10 Things WWE Did Right At Payback

By John Canton /

The WWE Payback event from Chicago featured a lot of predictable outcomes, plenty of weapons being used and perhaps the end of some long term feuds. It also might be the last time we see Batista for a few months in a PPV setting although his availability always seems to be changing. All three champions successfully defended their championships with Sheamus, Bad News Barrett and Paige all winning clean. The WWE World Heavyweight Champion Daniel Bryan is still on the shelf with a neck injury, but he did have a role in a newsworthy segment. The tag team champions The Usos had a presence on the show too, even though they weren't in a match. What the show lacked was the element of surprise. There were no heel turns, no surprise finishes and nothing that would be considered a major happening. That's not a bad thing necessarily, but there really was nothing newsworthy about what happened. There were some CM Punk chants although it was not nearly as many as we heard on the Chicago Raw in March when the show was full of them. On Twitter, Punk spent his evening tweeting about his Chicago Blackhawks, who lost their NHL game 7 against the Los Angeles Kings. He did tweet "I love you Chicago" about 15 minutes before the PPV began, so maybe he was made aware of the Punk chants on the Kickoff show. Like most WWE PPVs, there was good in-ring action from top to bottom. WrestleMania is still the best PPV of the year and this was not at that level, but there were still plenty of things that went well. Here are 10 things that WWE did right at Payback.

10. Bad News Barrett Is Succeeding As Intercontinental Champion

The fourth Intercontinental Title reign of Wade "Bad News" Barrett started one month ago at Extreme Rules and he continued his momentum with a win over Rob Van Dam. Nobody really expected RVD to win, nor should they have. At this point in his career, RVD is just a guy in his 40s that is there to put over the younger talent because WWE thinks his name still has a lot of value even though that's questionable at this point. What's good about this Barrett reign is that he's getting better responses from the crowd due to the "I'm afraid I've got some bad news" phrase that he does before his matches and the Bull Hammer finisher is very effective. The next step that needs to happen for Barrett is a worthwhile feud for the IC Title. It needs to be something that can go two or three months that makes people care about the babyface opponent, whoever it is. If it was up to me they should call up Sami Zayn from NXT and put him in a feud with Barrett right away. It would work.

9. Paige Is Proving To Be A Viable Champion

The Divas Champion Paige was on the defensive for much of her match against the volatile Alicia Fox. However, there was never a point where it looked like Fox was going to win or that the fans bought into it. The fans were busy not caring about the match and chanting things unrelated to the women. It wasn't a match that was close to the level of the outstanding matchup at NXT Takeover as Charlotte beat Natalya, but that's because women on the main roster rarely get a lot of time to have longer matches. It's just how WWE is. Frustrating? Sure. Likely to change? No. It's been this way for years. While Triple H's influence is growing and he does like longer matches like we see on NXT, until it becomes a regular thing on the main roster the longer matches for divas isn't something we should expect. None of that is the fault of Paige, though. She's a good champion in her early 20s with a very bright future. Look for her to hold onto the Divas Title until AJ Lee comes back likely in July at which point they'll probably have a lengthy feud.

8. Rusev Continues To Impress

The match between Rusev and Big E was brief in that it went under five minutes, but it sent the message that Rusev continues to be a force in WWE. He's had short matches for a couple months of now. Nobody on the main roster has really pushed him yet. There was a great spot in the match with Rusev standing on the apron and Big E nailed him with a Spear that sent both guys crashing to the floor. It's a spot that Big E does once in a while. It's always very impressive looking. That€™s about the only significant offense that he got, though. He was dominated by Rusev. It's hard to know what WWE has planned for Rusev and the "ravishing Russian" Lana. They could really have him make a name for himself by going after a top face like John Cena, but it may be too soon for that. It could be another midcarder that's next on his hit list, which could lead to the undefeated Rusev getting pushed to the limit although it would be a surprise if he were to lose a match any time soon. Six months ago Big E was a guy with a very bright future. He has fallen off a lot since then.

