10 Things WWE Regrets About The Royal Rumble
"This isn't the Rumble I had in mind!"
The Royal Rumble, flawed history and all, is something that unites a fandom at constant odds with one another. No, that WALTER Vs. Joe Coffey match wasn't a merely flawed match. It was uneven well before the botches, you're not looking past the easy kick-out spots, and booking three NXT UK TakeOver cards per year isn't an achievement.
F*ck off.
But the Rumble unites us; a mathematical formula for fun, drama, anticipation and surprises, daft comedy and the most serious storyline stakes imaginable, the hour-plus epic is invariably a spectacle. Even when it's misjudged, even when it actively strives to make us disavow our very fandom, it yields moments of magic - be they a cool, unique Kofi Kingston near-elimination, or a welcome face returning from a cherished yesteryear. On which other night of the year would we ever in loud voice count down with anticipation, knowing there is a high risk of King Corbin emerging from behind the curtain?
We all have regrets about the institution. For example: why do we look forward to it, why must we hurt ourselves when the previous decade yielded no less than six uninspiring winners?
So does the company that promotes it...
10. Super-Sh*tty Staredown
WWE always tried to elevate the rivalry between John Cena and Randy Orton into the pantheon of the legendary - Rock Vs. Austin acting as the clear inspiration.
Much of its failure stems from the year 2009, in which, across all match types, Cena and Orton clashed on no less than five occasions, with four of those matches taking place consecutively from SummerSlam to Bragging Rights. The overkill culminated in - deep breath - a 60 Minute Iron Man Anything Goes, Falls Count Anywhere, No DQ match. Fans were left literally tired by all this, and so any attempts to resuscitate the programme failed spectacularly.
The first such attempt took place during the 2011 Rumble match. Orton entered at #39, and after a brief flurry of eliminations, turned around to face his career nemesis. With hushed breath, fans were meant to savour this meeting of the two legends. They...did not. Instead, they rubbed the sleep out of their eyes. They were seein' double here: two Eric Escobars! There was no palpable emotion to be felt; even apathy was out of reach. They couldn't even bring themselves to groan.
This all changed three years later.
Despite the events of 2011, WWE relegated Daniel Bryan to the midcard, and promoted Cena and Orton as the two biggest stars in the company - the only two worthy of unifying and feuding over the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships. Booed out of the building, the fans didn't even want this match at the Rumble, much less 'Mania, as Cena had optimistically pointed towards in '11.
With one arrogant gesture - we can use this in a hype video! - WWE tainted the aura of their two supposed legends.
9. A Paper Champion
One of several PR gaffes the WWF unleashed throughout a tumultuous 1990s, Sgt. Slaughter dethroned the Ultimate Warrior, via Macho Man interference, to set up the two major matches selling WrestleMania VII.
Originally scheduled for the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, the disastrous reception to the Gulf War exploitation angle saw the pay-per-view downsized to the neighbouring Sports Arena. Attempting to frame this as a safety measure - Slaughter was so over as to be a target, apparently - as spin goes, this was an unsuccessful as the original Sin Cara.
The angle itself was crafted very well - the Macho King's sceptre shot while not iconic was certainly unforgettable - but the sentiment behind it drove off an uncaring public and savage mainstream media alike. The taste was as dubious as the result, which hardly helped: Hogan could struggle to slam the Giant and face the Ultimate Challenge, but Slaughter was a paper champion before we even learned the term.
The events of the 1991 Royal Rumble in part shaped years of commercial and public image decay; with a bloodthirsty mainstream ready to pounce on any unsavoury development, and there were several of them, putting the spotlight on Slaughter, the cheapest of ploys, poetically altered the WWF's fortunes.
8. Sheer Desperation
The 1997 Royal Rumble reeked of desperation.
Optimistically promoted in the San Antonio Alamodome, Vince McMahon, as he was wont to do, overestimated the appeal of Shawn Michaels' white meat babyface character, even among his hometown fans, leading to embarrassing ticket sales consistent with the WWF's limited appeal at the tail end of the New Generation Era.
Desperately giving away thousands of tickets via Taco Bell coupons - all to convince a wider American public that the WWF was as big as you remembered it - Vince McMahon also partnered with Mexican lucha promotion AAA to persuade the local Hispanic population to fill seats, resulting in a relationship that was far more hassle than it was worth.
