketing tool that has proved invaluable for New Japan over the last 12 months, and WWE could use some of that itself. The fact that it's a much bigger animal would only make the snowball effect even greater.
5. Creative Control
Anyone familiar with the events that led up to the collapse of WCW will know that, in wrestling (as in any other profession), absolute power corrupts absolutely. You can't go giving creative privileges to one set of stars and not another.
New Japan, however, seems to have struck exactly the right balance. While there's no indication that Kazuchika Okada threatened to walk out of the company unless he got to score a make-believe win in Wrestle Kingdom's headline match, it's clear that he - along with everyone else - gets to call his own spots in the ring.
This is something that the WWE decision-makers could do with incorporating in their show - that is to say, allowing wrestlers, in particular the experienced ones who can be trusted with their own choreography, much more freedom inside the squared circle.
We fully understand why they are reticent in this regard: Vince McMahon's punishing road schedule means that bookers must be conservative with their performers' bodies. But, on the biggest stages, there's surely no harm in loosening the shackles every now and then.
4. Simplicity
It seems a little harsh to compare one of the worst WrestleMania world title matches in recent memory with a bout that drew universal acclaim as recently as last week - but there's a point be made here.
Randy Orton versus Bray Wyatt at WM 33 last year came off the heels of a slow-burn storyline in which The Viper infiltrated The Eater of Worlds' close-knit band of brothers in order to destroy them from within.
None of that was particularly bad - but, on the night, it suffered from being overly-elaborate. Instead of a straight wrestling match between two objectively gifted performers, we got lights-out arena effects and slideshow projections of cockroaches.
By contrast, Kazuchika Okada and Tetsuya Naito simply contested a 30-minute-plus match built primarily around the IWGP Heavyweight Title and both performers' conviction that they were the very best in the world. The booking was simple and stripped-back, exactly the kind of thing that goes over well in today's so-called "reality" era.
3. A Strong Undercard
Traditionally, Wrestle Kingdom has drawn praise for its stunning main events but criticism for a comparatively weak undercard on which some of the matches fail to deliver anything beyond a few moments of comic relief.
This year, that all changed. The top-billed matches were every bit as good as usual, but the undercard was significantly improved thanks to matches like the IWGP Junior Heavyweight four-way and Kota Ibushi versus Cody, which went on third.
Everyone on the show brought their A-game, and the effect of this was that you, as a viewer, constantly felt like you were watching something big. All of the wrestlers seemed special, as though their place on the card had been earned instead of merely awarded.
There are a whole host of WWE pay-per-views from 2017 which show Vince McMahon and co have a long way to go to reach this sort of standard. We've been stuck watching last-minute bonus bouts and nondescript Cruiserweight Title matches for too long - and it can really effect the atmosphere in the arena.
2. Secondary Belts Matter
Emboldened by the memory of Stone Cold and The Rock warring over the IC Title at the dawn of the Attitude Era, fans have been crying out for WWE to make proper use of its secondary belts for at least the last decade.
For the most part, we continue to be disappointed. The latest attempt to bring prestige back to the US and Intercontinental straps seems to be centred around having nominal main eventers like John Cena and Roman Reigns climb down to the mid-card - which is great on paper, except that they rarely seem all that interested.
In sharp contrast, Hiroshi Tanahashi - one of the biggest stars in NJPW history - was last week only too happy to contest the Intercontinental Championship, a title which has previously headlined Wrestle Kingdom, with Jay White.
Meanwhile, Will Ospreay won the Junior Heavyweight crown after a pulsating 20-minute clash with Marty Scurll, Hiromu Takahashi and Kushida, another match that appeared to carry much more significance than its WWE equivalents.
1. Victory In Defeat
One of the biggest takeaways for first-time viewers of NJPW is often that even those who lose end up looking like a million bucks.
On Thursday, it was the turn of Tetsuya Naito, who saw his challenge for the IWGP Title come up just short; Chris Jericho, beaten after half an hour by Kenny Omega; and Jay White, undone by veteran Tanahashi after a valiant go the IC Championship.
The WWE creative team, for all of their sins, clearly know how to do this as well. Some of the most celebrated matches in the company's history - Stone Cold against Bret Hart at WrestleMania 13 and Benoit against Angle at the Rumble spring immediately to mind - have seen the loser emerge with more credibility than they had going in.
So, how come they manage to let us down so often? In the last year alone, we've seen the likes of Bray Wyatt and Shinsuke Nakamura suffer career-defining defeats from which it appears they may never recover.
The company has gotten into the unfortunate habit of putting over its current "projects" to the detriment of their opponents - and, in the long-term, it only serves to weaken the pool of main event players.