7. The Usos Have A Great Rivalry Brewing With Wyatt Family

Heading into Payback some people were thinking that maybe WWE would add a match between The Usos and Erick Rowan/Luke Harper because they have been interacting a lot on television in the last month. Rowan & Harper even beat them in a non-title match, so a title match is likely going to happen soon. The Usos showed up as backup to John Cena for his Last Man Standing Match with Bray Wyatt and they were able to neutralize Rowan & Harper, who had a hand in Cena losing to Wyatt at Extreme Rules in a cage match. They will most likely have a tag team title match at Money in the Bank in four weeks, which is a good idea because by that point the feud should be really hot. There's a contrast in styles with the Wyatt Family as bigger wrestlers while the Usos are known as high flyers. A title change is very possible too. Any time you can use another feud to build up others and create a new rivalry out of it then it has to be considered a success.

6. Sheamus Retains US Title Without Hurting Cesaro's Stature

The PPV opener saw Sheamus successfully defend the US Title against Cesaro in a hard hitting battle between two guys who are very capable in the ring. Every time they wrestle it's a physical match. This one was no different. Going into the match, it was hard to know how they would do the finish. If Sheamus won decisively with a Brogue Kick then that would probably hurt Cesaro to lay down for somebody's finisher. If Cesaro won then the title reign of Sheamus would have been a waste. Plus, it doesn't seem like Cesaro needs a midcard title at this point. By doing the rollup finish for Sheamus they did something that happened "out of nowhere" and didn't really hurt Cesaro by losing. From WWE's point of view, the thinking might be that since Cesaro is possibly going to win Money in the Bank that it's okay for him to win on a rollup to Sheamus in a match like this that really doesn't mean anything. Cesaro would be elevated with the MITB win. Nobody's going to remember that he lost clean to somebody like Sheamus. By the way, Paul Heyman telling the crowd that CM Punk wasn't there because he was at the hockey game was great. Actually he's not there because he chose to walk out of the company, but what Heyman said was true too.

5. Evolution Could Be Done As A Group

It was fun while it lasted, right? Evolution's return following WrestleMania was a welcome sight because it had been so long since they were together. The group ran roughshod on WWE personnel for most of 2003 and 2004 before they went their separate ways. After winning 31 World Titles on their own, the trio reunited without Ric Flair to prove they were superior to The Shield. Their loss was decisive. All three members got pinned within a few minutes of each other after dominating the majority of the match. If it's not the end of the group then they better do a heck of a job of building them back up. Where does everybody go from here? Batista's likely gone for a few months to promote his Guardians of the Galaxy movie. Triple H will continue as the heel authority figure with his wife. Maybe Randy Orton can get his WWE Title rematch that he never received. It's been two months. Most likely he'll be in the Money in the Bank match. Considering that groups like The Shield and Wyatt Family are still going strong then it's not a bad idea to see Evolution ending. Too many groups would hurt things. Batista looked so out of place in the blue outfit, but it was pretty funny to see #Bluetista trending on Twitter too.

4. Even in Defeat, Bray Wyatt Is A Bigger Star

The purpose of the John Cena/Bray Wyatt feud was to help Wyatt become a better star. He had a lot of momentum heading into it as the guy that beat Daniel Bryan at the Royal Rumble and he got the pinfall against The Shield at Elimination Chamber. It was WWE's way of saying "this guy is going to be a big deal." When Wyatt lost to Cena at WrestleMania a lot of people complained. A WrestleMania win would have been huge for him because it's something he could have bragged about for a long time. Instead, Cena won clean. Wyatt got the win at Extreme Rules, but it was an overbooked mess that involved a little kid costing Cena. It was just weird. If you thought Wyatt was going to win the feud you probably haven't paid attention to Cena feuds enough. He rarely loses feuds. He might have two to three month rivalries, but in the end he usually emerges as the victor. Cena actually lost his most recent feud with Randy Orton although it's not like it hurt him much. As we look back on this rivalry, can we say that Wyatt is a bigger star because of it? Yes. He'll get bigger reactions now. He also looked like he belonged. In the end, that matters more than wins or losses. A lot will depend on how he's booked going forward, but for now fans should be happy with how he was used and his status as a bigger name in WWE today.