Owner Antonio Peña mis-sold his product to Vince; the exciting WCW stars promised to creative figure and intermediary Jake Roberts were signed to invalid contracts, and thus, the likes of Rey Misterio, Jr. did not appear. Instead, more aged and unspectacular talents littered the event, with Mil Máscaras the most infamous. He eliminated himself, mirroring AAA's nonexistent contribution to getting the WWF over. McMahon severed an arrangement struck with an inroad to Mexico City in mind shortly thereafter.
The '97 Rumble was an arduous grift that initially left management delighted by the attendance - but really, it failed in its remit to change the perception of the WWF from small fry to big time.
7. Evidence Of Bullying And Spite, Various
With new competition in the form of All Elite Wrestling, WWE's thick and rancid travel brochure is coming back to haunt them.
For well over a decade, the inherently toxic company luxuriated in this monopoly. Once dominated by the earnest, genuine good guy that was Bruno Sammartino, WWE mutated into a full-scale heel territory as the 21st century took shape. Virtually every performer that is not an eight foot tall freak show probably hesitates before signing across the dotted line, pausing to think: There's a very good chance they're going to f*ck me, isn't there?
There's probably a good chance that, if I don't immediately grasp rules that change from second to second, my chest is going to get lacerated, like Daniel Puder. There's a good chance that a morbidly obese man might just simulate rape on my person, like Matt Hardy in 2006.
Well pal, be grateful! You're not getting any at home now that Lita left ya, hahahahaha!
There's probably a good chance that, like Daniel Bryan, even if I work really hard to become an undeniably popular megastar, Vince will deny me, and push somebody really unpopular in my place!
6. Making It Really Violent And Sexual
The Royal Rumble 2000 was a blast.
Tazz debuted, obliterating Kurt Angle with a suplex smorgasbord in the platonic ideal of what the hot opener and debut used to be. A shell-shocked Angle sold this brilliantly later in a broadcast that also brought us an all-action, fresh-as-hell Tables match between the Dudley and Hardy Boyz, a seminal ultra-violent classic of a WWF Championship match, a Rumble that obliterated Taka Michinoku's face in wonderful schadenfreude fashion, and the Miss Rumble swimsuit contest that so delighted the teenage boys watching at home and the teenage boys sat in the commentary booth. There were so many puppies on display that Jerry Lawler sweated more than he had in November 1993.
Channel 4 didn't have a blast; perhaps expecting more of the well-remembered DayGlo stadium-sized family-friendly lustre of SummerSlam 1992, the UK broadcaster didn't seem to ask what Vince was up to these days, and were very much appalled by the WWF's new direction of exposed, withered breasts and blood-soaked flesh punctures.
The relationship severed within three hours, the WWF lost a shortcut to every prospective British home.
5. A Rash Decision
If WWE = Vince McMahon - and it does, it's hardly Triple H mutilating his NXT prospects on the abattoir that is the main roster - then WWE most certainly regrets bum-rushing the ring at the 2005 Royal Rumble, WWE most certainly regrets tearing both quadricep muscles apart, and WWE definitely regrets making a t*t of themselves on the third-most ordered pay-per-view of the year.
They couldn't repeat this if they tried, and many have since to unsuccessful effect; at the close of the match, Batista and John Cena eliminated themselves in picture-perfect stereo. Were Vince not an impulse-driven id of man, he might have paused, and remembered that there was precedent for such a development: the planned finish of the 1994 match. At first sight, most thought the finish was a retread of that, and a clever one: the Beast and the Doctor of Thuganomics were the new, dual faces of the company, and the finish painted them as equals.
In the aftermath, an enraged Vince painted them both as greenhorns by acknowledging the botch and ordering a restart. Vince could have let the intrigue build as the show faded to black without a conclusion, and could have booked a ratings monster of a RAW match - or a climactic, big money decider at No Way Out.
But no: Vince is an impulse-driven id of man, and elected instead to literally double down on the botch.
4. Buyer's Remorse
"Eddie's dead. Right before 'Mania, too. Typical! Who plays his ghost?"
"That's insensitive, Vince."
"Damnit, you're right. Have Randy say he's in hell, and have Rey Mysterio effectively inhabit his body for a few months."
"That's better."