3. Stephanie McMahon Got What She Deserved

Stephanie McMahon has been terrific as a heel authority figure. While I've been very vocal about how WWE relies too much on heels in power, it's not due to the performance of Stephanie. It's simply because this story has been done far too many times over the last 16 years when Vince McMahon was making life difficult for Steve Austin. What was great about the segment on Payback was that Stephanie walked out to the ring with a big smile as she was set to either strip Daniel Bryan of his job or fire Brie Bella. Instead, she was the victim of a retort from Daniel and Brie as she called Stephanie a bitch. Then Brie said that Stephanie couldn't fire her because she quit. Stephanie looked happy again, but then Brie slapped her in the face and Stephanie was humiliated. The reason it was such a successful part of the show is because it's important for the heel to get what's coming to them once in a while. Nobody has done anything to make Stephanie look weak for so long that when Brie hit her the fans popped huge because they know that it mattered a lot to see that. A highlight of the show was when the crowd chanted "CM Punk" during the segment, which led to Bryan laughing and Stephanie reacted to it by saying "the fans want you to quit just like CM Punk did." Huge heat. It added to the segment. Great thinking by Stephanie in a difficult spot. The only weird aspect of the segment was that Brie seemed happy even though she "quit" her job, but that's probably because she was happy to stand by her man. The story is about Bryan more than it is about her job.

2. New Feuds Are On The Horizon

The best thing WWE did at Payback was they likely put an end to two feuds that needed to be done. John Cena's story with Bray Wyatt started back at January's Royal Rumble when Wyatt cost Cena the WWE Title match against Randy Orton. After three straight PPV matches where Cena won two of them, it looks as though the storyline is over although there were rumors that it might continue. I hope not. It has run its course. The Shield beat Evolution at last month's Extreme Rules show in a clean fashion. There was no controversy at all. After Evolution attacked them again, it set up the rematch at Payback. This match was a lot different than the other one because weapons were legal and there was a No Holds Barred stipulation even though there was a ten minute period where they were doing tags for some reason. After The Shield's win, it looks like this one is done. With Money in the Bank coming up later this month, then Battleground in July and a major SummerSlam show in August it's time for WWE to build up some new rivalries. Payback was the end of two big feuds. They were fine, but WWE needs to improve on things and offer up something new as we head on the road to Money in the Bank.

1. The Shield Continues Their Dominance As Triple H Loses Again

Ever since The Shield debuted in WWE in November of 2012 they have been booked in such a strong way that it's fair to say that nobody has looked stronger in the last 18 months. Daniel Bryan became a WWE Champion, but think about all the missteps along the way for him. In the case of The Shield, they have been consistently strong from the moment they started with wins over key names along the way. As a babyface trio this year they might be even better. Roman Reigns was really singled out in the match as Evolution took out Rollins & Ambrose at one point so they could destroy Reigns in the ring with kendo stick shots as well as using chairs against him. His ability to fight back is earning the respect from the fans. They admire his ability to take a licking and keep on ticking, so to speak. When Seth Rollins hit that dive off the top of the video screen that was about 15 feet high it was the biggest "wow" moment of the match. It was similar to Extreme Rules when he did a balcony dive. Those kinds of things show that Rollins will do anything to help his team win and will endear him to fans. They really didn't book Dean Ambrose to do anything that made him stand out although he did get to pin Randy Orton. As for Triple H, he ended his night looking up at the lights. He has his haters, but the man has put over Daniel Bryan clean and he put over The Shield for the second time although at Extreme Rules it was Batista that got pinned. It's nice to see that the mid 40s version of Triple H realizes it's time to put the young guys over. We shouldn't focus on when The Shield might break up although that's obviously one of those things that is hard to avoid talking about. It's just a shame that sometimes we focus on that too much instead of enjoying how great this trio is on a consistent basis. We're witnessing something special with The Shield. Enjoy it while it lasts.