The ballad of Rey Mysterio, 2006, painted WWE as a ruthlessly disgusting conglomerate that used a death - a death they were arguably complicit in - as sweet sweet hot hot heat. The beneficiary of the push, Rey Mysterio, won that year's Royal Rumble match after entering at #2 in a spot of poor luck Michael Cole optimistically suggested was the work of that posthumous prankster, the deceased Eddie Guerrero, for f*ck's f*cking sake.
Rey won the big one at WrestleMania 22: Big Time, following which Vince demonstrably regretted the whole affair. Were all those countless, humiliating defeats - at the hands of Mark Henry (05:18), The Great Khali (03:29), Finlay (06:00) - manifestations of McMahon's internal guilt over exploiting Eddie's death, or did he really just not want this tiny Cruiserweight to go over? At all?
3. A Disastrous Endorsement
The 2015 Royal Rumble was, in retrospect, hilariously bad.
Just this wonderfully harebrained, magnificently spiteful thing, Vince must have sneezed on Sunday morning, or something, for he punished himself and all matter in the WWE Universe by laying out a match calibrated perfectly to annoy f*ck out of everybody in the arena - and, given the rise of the #CancelWWENetwork hashtag, everybody with a Twitter account.
It wasn't the dumbest bullsh*t ever, but the cynical gesture - Roman Reigns is going to avenge all of your humiliated, buried favourites by last eliminating the two creaking dinosaurs that killed them off - was much too cynical. In effect, the layout mirrored and magnified precisely why Roman Reigns was so profoundly unpopular with the audience. He was put over by default: you gotta like Roman, because everybody else is terrible!
At least one person liked Roman in Philadelphia: The Rock. That was the idea, anyway; Rock, mortified at a reception even he couldn't control, let the mask slip once his initial return pop subsided to a sustained din of mightily pissed off vuvuzelas.
To recap: WWE killed their top babyface, killed everybody else to get that top babyface over, which of course failed, and made The Rock think twice about tainting his brand.
At the close of the 2005 West Side Story-inspired Rumble commercial, Vince woke up in a cold sweat. "That's not the Rumble I had in mind!"
For once in his life, he was 10 years too early.
2. The Whole CM Punk Concussion Thing
At some point during the 2014 Royal Rumble match, CM Punk suffered a concussion during a blown spot with Kofi Kingston; noticing this. Dr. Chris Amann was dispatched to ringside by management to measure the temperature of the situation.
Trusting the judgment of the concussed pro wrestler and not the sober of mind medical professional, WWE refused to take the injury seriously and use it as pretext to bring forward the planned illegal elimination spot. Perhaps worried by Punk's threat - "If you make me leave this f*cking match, I'll f*cking quit now" - WWE neglected his wellbeing, and indulged his sense of professional pride.
The problem with that is, once more clear of mind, Punk came to realise that he had f*ck all of that left, and quit regardless.
Of course, this was among the more shocking developments of the decade. WWE weren't to know. But WWE should have known better as it pertained to the serious injury Punk suffered, the neglect towards which, in part, painted its medical staff as utter dopes in the minds of the Punk Vs. Amann jury.
This in retrospect is an awful, regrettable look for WWE about as unsightly as a baseball-sized lump.
1. "Actually, No. No. You CAN'T Have Nice Things."
Fully aware that the decision to put Roman Reigns over in the main event at WrestleMania, again, was going to annoy the biggest crowd of the year, Vince McMahon extended an olive branch. Shinsuke Nakamura was to win the Royal Rumble, thus setting up a long-awaited rematch between the King of Strong Style and AJ Styles. Billed as a Dream Match, the storyline underwhelmed, but it was incidental to the promise: AJ and Shinsuke were going to tear the house down.
It wasn't an olive branch after all, but an outstretched arm with which he punched us in our balls for daring to dream.
After a 20 minute match very much laid out in the methodical WWE mould, Shinsuke turned heel on AJ. Our guy won the Rumble, but not the big one - but it was fine. This new heel Shinsuke, restored to his old, mischievous sh*t-kicker self, was going to kick AJ all over the place in matches with a more dangerous, brutal dynamic.
This didn't happen, either: the whole thing, the victory, the turn, the character development, was all in service of prolonging AJ's unremarkable and overlong reign with the WWE Championship - and the feud itself was prolonged by Shinsuke just punching AJ in the balls over and over again.
Somehow, Fox saw this, and threw billions at it - so Vince probably doesn't regret it after all.